Judge to go ahead with review of Alberta separation question
Court of King's Bench Justice Colin Feasby says it will benefit democracy to have a full hearing on the constitutionality of the question.
Alberta's chief electoral officer, Gordon McClure, referred the question to court last month so a judge could determine whether it violates the Constitution, including treaty rights.
The group that submitted the question applied to have the referral quashed.
The Alberta Prosperity Project wants to ask: 'Do you agree that the Province of Alberta shall become a sovereign country and cease to be a province in Canada?'
A lawyer for the group argued judicial scrutiny is premature, since there's no guarantee enough signatures would be gathered to put the question on a ballot.
Story continues below advertisement
He also said the act of asking a question doesn't violate the Constitution.
1:50
Petition led by former deputy premier to keep Alberta within Canada begins
Lawyers for Justice Minister Mickey Amery and the chief electoral officer did not take a position on quashing the referral.
Get breaking National news
For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
Amery and Premier Danielle Smith have criticized the electoral officer's decision to refer the question to the court, saying it should be approved and only face judicial scrutiny if it garners a majority vote in a referendum.
'Alberta's government believes that the proposal is not unconstitutional and therefore should be approved and permitted to proceed,' Amery's press secretary, Heather Jenkins, in a statement last week.
'It is settled law that any province is entitled to consult its population by referendum on any issue.'
Feasby said McClure was just doing his job and following international best practices for administering referendums.
Story continues below advertisement
A letter from Amery's lawyer to the judge last week said the minister plans to make submissions if there is a review.
Other groups, including the Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation in northern Alberta, have said they also hope to make submissions.
2:01
Indigenous chiefs accuse Premier Danielle Smith of stoking Alberta separatism talk
If the proposed question is approved, the Alberta Prosperity Project and its chief executive officer, Mitch Sylvestre, would need to collect 177,000 signatures in four months to get it on a ballot.
A competing referendum question was approved by McClure in June and asks if Alberta should declare an official policy that it will never separate from Canada.
Efforts to gather signatures for that proposal, put forward by former Progressive Conservative deputy premier Thomas Lukaszuk, got underway earlier this month.
Story continues below advertisement
Lukaszuk needs to collect nearly 300,000 signatures in 90 days in order to get his question on a ballot, as his application was approved before new provincial rules with lower signature thresholds took effect.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
3 minutes ago
- Global News
Trump says he'll push for Ukraine ceasefire at ‘high stakes' Putin summit
U.S. President Donald Trump said he would be disappointed if Friday's pivotal sit-down with Russian President Vladimir Putin doesn't lead to an immediate ceasefire in Ukraine, setting new stakes for a summit that could determine the trajectory of the war. Trump made the comments as he flew to Alaska to meet with Putin, who is expected to hold firm to his long-term goals in Ukraine, including cementing territorial gains and eventually pulling the former Soviet republic back under Russia's control. Ukraine and its European and Canadian allies — as well as Ukrainian diasporas in Canada and around the world — are pushing to ensure Trump doesn't make a deal with Putin without Kyiv's involvement. Trump told reporters aboard Air Force One he's 'not here to negotiate for Ukraine' and that further diplomacy will be necessary, but made clear he's looking for 'certain things' — including an end to the fighting. Story continues below advertisement 'I want to see a ceasefire rapidly,' he said. 'I don't know if it's going to happen today, but I'm not going to be happy if it doesn't happen today. … I'm just saying I want the killing to stop.' 1:57 Trump keeps lowering expectations of summit with Putin Russian forces this week have breached the Ukrainian front lines in the eastern Donetsk region, one of four Ukrainian regions that Russia illegally annexed in 2022. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said Friday on Telegram that Russian attacks continued overnight as the Alaska summit drew near. The Kremlin says the summit at Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson in Anchorage, Alaska, is set to start at 11:30 a.m. local time, which is 3:30 p.m. eastern time. Trump said in an interview with Fox News on Thursday that he will either hold a joint press conference alongside Putin after the meeting or hold his own press conference alone, depending on the outcome of the talks. Story continues below advertisement 'HIGH STAKES!!!' Trump posted on Truth Social before boarding Air Force One. What's at stake for U.S., Russia and Ukraine? Trump vowed throughout his re-election campaign last year that he would solve the Russia-Ukraine conflict within 24 hours of taking office. Yet he acknowledged Thursday that the war was 'the most complicated' among other global conflicts his administration has sought to end. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy For Putin, the invitation to Alaska effectively ended the years-long western strategy of isolating the Russian leader that was spearheaded by former U.S. president Joe Biden. Putin said Thursday the talks could set the stage for a new long-term nuclear arms treaty with the U.S., after he scuttled the previous deal amid mounting U.S. and European sanctions and as NATO steadily increased its military aid to Ukraine. Moscow is also seeking to restore economic ties with the U.S. as its domestic economy struggles under high inflation and a focus on its military industries. Story continues below advertisement Trump said Friday that business deals with Russia were possible, but 'they're not doing business until we get the war settled.' 