The Universe's Missing Black Holes May Have Been Located
There are the stellar-mass black holes, which range from five to 50 times the mass of our Sun. Then, there are supermassive black holes (SMBHs), which are millions to billions of times more massive than the Sun.
Finally, there are intermediate black holes (IMBHs), with masses that fall somewhere in between.
Whereas scientists have observed plenty of stellar mass black holes and SMBHs, evidence of IMBHs has been a lot harder to come by. That has posed a problem: IMBHs are thought to be the transitional bridge between stellar black holes and SMBHs as they grow, a glaring 'missing link' in black hole evolution.
In a series of new studies, an international team led by researchers from Vanderbilt University's Lunar Labs Initiative (LLI) has announced that it may have found evidence of these elusive objects.
In one of the papers, a team led by astronomers Krystal Ruiz-Rocha and Anjali Yolkier describes how the researchers reanalyzed data from the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory (LIGO) and the Virgo Collaboration to search for possible indications of IMBH mergers.
The results indicate that these observatories recorded gravitational wave events that correspond to mergers between black holes that were 100 to 300 solar masses. This makes these events the largest black hole collisions recorded by astronomers, and places them in the range where they expect lightweight IMBHs to be.
"Black holes are the ultimate cosmic fossils," says astronomer and senior author Karan Jani.
"The masses of black holes reported in this new analysis have remained highly speculative in astronomy. This new population of black holes opens an unprecedented window into the very first stars that lit up our Universe."
In related research, scientists showed how the upcoming Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA) mission, which is scheduled to launch in the late 2030s, could help verify these results.
Whereas detectors like LIGO and Virgo can capture the final stages of a black hole collision, LISA will be able to track them for years before they merge as they spiral in towards each other, generating ripples in space-time. This extended observational timeframe will allow astronomers to learn more about the black holes' origin, evolution, and what will become of them.
"We hope this research strengthens the case for intermediate-mass black holes as the most exciting source across the network of gravitational-wave detectors from Earth to space," says Ruiz-Rocha.
"Each new detection brings us closer to understanding the origin of these black holes and why they fall into this mysterious mass range."
Looking ahead, the team plans to explore how IMBH could be observed using gravitational wave observatories on the Moon.
NASA is exploring the possibility of building just such an observatory on the Moon as part of the Artemis program's long-term objectives. This plan has existed since the Apollo Era and would build on the Lunar Surface Gravimeter experiment left behind by the Apollo 17 astronauts.
"This is an exciting moment in history – not just to study black holes, but to bring scientific frontiers together with the new era of space and lunar exploration," says Jani.
"We have a rare opportunity to train the next generation of students whose discoveries will be shaped by, and made from, the Moon."
The findings are reported in The Astrophysical Journal Letters, with supporting research published in The Astrophysical Journal, here, here, and here.
Mysteriously Magnetic Moon Rocks Might Have an Explosive Origin Story
Fiery Orange Gems From The Moon Reveal Secrets of Its Violent Past
A Giant Hole Just Opened in The Sun – And It's Blasting Earth With Solar Wind
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
a day ago
- USA Today
A peculiar supernova prompts new theories about the cosmos
Scientists think a gigantic dying star tried to swallow a black hole. It didn't end well for the star, a new study says. A new discovery about what happens when a supernova – an exploding star – and a black hole collide could change the way scientists understand the lives and deaths of stars. The finding was the first time astrophysicists have observed a giant star exploding as the result, they believe, of its interaction with a dense black hole. The supernova was triggered by the intense gravitational stress of trying to "swallow" the black hole up, the study's authors say. The phenomenon may happen more than scientists realize, and new tools to observe supernova explosions could reveal other instances of black holes sparking supernovas, according to the lead study author. "If that is much more common, then it would transform the way we think about how stars explode," said Alex Gagliano, lead author of the study and fellow at the National Science Foundation Institute for Artificial Intelligence and Fundamental Interactions. One of the coolest parts of the discovery