Apple's Siri Struggle: New Report Explains What Went Wrong
PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.
A lot has been said about Siri in the past year after Apple failed to deliver on its promise of a supercharged voice assistant. Multiple delays and lawsuits later, we now have details on what went wrong at Cupertino.
According to Bloomberg's Mark Gurman, Apple rushed the development of its AI features after OpenAI's ChatGPT launched in 2022. Things began falling apart when the team tried merging Siri's old code with the new one.
Sources tell Gurman that Apple had no plans to launch Apple Intelligence until ChatGPT arrived. Apple's software chief, Craig Federighi, realized the chatbot's potential a month after its launch when he used it to write code for a personal project.
Soon, Federighi, along with Apple's then AI head, John Giannandrea, and a few other executives, started meeting with OpenAI, Anthropic, and other AI companies to learn more about these AI models. Federighi also told his team that iOS 18 should infuse as many AI-powered features into an iPhone as possible.
Giannandrea then assembled a team and started working on building large language models (LLMs) for AI features. However, as Apple inched closer to Apple Intelligence's public reveal in June 2024, internal tests showed that the chatbot lagged significantly behind ChatGPT, with OpenAI's product delivering 25% better accuracy.
The desperate need for AI forced Apple to look for partners. For stronger user privacy, Giannandrea suggested Google, but Apple announced OpenAI as its first AI partner at WWDC 24. Many AI-powered features were announced at the June event, including the ability to summon ChatGPT for requests Siri can't fulfill. A delay pushed that feature to December 2024, but many others that were announced are still MIA, resulting in lawsuits and a new chapter in Apple's ever-growing Siri struggles.
Some Apple Intelligence features were too buggy when Federighi started testing them on his personal phone before iOS 18.4. Worse, the communication between Apple's product development and marketing teams was poor. Apple had to pull down TV ads for iPhone 16 features that were nowhere close to being ready.
Internally, Giannandrea has absorbed much of the blame for Siri's failure. Several employees claim that Giannandrea lacked urgency for generative AI; another Apple executive says Giannandrea believed consumers don't trust it enough and that AI agents are far away from replacing humans, Bloomberg reports. The exec has blamed overhyped marketing. CEO Tim Cook eventually lost faith in Giannandrea and replaced him with Vision Pro's head, Mike Rockwell, in March.
Aside from these issues, Siri's code was seen to have a major technical flaw. To add AI features, Apple engineers split Siri's infrastructure in half. When they tried to merge Siri's new AI features with legacy features, such as setting the alarm, things started falling apart.
A team in Zurich is now creating a new software architecture built entirely on an LLM-based engine, called LLM Siri. Their aim is to make Siri more conversational and better at processing information. In the EU, Apple will also let users replace Siri with third-party assistants, according to a source.
According to an earlier New York Times report, some of Siri's announced but unreleased features are expected this fall. Meanwhile, Apple is prepping for a huge iOS revamp scheduled for WWDC 25 next month.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Insider
36 minutes ago
- Business Insider
Tesla's (TSLA) Full Self-Driving Could Expand in China Due to New Data Export Rules
China has released draft guidelines that could help EV maker Tesla (TSLA) expand its advanced driver-assistance features in the country, according to a Bloomberg report on Friday. For the first time, Beijing has provided clear rules on how data generated in China, including from driver-assistance systems and product development, can be accessed, used, and exported. This is an important step for companies like Tesla, which need to send data abroad in order to improve their systems. Confident Investing Starts Here: The proposed guidelines were published by China's Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, along with seven other government agencies, and are now open for public comment. The framework covers key types of information, such as autonomous driving algorithms, training images, operational data, and vehicle-to-road perception data. These are all critical for developing and improving advanced driver-assistance technologies like Tesla's Full Self-Driving (FSD) system. Being able to export this data is especially valuable for Tesla because the core team working on FSD is based in the U.S., and having access to real-world data from Chinese roads would help optimize the system's performance in China, the world's largest car market. It's worth noting that, until now, strict data controls have been a barrier for foreign automakers. However, the new guidelines could provide Tesla with a clearer path to making its most advanced driver-assistance features more competitive in China. What Is the Prediction for Tesla Stock? Overall, analysts have a Hold consensus rating on TSLA stock based on 14 Buys, 12 Holds, and nine Sells assigned in the past three months, as indicated by the graphic below. Furthermore, the average TSLA price target of $285.97 per share implies 12.1% downside risk.