2:49 Trump warns 'severe consequences' if Putin doesn't end war in Ukraine The U.S. president has promised additional sanctions on Russia and other 'severe consequences' if Putin doesn't demonstrate a willingness to make peace. Previous deadlines for a ceasefire deal set by Trump have come and gone without any action from the U.S. A sanctions package endorsed by Republicans and Democrats has stalled in the U.S. Senate until Trump explicitly endorses it, something he has yet to do. Trump said Friday his talks with Putin will include Russian demands that Ukraine cede territory as part of a peace deal. He said Ukraine has to decide, but he also suggested Zelenskyy should accept concessions. 'I've got to let Ukraine make that decision. And I think they'll make a proper decision,' Trump told reporters travelling with him to Alaska. Story continues below advertisement Trump had previously said 'land swapping' would likely be included in any peace deal and that Ukraine would get at least some of its territory occupied by Russia back. Zelenskyy had repeatedly said ceding territory is an unacceptable concession for Ukraine, whose borders are enshrined in its constitution. Changing them would require a referendum among the Ukrainian people. Trump also said there's 'a possibility' of the U.S. offering Ukraine security guarantees alongside European powers, 'but not in the form of NATO.' Putin has fiercely resisted Ukraine joining the trans-Atlantic security alliance, a long-term goal for Ukrainians seeking to forge stronger ties with the West. 2:00 Ukraine must be involved in peace deal, EU leaders warn The meeting comes as the war has caused heavy losses on both sides and drained resources. Story continues below advertisement The United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights reported this month that the number of civilian casualties in Ukraine in July was the highest on record since May 2022. Prime Minister Mark Carney took part in talks Wednesday with European leaders and spoke directly with Zelenskyy on Monday. He said Canada's partners are 'united on shared principles,' particularly that Ukrainians must decide on their own future. Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand spoke with her Ukrainian counterpart Thursday and said borders can't be changed by violence. 'We will continue to support Ukraine through diplomatic measures, military assistance and economic aid to hold Russia accountable for its illegal war,' she wrote on social media, adding that Canada's support is 'unwavering.' Ukrainian Canadian community leaders and humanitarian advocates say they're cautiously optimistic that Trump is listening to the pressure from Canada and Europe to stand up for Ukraine's interests — warning that appeasement will only embolden Putin and Russia. 'I think we're going to find out, is President Trump there to be an ally of Russia or an ally of Ukraine, or some third option,' said Ihor Michalchyshyn, CEO and executive director of the Ukrainian Canadian Congress. —With files from The Associated Press and Reuters
Global News
an hour ago
- Global News
Conservatives call for inquiry into ‘appalling' government spending on Canadian ISIS women
The Conservatives are calling for an inquiry into the government's 'appalling' expenditures on Canadian ISIS women returning home from Syria. A letter signed by Tory MPs on Friday asked the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security to convene immediately to deal with the matter. The move came after Global News reported that declassified documents showed Ottawa spent at least $170,000 on the women and their children. The money paid for costs incurred when eight women who had travelled to Syria to join the Islamic State returned to Canada with their kids in 2022 and 2023. Expense reports released under the Access to Information Act showed business class flights, stays at a Marriott hotel, room service, junk food and alcohol. Among the expenses, which were for both the families and government staff, was a $95 wine tab, $24 sandwiches and purchases of chips, chocolate bars and Timbits, as well as a $2,800 catering fee for a banquet. Story continues below advertisement 'The fact that these items were purchased for those detained as alleged terrorists is appalling in itself,' the MPs wrote in a letter addressed to committee chair Jean-Yves Duclos. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'With Canadians lining up in food banks in record numbers and struggling with housing costs, the Liberal government must answer for why they spent $170,000 on lavish costs to repatriate reported ISIS criminals.' View image in full screen Expense reports released under Access to Information Act on costs of repatriating Canadian ISIS women and their kids. Global News The letter, obtained by Global News, said the opposition was 'calling for the committee to be immediately recalled to launch a full inquiry into this matter.' Under parliamentary rules, if four members of a committee, representing at least two political parties, request a meeting, the clerk must do so within five days. The Bloc representatives of the committee would have to sign on before it would prompt a meeting. Story continues below advertisement Global News requested details on the costs of the repatriations under the Access to Information Act two years ago. The department did not release any materials until Aug. 7, 2025. Even then, they do not cover the full costs associated with the repatriation. Global Affairs Canada said it was still consulting with a foreign government about releasing those. The women were living in B.C., Alberta, Ontario and Quebec when they travelled to Syria and Iraq to live under ISIS rule. All were eventually captured when ISIS fell to U.S.-backed Kurdish fighters and an international coalition that included the Canadian Forces. The federal government agreed to bring the women and children back to Canada after their families launched a case in the Federal Court demanding their return. In a statement to Global News, Global Affairs declined to answer questions about its expenses or disclose the full costs associated with repatriating the Canadians. 'While we cannot comment on specific expenditures related to the operation, Global Affairs Canada assumed certain immediate costs to support the safe return and well-being of the women and children repatriated to Canada,' it said.
