logo
Delhi: No trauma centre for Uphaar Cinema fire later victims, ₹60cr fine missing

Delhi: No trauma centre for Uphaar Cinema fire later victims, ₹60cr fine missing

Hindustan Times13-06-2025
Twenty-eight years after the Uphaar cinema fire claimed 59 lives and wounded over 100 others, the trauma centre promised in memory of the victims remains missing. Victims' families said the absence of the facility — despite ₹60 crore collected from Gopal Ansal and Sushil Ansal, cinema owners who were convicted in the case, nearly a decade ago — on the Supreme Court's orders underscores the indifference to justice and public safety.
The trauma centre was to be built in west Delhi's Dwarka within two years of a 2015 SC directive, using fines paid by the Ansal brothers. The plan was clear: the Delhi government was to allocate at least five acres of land and construct a state-of-the-art trauma centre in one of the city's most accident-prone areas. Yet today, no foundation stone has been laid, and the ₹60 crore — now estimated to have grown to over ₹100 crore with interest — remains unaccounted for.
'For decades, we have fought a legal battle for only two things: one, to get justice for our children, and another, that the tragedy can help bring some change,' said Neelam Krishnamoorthy, whose children -- Unnati, 17, and Ujjwal, 13 -- were among the 59 who were killed in the fire in the south Delhi hall where Sunny Deol starrer Border was being screened. She leads the Association of Victims of Uphaar Tragedy (AVUT). 'We're not asking for favours. All we want is that the fine deposited by the Ansals be used to make the trauma centre, which will be very beneficial for the residents of Delhi and, in times of any incidents like this, can help save lives,' she said.
'AVUT members now fear that we are getting old, we do not know whether we will be here tomorrow or not, and so no one will be there to question the government. Hence, we are raising the issue and want the government to act on it,' she said.
In a landmark judgment in August 2015, the Supreme Court, instead of sending the Ansals back to prison, ordered them to pay ₹30 crore each. The court directed the Delhi government to use this money to build a trauma facility in memory of the victims. The order called for a 'Victims of Uphaar Memorial Trauma Centre' with a dedicated burns ward and accident services.
The money was deposited with the Delhi government in November 2015. Yet nearly 10 years later, the families say they have been met with silence and bureaucratic apathy.
In multiple RTI queries filed in 2019 and again in 2024, departments including the Chief Secretary's office, the health ministry, the law department, and the Directorate General of Health Services responded saying that the information 'is not available' or 'does not pertain' to them.
'The state has neither allotted land nor offered any explanation,' said Shekhar Krishnamoorthy, another AVUT member who lost both children in the fire. 'We are left wondering whether anyone will be held accountable, or if time and delay will again erase the promise of justice.'
AVUT has now approached the Supreme Court again, urging it to push for the implementation of its 2015 order. On April 22 this year, the court issued notice to the Delhi government, seeking a response. The next hearing is scheduled for July 16.
HT reached out to an official in the chief minister's office for a response, but the official did not respond till the time of going to print.
For the families, the centre is not merely symbolic. 'This is not just about memory,' Neelam said. 'This is about public health. This is about preventing the next Uphaar.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

‘Probe should be judicially examined': HC upholds summoning of 6 cleared by SIT in Tarn Taran murder trial
‘Probe should be judicially examined': HC upholds summoning of 6 cleared by SIT in Tarn Taran murder trial

Indian Express

time8 minutes ago

  • Indian Express

‘Probe should be judicially examined': HC upholds summoning of 6 cleared by SIT in Tarn Taran murder trial

