logo
‘Arbitrary, to be replicated in Bengal.' What pleas by ADR, Mahua challenging EC's Bihar exercise say

‘Arbitrary, to be replicated in Bengal.' What pleas by ADR, Mahua challenging EC's Bihar exercise say

The Printa day ago
While Moitra argued this was a violation of the right(s) to equality, freedom of speech and expression and life, Yadav also termed the decision 'manifestly arbitrary, unreasonable and violative of electoral laws'.
The origins of this case lie in a June 24 decision of the ECI, which directed the state election commission to conduct a special intensive revision of the electoral polls in Bihar.
New Delhi: Trinamool Congress (TMC) MP Mahua Moitra and Bharat Jodo Abhiyan national convener Yogendra Yadav, among others, have moved the Supreme Court against the Election Commission of India's (ECI) decision to conduct a Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in poll-bound Bihar, saying that a similar second revision of the voters list can be replicated in the state of West Bengal, in a similar fashion.
'It is submitted that it is for the very first time in the country that such an exercise is being conducted by the ECI, where electors whose names are already there in electoral rolls and who have already voted multiple times in are being asked to prove their eligibility,' Moitra's petition contended.
Apart from this, similar petitions have been filed by non-profit organisations Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR) and People's Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL). Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) MP Manoj Jha has also filed a similar petition before the top court.
ADR's petition, which has been filed through advocate Prashant Bhushan, also mentions alleged lack of due process and an 'unreasonably short timeline' for the revision exercise to take place, while adding that it could result in the removal of lakhs of genuine voters from electoral rolls leading to their disenfranchisement.
'ECI has issued unreasonable and impractical timeline to conduct SIR in Bihar with close proximity to state elections which are due in November 2025. There are lakhs of citizens who do not possess the documents as required under the SIR order, there are many who may be able to procure the documents but the short timeline mentioned in the directive may preclude them from being able to supply the same within the time period,' it argued.
Also Read: 'Worst attack' on Constitution, says Oppn after meeting EC over voter verification drive in Bihar
Mahua Moitra's petition
In her petition, Moitra also argued that the ECI's move violated provisions of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, and Articles 325 and 326 of the Constitution which state that no one can be ineligible for inclusion in a special electoral roll on grounds of religion, race, caste or sex, and mandate universal adult franchise for all.
By way of her petition filed through advocate Neha Rathi, Moitra said she has information that the '(SIR) exercise is stated to be replicated in West Bengal from August 2025 for which instructions have already been given'.
Saying that such a revision of electoral rolls is a direct threat to democratic rights, Moitra's petition argued that the electoral body was acting at the behest of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), and was attempting to disenfranchise millions of voters, especially migrants and the economically disadvantaged.
If not set aside, the order can lead to large-scale disenfranchisement of eligible voters in the country and undermining of democracy and free and fair elections in the country, Moitra said while adding that the ECI must be restrained from issuing similar orders in other states too.
Yogendra Yadav's petition
By way of his PIL, Yadav challenged the ECI's special exercise in Bihar, saying it violated Section 22 of the RP Act, and Rule 21-A of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, since both laws require procedural safeguards before deletion of names.
Section 22 of the 1950 Act, outlines the process for correcting, transposing, or deleting entries in electoral rolls. It states that the Electoral Registration Officer (ERO) is allowed to make changes to electoral rolls, either on an application or on their own motion, after an inquiry. However, such changes can be made only if an entry is erroneous, or there is a change of residence within the constituency, or requires deletion in case of someone's death.
On the other hand, Rule 21-A talks about the process of including names which have inadvertently or erroneously been omitted due to some
The ECI order
ECI's June 26 order directing that an SIR be conducted requires the inclusion or retention of a voter's name in the electoral roll upon producing citizenship documents, like citizenship proof from either or both parents.
If a voter cannot furnish this, they run the risk of exclusion.
Moitra said this violates Article 326, which grants universal adult franchise to all persons, and introduces extraneous requirements which are not originally envisaged under the RP Act, 1950. The order arbitrarily excludes commonly accepted identity documents such as Aadhaar and ration cards from the list of accepted documents, which puts a 'huge burden' on the voters who are at a risk of getting disenfranchised, the petition said.
It also pointed to current field reports from the state of Bihar that confirm that lakhs of residents across rural and marginalised areas in Bihar are at an imminent risk of disenfranchisement due to these stringent and unreasonable requirements.
(Edited by Amrtansh Arora)
Also Read: ECI's voter verification drive in Bihar is tailor-made to keep Dalits, Muslims, EBCs out
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