is that it was made possible by the use of artificial intelligence, or AI, Gagliano said. AI helped flag a star behaving unusually early on, which allowed the team to closely monitor as a surprising event unfolded. The study, published in the Astrophysical Journal, was conducted by a team led by the Center for Astrophysics, a collaboration between Harvard and the Smithsonian, and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. It was part of the Young Supernova Experiment, which hopes to discover thousands of new cosmic explosions. What is a supernova? A black hole? A supernova is the spectacular explosion of a gigantic dying star. Stars – giant balls of gas – all have a life cycle, which can range from millions to trillions of years, according to NASA. When a huge star, several times the mass of the Sun, runs out of its nuclear fuel at its center, gravity's force takes over and it suddenly collapses, creating shock waves that cause the outer part of the star to explode into a supernova. A supernova typically leaves behind a very dense core. The very largest supernovas leave behind black holes, infamous for their great mystery. Black holes are points in the universe where gravity is so strong that nothing, not even light, can get out, NASA says. Their gravity is so strong because matter is squeezed into a tiny space. Because no light can escape, black holes are invisible, but scientists can spot evidence of them when they suck in matter and gas, which glow as they near the black hole. Sometimes black holes are observed to have companion stars, stars that orbit around them. That's the interaction researchers zeroed in on in this new discovery. The mystery of black holes: What's at the center of a black hole? Scientists have a sobering answer. Why is this exploding star so special? The discovery of the supernova dubbed SN 2023zkd was so unusual because it put together pieces of a puzzle that had never been seen together before, Gagliano said. Usually, a supernova explosion gets brighter over a period of a week or two before reaching its peak and then gets dimmer, he said. At first, SN 2023zkd looked like a typical supernova explosion, just a sudden peak of brightness. But it dimmed at an unusually slow rate afterward, causing an AI program to flag it for further study. Scientists watched its decline for months, and then came a very strange behavior: It began to brighten again in a second peak. To understand this, the researchers looked back at old archival data and discovered that before its first blast, the star had been slowly brightening for a period of about four years, an incredibly uncommon sight. All these factors combined pointed to one likely explanation. About 730 million light-years from Earth, SN 2023zkd had been a star locked in an orbital dance with a black hole, and as they gradually got closer to one another, the black hole pulled at the star's material, causing the gradually increasing glow, Gagliano said. At the moment of the explosion, the star and black hole became so close that the star couldn't survive anymore, he said. The extreme gravitational stress from the black hole caused the supernova explosion. The second peak of brightness happened when the explosion itself collided with a disc-like cloud of dust and gas leftover from the interaction between the star and the black hole. "It's been known for a long time that the majority of stars have companions that interact with them at some point during their lives... but we never really thought that this interaction played a leading role in driving the death of a star," Gagliano said. "That is something that is very new and exciting and I think will force us to revisit how we think about simulating the end of a star." How AI is helping astrophysicists make new discoveries The explosion was first discovered in July 2023, after the research team was alerted to unusually slow dimming of the glow of a supernova. The alert came from an AI program designed to scan the sky for all the supernovas and each morning report on any unusual activity. The alert allowed the researchers to continue to observe the supernova and see as it shockingly began to brighten again, indicating a second explosion. More: Black holes caught devouring massive stars in biggest explosion since Big Bang Were it not for the AI program, the initial explosion may have just looked observationally like many other supernovas and scientists would never have looked back to see its slow brightening and deduced that it was interacting with a black hole, Gagliano said. AI's role in sifting through mountains of data that human researchers can't and flagging anomalies is growing in several scientific fields, from medicine to astrophysics, Gagliano said. "One of the only reasons that we were able to make this discovery and understand how scientifically interesting it was was through the combination of researchers in machine learning and in astrophysics," he said.
