Allahabad High Court sets aside Juvenile Justice Board, Pocso court orders; directs minor to be tried as ‘juvenile' and not as an adult
The court observed, 'This court has no hesitation to hold that the nefarious effects of the visual mediums like television, internet, and social media on adolescents are not being controlled, nor it appears that the government can control the same, to prevent its deleterious effect on the adolescents, due to the uncontrollable nature of technologies involved. The 'Nirbhaya case' was an exception and not a general rule and all juveniles cannot be subjected and tried like adult without proper consideration of the overall social and psychological effects on their psyche.'
The criminal revision claimed that the impugned orders wrongly held the revisionist to be tried as an adult, and his assessment by the Juvenile Justice Board, as well as the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (Pocso) court, is not in accordance with the law.
The counsel for the revisionist submitted that in the case of both the assessment and medical reports, the experts held that the psychological assessment of the juvenile was suggestive of a mild deficit in intellectual functioning.
But the Board had relied upon the allegations made in the First Information Report and the statement of the victim recorded under Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) by ignoring the clinical psychologist report and held that it was not bound by the reports submitted by the experts. The counsel argued that denying the expert report will frustrate the provisions of Section 15 (1) of the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015.
The counsel for the State submitted that although the preliminary assessment report and the report of psychologist are in favour of the minor boy, the Board has recorded clear findings that the revisionist was able to understand the consequence of crime committed by him and, therefore, the Board was not bound to accept the report of the psychologist and held that the revisionist be tried as an adult.
'There is nothing on record to indicate that the revisionist is a predator on the prowl and is prone to repeating the offence without any provocation. He never indulged in any such or other offence earlier. Maturity of his mind has not been certified by the psychologist. Merely because he committed a heinous crime he cannot be put to par with an adult when his social exposure was also found to be deficient by the psychologist,' the high court stated in its order.
'In view of above consideration, the impugned judgments and orders passed by both the courts below are set aside. Criminal Revision is allowed. The revisionist is directed to be tried as a juvenile by the Juvenile Justice Board in accordance with law,' the court added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
39 minutes ago
- Time of India
Interfaith marriages without religious conversion illegal: Alld HC
Prayagraj: The Allahabad high court ruled that interfaith marriages without religious conversion are illegal and refused to quash criminal proceedings against a man accused of marrying a minor at an Arya Samaj temple, reports Rajesh Kumar Pandey. The Allahabad High Court directed the state home secretary to investigate how Arya Samaj temples are issuing marriage certificates without following rules and submit a compliance report. The court declined to set aside the criminal proceedings against the man who married a minor after allegedly kidnapping her. In his order dated July 24, Justice Prasant Kumar made it clear that the investigation has to be made by an officer not below the rank of deputy commissioner of police. Before passing the above directions, the court found that the applicant and the victim belong to different religions. "There is averment in the application that they have solemnized marriage in Arya Samaj Mandir at Prayagraj. However, the same could not have been done without proper conversion as per the existing law," added the court. With these observations and directives, the court dismissed the petition filed by one Sonu alias Shahnur, who had moved the court to quash summoning order dated September 12, 2024 issued against him as well as the entire proceedings of criminal case going on against him under section 363 (punishment), 366 (kidnapping a woman to compel her to marry) 376 (rape) of IPC and sections 3/4 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offence (Pocso) Act at Nichlaul police station of Maharajganj district. During the course of hearing, the counsel for the applicant submitted that Shahnur had solemnized marriage with the victim on February 14, 2020. He further submitted that since the girl was minor, she was sent to Nari Niketan and when she became an adult, she started living with the applicant. On other hand, the government counsel submitted that the girl is minor as per her high school certificate and she could not have solemnized marriage with the applicant. He submitted that the applicant and the victim come from different religions, as such, their marriage cannot be considered valid until and unless proper conversion is carried out in accordance with the provisions of the UP Prohibition of Unlawful Conversion of Religion Act, 2021. He further submitted that the marriage certificate has been issued by Arya Samaj Mandir, which seems to be a fabricated document. In support of his arguments, the state counsel quoted an earlier order passed by this court, in which the court pointed out that certain people who claim themselves of Arya Samaj and are getting marriages solemnized illegally with mala fide intentions without even verifying the age of the couple. The court will hear the case next on August 29.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Delhi Police's Fingerprint Bureau Gets ISO Certification
