Meatworks, council clam up over effluent breach
Owners of the Kokiri meatworks are refusing to answer questions about the latest breach of its resource consent while the matter is under investigation by the West Coast Regional Council.
ANZCO Foods Ltd was prosecuted by the council and fined $60,000 in the Greymouth District Court this month for submitting false and misleading monitoring reports about its effluent discharges.
Kokiri is permitted to release 6100 cubic metres of wastewater a day from its oxidation pond into the Arnold River.
The effluent includes wastewater from toilets, stock wash-down facilities and the plant itself.
The company told the council this month that it had exceeded that limit on April 7.
But it has declined to answer further questions about why it was unable to stick to the consented limit.
Local Democracy Reporting asked the company how the excess effluent release happened, whether the oxidation pond flooded and whether it had plans to enlarge its system or take other steps to avoid repeats.
In court, the company said its previous misreporting was down to "a serious lapse of judgement" by one employee and it had new systems in place to ensure accurate monitoring and reporting.
LDR has asked if that meant Kokiri would simply do a better job of reporting its consent breaches in future rather than take steps to prevent them.
The company's communications manager Janet Wright responded: 'The event you're inquiring about is an open event with the Regional Council and as such we're unable to comment on it.'
The council has declined to say by how much Kokiri exceeded its allowable effluent discharge on April 7, because it is in the throes of investigating the breach.
It did say that its records showed the company had exceeded E.coli counts in its releases three times between 2017 and 2023.
LDR has asked under the LGOIMA (Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act) whether the West Coast Regional Council will review the conditions of Kokiri's resource consent.
- By Lois Williams
Local Democracy Reporter
• LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
a day ago
- RNZ News
West Coast council staff kept busy by information requests
File photo. Photo: 123rf Requests for official information are on the rise on the West Coast, including some described as 'vexatious'. A report to Tuesday's Operations Committee meeting shows the West Coast Regional Council handled 39 LGOIMA (Local Government Official Information and Meeting Act) requests in the June quarter. Nine involved the Taylorville Resource Park consent application. A resource consent hearing for the controversial private dump near Greymouth is set down for two days next month. Compliance visits to mining sites; council staff and contractor numbers; Buller plateau mining consents and all records on historic demolition waste also featured in the list of LGOIMA requests. All but two of the requests were processed in the statutory timeframe, the report said. The Ombudsman had contacted the council once over a report the council initially refused to release. The council had revised its decision but due to an 'internal error' still failed to release the report. That had been rectified, and an apology provided for the error, the report said. The majority of requests were granted in full or in part. The council withheld information on some requests involving the Taylorville Resource Park, on the grounds of protecting commercial information, legal privilege, privacy and free and frank expression of views by or to council staff. Chief executive Darryl Lew said the council had to be mindful of the Privacy Act and be meticulous with redactions in its responses. "It is an ever-increasing and concerning amount of time we put into this. But it's part of transparency (requirements for local government)." Some of the LGOIMA requests could be considered frivolous, he confirmed. "In the legislation, whether they are frivolous, vexatious, recidivist…we've still got to meet their requests. " Chair Peter Haddock said council had been criticised for having too many staff but dealing with 13 or 14 LGOIMA requests a month meant a massive amount of work. "Just looking through some of them, some are coming from the same people all the time, you can read it like a book, and it all comes at a cost to ratepayers. " The simpler requests were being handled in-house, but the more complex ones were still managed by a contractor, staff confirmed. LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Scoop
2 days ago
- Scoop
Westland Mayoral Race Heats Up With Rates Cap Promise
At a packed meeting in Hokitika's Grey Power rooms, Westland mayoral candidate Jacquie Grant is giving the audience exactly what they want to hear. If the colourful local business owner gets to head the Westland District Council, she promises to slash its budgets by 10%, cap the rates and put an end to waste. 'When my home renovation job was finished the council sent three officers to inspect it. Three! Maybe two of them were there to protect the third one from me,' she says. The 81-year-old came to New Zealand from Australia as a young person seeking a safe place to live as a trans woman. Over the years she has fostered more than 70 children, built an export business making and selling sock-knitting machines, and been honoured with an ONZM. She served two terms on the Grey District Council some years ago and has campaigned several times – unsuccessfully – for a seat at the Westland council table. This time she believes, given the mood of the ratepayers, she has a good chance of unseating mayor Helen Lash, who's been in the job just three years. 'The affordability of rates has become a broken promise … it feels like we've been left behind and frankly that's because we have,' she told her Grey Power listeners on Thursday. Westland pensioners are doing it hard, even those who own their own homes, she told LDR. 'They're being hit with $4500 rate bills for properties worth $350,000. They can't pay their insurance now. You see old people at the supermarket here buying bones and lamb's fry from the pet food counter. People are living hand-to-mouth. ' Grant's 10-point plan to rein in council spending includes closing Destination Westland and demanding better returns from the council's contracting company, WestRoads. 'I would close the iSite, move it into the theatre and make that more viable - that's five jobs gone and you'd save half a million a year,' she says. Despite her advancing years, Grant says she's up to the mayoral workload. 'I'm fit as a fiddle,' she says. 'We're a long-lived lot in my family – I only just lost my mum, my grandparents were 106 and 103, my siblings are all alive and kicking. I might be around for a while.' Following the meeting, incumbent mayor Helen Lash bit back at the promises. She says she knows many people in Westland are doing it tough and populist policies go down well with voters, but there's a catch. 