Two years on from Loafers Lodge fire Newtown building looms virtually unchanged
The Loafers Lodge fire in May 2023 killed five of the building's 92 residents.
Photo:
Supplied / Axel Dann
Some survivors of a fatal boarding house fire are still struggling with the trauma of that night two years on, the Wellington City Missioner says.
Today marks the second anniversary of the [https://www.rnz.co.nz/programmes/in-depth-special-projects/story/2018890914/this-one-s-real-the-loafers-lodge-fire
Loafers Lodge fire in Newtown] that killed five of the building's 92 residents and left those who escaped homeless.
Michael Wahrlich
, Melvin Parun, Peter O'Sullivan,
Kenneth Barnard and Liam Hockings
lost their lives in the devastating blaze that began shortly after midnight on 16 May, 2023.
Two years since the fatal fire, most of the Loafers Lodge residents have found permanent homes, but survivors were reluctant to speak to RNZ for this story.
Meanwhile, the gutted three-storey building stands virtually unchanged on Adelaide Road and its future remains unclear.
Police said a man facing murder and arson charges is due to reappear in court at the end of this month.
In the immediate aftermath of the fire, Wellington City Mission became the go-to organisation for survivors, with staff having said their lives changed overnight.
Missioner Murray Edridge described it as an intense and challenging time.
"We got to hear stories about people having to climb over bodies to get out of the building. People who chose to jump out windows because there was no way out of the building.
"These were deeply traumatic events that for a number of people will stay with them probably the rest of their days."
Wellington City Missioner Murray Edridge.
Photo:
RNZ / Samuel Rillstone
He said it was not only a tragedy for the five people who lost their lives, but for the survivors who lost their home, and some of them, all their possessions.
Kāinga Ora Wellington regional director Vicki McLaren said she could not disclose current information, but said at the time of the fire 41 Loafers residents were placed in Kāinga Ora houses, while others found homes in the private market or transitional housing.
Edridge confirmed in the two years since, most had found permanent homes, some had left Wellington, and six remained at the Mission.
Survivors contacted by RNZ were reluctant to speak on record for this story, however Miimetua Cameron - who was one of the last people to escape her floor - asked that any article highlight the work of the City Mission and Wellingtonians for "their kind donations".
In the hours after the blaze, Cameron, who works at Taylor Preston, [https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/490129/residents-of-loafers-lodge-now-working-on-recovery
told RNZ she was lucky to be alive], but had no idea where she and her partner would live.
Speaking to RNZ this week, she said the couple's new accommodation was a significant improvement - a single unit with its own kitchen facilities.
Miimetua Cameron lived at Loafers Lodge for three years.
Photo:
RNZ / Ashleigh McCaull
Edridge said while some ex-Lodgers were doing really well, a recent fire drill showed others were still struggling.
"Even just the alarm in the building, the requirement to evacuate, triggered a number of people so severely - and it was a reflection on the experience they had two years ago.
"So, for most of us life has moved on, for the people directly impacted by the fire, it hasn't. In fact, it still stays with them very significantly."
He said part of the problem was that the Lodge still remained on Adelaide Road, and he was disappointed that another year had passed and nothing had changed.
He wanted to see an urgent resolution - whether that be demolition or a rebuild.
"The stark reminder that creates everyday for people as they drive or walk past the site, where we still see a burnt out shell, that will be retraumatising for many of these people time and time again.
"I guess my call is to whoever is responsible - legal, insurance, owners - to resolve it."
RNZ contacted the owner of the building, but they declined to comment for this story.
The Loafers Lodge building remains unchanged in 2025.
Photo:
RNZ / Samuel Rillstone
The fire triggered a series of
inquiries into fire protections
.
A Wellington City Council audit released in June 2023 found 25 similar buildings to Loafers Lodge in the capital. Twenty-one had a current building warrant of fitness, one never had one and three did, but they were not current.
Following the fire, the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) launched a
probe into 37 buildings like Loafers Lodge
(buildings that were at least three storeys tall, a boarding house and had no sprinklers). It found more than 100 problems, including smoke detectors not working and unmonitored alarm systems.
It also found the boarding houses were on average 60 years old. Most were not built originally to be accommodation and 69 percent had issues with safety systems.
MBIE's head of building system, delivery and assurance Simon Thomas said issues around building warrant of fitness inspections had been resolved as of October last year.
In addition to further guidance on building warrant of fitness compliance, an amendment to the Building Act in November 2024 increased fines and penalties for breaches, he said.
