Wagner Park's disastrous eco-zealot makeover is an insult to downtown New York City
But New Yorkers should howl to the moon — and to the state legislature in Albany — over the desecration of a public jewel, done to suit the agenda of environmental zealots egged on by former Gov. Andrew Cuomo.
It's the most rotten Lower Manhattan scam since hustlers sold 'tickets' to the free Staten Island Ferry — only the warped park's victims aren't tourists but Wagner Park's millions of annual users, most of them New Yorkers.
The original Wagner Park, near Battery Park City's southern tip, opened in 1996 to universal acclaim. New York Times architectural critic Paul Goldberger called it 'one of the finest public spaces New York has seen in at least a generation.'
Advertisement
7 Wagner Park's once-level, river-facing side swelled into a stepped cliff of wooden, bleacher-like seats in an effort to prevent flooding that some feel went too far.
Tamara Beckwith
Battery Park City residents as well as New Yorkers from every part of town and tourists agreed. They fell in love with the 3.5-acre oasis' peaceful, river-fronting lawns that were ideal for sunbathing and taking in views of the harbor and the Statue of Liberty. A popular Italian restaurant buzzed indoors and outdoors with happy sun-worshippers and sightseers.
Now, they're all gone in the name of 'saving' the park from a mythical flood that exists only in its designers' imaginations.
Advertisement
The state-controlled Battery Park City Authority is, naturally, trying to cosmeticize the debacle with promises of future outdoor arts programs and hype over four planted 'ecological zones' that merely take space away from the original lawns.
We're meant to be impressed by an 'integrated flood barrier system' that 'maximizes water capture and reuse,' a 63,000-gallon underground cistern for rainwater reuse, 'flip-up deployables' (whatever they are), sustainable materials, native plantings and 'lush gardens planted with native, salt-resistant species.'
7 The park's central area was elevated 10 feet in order to conceal a buried flood wall.
Tamara Beckwith
7 Much of the lawn was sliced and diced into a ziggurat of paver-surfaced ramps and stairs that have no clear entry points.
Tamara Beckwith
Advertisement
But park-goers know otherwise.
Novelist Jon Pepper, a Battery Park City resident, said the new pavilion — slightly larger than the original one and relocated to the east — 'looks like bunkers on the Maginot Line,' a reference to France's WWII defense that failed to stop the Nazi advance.
Say this for the builders: They delivered, on time and within budget, precisely the lousy product that BPCA brochures promised.
Mature London plane trees were uprooted. The park's central area was elevated 10 feet in order to conceal a buried flood wall. Much of the lawn was sliced and diced into a ziggurat of paver-surfaced ramps and stairs that have no clear entry points.
Advertisement
7 Jon Pepper, a Battery Park City resident, said Wagner Park's new pavilion 'looks like bunkers on the Maginot Line,' a reference to France's WWII defense that failed to stop the Nazi advance.
Tamara Beckwith
The park's once-level, river-facing side swelled into a stepped cliff of wooden, bleacher-like seats where I saw precious few users on two sunny afternoons this week.
The revamped lawn is, on paper, only slightly smaller than the original one. But it's effectively much smaller due to the way it's segmented into landscaped portions that aren't conducive to lazing and lolling.
The modest concession building on the park's eastern side gave way to a lumbering red-brick structure that looms over the lawns' remnants like an intergalactic invader.
7 New Yorkers fell in love with the 3.5-acre former oasis' peaceful, river-fronting lawns that were ideal for sunbathing and taking in views of the harbor and the Statue of Liberty.
Helayne Seidman
7 The park's old, expansive lawn spaces were conducive to lolling and lazing.
Gabriella Bass
The BPCA put out a 'request for proposals' to operate a two-level, 5,000-square-foot restaurant — one-third larger than previous license holder Gigino's. The greater number of seats, combined with the pavilion's 'community center' and rooftop viewing area, will shatter Wagner Park's low-key ambience that was at the heart of its charm.
How did this all happen?
Advertisement
Besides enriching a legion of architects, engineers and landscape designers, the mutant 'park' is supposed to protect against a theoretical, worse-than-worst case, one-day-or-someday '100-year' flood caused by rising sea levels.
In fact, no such catastrophe has ever occurred. The original park was so securely engineered that Wagner Park suffered no damage whatsoever when superstorm Sandy caused the city's highest sea level rise ever recorded.
7 Locals led a fight to save the old Wagner Park that ultimately failed.
Gabriella Bass
All of landfill-based Battery Park City was designed to withstand any conceivable high water. Which was why, as New York Magazine reported and illustrated, the entire three-mile long complex 'shone brightly' after Sandy while most of the rest of Manhattan was dark.