‘Misleading': Election Commission Fact-Checks Kharge's Post On Bihar Voter List Revision
‘Misleading': Election Commission Fact-Checks Kharge's Post On Bihar Voter List Revision

News18

time32 minutes ago

  • News18

‘Misleading': Election Commission Fact-Checks Kharge's Post On Bihar Voter List Revision

Last Updated: The ECI dubbed the Kharge's claim as "misleading" and said that there were no change in the instructions of SIR that is being carried out in Bihar ahead of the assembly elections. The Election Commission of India (ECI) on Monday fact-checked Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge over Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of voters' list in Bihar, who had claimed that the poll body has amended the process of voter verification from asking for documents to only filling a form without any documents citing a newspaper advertisement. The ECI dubbed the Kharge's claim as 'misleading" and said that there were no change in the instructions of SIR that is being carried out in the state ahead of the assembly elections. 'The claim made in this post, that no document is required and only filling the form is sufficient, is misleading. There is no change in the instructions. SIR is being conducted as per the orders dated 24.06.2025. While submitting the filled enumeration form before 25th July 2025 is mandatory, the documents can be submitted at any time either before 25th July 2025 or during the claims and objections period," the ECI said in a post on X. Meanwhile, the Election Commission's decision to initiate a Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of Bihar's electoral roll in the run-up to the assembly elections later this year has triggered major political controversy. The opposition parties have been alleging that the BJP is trying to snatch voting rights from crores of people in Bihar. On Sunday, the Congress President accused the BJP of conspiring to deprive the people of Bihar of their voter rights through the revision of electoral rolls and said the voters of the state would teach the saffron party a lesson for its attack on democracy and the Constitution. He cited a new advertisement issued by the Election Commission (EC), urging the voters of Bihar to only fill a form under the SIR, and alleged that 'when people rise, BJP backtracks". 'With the support of the Election Commission, the master plan that the BJP had devised to deprive crores of people in Bihar of their voting rights now seems to be ensnaring the BJP itself," Kharge alleged in a post in Hindi on X. भाजपा ने चुनाव आयोग के सहयोग से, बिहार में करोड़ों लोगों का वोटिंग का अधिकार छीनने का जो मास्टर प्लॉन बनाया था, उसमें अब भाजपा खुद फँसती नज़र आ रही है।पहले दिन से ही, कांग्रेस पार्टी Special Intensive Revision of Electoral Rolls (SIR) के ख़िलाफ़ आवाज़ उठा रही है। जो लोग… — Mallikarjun Kharge (@kharge) July 6, 2025 'Why are people who have been voting election after election being asked to show their documents for voting? 'Forcibly depriving the poor, weak, deprived, Dalits, oppressed and backward people of their voting rights is the conspiracy of the BJP-RSS," he alleged. The Congress chief claimed that nearly eight crore people will suffer because of the SIR. 'The responsibility to correct the voter list lies with the EC, not the public. 'When the pressure from the opposition, the public and civil society increased, the Election Commission hurriedly published these advertisements today, which state that now only a form needs to be filled and showing documents is not necessary," he claimed. 'This is part of the BJP's tactic to mislead and confuse the public. The truth is that the BJP has decided it will crush democracy at all costs. But when faced with public opposition, it cleverly takes a step back," the leader of opposition in the Rajya Sabha alleged. Meanwhile, the ECI has explained the need for the SIR across India as its constitutional mandate to protect the integrity of electoral rolls. It decided to begin with Bihar since it is the first state where the next assembly election will be held later this year. It said that the SIR is being implemented smoothly at the ground level with the active cooperation of the electors. The EC added that all voters are directly made aware through more than 77,000 BLOs and 4 Lakh volunteers as well as 1.5 lakh BLAs appointed by all political parties. 'In accordance with Article 326, the orders of SIR dated 24 June 2025 clearly enable all eligible electors to be included while excluding ineligible electors after verification by the concerned ERO," the EC said. Get Latest Updates on Movies, Breaking News On India, World, Live Cricket Scores, And Stock Market Updates. Also Download the News18 App to stay updated! tags : Bihar elections Mallikarjun Kharge Location : New Delhi, India, India First Published: July 07, 2025, 23:35 IST News elections 'Misleading': Election Commission Fact-Checks Kharge's Post On Bihar Voter List Revision

Poll Body Fact Checks Mallikarjun Kharge's Post On Voter List Revision
Poll Body Fact Checks Mallikarjun Kharge's Post On Voter List Revision