Firefighters at the scene of the blaze in 2023.
Photo:
RNZ / Angus Dreaver
Meanwhile, MBIE's head of tenancy Kat Watson said it had filed an application to take a boarding house operator to the Tenancy Tribunal for a range of breaches found in the initial investigation.
No date had been set for the hearing, and Watson could not say whether the breaches were related to fire safety, given the case was yet to be heard.
After the probe into boarding houses, the government asked MBIE to do a full review of the building code's fire safety provisions.
The Minister for Building and Construction Chris Penk told RNZ he expected the final report and recommendations to be delivered within weeks, and that it would be made public shortly after.
He said more than 350 pages of feedback from architects, to builders and building occupants, had to be compiled.
"[It] has been a long and arduous task but it's an important one and we're determined to get it right, not to rush it."
He said no one should have to endure the loss and trauma that resulted from the fire at Loafers Lodge.
"We remain committed to learning from this event to prevent similar tragedies in the future."
A man, who has name suppression, has pleaded not guilty to murder and arson charges and is due appear at the High Court in Wellington at the end of May.
At the end of last year, Fire and Emergency (FENZ) said it was unable to release a
review into how it responded to the fatal fire
while a criminal investigation was underway.
FENZ regional manager Bruce Stubbs said the organisation would continue to support police with the ongoing court case.
He said two years on, FENZ's thoughts were with those who perished in the fire and also with staff who performed "multiple rescues that evening in severe fire conditions".
In a statement, mayor Tory Whanau said her heart went out to the whānau and friends of those who perished and continued to grieve.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter
curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Person dies after colliding with power pole in Northcote
Police said the car crashed on the corner of Onewa Road and Seaview Ave. Photo: RNZ / REECE BAKER One person has died after their car crashed into a power pole in the Auckland suburb Northcote on Tuesday. Police said the car crashed on the corner of Onewa Road and Seaview Ave, just after 4:30pm. The person could not be revived and died at the scene. The Serious Crash Unit carried out an examination.
Scoop
an hour ago
- Scoop
Government Warned Corruption And 'Insider Threats' Increasing In New Zealand
The government has been warned that corruption and "insider threats" are increasing in New Zealand, despite the country's longstanding reputation as a country largely free of it. An advisory group says the country is poorly prepared to tackle the increasing threat and recommends developing a national anti-corruption strategy and modernising the Crimes Act, which the Minister responsible says is key. The Ministerial Advisory Group on transnational and organised crime was set up in February to provide independent advice and recommendations to improve the cross-government response to what Associate Minister of Police Casey Costello described as " an increasing threat." Previous reports have said New Zealand was "losing the fight" against organised crime, and specified a need for police to have greater financial powers to fight it. The third report has stated New Zealand's "lucrative market" and established crime networks have made the country "more susceptible than ever" to corruption and insider threats. It also pointed to the "deteriorating situation in the Pacific" as making the region more vulnerable. It defined corruption as the "abuse of access or authority to advance the objectices of organised crime". "It is a critical enabler of organised crime, particularly at national borders. It grants criminal networks access to protection, sensitive information, and operational impunity. "This is a real and increasing threat," the report said. The group was told by enforcement agencies about "trusted insiders" at ports and airports helping to retrieve concealed shipments of illicit drugs before customs inspections. "That information is consistent with an unpublished global report which estimates that 70 percent of maritime seizures worldwide involved links to trusted insiders." It raised a specific concern in the Pacific where exposure is increased due to expansive maritime borders, strategic trade corridors and growing cross-border flows of goods and people. "When individuals in border security, customs, or immigration are compromised, criminal groups can exploit these weak points to smuggle drugs, weapons, other illicit goods, and people with minimal detection. "Bribery, coercion, and cronyism can transform ports, airports, and checkpoints into open channels." If corruption was left unchecked, the report warned it could erode the integrity of New Zealand's institutions and undermine its collective security. "We are already seeing increasing pressure on Pacific nations which have limited capacity to detect, investigate and prosecute organised crime threats. "The financial incentives offered by organised crime groups can be tempting - especially for those working in jobs with useful access, but low pay, in New Zealand and within the Pacific." The advisory group reports to Costello who told RNZ she was not surprised by the contents of the report, except to learn that New Zealand was the only Five Eyes member who did not have an anti-corruption strategy. She did however believe New Zealanders might be shocked to learn corruption was getting worse, "we've kind of considered ourselves as a little bit of a