Global News
2 hours ago
- Global News
Premier Smith, Alberta Next panel face hecklers, supporters at fiery Edmonton event
A travelling panel collecting public feedback on Alberta's grievances with Ottawa struggled to keep an emotionally-charged crowd on topic at its third summer town hall on Thursday night. Premier Danielle Smith and members of her Alberta Next panel drew its biggest crowd yet — nearly 750 people — in Edmonton to brainstorm about possible future referendum questions. View image in full screen Protestors gather outside a town hall hosted by the UCP's Alberta Next panel in Edmonton on Thursday to show their opposition to the idea of Alberta separation. Global News Division and outrage in the room quickly spilled over into anger, F-bombs, and challenges to Smith's United Conservative Party government that weren't on the agenda, from health care to accountability and transparency. Story continues below advertisement When asked why the UCP had recently removed a requirement for ministers and senior staff to publicly release receipts for expense claims over $100, Smith said something went awry and made an unexpected policy announcement. The change was supposed to be an effort to keep the location of frequently-used hotels for government trips redacted, she said. 'We're going to see if we can maybe try to track down what happened and do a reversal,' said Smith. In her friendly opening remarks, Smith said 'when Edmonton speaks, we listen.' She was met with a flutter of guffaws from one end of the room. 1:49 Frustrations aired to Danielle Smith at 'Alberta Next' town halls As the lineups to two open mics in the room grew difficult to corral, off-topic questions and comments drew frequent interruptions from the crowd and the moderator, Bruce McAllister. Story continues below advertisement He soon became the target of vocal disdain. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy In an effort at crowd control, he compared the behaviour of some in the crowd to that of a toddler in a grocery store throwing a tantrum. Many who spoke at the mic were critical of the proposals and the panel's mission. But most in attendance registered their support for the panel's six policy ideas in straw polls, including pulling out of the Canada Pension Plan and creating a provincial police force to replace the RCMP. Some cheered enthusiastically as pre-released videos were projected beside the stage. View image in full screen Supporters of the idea of Alberta separation gather outside the town hall hosted by the Alberta Next panel in Edmonton on Thursday. Global News With a show of hands, the crowd came down in favour of ideas like withholding social services for some immigrants, and reforming federal cash transfers and equalization. Story continues below advertisement Others in attendance pushed back and got heated over issues like health care. Some called the government's videos propaganda, misinformation, or in one case, 'disgusting' for appearing to blame newcomers for pressures on housing and social services. Several people questioned why the UCP wasn't focused on addressing more basic public needs. At one point, one man asked: 'Why do we think we should have to fight tooth and nail for our right to health care?' Smith was soon defending her government's decision to force many Albertans to pay for COVID-19 vaccinations this fall. The premier noted that COVID shots are no longer being funded by the federal government, and was met with heckles. 'It's true,' Smith said, punctuated with some light profanity in a response that was met with applause. 2:00 Concerns raised around 'roadblocks' to access the COVID 19 vaccine for vulnerable groups In her closing remarks, she acknowledged the polarization in the room, but insisted Alberta can't expect to get a fair deal from the federal government 'just by sitting down and having tea together.' Story continues below advertisement 'I am all for diplomacy, but you have to be willing to meet people on a two way street,' she said, pointing to federal green electricity policies she has long labelled unachievable. Smith has said one of the reasons for the panel is to address concerns that are inspiring separatist sentiment in the province. Opposition NDP Leader Naheed Nenshi has said there are provincial grievances with Ottawa that need to be addressed, but has dismissed the panel as a way for Smith to curry favour with extreme elements of the UCP to keep them from splintering off. He's also said the government is using it to conjure up unreliable data to support things it already wants to do. The panel also held town halls last month in Red Deer and Edmonton. All three drew protesters at the gates and inside, dismissals of the panel as a self-serving political exercise meant to stir up discontent and division. It is next set to host events in Fort McMurray and Lloydminster in two weeks.
