Apartment prices rebound fails to materialise as investors sell at a loss
After a striking surge in stand-alone home prices during the pandemic when house prices doubled the gains recorded by apartments, the gap in favour of houses has widened again.
Many forecasters had expected unit prices to catch up. But new figures suggest the humble unit remains very humble indeed.
A new report from the Cotality group (formerly CoreLogic) says there is 'a persistent underperformance in the unit sector over the decade to March'.
Eliza Owen of Cotality suggests: 'What we are seeing is a re-acceleration in the outperformance of house, which must be frustrating for unit investors.'
Put simply, the majority of all properties in the March quarter that sold for a loss – 63 per cent – were units.
Worse still, the black spots are in major cities where most everyday investors place their interests – often using negative gearing to finance their investments. Around 90 per cent of all loss-making sales in Sydney are apartments.
Meanwhile, in Melbourne, more than one in five apartments have been sold at a loss.
What's happening? In a word, oversupply. Property developers have swamped key suburbs with off-the-plan projects that offer a low cost entry point into the market. That's why the ongoing rock bottom rental vacancy rate of 1 per cent has not helped unit prices turn the corner.
At it's worst – where there is a combination of oversupply and high property taxes – such as in Victoria, the numbers become abysmal. The figures this year for Melbourne are the worst recorded since the deep recession in the state that hit more than three decades ago in the 1990s.
The other key factor is that investors are selling at the slightest prospect of opportunity.
The first rate cut this year back in February prompted a wave of selling into the market. Many of those sellers had held loss-making apartments for a long time – the median hold period on units sold at a loss was 8½ years.
Allowing for inflation – not to mention mortgage servicing costs – this means property investment for many unit investors has been a complete failure.
Over the last decade stand alone homes have literally done twice as well as units – rising 80 per cent against 38 per cent.
A closer look at the numbers reveals that a significant drag on the wider unit numbers comes from just four areas, which account for around 20 per cent of unit losses, and three of these areas are in Melbourne: Melbourne city, Port Philip and Stonnington. The fourth is Parramatta in Sydney.
Outside of the black spots of central Melbourne and Sydney, there has been a very recent uptick in unit prices in some suburbs with analysts expecting profitability to improve in all corners of the market if the RBA continues to cut interest rates.
In the overall market, 95 per cent of all property resales delivered a profit, representing about 86,000 resales in the March quarter, where the median nominal gain was $305,000, down from $310,000
James Kirby
Associate Editor - Wealth
James Kirby, Associate Editor-Wealth, is one of Australia's most experienced financial journalists. James hosts The Australian's twice-weekly Money Puzzle podcast. He is a regular commentator on radio and television, the author of several business biographies and has served on the Walkley Awards Advisory Board He was a co-founder and managing editor at Business Spectator and Eureka Report and has previously worked at the Australian Financial Review and the South China Morning Post. Since January 2025 James is a director of Ecstra, the financial literacy foundation.
@kirby_journo
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Australian
20 minutes ago
- The Australian
Long Shortz: Petratherm
Tylah Tully chats with Petratherm (ASX:PTR) CEO Peter Reid after the company's recent step-out drilling at the Rosewood prospect extended mineralisation up to 3km north and uncovered additional targets. Within the joint venture Muckanippie project, Petratherm has now earned into a 70% equity. Large-scale metallurgical test work completed on bulk samples is underway in Brisbane, with early results supporting the potential for a world-class discovery. The company has appointed veteran mineral sands specialist Victor Araujo as Head of Project Development to guide the project through early-stage scoping and future mine development. Watch the video for more. This video was developed in collaboration with Petratherm, a Stockhead client at the time of publishing. The interviews and discussions in this video are opinions only and not financial or investment advice. Viewers should obtain independent advice based on their own circumstances before making any financial decisions.