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Scientists Discover What Appears to Be the Largest Black Hole in the Universe, So Heavy That It Completely Bends the Light Around It Into a Giant Ring
Astronomers have discovered what could be the largest black hole ever detected. With a mass of 36 billion times that of our Sun, its gravity is so powerful that it bends the light of an entire galaxy behind it into a near-perfect circle called an Einstein ring, effectively reducing a realm with trillions of stars of its own into an astrophysical fashion accessory. It's 10,000 times as heavy as our Milky Way's own central black hole, and is nigh unto breaking the universe's theoretical upper limit. If anything ever warranted being called a cosmic monster, it's this. "This is amongst the top ten most massive black holes ever discovered, and quite possibly the most massive," Thomas Collett, a professor of astrophysics at the University of Portsmouth and coauthor of a new study about the giant in the journal Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, said in a statement about the work. Other detections of similar sized objects, Collett noted, have generally come with uncertainties too large to be definitive. This not-super but ultramassive black hole lurks in the center of the famous Cosmic Horseshoe galaxy, which itself ranks among the most massive ever spotted. The galaxy is considered a fossil group, which formed from other large galaxies — and their constituent supermassive black holes — collapsing together. "So we're seeing the end state of galaxy formation and the end state of black hole formation," Collet said. It's no exaggeration to say, then, that we're literally witnessing a black hole's final form. Located some five billion light years away, the Cosmic Horseshoe is so named due to its gravitational lensing effect, a phenomenon in which the light of a background galaxy is warped by the gravity of a foreground one. Lensing is common throughout the cosmos, and it can be a fortuitous tool for astronomers, acting like a magnifying glass that allows them to observe distant objects whose light would otherwise be too faint to examine. But in this case, the huge foreground galaxy and its companion in the background happen to be in almost perfect alignment with our Earthly perspective, bending the light into an incomplete ring. Astronomers have long suspected that there was a black hole at the heart of the Cosmic Horseshoe, but have never been able to spot — let alone measure — it. One of the reasons why is its extreme distance, at billions of light years away. But the even more impressive hurdle that's been overcome is that it's a "dormant" black hole that's no longer accreting matter, according to Carlos Melo, lead author from the Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul in Brazil. "Typically, for such remote systems, black hole mass measurements are only possible when the black hole is active," Melo said. "But those accretion-based estimates often come with significant uncertainties." When a black hole devours significant amounts of matter, the infalling material gets heated up and radiates huge amounts of energy and light, forming what's known as an active galactic nucleus. (The brightest of these are called quasars.) But this detection "relied purely on [the black hole's] immense gravitational pull and the effect it has on its surroundings," Melo said. Their method involved a combination of lensing and what's known as stellar kinematics, which allows astronomers to infer a black hole's mass by studying the velocity of stars trapped in the surrounding galaxy. "What is particularly exciting is that this method allows us to detect and measure the mass of these hidden ultramassive black holes across the universe, even when they are completely silent," Melo said. And its size is no coincidence. There's a reason, the astronomers argue, that we're finding this ultramassive rarity in one of the heaviest galaxies on record, and not in one of relatively unremarkable size like our Milky Way, which hosts a comparatively puny black hole of 4.3 million solar masses. "We think the size of both is intimately linked," Collet said, "because when galaxies grow, they can funnel matter down onto the central black hole." That may seem like an obvious conclusion to draw, but how supermassive black holes attain their enormous sizes remains one of the great mysteries of cosmology. Some have been spotted so early on in the universe's history that they physically shouldn't exist, not having enough time to accrete the mass they possess. If it formed from galactic mergers, it provides a strong clue of at least one mechanism that can spawn these colossal objects. More on black holes: Bizarre "Infinity Galaxy" Could Hold the Secrets of Supermassive Black Holes Solve the daily Crossword
Medscape
3 days ago
- Medscape
Flu, Not Antiviral, May Cause Neuropsychiatric Risk in Kids
