Why Plug-In Hybrids Aren't as Green as They Seem
So, while hybrid sales now largely rise faster than EV sales, why do these eco-darlings wear such a convincing mask?
Pull away from the curb with a full battery and you'll believe the hype. The cabin is eerily silent; the instant torque feels futuristic. But as the charge dips below a few dozen miles of electric range, the gas engine awakens - first a polite cough, then the familiar rumble of an internal-combustion motor. At that point, fuel consumption climbs to levels that rival conventional hybrids.
Key point: WLTP tests start with a full battery and measure over a short distance. They assume near-perfect charging habits. In everyday use - with longer trips, forgetful charging, or frequent cold starts - plug-in hybrids spend far more time in gasoline mode.
Lab versus road: WLTP rating: 27–36 g/km CO₂ Real-world: 85–114 g/km CO₂ Real emissions are ~3× higher Average multiplier: The European Commission's 2024 report finds PHEVs emit on average 3.5 times more CO₂ in real driving than in WLTP tests
Charging habits: Official figures assume drivers plug in before every trip. Surveys show many PHEV owners charge infrequently, reducing the share of electric kilometres and pushing up fuel use.Battery size and weight: Compact batteries limit all-electric range. Once depleted, the extra mass means the petrol engine works harder, raising consumption.Test cycle limitations: Laboratory procedures can't replicate real-world factors-ambient temperature, driving style, terrain, or accessory use (air-con, heating).
Related: Shopping for a 2025 BMW 3-Series? Here's What Experts Say You Should Look at Instead
The "utility factor" estimates the share of electric driving. WLTP assumes a high UF based on ideal conditions; real-world surveys report widely varying UFs, often below 60%, especially in colder climates or for longer commutes. Exact values depend on driver behaviour, geography, and charging infrastructure - but rarely match the theoretical maximum.
Complexity and cost: More components = higher purchase price and maintenanceEnvironmental trade-offs: Battery production has significant carbon footprint; heavy vehicles can cause more tyre and brake wearBehavioural rebound: Feeling "eco-friendly" may encourage longer trips or less fuel-efficient driving once the engine engages
PHEVs offer a partial bridge to full electrification - useful for drivers with irregular charging access who still want some electric miles. But they require disciplined charging and realistic expectations. Unplugged, they function as petrol cars with extra ballast.
For genuine emissions reductions, battery-electric vehicles (BEVs) currently deliver the most predictable real-world performance - no tailpipe emissions, simpler powertrain, and steadily improving charging networks.
Plug-in hybrids blur the line between electric and combustion power, and their marketing can oversell the environmental benefits. Verified data show real-world CO₂ emissions are roughly three to four times laboratory values. If you choose a PHEV, plan to charge faithfully and evaluate whether its limited electric range fits your driving patterns. Otherwise, you may be driving a "green" badge on a gas-car platform - without so much green.
Copyright 2025 The Arena Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
21 hours ago
- Yahoo
Mechanic reveals ‘expensive' cars Aussies should avoid buying: ‘Don't last'
An Aussie mechanic has revealed the popular car brands he recommends people steer clear of unless they are prepared to be hit with extra costs. He said the brands 'don't last' as long and are more expensive to service and maintain. Talal Almasri has been a mechanic for more than 15 years and said he'd seen his fair share of car brands. The 42-year-old Sydney mobile mechanic, who works on Airtasker, told Yahoo Finance he generally advised people to avoid buying European cars like Volkswagen, Mercedes, Audi and BMW. Almasri said European cars were built for colder environments and were 'very expensive' to get parts for and more expensive to service. RELATED Major EV warning as true battery range for big brands like Tesla and BYD exposed ANZ hikes home loan interest rates in 'surprise' move ahead of RBA cash rate meeting Little-known Centrelink perk offers Australian students free flights 'The brakes will cost you more, the maintenance will cost you more, parts will be on order and you have to let it sit there for a few days, for example, for the mechanic to order the part,' he said. 'As long as you're prepared [to pay that extra cost]. If you're not prepared, that's when I say don't buy one. If you're on a budget with your expenses, the European car is not going to help you.' Almasri said one of his customers, for example, was recently quoted $3,000 to do the front brake pads on her Mercedes AMG GLC63. Almasri said he would instead recommend people go for a Japanese car, such as a Toyota, Nissan, Mazda or Mitsubishi. 'Parts are available, they are reliable and they do last in the Australian climate as long as you maintain them,' he said. Almasri said customers often told him they didn't like the more 'basic' Japanese cars and preferred the look and feel of European cars. 'As long as you're happy to pay the maintenance cost, that's all that matters. It's going to cost you more, the parts, the labour, everything's more expensive,' he said. Major car mistake millions of Aussies are making No matter which car brand you go with, Almasri said the key to making sure your car lasts was regular maintenance. 'If you don't maintain it, it will blow up, even if it's a Toyota. Toyota is unbreakable as long as you maintain it,' he told Yahoo Finance. 'It's the people that leave it overdue and wait and wait and wait, this is where you are going to have problems, where you're gonna get something damaged and it's gonna cost you more in the long term.' Recent Finder research found that one in four motorists had avoided taking their car in for a scheduled service due to financial constraints. Finder insurance expert Taylor Blackburn said many households were finding it harder to prioritise car maintenance given the rising cost of living. 'Keeping a car on the road is becoming increasingly expensive due to rising costs in maintenance, fuel, and insurance," he said. 'Ignoring minor car troubles, like a cracked hose or a dirty filter, might seem like a way to save money now, but these cheap fixes can quickly escalate into expensive repairs if left unaddressed." Almasri recommended servicing your car every six months or every 10,000 kilometres, whichever comes first. He also urged drivers not to wait until their fuel tank was nearly empty before filling up. 'You've got to fill up as soon as, minimum, you have a quarter of a tank. Do not run it lower than that because that's when you can create problems from the bottom of the fuel tank and the fuel pump can get damaged by sucking up usually dirt at the bottom of the fuel tank,' he said. 'When people drive with the fuel light on, I would not recommend that. Do not do that, that's very dangerous.'