Local residents fought fiercely against losing their beloved oasis, but in the end, the 'resiliency' lobby of climate-change alarmists carried the day.
Of course, New Yorkers don't want a woke lesson in saving the earth. They want a park easy to love — which, at Wagner Park, will live only in memory.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
5 minutes ago
- New York Post
Lizzo name-drops Sydney Sweeney in new song over American Eagle jean fiasco
Singer Lizzo has made a tongue-in-cheek reference to Sydney Sweeney's jean fiasco, following the mass backlash her American Eagle campaign ad received. The 4-time Grammy winner, 37, name-dropped the 'Euphoria' actress in her new song, 'I'm Goin' In Till October,' which she teased to her 11.6 million Instagram followers on Wednesday. The 'Truth Hurts' hitmaker rocked a pair of tight denim shorts for the teaser clip, in which she mentioned the 27-year-old actress following her jean ad that some critics claimed was full-on Nazi propaganda. Advertisement 5 Lizzo has made a tongue-in-cheek reference to Sydney Sweeney's jean fiasco in a new song. Instagram / @lizzobeeating 'No kizzy / He ain't got no business being with me,' Lizzo raps on the track. 'Fat ass pretty face with the t–ties / Bitch, I got good jeans like I'm Sydney.' 'IM GOIN IN TILL OCTOBER 😤,' the singer captioned the video. Advertisement In the clip, the 'Juice' singer wore a long platinum blonde wig and twerked up against a red Porsche. Sweeney became the talk of the town after she was featured in an American Eagle ad for the brand's fall denim campaign. The 'Anyone But You' actress sparked a 'woke' uproar from social media users who objected to the 'great jeans' wordplay that some interpret as having racial overtones. Advertisement The ad prompted intense public discussion since its launch, centering on advertisements that play with the phrase 'Sydney Sweeney has great jeans.' American Eagle has since responded to the discourse, issuing a public statement in which it doubled down on its creative choices. 5 The 'Euphoria' actress, 27, was hit with mass backlash following her American Eagle campaign ad. American Eagle 5 The 4-time Grammy winner, 37, name-dropped Sweeney in her new song, 'I'm Goin' In Till October.' Instagram / @lizzobeeating Advertisement 'This campaign is and always was about the jeans. Her jeans. Her narrative. We will continue to honor the unique ways everyone wears their AE jeans with confidence,' the company said. 'Great jeans flatter everyone.' The retailer emphasized that its focus remained on fashion rather than any other interpretation of its messaging. The 'White Lotus' actress, for her part, has remained silent throughout the debate. 5 The 'Truth Hurts' hitmaker rocked a pair of tight denim shorts for the teaser clip. Instagram / @lizzobeeating 5 Sweeney's ad, which was praised by President Trump, was accused of being full-on Nazi propaganda by some critics. American Eagle It comes just days after President Trump weighed in on the ad, praising it as 'fantastic' after finding out that Sweeney is a registered Republican voter. 'Oh, now I adore her ad … If Sydney Sweeney is registered, I think her ad is fantastic,' Trump said over the weekend.
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
‘Dongji Rescue' Star Kevin Lee on Playing a War Hero After a Decade as Chinese Cinema's Go-To Bad Guy: ‘I'm Ready for More Than Just the Villain Role'
After nearly a decade of playing memorable villains in some of China's biggest blockbusters, Kevin Lee is finally getting to be the good guy. In 'Dongji Rescue,' the keenly anticipated $80 million Chinese WWII action thriller from Cannes award-winning filmmaker Guan Hu ('Black Dog,' 'The Eight Hundred'), Lee trades his usual combat boots and weaponry for a more sympathetic role as a British POW caught in one of the war's most devastating maritime tragedies. More from Variety 'Black Dog' Director Guan Hu's $80 Million WWII Epic 'Dongji Rescue' Lands European Distribution With Trinity CineAsia 'Black Dog' Director Guan Hu Brings $80 Million WWII Epic 'Dong Ji Island' to Cannes Market With Seventh Art Pictures Beijing International Film Festival Marks Triple Milestone With Star-Studded Opening The film, co-directed by Hu and Fei Zhenxiang, dramatizes the real-life Lisbon Maru incident of October 1942, when an American submarine accidentally torpedoed a Japanese vessel transporting approximately 1,800 British prisoners of war from Hong Kong. Chinese fishermen from Dongji Island ultimately rescued more than 800 survivors in what ranks among the war's most harrowing episodes involving British forces. Lee stars alongside Chinese A-listers Zhu Yilong ('Only the River Flows'), Wu Lei ('Shadow') and Ni Ni ('The Flowers of War'), plus British newcomer William Franklyn-Miller. For Lee, whose breakout role in 'Wolf Warrior' established him as the quintessential Western villain in Chinese cinema, 'Dongji Rescue' represents both a career pivot and a deeply personal project. 