Opinion: Will the ‘Abundance' agenda change politics?
'Abundance' dissects how progressivism has crippled innovation, housing and essential development. The liberal authors artfully recommend a liberalism that protects and builds. Although causing a rift in the Democratic Party, could this signal a shift in the trajectory of national politics?
COWLEY: Reminiscent of Princess Leia's plea to Obi-Wan Kenobi, the Abundance agenda is Democrats' 'only hope.' Government is getting in their way, stifled by layers of self-imposed regulatory burdens. Government should be judged by its outcomes, not the rigid principles it follows. Process has been prioritized over product.
Stymied public projects are merely symptoms of a larger illness within the Democratic Party. They have countless militant factions, each fighting for their niche issue to be pervasively included in all facets of government. Environmental activists demand prairie dog protection from new transmission lines. Clean air advocates want mass transit to be carbon-neutral. Even Biden saw how his infrastructure spending bills didn't have a meaningful impact because a large chunk was gobbled up by red tape and compliance costs. Imposing restrictions on their own desired outcomes results in money spent, time wasted and little to show for it. They cannot be all things to all people. Leadership is sometimes saying no.
Although not entirely the fault of Democrats, upward mobility and the American Dream are becoming relics of the past. In 1940, children had a 92% chance of out-earning their parents. By 1980, it fell to 50%. If we don't build and innovate, economic opportunity dwindles. AI is the next frontier for discovery and development. This global race is one that Americans cannot afford to lose, and both parties should be paying attention.
PIGNANELLI: 'The formation of ideological factions within political parties — starting among intellectuals and writers — is a staple of American history.' — Jonathan Chait, The Atlantic
I remember when Friedman's program promoting the free market aired on PBS (that's right) in January 1980, when President Jimmy Carter was beating Ronald Reagan 65%-31 %. In November, Reagan won in a landslide. Ideas have power.
Abundance philosophy has existed for years. But this book compiled supportive documentation into a mass communication vehicle. The well-intentioned government programs established 50 years ago are crippling housing and the implementation of technological innovations. The authors argue that progressives are focused on process and litigation rather than achieving results that benefit society. Presidents Barack Obama and Joe Biden passed massive legislation to fund projects in healthcare, technology and alternative fuels that were impossible to initiate due to regulatory barriers.
Severe left-wing opposition to abundance advocates underscores their fear of losing influence. Indeed, pundits predict a civil war within the Democratic Party between the far left and moderates eager for a new ideology. This demand for competent, efficient government can attract independents and moderate Republicans.
America is amidst a major political realignment, and abundance is a new dynamic. We are witnessing history.
Utah is well governed. But are there aspects of 'Abundance' that could be utilized to promote the objectives of our state officials?
COWLEY: Utah understands that less is more when it comes to government. The Legislature is actively removing government barriers to innovation. For example, Utah's regulatory sandbox allows entrepreneurs to seek regulatory relief in their businesses while serving as laboratories of innovation. Look at the speed with which nuclear power is coming to Utah. Yet, more could be done on permitting and zoning to address Utah's significant housing shortage.
PIGNANELLI: Gov. Spencer Cox appropriately notes that Utah has performed DOGE-like functions for years. Senate President Stuart Adams is promoting clean nuclear energy. Speaker Mike Schultz and lawmakers pursued a similar objective by mandating that the Utah Higher Education reallocate 10% of state funds to more productive uses. Despite public grumbling, insiders are grateful for the political protection that compels them to readjust resources.
These goals also apply to conservatives to discourage their policies that inhibit housing and economic development at the local government level. Abundance should not be beholden to any political party, but rather a mindset that if government is used, it must be practical and not an interference.
Will 'Abundance' be a campaign issue in the future?
COWLEY: The Abundance agenda may help Democrat candidates become more appealing to Utah voters as the battle between progressives and moderates wages on. The real question is if they see the existential crisis befalling them and what will they do to avoid extinction. Staying the course doesn't have an upside. There is no drama-filled Twitter spat or blunder big enough that Trump could commit for the millions of Americans who voted for him to suddenly support the progressive agenda. Democrats need to loosen the stranglehold activists have on their party in order to rack up wins.
PIGNANELLI: Abundance will be weaponized against moderate Democrats by left-wing progressives in internal battles. Democrats and Republicans in swing districts will advocate for this philosophy.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox News
an hour ago
- Fox News
NBC News host presses Democratic Gov. JB Pritzker on his billionaire status
Gov. JB Pritzker was pressed by NBC's Kristen Welker on Sunday on his billionaire status, as some members of the Democratic Party have criticized wealth and suggested billionaires shouldn't exist.