Business Insider
2 hours ago
- Business Insider
Meta, OpenAI, and Palantir (PLTR) Executives Join U.S. Army to Improve Military Tech
Top tech leaders from Meta (META), OpenAI, and Palantir (PLTR) are joining the Army Reserve as lieutenant colonels in a new unit called the 'Executive Innovation Corps,' known as Detachment 201, the Army announced Friday. The unit is part of a push to bring Silicon Valley expertise into the military. Among those being sworn in are Meta CTO Andrew Bosworth, OpenAI Chief Product Officer Kevin Weil, Palantir CTO Shyam Sankar, and Bob McGrew, an advisor at Thinking Machines and former OpenAI Chief Research Officer. Confident Investing Starts Here: Detachment 201 will let these tech leaders serve part-time as senior advisors in order to help the Army adopt advanced technologies quickly. The unit is designed to fuse cutting-edge commercial tech with military innovation, which will support projects like the Army Transformation Initiative that aims to modernize the force by using more efficient and scalable solutions. The program also allows executives to serve without leaving their day jobs, which could inspire more tech professionals to contribute in uniform. This initiative comes as the Army works to replace outdated systems and buy more commercial tech that can serve both military and civilian needs. Indeed, Meta is already partnering with defense firm Anduril on extended reality (XR) tools for soldiers. In addition, OpenAI's ChatGPT could be used to improve military productivity, while Palantir supplies AI-enabled hardware like the TITAN vehicle. The Army didn't say how fast Detachment 201 will expand, but this first wave of new members points to a growing collaboration between the tech industry and the military. Which Tech Stock Is the Better Buy?
Miami Herald
2 hours ago
- Miami Herald
Car buyers should be nervous about this emerging trend
If you are in the market for a new vehicle, signs suggest that the buyers' market, which thrived in the first half of the year, is coming to an end. Due to the uncertainty surrounding President Donald Trump's trade war, dealers have increased incentives to combat consumer sentiment, which has been in the tank since Trump took office. Related: Car buyers should shop these brands for the best tariff deal Nearly half of American drivers cite car expenses as the reason they can't save any money, and the average American spends about 20% of their monthly income on auto loans, fuel, insurance, and maintenance. Most financial experts cap the monthly income you should spend on a vehicle at 15%. According to a MarketWatch Guides survey, about 10% of drivers say they spend 30% of their monthly income on driving, while another 12% said they "found themselves living paycheck to paycheck due to the financial strain of their cars." So, finding the right car for the right price is the name of the game. According to a new analysis from Bank of America, this year has been good for car buyers. But things are about to take a turn. Image source: Bounds/Bloomberg via Getty Images Car dealers have piled on the incentives in recent months to get customers through their doors. The plan worked. Auto sales have climbed sharply in recent months as consumers were motivated by the incentives and the need to buy vehicles before any tariff-related price increases. But Bank of America is now saying that the growth it saw in consumer vehicle loan applications has declined from its peak in April, "suggesting that 'buying ahead' has largely run its course." Bank of America expects lower-income and younger buyers to feel the most pain, as its data shows that median car payments have grown faster than new and used car prices since 2019. Shockingly, of those households with a monthly car payment, 20% have a payment over $1,000. Related: Car buyers notice a disturbing trend at the car lot Meanwhile, Baby Boomers, Gen X, and older Millennials all saw decreases in the percentage of their members paying more than $2,000 a month for their vehicles in the past few months. Gen Z and younger Millennials saw an increase in members paying over that amount. Bank of America also saw an increase in $2,000 a month auto bills among people making less than $50,000 and between $50,00 and $100,000. Meanwhile, that type of spending decreased among people making more than $100,000. "Bank of America payments data shows that overall median car payments are already more than 30% higher than the 2019 average and have now outpaced both new and used car prices, possibly as there is a push towards more expensive cars," analysts Taylor Bowley and David Tinsley wrote. However, the majority of automakers reported reducing incentive spending in May. Dealers like Volkswagen, Mazda, Land Rover, Volvo, and BMW all reduced incentive spending by more than 10%. Incentives were also notably lower month over month for Stellantis. Car buyers must consider several factors before making a purchase. Of course, the vehicle itself is only part of the expense, as it will need insurance, maintenance, and gas to run. In addition to capping your car payments at about 15% of your monthly take-home, financial experts also recommend shoppers aim for a 20% down payment, a 36 to 48-month loan term, and expenses (including insurance) at between 8% and 10% of your gross monthly income. Experts also recommend that you know your credit score and loan approval amount in advance and that you shop around with different lenders for the best rate. Related: New car prices are rising; here's where to get the best deal The Arena Media Brands, LLC THESTREET is a registered trademark of TheStreet, Inc.