New Delhi: The Fingerprint Bureau of achieved a notable milestone by receiving the ISO 9001:2015 certificate. This quality management system standard acknowledges its rigorous methods and procedures in fingerprint analysis and crime investigation, as certified by a quality control certification body. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now This is significant as the certification has made the investigations validated by the bureau more credible, according to police. The bureau helped crack a significant number of cases in the last three years, the data shows. According to special commissioner of police Devesh Srivastava, the bureau helped solve 171 cases in 2022, while 275 cases were solved in 2023, and the figure rose to 314 in 2024. By July 25, the bureau already helped crack 101 cases. Given the performance of the last few years, police brass decided to obtain the standardisation of its work. The processes and technicalities of its working were formalised and documented. After a thorough audit of the procedure and documentation, the Quality Control Certification granted the ISO 9001:2015 certificate to the Fingerprint Bureau Unit. Established in 1983, the bureau is a specialised wing that plays a crucial role in identifying suspects and linking them to crime scenes through scientific analysis of fingerprints. "Initially, fingerprint-related work for Delhi Police was managed by the Fingerprint Bureau in Phillaur, Punjab. While this arrangement served its purpose, the process of obtaining fingerprint results was often time-consuming and challenging for Investigating Officers," Srivastava recalled. Recognising the need for a more efficient and streamlined system, the establishment of an independent Fingerprint Bureau for the Union Territory of Delhi was proposed. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now In response, a full-fledged Fingerprint Bureau was set up in 1983 at RK Puram. The first batch of fingerprint cadre personnel joined in 1985, marking the beginning of expert, in-house fingerprint analysis in Delhi. "With a vast database pool of over 5 lakh criminals, the bureau, which is a part of the crime branch, utilises advanced forensic techniques and software to deliver accurate and timely results," Srivastava said. The Fingerprint Bureau databases include the Automated Fingerprint Identification System (AFPIS), the National Automated Fingerprint Identification System (NAFIS), and the Crime Record Information System (CRIS). The use of modern technology and traditional expertise has made it an indispensable part of Delhi Police's crime-solving mechanism, members of the team said. "The bureau's activities include capturing finger/palm prints of arrested and convicted persons, editing and analysing received finger/palm slips, and operating modern applications. The unit also imparts training and refresher courses for Delhi Police personnel and other law enforcement agencies," explained a senior officer. The ISO standard provides a framework for consistently delivering services that meet court and regulatory requirements, ultimately contributing to a higher rate of conviction. The bureau's director, Sanjay Jha, works in close coordination with DCP Harsh Indora to analyse possible suspects in crimes. This certification is expected to further improve the quality and legal value of evidence. "This recognition highlights the unit's commitment to maintaining high standards in crime investigation. It is also a testament to the police striving for quality management and public satisfaction," Srivastava added.
Time of India
4 hours ago
- Time of India
Health dept distances itself from rape accused
Gaya: The health department has clarified that the ambulance driver and technician accused of raping a home guard job aspirant in Gaya are not its regular employees but were hired through a private agency. The alleged incident took place on July 24 when the woman was raped inside a slow-moving ambulance between the Bihar Military Police (BMP) ground and Anugrah Narayan Magadh Medical College Hospital. Speaking to reporters, Gaya civil surgeon Dr Raja Ram Prasad said, "Both the driver and the technician are not regular employees of the health department. Their recruitment was done by a private agency engaged at the state level. Therefore, the question of departmental action against them does not arise." When asked whether background checks had been conducted before the duo were deployed, the civil surgeon said, "It is for the agency to explain." On the medical report of the survivor, Bodh Gaya SDPO Saurav Jaiswal said it was expected to be made available soon. "The sealed report will be received by the investigating officer, Rinku Kumari," he said. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like No annual fees for life UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo Gaya SSP Anand Kumar said the survivor's statement would be recorded before a judicial magistrate. "The statement will be taken under Section 183 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), which is the amended version of Section 164 of the CrPC," he said. Meanwhile, questions have been raised over possible administrative lapses at the recruitment venue. Authorities have yet to clarify whether a doctor was present at the site or who authorised the woman's hospitalisation without standard precautions, such as ensuring a woman attendant accompanied her.