NDTV

timean hour ago

  • NDTV

Poll Body Fact Checks Mallikarjun Kharge's Post On Voter List Revision

New Delhi: The Election Commission of India (ECI) has fact checked Congress chief Mallikarjun Kharge's post on the special intensive revision (SIR) exercise, or voter list revision, being carried out in Bihar ahead of the assembly election due later this year. Mr Kharge in a post on X had claimed the ECI amended the process of voter verification from asking for documents to only filling a form without any documents, following what he called "pressure from the Opposition, public and civil society". In response, the ECI today said Mr Kharge's post was "misleading". "The claim made in this post, that no document is required and only filling the form is sufficient, is misleading," the ECI said in a post on X. "There is no change in the instructions. SIR is being conducted as per the orders dated 24.06.2025. While submitting the filled enumeration form before 25th July 2025 is mandatory, the documents can be submitted at any time either before 25th July 2025 or during the claims and objections period," it said, and shared a link to the order it referred to in the post. #ECIFactCheck See details in image below 👇 Stay Tuned, Stay Informed. Link to #SIR order dated 24th June 2025 : — Election Commission of India (@ECISVEEP) July 7, 2025 The SIR exercise has become a huge political issue, with the Opposition Congress and other parties alleging the BJP is trying to snatch voting rights from crores of people in Bihar. The ECI has explained the need for the SIR across India as its constitutional mandate to protect the integrity of electoral rolls. It decided to begin with Bihar since it is the first state where the next assembly election will be held later this year. In his allegations, the Congress chief questioned the ECI why it wants people who have been voting in election after election to show documents for voting again. "Forcibly depriving the poor, weak, deprived, Dalit, oppressed, and backward people of their voting rights is a conspiracy of the BJP and RSS," Mr Kharge alleged, referring to the BJP's ideological mentor Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS). The ECI has said Aadhaar and ration cards are not among the documents that will be accepted in the SIR exercise. Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) MP Manoj Jha in an interview to NDTV raised concerns that only 14.18 per cent of Bihar's 7.9 crore voters submitted enumeration forms till July 5 - despite 87 per cent form distribution - which could lead to widespread exclusion. He pointed to the exclusion of Aadhaar and ration cards, widely held by Biharis, from the 11 accepted documents, arguing that this violated the Representation of the People Act.

'Welfare Schemes For All': Kiren Rijiju, Asaduddin Owaisi Spar On X Over Minority Rights
'Welfare Schemes For All': Kiren Rijiju, Asaduddin Owaisi Spar On X Over Minority Rights

News18

timean hour ago

  • News18

'Welfare Schemes For All': Kiren Rijiju, Asaduddin Owaisi Spar On X Over Minority Rights