Influenza, and not the antiviral treatment for it, is responsible for increased neuropsychiatric risks in pediatric patients, new research suggested. The risk for these events was about 50% lower in children treated with oseltamivir (Tamiflu), the most widely prescribed antiviral for influenza, compared to no treatment, investigators found. Oseltamivir currently carries a warning label about increased risk for neuropsychiatric events, including seizure. However, the label is based on low-quality studies, lead investigator James W. Antoon, MD, PhD, assistant professor of pediatrics at Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, Tennessee, told Medscape Medical News . The findings of the study, which Antoon said is the most rigorous of its kind to date, suggest that the warning label may no longer be necessary. 'Our main finding was that oseltamivir prevents neuropsychiatric events and that neuropsychiatric events during periods of influenza is really driven by influenza itself,' he said. 'This influenza antiviral is safe and effective and should be used as early as possible in the course of influenza illness.' Definitive Answer? Oseltamivir is currently the most commonly prescribed antiviral for influenza for both children and adults and is particularly beneficial during the illness' early stages. The FDA added the warning label to the drug packaging after safety concerns were raised in 2006. However, the researchers noted that 'it is important to note that these warnings were placed on the basis of case reports rather than studies on associated risks for these events.' No randomized study to date has shown a significant association between the medication and neuropsychiatric events in pediatric patients, and there have been conflicting results from observational studies, they added. Antoon said he first became aware of the warning during his medical residency. However, upon reviewing the studies examining the link, he found that there was little high-quality research on the topic. Once he began practicing, he noted that parents frequently expressed concerns about these risks. 'Even for children at high risk for influenza complications, who would benefit from treatment, parents would decline it. So we chose to do this study to be the definitive answer of whether oseltamivir is associated with neuropsychiatric events or is it the underlying influenza that's really driving the alterations in children's behavior,' Antoon said. The retrospective cohort study assessed data from influenza seasons in 2016-2017 and 2019-2020. It included 692,295 children and adolescents aged 5-17 years (median age, 11 years; 50.3% girls) enrolled in Tennessee Medicaid. Each person-day of follow-up was stratified into one of five exposure groups: no exposure (to influenza or oseltamivir), untreated influenza (up to 10 days after diagnosis), treated influenza, posttreatment (time between oseltamivir completion to end of influenza period), and influenza prophylaxis (oseltamivir treatment without influenza). The primary outcome was any neuropsychiatric event that required hospitalization. Helpful, Not Harmful Results showed that 129,134 individuals had 151,401 influenza episodes, and 66.7% of those episodes were treated with oseltamivir. Among the participants deemed to be at high risk for influenza-related complications, 60.1% received oseltamivir treatment. There were 898 neurologic and 332 psychiatric events during 19,688,320 person-weeks of follow-up. The most common serious neuropsychiatric adverse events were mood disorders (36.3%) and suicidal or self-harm behaviors (34.2%), followed by seizures (13.7%). The overall incidence rate ratio (IRR) was 6.25 per 100,000 person-weeks for a serious neuropsychiatric event. The risk for these events was significantly lower during periods where influenza was treated with oseltamivir (adjusted IRR, 0.53; 95% CI, 0.33-0.88) and during posttreatment (adjusted IRR, 0.42; 95% CI, 0.24-0.74) than during untreated influenza. 'Sensitivity analyses suggest misclassification or unmeasured confounding would not explain these findings,' the investigators wrote. Subanalyses showed that the adjusted IRRs for neurologic and psychiatric events separately in the treated group were 0.45 (95% CI, 0.25-0.83) and 0.80 (95% CI, 0.34-1.88), respectively. Antoon noted that neurologic events are more common than psychiatric events in young patients and that the lower number of those outcomes overall may have led to a smaller decrease in psychiatric events. 'All of the results together suggest that oseltamivir is not associated with neuropsychiatric events and, in fact, may be helpful in preventing these events in children,' Antoon said. 'Double-Edged Sword' Commenting for Medscape Medical News , Soonjo Hwang, MD, associate professor of psychiatry and from the Child and Adolescent Psychiatry Department at the University of Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha, Nebraska, noted that although the study provides important and reassuring information, he wouldn't necessarily say it provides the definitive answer on this topic. Hwang, who was not involved with the research, noted that the study was a retrospective cohort review with several confounding variables that were not controlled for, including various socioeconomic factors and how amenable the parents were to the treatment options. Additionally, he pointed out that medication warning labels for pediatric populations are often based on case reports because of the difficulty in conducting clinical trials in an ethical way in such a young group. 'It's kind of a double-edged sword. You want to use the medicine as safely as possible, but you also don't want to limit the access to treatment options just because there are no sufficient data available,' Hwang said. So what should clinicians do while waiting for additional research? 'I think, as a clinician, you need to have an informed conversation with parents of young children about the risk and benefit of any treatment option and make the best judgement you can case-by-case. But, indeed, we really need more clinical trials to make sure we're using them in a safe way but also in an effective way,' he concluded.