The Punjab and Haryana High Court Tuesday refused to quash a Tarn Taran trial court's order summoning six more people to face trial in a 2020 petrol pump murder case, holding that Special Investigation Team (SIT) findings are not binding on courts. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj, dismissing a revision petition by five of those summoned, relied heavily on the Supreme Court's 2014 Constitution Bench ruling in Hardeep Singh vs State of Punjab, which defined the scope of Section 319 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC). 'The truthfulness of the plea of alibi raised by the petitioners can be verified on the appreciation of the evidence led by the parties,' the court said, adding: 'There is no gainsaying that the findings arrived at by the SIT are not binding on the court and every investigation has to be judicially examined.' The case stems from an October 11, 2020, shooting at the Raj Kumar Brothers petrol pump on Khemkaran Road in Bhikhiwind. According to the FIR, complainant Dinesh Kumar was at the pump with his brother-in-law Mandeep Kumar alias Monu, who died in the attack, Paramjit Kumar and an employee when a group of armed men arrived. Kumar named seven accused, including Satwinder Singh alias Pasi, Gurpreet Singh alias Gopi, Charanjit Singh, Harbhajan Singh, and Surjit Singh alias Vicky, along with 15–20 unidentified others. He alleged that Gopi fired the fatal shot, while others attacked and threatened them. The motive was linked to a civil dispute over a passage adjoining the pump. An SIT formed on November 17, 2020, later gave three accused, namely Charanjit, Surjit, and Jasbir Singh Pasi, a clean chit based on CCTV footage and call records. Over subsequent reports, Harbhajan, Kulbir Singh Pasi and Gurnam Singh Pasi were also declared innocent. Initially, only Gopi and Satwinder faced trial. During the trial, complainant Dinesh Kumar, testifying as a witness, repeated his allegations against all the accused. This led to a fresh application under Section 319 CrPC, which allows a court to summon others for trial if evidence emerges against them. On June 7, 2024, the trial court summoned all six earlier let off by the SIT. The petitioners argued that the SIT's scientific evidence, including CCTV and call data, proved their alibi, and said the trial court had ignored the discretionary and exceptional nature of Section 319 powers. They also cited a cross-case filed by Charanjit Singh against the complainant's side. Quoting Hardeep Singh, Justice Bhardwaj underlined that Section 319 CrPC confers 'discretionary and extraordinary power… to be exercised sparingly… only where strong and cogent evidence occurs… and not in a casual and cavalier manner.' The judge also cited the Supreme Court's view that the evidence required under Section 319 'is more than prima facie… but short of satisfaction that the evidence, if goes unrebutted, would lead to conviction' and that 'there is no scope… to form any opinion as to the guilt of the accused.' Referring to earlier precedents, including Joginder Singh (1979) and Anju Chaudhary (2013), the court noted that even those named in the FIR but not charge-sheeted can be summoned if warranted. Finding 'no infirmity' in the Tarn Taran court's order, Justice Bhardwaj dismissed the petition without commenting on the merits.

Report says China a 'global mining mafia': At least 15 gold-rich nations complain about illegality
Report says China a 'global mining mafia': At least 15 gold-rich nations complain about illegality

First Post

time10 minutes ago

  • First Post

Report says China a 'global mining mafia': At least 15 gold-rich nations complain about illegality

Illicit mining operations in nations like Indonesia, where oversight is frequently compromised and enforcement is lax, are now contributing to meeting that demand A growing network of Chinese-led syndicates is fueling an increase in illicit gold mining throughout Indonesia, turning small-scale, traditional operations into large-scale businesses and igniting concerns about corruption, environmental damage, and geopolitical risk. Demand for gold has surged as a result of China increasing its gold reserves as part of a larger plan to lessen reliance on the US dollar. Illicit mining operations in nations like Indonesia, where oversight is frequently compromised and enforcement is lax, are now contributing to meeting that demand, according to a recent Washington Post investigation. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Local communities pushed aside What were formerly unofficial, artisanal mining sites have evolved into highly mechanised areas controlled by Chinese investors and operators in areas like West Kalimantan and West Nusa Tenggara. These syndicates extract gold on a scale well beyond the law, frequently without the necessary permits or safety precautions, using imported heavy machinery, chemical leaching systems, and a large number of local workers. In one instance, Chinese investors allegedly made over $5.5 million a month from illicit mining in Lombok's Sekotong district before local communities rebelled due to contaminated water and disappearing farmland. Only after villagers set fire to the mining site in August 2024, forcing authorities to step in, was the operation shut down. Yu Hao, a Chinese national, was arrested in Ketapang, West Kalimantan, for running a gold mine without a license in another well-known case. According to the prosecution, his company used shell corporations and falsified documents to unlawfully extract more than $67 million worth of gold and silver. Despite being found guilty and given a prison sentence, a local court controversially reversed the decision; however, in response to public outcry, Indonesia's Supreme Court later upheld the verdict. Environmental Damage and Global Supply Chain Risks These mining mafias sometimes operate under dormant mining licenses, bribe local officials, and take advantage of legal grey areas. Investigators caution that the criminal networks responsible for them are cross-provincial and could be connected to international smuggling rings and money laundering schemes. According to analysts, the illicit gold trade now generates more than $30 billion a year worldwide. The effects on the environment are dire. Gold processing uses cyanide and mercury, which have ruined crops, contaminated groundwater and rivers, and increased health problems in the communities around them. Due to corruption or the influence of well-funded foreign actors, local authorities frequently do nothing. Despite international concerns, China has refused to engage in multinational efforts to regulate illegal gold flows, and its gold import practices remain opaque. Analysts warn that without coordinated global action, tainted gold will continue to enter legitimate markets, undermining supply chain integrity and fueling further environmental damage.