New York Post
3 hours ago
- New York Post
Andrew Cuomo proposes ‘Zohran's Law' after privileged Mamdani clings to rent-stabilized apartment
Mayoral candidate Andrew Cuomo proposed 'Zohran's law' that would block privileged New Yorkers like his socialist rival Zohran Mamdani from living in rent-stabilized apartments. Mamdani, 33, who rakes in $142,000 a year as a state assemblyman and whose wealthy family includes his filmmaker mom and professor dad, has been living in a $2,300-a-month, one-bedroom pad in Astoria. 'I'm calling the legislation 'Zohran's Law.' This is obviously an abuse of the system,' Cuomo told The Post Sunday. 4 Andrew Cuomo is pushing for legislation blocking privileged New Yorkers from scooping up rent-stabilized pads. Matthew McDermott 'We're not supposed to be providing rent-stabilized apartments to the children of millionaires.' The qualifications would include a 'means test' based on the monthly rent and other factors, Cuomo said though he did not share specifics. The legislation would require approval from the Democratic-run state legislature and Gov. Kathy Hochul. 4 Cuomo's proposal is named after socialist mayoral hopeful Zohran Mamdani. LP Media Cuomo has been on the attack against Mamdani since last Friday over the cushy apartment in high cost Astoria. 'Somewhere last night in New York City, a single mother and her children slept at a homeless shelter because you, Assemblyman Zohran Mamdani, are occupying her rent-controlled apartment,' Cuomo wrote in a viral tweet that racked up more than 28 million views. 'I am calling on you to move out immediately and give your affordable housing back to an unhoused family who need it. Leaders must show moral clarity. Time to move out,' Cuomo added. 4 Mamdani makes $142,000 a year as a state assemblyman and his wealthy family includes his filmmaker mom and professor dad. Mamdani, the Democratic Party nominee, has proposed to freeze the rent of government-regulated apartments if he wins the general election in November. Former Gov. Cuomo lost to Mamdani in a June Democratic primary but is running in November on the 'Fight and Deliver' independent ballot line. Incumbent Mayor Eric Adams also is running as an independent after dropping out of the primary as he faced federal corruption charges, which have since been dropped. 4 Mamdani has been living in a $2,300-a-month, one-bedroom apartment in Astoria. Brigitte Stelzer Curtis Sliwa, the founder of the Guardian Angels, is the Republican nominee and lawyer Jim Walden will also appear on ballots as an independent.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Gov. JB Pritzker won't rule out presidential bid in 2028, attacks Republican remap effort in Texas
In his strongest public comments to date about his future political plans, Gov. JB Pritzker said Sunday he won't rule out seeking the Democratic nomination for president in 2028 even while he seeks reelection to a third term as Illinois' chief executive next year. Pritzker, appearing on NBC's 'Meet The Press,' also contended that a Republican-backed remap of Texas' congressional districts — which sent more than 30 of that state's House Democrats to Illinois to block the move — would be 'unconstitutional' for violating federal voting protections for racial and ethnic voters. Pritzker, who announced his bid for a third term as governor in June, has not explicitly said he is seeking the presidency. But he has had several speaking engagements in front of Democrats across the country, along with frequent national TV and podcast appearances. His role in hosting Texas House Democrats attempting to block the GOP remap has also raised his profile. Asked by Meet the Press moderator Kristen Welker if he would rule out a presidential bid, Pritzker said, 'I can't rule anything out.' 'But what I can rule in is that no matter what decisions I make, and I mean, in particular about what I do here in the state of Illinois, is about the people of Illinois. Indeed, any future decisions of mine will always be guided by that,' the Democratic governor said. 'I'm focused on running for reelection as governor of the state of Illinois, and everything that I do really is focused on lifting up the people of my state.' Illinois Republicans have routinely seized on Pritzker's presidential aspirations, accusing him of putting his political ambitions ahead of the more parochial concerns of the state's voters. But more than a month after Pritzker announced his bid for a rare third term, the state GOP has so far failed to field a big-name challenger to the billionaire Democratic governor or any of the other statewide Democratic officeholders ahead of their marquee event of Republican Day at the Illinois State Fair this week. Pritzker also during the Sunday morning program defended Illinois' heavily gerrymandered congressional map, which gave Democrats a 14-3 advantage in the state's U.S. House delegation. Pritzker noted that the map was done as part of the typical, post-federal census cycle of remapping rather than what Texas Republicans are attempting to do, which is redraw that state's congressional map mid-decade. Pritzker also said the Illinois map met federal voting rights requirements. 