UK court awards £700 million to HP in late tycoon's fraud case
A UK court ruled in 2022 in favour of the U.S. technology giant, now known as Hewlett Packard Enterprise (HPE), in a civil case linked to the sale of Lynch's company, Autonomy.
Lynch, once dubbed the "British Bill Gates", founded software firm Autonomy in the 1990s. Its $11 billion sale to Hewlett Packard in 2011 also saw him face fraud charges in the United States.
HP accused Autonomy of artificially inflating its revenues and growth before the sale and had demanded $5 billion in compensation.
"We are pleased that this decision brings us a step closer to the resolution of this dispute," said a spokesperson for Hewlett Packard.
"We look forward to the further hearing at which the final amount of HPE's damages will be determined," they added.
The further hearing, dealing with matters including interest, currency conversion and whether Lynch's estate can appeal the decision, is scheduled for November.
The British court had not yet awarded damages when Lynch was killed along with his 18-year-old daughter Hannah, four friends and the yacht's cook in the sinking of his British-flagged vessel Bayesian in a storm in August 2024.
Lynch, 59, his family and guests were on board celebrating his acquittal in the massive U.S. fraud case.
The 56-metre (185-foot) yacht was struck by a mini-tornado before dawn as it was anchored off Porticello, near Palermo.
Hewlett Packard had recorded nearly $9 billion in write-downs, including more than $5 billion it claimed resulted from accounting manipulations by Autonomy's directors before the sale.
But justice Robert Hildyard in the British case wrote in his ruling that "HP's claim was always substantially exaggerated".
The initial compensation award had been expected in September 2024, and before his sudden death Lynch had prepared a written reaction to the judgement.
The ruling "exposes HP's failure and makes clear that the immense damage to Autonomy was down to HP's own errors and actions", he wrote, adding that the company would consider appealing the decision.
A spokesman told AFP any debts would have to be discharged from Lynch's estate.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
15 minutes ago
- Hans India
Modi's cricket metaphor for India-UK ties
London: "There may be a swing and a miss at times, but we always play with a straight bat!" Prime Minister Narendra Modi told his British counterpart Keir Starmer on Thursday as he used a cricketing metaphor to describe India's partnership with the UK. Modi also said that India was committed to building a high-scoring, solid partnership with the UK. 'For both of us, Cricket is not just a game, but a passion. And also, a great metaphor for our partnership. There may be a swing and a miss at times, but we always play with a straight bat! We are committed to building a high-scoring, solid partnership,' Modi said in his media statement after bilateral talks with Starmer. He said the agreements signed today and Vision 2035 are milestones that take this spirit forward. India and the UK inked a landmark free trade agreement on Thursday. Prime Minister Modi, along with Prime Minister Starmer, also interacted with players of the 'Buckingham Street Cricket Hub' in London. Cricket, which is believed to have originated in the UK, is the most popular sport in India. The Indian cricket team, led by Captain Shubman Gill, is currently touring England for a five match test series. The two teams are playing their fourth test match in Manchester.