'When I first read the script, I was shocked,' Lee tells Variety. 'I'd never heard of the Lisbon Maru incident, yet here was this deeply moving story of ordinary Chinese fishermen risking everything to save British POWs. As a Brit who's lived in China for over a decade, it hit me on many levels.' The role marks a significant departure for Lee, who has spent years perfecting his antagonist craft in films like 'The Battle at Lake Changjin' and 'Snipers.' His character in 'Dongji Rescue,' Lieutenant Colonel H.W.M. (Monkey) Stewart, is based on a real British high-ranking POW, adding layers of historical responsibility to the performance. 'It definitely felt refreshing,' Lee says of the shift. 'I've played antagonists in many Chinese films and always took pride in those roles. But 'Dongji Rescue' let me step into truth and empathy.' The casting came during a particularly hectic period for the actor. 'I auditioned during a quiet period in 2024, running on five hours of sleep after wrapping another project.' he recalls. 'Luckily, negotiations followed soon after.' To prepare for the historically grounded role, Lee immersed himself in research about POW conditions, survivor testimonies, and classic war films. He also watched 'The Sinking of the Lisbon Maru,' the documentary that was China's entry to the Oscars' international category and covers the same incident. 'The documentary hit me hard, emotionally,' Lee admits. 'A lot of tears. These weren't just background names, they were real men with families and dreams, caught in something horrific.' The physical demands of the shoot proved equally challenging. 'The hardest part? Swimming scenes, fighting currents, dodging debris, timing everything for camera,' he says. 'It was intense.' Looking back on his unlikely journey from an aspiring actor making a living as a finance executive in China to action star, Lee describes his entry into Chinese cinema as a combination of fate, opportunity and persistence. The turning point came during a chance encounter with 'Wolf Warrior' actor-director Wu Jing while renewing his visa in Beijing. 'That meeting changed everything,' Lee explains. 'I quit my job in finance, took a leap of faith, and stayed because I worked hard and didn't give up. Against all the odds, it has somewhat paid off.' In 'Wolf Warrior' (2015), Lee played Mad Cow, a mercenary in the villain squad opposite Wu Jing in the action thriller that would launch China's most successful patriotic film franchise. The $89 million box office hit established Lee as the go-to Western antagonist in Chinese cinema and opened doors to a decade of high-profile roles. 'I will be forever grateful for and will always be indebted to Wu Jing for trusting in me,' Lee says. Since then, Lee has built an impressive filmography across some of China's biggest blockbusters. In 'The Battle at Lake Changjin' (2021), he played Colonel Allan MacLean, commanding officer of the 31st Infantry Regiment in the $200 million Korean War epic that became China's then highest-grossing film of all time with $913 million worldwide. He was cast as a hitman in Jackie Chan's 'Kung Fu Yoga' (1017) and in Zhang Yimou's 'Sniper' (2022) and his credits also include 'Super Me,' '100 Yards,' 'Pound of Flesh' and 'S.W.A.T.' Despite his success in the villain space, Lee is eager to expand his range. 'The truth is, I'm a pretty sweet guy off-screen and I'd love a shot at those type of roles,' he says. 'As a foreign actor in China, roles are limited by the scripts. Majority of movies here are either period, war or wuxia [martial arts] movies. Foreign actors in China rarely get cast in rom-coms or comedies, which is a shame.' Having witnessed the rapid evolution of China's film industry over more than a decade, Lee has seen significant changes in how international actors are integrated on set. 'It's changed a lot,' he reflects. 'Now, there's better communication, more inclusion and stronger professionalism.' Lee continues to study monologues, work on his American accent and shoot skits whenever possible. 'I'm deeply passionate about this craft,' he says. As for what's next, Lee sees 'Dongji Rescue' as a potential turning point. 'It allowed me to step into something more nuanced — a role with heart, with dignity and based on a real human being,' he says. 'And I hope it signals to the industry that I'm ready for more than just the villain role.' While China remains home after more than a decade, Lee has his sights set on global expansion. 'Hollywood is a huge goal of mine as well, like any ambitious actor, I guess,' he says. 'The experience I've gained makes me a better actor and storyteller, and I want to bring that experience to new audiences. I'm ready to mix with the best and grow even further.' 'Dongji Rescue' hits U.K. and Irish cinemas Aug. 22, with other European territories following from Aug. 29. It opens in China on Aug. 8. Best of Variety New Movies Out Now in Theaters: What to See This Week What's Coming to Disney+ in August 2025 What's Coming to Netflix in August 2025