'Don't forget, the map that they put together, it violates the Voting Rights Act, and it violates the Constitution,' said of the efforts, which are being spearheaded by Texas Gov. Greg Abbott and were encouraged by President Donald Trump to try to flip five seats now held by Democrats to Republicans to protect the GOP's narrow U.S. House majority in the midterm through the end of Trump's second term. 'Gov. Abbott is the joke. He's the one who is attempting mid-decade here, at a time when frankly all of us are concerned about the future of democracy, he's literally helping whittle it away and licking the boots of his leader, Donald Trump,' Pritzker said. 'He's attempting to thwart federal law and take away five seats that are in the hands of Black, brown, minority Congresspeople and the people that they represent. He's taking those votes away. He's violating the Constitution,' he said. 'And all of us need to stand up and speak out and make sure that it's understood across the country that what they're trying to do in Texas is illegal.' Sunday marked one week since Texas House Democrats fled the state to Illinois and other northern states to prevent the GOP-led House chamber in Texas from having a quorum to conduct legislative business, including passing the new congressional map. The special legislative session House Democrats are boycotting is scheduled to end Aug. 19. 'The Texas Democrats that are here are welcome,' he said of a group of more than 30, who have been staying in west suburban St. Charles. 'We're providing them a safe haven, a place for them to visit and stay, breaking quorum, because they're heroes that are standing up not just for their own constituents and for the people of Texas and their rights but also for the rights of people all across the country.' Related Articles Texas Republicans ask Illinois court to order arrest of House Democrats who fled state as part of remap battle How Texas Democrats' walkout has launched a fight across the US over political maps FBI agrees to help find Texas Democrats in Illinois, but Gov. JB Pritzker calls move 'grandstanding' Gov. JB Pritzker says he's working with state and local authorities to protect Texas lawmakers, especially after suburban hotel bomb threat As a candidate for governor, Pritzker voiced support for the independent drawing of congressional and legislative boundaries and vowed to veto any map that is 'drafted or created by legislators, political party leaders and or their staffs or allies.' But he signed the post-2020 census maps drawn up by Democratic legislative leaders and has said lawmakers failed to take steps to enact an independent mapmaking system. On Facebook on Sunday, Pritzker threw the issue of congressional mapmaking to Congress. 'Donald Trump and Republicans are pushing illegal maps that violate the Voting Rights Act,' the governor wrote. 'Instead, Congress should pass fair, independent maps nationwide. Without that, Democratic states must consider all the options to protect our constitutional republic.' On Fox News Sunday, Abbott, the Texas governor, said the legislative stalemate 'could literally last years.' 'I'm authorized to call a special session every 30 days. It lasts 30 days, and as soon as this one is over, I'm going to call another one, then another one, then another one, then another one,' Abbott said. 'If they show back up in the state of Texas, they will be arrested and taken to the Capitol. If they want to evade that arrest, they're going to stay outside of the state of Texas for literally years, and they might as well just start voting in California or voting in Illinois, wherever they may be.' Though the Texas Supreme Court has said quorum-breaking is part of the state's constitution, Abbott has asked the state's highest court to declare the seats of House Democrats as 'abandoned' and allow him to fill the vacancies. Abbott belittled the efforts of Democratic governors, like California's Gavin Newsom and New York's Kathy Hochul, who have vowed to remap their states' congressional boundaries to counter actions by Texas. 'The fact of the matter is, they are bringing a gun to a gunfight, but they have no bullets because they lost their bullets when they engaged in redistricting, in gerrymandering, over the past decade,' he said. 'They've run out of Republicans that they can move out of office. If Texas had drawn our lines mathematically the same way that California had, we would be not adding five more seats. We would be adding 10 more seats.' Abbott also sought to dispel concerns about federal Voting Rights Act violations in the proposed GOP map, saying of the five seats being redrawn, 'four of the new seats will be predominantly Hispanic.' 'The problem that Democrats have in the state of Texas is Hispanics, Black voters and other voters. They have learned now that the ideas that Democrats stand for are contrary to the ideas that the Hispanic community and black community stand for,' he said.