haven". The report specified New Zealand's "reputation as a country largely free from corruption has long been a source of national pride and international credibility". But also pointed this had led to a "degree of inertia," referencing Julie Haggie, chief executive of Transparency International NZ, who said in the report "New Zealand's response to increasing corruption pressures over several years has been lacklustre and complacent". "New Zealand is poorly prepared to deter and tackle the increasing threat of corruption, but that is not to say nothing is being done," said the report. Costello said the report was not suggesting organisations were corrupt, but the ability for organised crime to target individuals was there. "That's where we see that familial or cultural pressures, that ability to have control over individuals, and that's not just in the drug world." She said New Zealand was not out of control, but the country needed to shift the way it was doing things, strengthen legislation and put clear strategies in place. Costello believed bringing the Crimes Act up to date to deal with corruption was one of the key recommendations. She said work being done at the moment was bringing agencies together to have consistency around sharing information. Another recommendation was to have a centralised agency that would have oversight across all agencies. "Whether that's in the public service commission, or whether it's in police or SFO [Serious Fraud Office] or a new agency, it's having that one oversight so that we work more cooperatively." In regards to the Pacific, she said it was important New Zealand supported its economic growth and viability. "When people are poor, then the amount of money you need to corrupt someone is relatively low. "Leaning in more to support those economies to help them not just gain knowledge, but actually keep these systems in place. "How do they optimise their control of their border so they're collecting excise, that they're optimising the revenue they can get from legitimate business, as well as ensuring that they aren't corrupted." She said the reports were about making New Zealanders more aware about organised crime and an appreciation of the challenges that it presents.
Otago Daily Times
an hour ago
- Otago Daily Times
Alleged mushroom murderer accused of lying
Accused triple-murderer Erin Patterson has been accused of lying about throwing up remains from a beef Wellington and serving herself on a different plate. On her sixth day in the witness box, the 50-year-old has disputed evidence from a doctor, nurse, her estranged husband Simon and what the only surviving lunch guest told the jury in her trial. Patterson has entered week seven of a Victorian Supreme Court trial accused of three murders and one attempted murder over a toxic mushroom dish she served up to Simon's family in July 2023. Her former in-laws Don and Gail Patterson, 70, and Gail's sister Heather Wilkinson, 66, all died in hospital days after eating death cap mushroom-laced beef Wellingtons cooked by Patterson. She has pleaded not guilty to all charges and claims the poisonings were a terrible accident. Patterson last week admitted foraging for wild mushrooms and accepted they may have been in the individual beef Wellingtons that she had prepared. Crown prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC, at the beginning of her third day cross-examining Patterson on Tuesday, accused her of more lies. Patterson on Friday said she'd a pre-surgery appointment for gastric bypass procedure at Enrich Clinic in Melbourne. But Dr Rogers put to Patterson that Enrich "does not offer gastric bypass or sleeve surgery". "I don't know," Patterson replied. "I had an appointment with them ... It was for weight-loss surgery but maybe it was a different kind." The prosecutor suggested she had lied about that appointment but Patterson said: "It wasn't a lie, that's what my memory was". Dr Rogers quizzed Patterson about sole surviving lunch guest Ian Wilkinson's evidence to the jury about being served the beef Wellington on one of four large grey plates. He also told the jury, in week two of the trial, Patterson had served herself on a smaller orange or tan plate. Patterson said she did not own any grey plates, and did not serve herself on a plate that was orange, tan and small. Dr Rogers asked Patterson about evidence that Heather Wilkinson said she noticed the cook had served herself the food on a "coloured plate which was different from the rest". "I didn't serve myself at all," she replied, before adding she wanted to "clarify" she did not own any matching sets of plates. "Somebody would've had different plates and I don't have four plates the same," Patterson said. Dr Rogers suggested her "whole story is untrue" about plating the food, to which Patterson replied: "You're wrong". She directly put to Patterson that she lied to medical professionals about vomiting to "try and account for why you didn't get seriously ill". "I wish that was true but it's not," Patterson said. Patterson further disputed evidence from Simon, saying she did not tell him she was worried she may "poo her pants" if she drove her son's friend home after the lunch. She disputed evidence from Leongatha doctor and nurse, Chris Webster and Kylie Ashton, about what they discussed when she admitted herself to hospital two days after the lunch. She said Leongatha hospital staff would not tell her what had happened to the other lunch guests. Patterson said she "probably was very stressed" when she went to the hospital because doctors had suspected death cap mushroom poisoning in the meal she prepared. "I was anxious at the idea we might've eaten those things," she said. The trial continues.