New York Times
2 hours ago
- New York Times
A Stunning Novel Follows Nazi Hunters Over Decades and Continents
THE FEELING OF IRON, by Giaime Alonge; translated by Clarissa Botsford. Before it became a Nazi laboratory for sinister experiments, the weapons room of Baron Wilhelm von Lehndorff's castle in East Prussia housed an exotic arsenal including 'Polish cavalry spears and Lithuanian infantry pikes, Swedish muzzle-loading muskets and British repeating rifles, crude Croatian Pandur busbies and elegant Austrian kepìs.' Yet none of these formidable arms, at least in Giaime Alonge's stunning new novel, 'The Feeling of Iron,' will be any match for a new weapon that will be tested in the future laboratory: a tiny orange square, smaller than a postage stamp, that promises the cost-effective creation of a superior warrior class. The Germans call it Lysergsaurediethylamid. It will become commonly known as LSD. In 1941, at the height of World War II, the belief is that soldiers tripping on acid will not experience exhaustion — and probably not morality, either. Maj. Hans Lichtblau, the Nazi scientist in charge of the lab, receives his first tab from his boss, who is none other than Heinrich Himmler. Alonge imagines Himmler as a mystic who likes LSD more than Jerry Garcia does. (His appearance here is a subtle reminder that much of the depravity described in the novel was not a fiction.) Under Lichtblau's control, the lab's subjects include two young Jewish prisoners, Anton and Shlomo, who escape the castle when the war turns and the Soviets arrive. In a second timeline, interwoven with the first, it is 1982 and we are witness to another laboratory, this one in far less fancy surroundings: the Honduran jungle. It's the era of Ronald Reagan and the Contras, and a new war is on, fought by non-nation-state proxies, including an Old Etonian with a taste for blood. Major Lichtblau is an old man living under a new name, Huberman. He has replaced the Reich with a new master: the Central Intelligence Agency. When he's not cooking coke and running guns with the Contras, Lichtblau/Huberman spends weekends taking acid in upstate New York with Timothy Leary or partying in Los Angeles. Movie stars like his life of intrigue as much as they like his stylish oil-heiress wife, his dark sense of humor and his access. Who cares where he came from if the coke is good? Memories are short outside the war zone. Anton and Shlomo, in these sections of the novel, come together to complete a mission: find Lichtblau and kill him. The assassination is funded not by the Israelis but by the Group, an international coalition of wealthy Jewish financiers who have trained their fortunes on revenge. Vengeance, its enduring allure and equally enduring futility, is Alonge's central theme. In the novel, history is not a line but an infinity loop. Characters change, yet are defined by the unending cycle of what Cormac McCarthy called 'the ultimate trade' — war. The novel's title comes from a conversation between Lichtblau and Baron von Lehndorff, just after the castle is appropriated by the Nazis. The baron, a former fencing champion, agrees to some friendly bouts with his guest, with whom he adamantly disagrees about everything else. 'You need to feel the blade as if it were an extension of your arm,' von Lehndorff advises during a break. 'You don't need eyes to move your wrist. The French call it le sentiment du fer, a feel for the iron.' It is a fine metaphor for what happens when war's costs are internalized and become part of us. Alonge is a screenwriter and an associate professor of film history at the University of Turin, and his style is as cinematic as the finest classic thrillers. As characters from the novel's two timelines converge, every narrative puzzle piece laid down in the past locks in perfectly. In its scope and beauty, 'The Feeling of Iron' also recalls great 19th-century novels like Tolstoy's 'War and Peace,' while its lyric, spare examination of a covert life is reminiscent of Joan Didion's 'Democracy.' Clarissa Botsford's translation is precise and eloquent, never splashy. Every line is a jewel. Some of the novel's most heartbreaking moments are in Alonge's depictions of children. When the young Lichtblau throws a Christmas party in the castle, he gives his girlfriend's son a train set, freshly confiscated from a wealthy family in Lille. Observing the boy unwrap the gift with glee, Lichtblau imagines the child it was actually meant for, 'a child who may well have vanished: buried … in a large pit dug by a bulldozer.' Lichtblau is unsentimental about slaughter. He is, he believes, a man of science, innovation and war. Eventually, he experiences his own moment of death as just another hallucination, one that he believes will, like all bad trips, come to an end. THE FEELING OF IRON | By Giaime Alonge | Translated by Clarissa Botsford | Europa | 443 pp. | Paperback, $19