Forbes
2 days ago
- Forbes
U.S. Tariff Snags Add To Europe Carmakers' Weak Sales, China Woes
Europe's carmakers, facing weaker sales and increased Chinese competition, will now have an added burden from U.S. tariff challenges. Sales of sedans and SUVs in Western Europe will likely slip about 2% in 2025, according to Auto Forecast Solutions, while GlobalData expects a 1.4% decline to 11.4 million. That compares with stagnation in 2024 and a big jump in 2023 of nearly 14% after the Covid pandemic. Current sales are still about 3 million shy of pre-Covid. 'Difficulty in foreseeing growth in exports after the U.S. trade deal means the local market will grow slowly over the next few years,' Auto Forecast Solutions said in its latest monthly report. Western Europe includes the big 5 markets of Germany, France, Britain, Italy and Spain. European manufacturers' second quarter financial reports included weaker profits, huge losses, and profit warnings. BMW was hurt the least as its profits declined, although the 5.4% margin was within its guidance. Mercedes cut its profit guidance. Volkswagen took a €1.3 billion ($1.5 billion) hit from tariff issue problems and cut its profit forecast. Multi-brand Stellantis lost €2.3 billion ($2.7 billion) in the first half. Volvo announced a $1 billion operating loss in the second quarter. Renault reported a net loss of €11.2 billion ($13.0 billion) in the first half. Second-quarter poor but could worsen HSBC Global Investment Research called second-quarter results disappointing but things could get worse. 'A tough quarter but it might not be the watershed we hoped for,' HSBC said in a report. HSBC said the reasons were varied, including pricing in the EU and soft volumes. The EU tariff deal with the U.S. was welcomed because it lowered tariffs from the proposed 27.5% to 15%. This compared with the previous 2.5%. 'But most of the carmakers were hoping for something more generous that reflected U.S. exports from BMW and Mercedes, or inward investment in the U.S. for VW.,' according to the report. Perhaps the Europeans should take some comfort after a report from the Wall Street Journal on Thursday which said automakers will take a collective set of losses totalling almost $12 billion from what it called the 'tariff wars'. Many foreign manufacturers will need to move production to the U.S., it said. The list was headed by Toyota with losses of just over $3 billion. Volkswagen was way back in second place on the list with losses about half that, with GM and Ford red ink close to $1 billion. 'Beyond the continuing cost of tariffs, automakers in the U.S., Japan, South Korea and Europe face years of retooling and supply-chain tweaks to adjust to the new realities,' according to the WSJ's Stephen Wilmot. Mergers, or the demise of weaker brands In Europe, manufacturers are being pressured by European Union rules designed to force all new car buyers into electric vehicles by 2035 and 80% by 2030. The rules were set up despite China's clear advantage in EV technology. This will put huge pressure on European profits as they struggle to meet ever-tighter CO2 emissions rules while being forced to shed big profit-making internal combustion engine-powered vehicles. This is likely to force weaker participants into mergers or may see the demise of marginal brands. Meanwhile, the Trump Administration has dumped its mandates to force buyers into EVs. This means that instead of previously mandated 50% share of EV new car sales by 2030, the market will allow consumers to decide, and market share is likely to be closer to 20%. Some politicians in the European Parliament are seeking to dilute EU rules. This may become more urgent if important European manufacturers look to be in danger of collapse at the expense of Chinese success.
Motor 1
2 days ago
- Motor 1
BMW's Electric M Cars Won't Have Silly Names: Report
BMW's Neue Klasse era officially kicks off next month with the debut of the iX3. Soon, every BMW will look like and have similar features to the automaker's bold new electric SUV— including performance cars. Thankfully, though, most of them should retain their iconic names. A post on the Bimmerpost forum by the user ynguldyn suggests that BMW won't add the letter "i" to the front of its new performance models. Instead, the performance variant of the iX3 , for example, will continue to be called the X3 M. M Performance models, though, will supposedly retain the letter "i" at the front of their nameplates; iX3 M60 xDrive. A separate BMW insider confirmed to Motor1 that these reports are indeed true. Production of those performance models won't kick off until sometime in 2027, the post suggests. The standard iX3, meanwhile, debuts next month in Munich and goes on sale in the US early in 2026. This coincides with reports from 2023, in which BMW M boss Frank van Meel said that the company would never use "i" and "M" letters together on the same vehicle. "We would never use an i on an M, even though it would be electric," Van Meel told Top Gear . BMW did trademark the name "iM3" in 2023, but that nameplate will likely never see the light of day. Of course, electric M cars aren't the only performance vehicles on the horizon. BMW recently confirmed that the inline-six and V-8 engines in its M cars aren't going anywhere. The company recently updated those engines to meet stricter Euro 7 regulations, and it promises to continue using them in M performance cars in the future. The Latest From BMW BMW Has Confirmed a New X7. Here's Everything We Know BMW Just Set the Coolest Nürburgring Record Source: Bimmerpost Share this Story Facebook X LinkedIn Flipboard Reddit WhatsApp E-Mail Got a tip for us? Email: tips@ Join the conversation ( )