Indian Express
15 minutes ago
- Indian Express
UK trade deal: India gains big in food, footwear, textile; to cut tariffs in auto, liquor
INDIA HAS secured market access for key job-creating sectors such as textiles, footwear, gems and jewellery, and marine products — where the UK is set to eliminate duties of up to 20 per cent. Negotiators have also managed to push for eliminating duties for almost 99.7% of tariff lines in India's food sector. In most food items, the tariffs were as high as 70 per cent. New Delhi extracted enhanced market access in export-oriented sectors such as marine and animal products, including seafood, dairy, and meat products, with tariffs reduced to zero from up to 20 per cent. On its part, New Delhi has allowed British companies to participate in a class of public procurement tenders, and also opened the highly-tariffed automobile and alcoholic beverage industries. The UK government said its large and varied manufacturing sectors will benefit from tariff cuts on aerospace (reduced from as high as 11% to 0%), automotives (from up to 110% down to 10%), and electrical machinery (from up to 22%). For the first time, India has allowed duty cuts for UK-origin alcohol including whisky, brandy, rum, vodka, liqueurs, mead, cider, and tequila. These products, which currently face a base customs duty of 150 per cent, will see steep reductions — but only if they meet a Minimum Import Price (MIP) threshold of $5 per litre or $6 per 750 ml bottle. For qualifying imports, the duty will be gradually lowered from 110 per cent in Year 1 to 75 per cent by Year 10, through equal annual reductions. This design helps shield India's domestic liquor market from low-cost imports while giving premium UK spirits a competitive edge, New Delhi-based think tank GTRI said. In a first, India has allowed UK firms to participate in government tenders, offering them Class Two status under 'Make in India' rules, which require 20-50 per cent domestic value addition. While India had previously opened public procurement under the UAE deal, experts said the deal offered to the UK is the most generous yet. 'This is the most extensive concession in government procurement that India has offered in any FTA to date and marks a strategic shift away from using public procurement as a tool for domestic industrial development. The 20 per cent local content rule allows UK firms to use up to 80 per cent inputs from third countries — such as China or the EU — while still receiving preferential treatment, effectively diluting the benefits that programmes like Make in India and Atmanirbhar Bharat were designed to protect,' GTRI said. The access granted to the UK could also set a precedent for future FTAs with larger economies like the EU or the US, potentially eroding India's ability to use public procurement as a lever for policy goals such as import substitution, domestic capacity-building, and employment generation, the think tank added. Experts said that India seems to have conceded significantly on Intellectual Property Rights (IPR), as UK patent holders are now allowed to give voluntary licences, representing a marked shift from the earlier stance. 'The IP chapter undermines policy space to facilitate access to medicines on two grounds. One, it explicitly mentions a preference for voluntary licensing over compulsory licensing. Two, it reiterates the European Free Trade Association (EFTA) provision which allows the patent holder to withhold information on the working of patents for three years,' an expert said on condition of anonymity. India and the UK (then part of the EU) began exploring the possibility of a trade deal back in 2007. However, Europe's demands for access to India's key job-generating sectors, such as automobiles and agriculture, were too steep for the government to build a consensus within the country, leading to the talks' failure. After deciding to withdraw from negotiations for the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) — a mega trade deal involving China, the ASEAN region, Australia, and New Zealand — over concerns about a surge in Chinese imports in 2019, India began looking to the lucrative West for deeper economic integration. Post-2019, when India adopted a decisive approach towards a free trade agreement with the UK, a political crisis in London played spoilsport, beginning with Brexit in 2016. While negotiations continued under three different British Prime Ministers from 2022 to 2025, several deadlines were missed, including the Diwali deadline set by former UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson. The deal only materialised after the Keir Starmer-led Labour Party won a landslide victory in May 2025. Another political push towards global deals was the election of US President Donald Trump. It incentivised countries to swiftly secure new markets, bringing the UK and India even closer in their search for certainty in a world that seems to be moving towards trade turmoil. The UK deal is significant as it marks the beginning of integration between the advanced services sector in the UK and that of India. India has finally opened its doors to high-end British cars and whisky, albeit in a phased manner. The India–UK Free Trade Agreement ensures comprehensive market access for goods across all sectors, covering all of India's export interests. India will benefit from tariff elimination on approximately 99 per cent of tariff lines, covering nearly 100 per cent of trade value — offering opportunities to boost bilateral trade between India and the UK, according to the Commerce and Industry Ministry. The pact includes chapters on goods, services, innovation, government procurement, and