'Yes, you can cap rates and slash budgets, but your core services are hit and they are two-thirds of our rates. What should we cut? Roads? Rubbish? We're almost caught up, but we still have footpaths to do.' One submitter to the long-term plan had drawn up a spreadsheet showing former councils had always kept the rates low in election years. 'We can't keep doing that. That's why we're now facing 12% and 13% increases.' The council has also been criticised over the size of its payout to former chief executive Simon Bastion, who resigned suddenly in June last year. 'It's been reported as $190,000 – but $100,000 of that was KiwiSaver, super scheme and holiday pay – you have to pay that. The actual severance amount was $90,000,' the mayor says. Some of Grant's ideas, such as sharing services with other councils, are already happening, Lash says. 'We already share waste management with Greymouth, and we plan to do more. Amalgamation of councils is coming down the track, we know that. But it can't happen fast.' There have been calls for the council to go it alone with water services instead of forming a Coast-wide entity, but that carries risks, the mayor says. 'We've said we will negotiate with Buller and Grey – Wellington wants it, and we've seen with other councils going it alone, next thing they get a Crown observer and have to pay for it.' Westland has less water debt than its neighbouring councils and wants to avoid subsidising them, Lash says. 'That's where I'm not prepared to go. Smoothing costs, they call it. If it gets to a sticking point, we will bow out.' Hokitika will soon have to build a new sewerage treatment system to meet tighter national standards, and that is unavoidable, the mayor says. 'Jacquie Grant is saying we could go for a cheaper option and that's her opinion, but it's not based on fact.' Pressure from tourism means Westland ratepayers have to build bigger sewerage systems than they need themselves, Lash says. 'I have brought this up with Tourism Minister Louise Upston, and Shane Jones - how much should we be subsidising tourism? Especially at Franz Josef, with 3500 beds and only 500 ratepayers.' The Government is now considering Westland's case, and the incoming council will have to choose the best option, the mayor says. The council has also copped some flak for advertising nine jobs in recent weeks. But most are long-standing vacancies or existing positions 'rescoped', the mayor says. And one is for a communications adviser. 'I've poured myself into the job, worked bloody hard; there's a lot of travel and late nights and I haven't done what I promised myself I would do, tell the community more about what we're doing and why. We need to do that.'
RNZ News
3 days ago
- RNZ News
A High Court case and contentious letterbox drop: Who is Andrew Clark?
Nelson-based Andrew Clark is running for mayor of Invercargill while simultaneously going for the top job in Tasman. Photo: LDR / Matthew Rosenberg An Invercargill mayoral candidate says he is still fit for office, despite past events landing him in both the headlines and court. Andrew Clark is contesting the position currently held by his brother Nobby, in a move which has surprised and irked his older sibling. In Tasman, where Clark currently lives, he is also running for mayor under the first name Maxwell. The business owner made headlines for a range of incidents since the early 2000s including a land dispute, receiving money from a gang affiliated event, and spreading misinformation through pamphlets. Clark said he gave a lot of voluntary help to people, and the issues were "out of perspective" compared to what normal life had been for a long time. "We've dealt with everything that comes up in a fair and reasonable basis, and I don't see any issue there whatsoever," he said. In 2004, Clark faced legal action after the purchase of a neighbouring estate went awry. Problems arose when Clark and his partner presented a written agreement which was signed by all parties, only to be later contested for not reflecting the verbal agreement. The elderly neighbour - a trustee - said it was clear they were retaining the house and a parcel of land, but Clark and his partner maintained the $300,000 price tag included everything. Judge Ronald Young said in his judgement he did not find Clark to be "a credible witness at all". "I had the distinct impression throughout his evidence that if he had no recollection of a proposition he was prepared to construct the happening and timing of it to suit himself," Young wrote. He believed Clark knew he was getting a "remarkable bargain" at $300,000 - a figure which was at least 50 percent under market value - and ordered the written contract be corrected. Clark told Local Democracy Reporting the neighbour "begged" them to buy the property with the sale only falling through after the other party pulled out thinking they could get more. He said the judge did not like him and he would have challenged the court ruling if he had money at the time. "Very unfortunate. I'm very saddened by it all... I wish I could undo what had happened, but that's not possible." Between 2012 and 2018, Clark was linked in media reports to a controversial Nelson biking event called Poker Run. Stuff reported the event was traditionally run by motorcycle gang associates with money raised going towards Clark's ambulance business Medimax. The events were monitored by police. Clark is still running Medimax, and confirmed it operates as a business and not a charity. There were never any problems with the motorcycle group, which was charged like any other organisation, he said. "These people, whether it's liked or not liked, they live in the community, they work in the community. "For us it was just a professional role, do a professional job. That's all that was." In 2018, Clark featured in a 1News bulletin as the man behind a pamphlet drop warning of a potential eight-metre tidal wave if the proposed Waimea Dam failed. Two thousand leaflets were distributed in Brightwater, a move labelled "dirty and sneaky" by then-Nelson MP Nick Smith. Former Tasman mayor Richard Kempthorne said a catastrophic failure would see water going through houses at levels between 50cm and 100cm. Clark confirmed to Local Democracy Reporting he personally delivered the brochures and said he was just trying to share a risk which he thought hadn't been fully considered. The information included contact details for elected representatives. Clark is one of eight candidates contesting the Invercargill mayoralty this year and said he would move south if elected. He will be in attendance at Tuesday's Southland Business Chamber mayoral debate. * LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air