Man's Post On Migrant Workers Amid Stray Dog Debate Viral: Why Internet Rounded Up 'Elites'
Man's Post On Migrant Workers Amid Stray Dog Debate Viral: Why Internet Rounded Up 'Elites'

News18

time35 minutes ago

  • News18

Man's Post On Migrant Workers Amid Stray Dog Debate Viral: Why Internet Rounded Up 'Elites'

Several actors including Jahnvi Kapoor and Varun Dhawan who have spoken in favour of stray dogs have been trolled online for their "privileged" opinions. If you have just logged in to the Internet, welcome. A lot has unfolded in the past 24 hours. The Supreme Court ordered the removal of stray dogs from the streets of the capital city while hearing a suo motu case against the canines attacking children. This has led to a national debate that doesn't seem to cease any time soon. One camp believes that SC's order to round up stray dogs is a short-sighted and inhumane decision, one that is impractical. Where will the stray dogs go? Questioned a large number of netizens who strongly believe that lack of shelter and space would eventually deplete their population in this 'cruel" and enforced crackdown on the canines. The other side argued that the stray dogs were a menace to society and the rising case of dog bites, some even leading to horrific deaths, put especially the vulnerable, kids and the elderly, at most risk. The human lives trumped the animal lives, they said. But what about the migrant workers, delivery drivers, or BPO employees who return home late regularly? A man's post on X, extending his empathy towards workers toiling on the streets at night, has resonated with many. 'You Don't Realise The Consequences" X user, who goes by the handle @Prithvi10_, wrote: 'People who work till late into the night are majorly migrants who work at restaurants / bars who finish their job and return home from narrow lanes, food delivery boys, there are even BPO employees who walk home a lil from their dropping point (sic)." He added that these people aren't well-to-do and have to fight off the strays daily. The delivery persons put their lives at risk by speeding on their bikes to fend off the chasing strays. 'Why should they go through this. These are just hardly 2-3 examples," the user wrote before stating that there are videos of children being attacked by the animals on the loose and many of those incidents lead to deaths. He added that the workers who were at constant mercy of stray dogs did not enjoy the privilege of having secure jobs, and one unfortunate attack on them would mean someone else would replace their job, leaving them with no salary to run home. Concluding his now-viral post, the user remarked that the privileged were guarded by their cars when they stepped out to smoke late at night, and they were in no position to realise the consequences of defending the presence of strays on the streets and in society. A Reddit user, agreeing with the viral post, remarked that they had spent 20 years around pet dogs and they still took the necessary precautions, including muzzles and leashes, to safeguard others as dogs naturally possessed 'animalistic instincts". So an unsupervised stray was prone to attacking unprovoked. 'I'm a dog lover and and a I own 3 dogs. I can without any doubt say that strays are not just a problem for the society but for their own self too. They are fried up in summers, they freeze in winters, they reproduce within themselves(incest) and are born with disabilities too. Apart from feeding them no one cares for them (sic)." 'For the strays no one cares, they are a ticking time bomb always. The SC order is justified and in the benefit of all. The only concern is that the authorities actually should care for the strays once they are moved to a shelter (sic)." The Reddit commenter also urged people to refrain from calling it 'animal cruelty". They added that it did concern them what the future of these strays would be at the shelter and if they would be looked after well. 'Elites Know Nothing" Dismissing their Instagram protest as performative, many on X panned Bollywood celebrities for sharing a forwarded template in support of the stray dogs. The prevailing argument was that Bollywood celebrities, shielded and insulated, lacked a true understanding of ground-level realities. 'They call it a menace. We call it a heartbeat." Gated society elites preach "love street dogs" because they've never had a pack chase them at midnight. Dump 20 outside their villas and watch that love PR started — Wellu (@Wellutwt) August 12, 2025 'Gated society elites preach 'love street dogs" because they've never had a pack chase them at midnight. Dump 20 outside their villas and watch that love evaporate.." a user remarked. Animal Rights Activities, Dog Lovers Animal welfare advocates have emphasised that extensive sterilisation programs, regular vaccination campaigns, and community feeding centres offer more compassionate and sustainable solutions for managing stray populations. 'The real fix? Large-scale sterilisation programs, regular vaccination drives, community feeding zones, and adoption campaigns. Not punishment. Not imprisonment." John Abraham, Sanya Malhotra, and Bhumi Pednekar were among the many celebrities who have reacted strongly to the SC order. About the Author News Desk The News Desk is a team of passionate editors and writers who break and analyse the most important events unfolding in India and abroad. From live updates to exclusive reports to in-depth explainers, the Desk More Get Latest Updates on Movies, Breaking News On India, World, Live Cricket Scores, And Stock Market Updates. Also Download the News18 App to stay updated! tags : Jahnvi Kapoor stray dog view comments Location : New Delhi, India, India First Published: August 13, 2025, 13:32 IST News explainers Man's Post On Migrant Workers Amid Stray Dog Debate Viral: Why Internet Rounded Up 'Elites' Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store