intellectual property rights. The two countries have also concluded negotiations on the Double Contribution Convention Agreement, or social security pact, which would help avoid double contributions to social security funds by Indian professionals working for a limited period in Britain. However, talks on the Bilateral Investment Treaty (BIT) are still ongoing. India's exports to the UK rose by 12.6 per cent to $14.5 billion, while imports grew by 2.3 per cent to $8.6 billion in 2024–25. Bilateral trade between India and the UK increased to $21.34 billion in 2023–24 from $20.36 billion in 2022–23. Ravi Dutta Mishra is a Principal Correspondent with The Indian Express, covering policy issues related to trade, commerce, and banking. He has over five years of experience and has previously worked with Mint, CNBC-TV18, and other news outlets. ... Read More
Indian Express
15 minutes ago
- Indian Express
India-UK trade deal: Relief on social security contributions boost for Indian firms, workers
India's trade deal with the UK will provide a boost to domestic services companies, with the two governments agreeing that employees working temporarily for a period of up to three years in the other country will only have to pay social security contributions in their home countries. This will raise take-home salaries and reduce costs for Indian companies, and is expected to benefit around 75,000 Indian workers. The reciprocal Double Contributions Convention (DCC) is in addition to the Comprehensive and Economic Trade Agreement (CETA) that covers nearly 100 per cent of trade value between India and the UK. The DCC ensures employees moving between the two countries and their employers will only have to pay social security contributions in one country at a time. For temporary workers, the DCC ensures that 'fragmentation of their social security record' does not occur, the UK government said on Thursday. According to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the DCC will inject 'new energy' into the Indian and UK services sectors, particularly in technology and finance. 'It will promote ease of doing business, reduce cost of doing business, and increase the confidence of doing business. Additionally, UK's economy would benefit from India's skilled talent. These agreements will enhance investments and generate new employment opportunities in both countries. Moreover, as agreements reached between two democracies and two of the world's major economies, they will lend support to global stability and global prosperity,' Modi said at the joint briefing with his counterpart, Keir Starmer, on Thursday. A DCC does not cover access to social security benefits and does not change rules on access to benefits. The UK has agreements similar to the DCC with almost 50 countries. India, meanwhile, has such an understanding with 20 countries. According to British media reports, the exemption for India will cost the British government about £100 million. As part of the trade deal, IT and IT-enabled services, financial and legal services, professional and educational services, and digital trade will get greater access to the UK market. 'Indian professionals, including those deployed by companies to work in the UK across all services sectors, professionals deployed on contracts such as architects, engineers, chefs, yoga instructors and musicians, will benefit from simplified visa procedures and liberalised entry categories, making it easier for talent to work in the UK,' the Commerce Ministry said in a statement on Thursday. Services trade is key for India as it enjoys a surplus, compared to a heavy deficit when it comes to merchandise trade. In 2024-25, while India had a total merchandise trade deficit of $287 billion with the rest of the world, it had a services trade surplus of $189 billion. Specifically, India's services exports to the UK rose 16 per cent in 2024 to £14.7 billion, according to data from the Office of National Statistics, while services imports from the UK were flat at £10.1 billion. The exemption on insurance payments to Indian employees temporarily working in the UK has been a source of friction in British politics for years. In 2022, the then Home Secretary, Suella Braverman, had expressed her reservations about the trade deal with India, warning that it could lead to greater immigration to the UK, adding that Indians accounted for the largest number of those who overstayed their visas. More recently, after the deal was announced in May, shadow justice secretary Robert Jenrick said the social security contributions exemption was a sign that Starmer put British workers 'last'. 'This trade deal means Indian workers here for less than three years will not pay national insurance in the UK. Starmer has hiked national insurance on Brits while giving an exemption to Indian migrants. British workers come last in Starmer's Britain,' Jenrick had said on X on May 6. However, the UK government said Thursday that the net impact of the DCC on the British economy was 'significantly positive' and the cost of the DCC agreement 'is likely to be a fraction of the overall deal's economic benefit'. It said the DCC will not make it cheaper for UK firms to hire Indian workers and is not seen to have a long-term impact on net migration. Siddharth Upasani is a Deputy Associate Editor with The Indian Express. He reports primarily on data and the economy, looking for trends and changes in the former which paint a picture of the latter. Before The Indian Express, he worked at Moneycontrol and financial newswire Informist (previously called Cogencis). Outside of work, sports, fantasy football, and graphic novels keep him busy. ... Read More