Last Updated: Union Minister Kiren Rijiju and AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi clashed on X over former's claim that minorities in India enjoy more benefits than the majority. Union Minister for Minority Affairs Kiren Rijiju and AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi on Monday engaged in war of words on X (formerly Twitter) after the BJP leader claimed that minorities in India enjoy more benefits and protections than the majority. While discussing the performance of his ministry on the completion of 11 years of Modi government in the Centre, Rijiju told the Indian Express Rijiju said in the interview that in the last 11 years, under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the government has championed the principle of ' Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas, Sabka Vishwas, Sabka Prayas '. During the interview he claimed that India is the only country where minorities enjoy more benefits than the majority. ' INDIA is the only country where the minorities get more benefits and protections than the majority community," Rijiju said in a post on X while sharing the interview. INDIA is the only country where the minorities get more benefits and protections than the majority community! — Kiren Rijiju (@KirenRijiju) July 7, 2025 'The approach has ensured that minority communities are active and equal participants in India's growth story. The main point we have to understand is that minority communities are receiving more funds and support from the government than the majority community, the Hindus. Whatever the Hindus get, the minorities also do. But what the minorities get, the Hindus don't," Rijiju told the national daily. In a long post on the microblogging platform, Owaisi said Rijiju was not showing the true picture of what Indian Muslims go through and reminded him to follow his duties as a minister under the Constitution. In a strong response, the AIMIM chief said that Rijiju was speaking like a 'monarch' instead of someone holding a constitutional post. 'You are a Minister of the Indian Republic, not a monarch Kiren Rijiju. You hold a constitutional post, not a throne. Minority rights are fundamental rights, not charity," he said. He questioned Rijiju's idea of 'benefits' by pointing to the abuse and violence Muslims face. 'Is it a 'benefit' to be called Pakistani, Bangladeshi, jihadi, or Rohingya every single day? Is it 'protection' to be lynched? Is it protection that Indian citizens were kidnapped and pushed into Bangladesh?" Owaisi questioned. Owaisi further raised concerns over the bulldozing of Muslim properties. 'Is it a privilege to watch our homes, masjids, and mazaars being bulldozed illegally? To be made socially, politically, and economically invisible?" he added. 'Is it an 'honour' to be the target of hate speeches from no less than the Prime Minister of India?" he said. Owaisi claimed that Muslims in India were no longer treated equally as citizens. 'India's minorities are not even second-class citizens anymore. We are hostages," he said. Alleging that Rijiju should answer why there is no religious parity in board memberships, he said, 'If you want to talk about 'favours', answer this: can Muslims be members of Hindu Endowment Boards? No. But your Waqf Amendment Act forces non-Muslims onto Waqf Boards — and allows them to form a majority." The AIMIM leader further accused the Modi government of slashing key scholarships for Muslim students. He cited government data and said that Muslims are being left behind. 'You discontinued the Maulana Azad National Fellowship. You defunded the pre-matric scholarship. You limited the post-matric and merit-cum-means scholarships. All because they benefited Muslim students," he added. 'Muslims are now the only group whose numbers have fallen in higher education. Their presence in the informal economy has gone up. They have been among the worst-hit by your economic policies. This is your own govt's data," he added. Furthermore, Owaisi said Muslim families are seeing a decline in progress across generations. 'Indian Muslims are the only group whose children are now worse off than their parents or grandparents. Intergenerational mobility has reversed. Muslim-concentrated areas are the ones most starved of public infrastructure and basic services," he stated. 'We are not asking to be compared with other minorities of other countries. We are not asking for more than what the majority community gets. We are demanding what the Constitution promises: social, economic, and political justice," he concluded. Rijiju's Responds To Owaisi The Union Minister later responded to the Hyderabad MP's allegations saying that if the minorities are living in pathetic condition in India then why a major section of the minorities from the neighbouring countries prefer to come to India. 'Ok… How come Minorities from our neighbouring countries prefer to come to India & our Minorities don't migrate? Prime Minister @narendramodi ji's welfare schemes are for all. The schemes of the Ministry of Minority Affairs provide additional benefits to the Minorities," Rijiju responded. Ok… How come Minorities from our neighbouring countries prefer to come to India & our Minorities don't migrate? Prime Minister @narendramodi ji's welfare schemes are for all. The schemes of the Ministry of Minority Affairs provide additional benefits to the Minorities.— Kiren Rijiju (@KirenRijiju) July 7, 2025 Rijiju further said that the welfare schemes guaranteed by the Modi government provide additional benefits to the minorities. Owaisi Responds To Rijiju The Hyderabad MP soon responded to the Union Minister over migration of minorities and said that according to Rijiju, if the minorities don't migrate it means they are happy. 'According to Hon'ble Minister Against Minorities, if we don't migrate it means we are happy. Actually, we are not in the habit of fleeing: we did not run away from the British, we did not run away during partition, and we did not run away because of Jammu, Nellie, Gujarat, Moradabad, Delhi etc massacres. Our history is proof that we neither collaborate with our oppressors nor do we hide from them. We know how to fight for our democratic rights and we will inshallah. Stop comparing our great nation with failed states like Pakistan, Bangladesh, Myanmar, Nepal & Sri Lanka. Jai Hind, Jai Samvidhan! Thank you for your attention in this matter!" he said. top videos View all According to Hon'ble Minister Against Minorities, if we don't migrate it means we are happy. Actually, we are not in the habit of fleeing: we did not run away from the British, we did not run away during partition, and we did not run away because of Jammu, Nellie, Gujarat,… — Asaduddin Owaisi (@asadowaisi) July 7, 2025 He urged the minister to compare the Indian minorities with that of Pakistan, Bangladesh, Myanmar, Nepal and Sri Lanka. About the Author Shobhit Gupta Shobhit Gupta is a sub-editor at and covers India and International news. He is interested in day to day political affairs in India and geopolitics. He earned his BA Journalism (Hons) degree from More Get Latest Updates on Movies, Breaking News On India, World, Live Cricket Scores, And Stock Market Updates. Also Download the News18 App to stay updated! tags : AIMIM Asaduddin Owaisi Kiren Rijiju minorities Location : New Delhi, India, India First Published: July 07, 2025, 16:54 IST News politics 'Welfare Schemes For All': Kiren Rijiju, Asaduddin Owaisi Spar On X Over Minority Rights

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store