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
Hidden fortune: What Aussie cleaners find in home clean-outs
Stressed Aussies are unknowingly tossing tens of thousands of dollars in the bin – with cleaners finding as much as $15,000 in cash hidden in a handbag in a shock new trend. A silent disaster is unfolding across Australia's suburbs as stressed descendants and downsizers rush to move on, with commercial cleaners clearing out properties find thousands of dollars worth of inheritance destined for skip bins. Bob Morton, co-founder of The Property Clearance Company, is among hundreds of businesses now rushed off their feet keeping up with demand as the $19.8 billion commercial cleaning sector expands into residential properties. 'We've seen people unknowingly throw away tens of thousands of dollars' worth of items and we've seen families break down over preventable misunderstandings,' he said. 'We've seen people toss out antique clocks, first-edition books and signed artworks thinking they were worthless.' 'One family threw out a set of vintage tools that later sold for more than $4,000.' 'We've found cash relatively often — sometimes thousands of dollars — and valuable jewellery like gold, diamonds, and even a Banksy artwork, which the family didn't know they had.' Govt pays $3.3m for unliveable derelict house 'We found a signed painting under a bed that was worth over $8,000. People don't always know what they're holding onto, but once it's gone, it's gone for good.' Among the salvaged items was a 1970s Steve Austin six million dollar man toy in its original packaging – worth a shattering $1,000 in the collectors' market. 'Some toys you buy today are worth nothing tomorrow, this one is unique.' Mr Morton said the team in the multistate family business he runs with wife Jude love finding things of both financial and sentimental value to clients. 'The ones that really come to mind are often the items of sentimental importance that had either been long since forgotten or people didn't even know were there. That happens a lot when families have lived in a home for decades, sometimes multi-generation.' 'Just a few weeks ago, we found a letter a client had written to her dad for Father's Day when she was seven. She's now in her 50s and had recently lost him. It was emotional for her and for our team.' 'There's jewellery and things like that people have long forgotten. One client said to me, I couldn't remember if this was real or not, because I've got a childhood memory of it but I hadn't seen it for decades. We were moving a cabinet out of a bedroom and a brooch was under it. We said, does this mean anything to you? It was very emotional.' He said a professional decluttering and clear out required five to seven days for a typical three bedroom home, and they are seeing a rise in downsizers overwhelmed by the need to declutter their life's possessions. 'This is one of life's biggest transitions and getting it wrong can cost far more than money,' he said. 'We do this for a living and are licensed second-hand dealers with an eye for both financial and sentimental value. Even then, we consult specialists for certain items.' Mr Morton has five red flags to watch for when decluttering or downsizing a home. The first, he said, was never throw things out before checking their value – what seems like junk to one generation can be a goldmine. 'Retro items from the '60s and '70s are especially valuable if in good condition — vinyl records, biscuit tins, designer furniture.' 'We've seen people throw out vintage tools worth $4,000 and priceless family treasures — all because they were in a hurry to 'just get it done'.' Don't let emotion cloud your judgment and rush you either, he warns. And he adds that most people's go-to strategy of blitzing through a house in one weekend is one of the worst things they could do. 'We hear it all the time. 'I wish I hadn't rushed it'. The problem is, once it's gone, you can't get it back. Taking time to thoughtfully sort through a home is the only way to ensure nothing important is lost.' Do not sell off the entire contents or dump it all in one go without having a look through. 'We've seen mid-century designer furniture, valuable art and antique tools snapped up for next to nothing,' he said. 'If someone offers to take a houseful of goods off your hands in one day, chances are you're being taken for a ride.' The other red flag, he said, was not documenting everything and creating an inventory – especially when multiple family members are involved in clearing out the family home to help elderly parents move into care or retirement living. 'We've had siblings argue over furniture, jewellery and even family photo albums,' Mr Morton said. 'An inventory protects everyone. It creates transparency, avoids suspicion, and gives families peace of mind.' The fifth red flag, he said, was thinking it was all 'just stuff'. He said every object has a story and some have significant emotional or monetary value. 'People often overlook sentimental items that hold family history and real monetary value. We help them see the difference.' 'That battered old typewriter in the garage might be a rare collector's item. Mum's handbag could be a vintage designer piece. Even handwritten recipes, love letters and holiday souvenirs can be deeply meaningful to future generations.' 'This is more than just a clean-up, it's the closing of a life chapter,' he said. 'Done right, it can be a respectful and even healing process. Done wrong, it's a source of lifelong regret.'
AU Financial Review
an hour ago
- AU Financial Review
Chris Hemsworth's neighbours sell Broken Head beachfront for $36m
Hollywood megastar and Broken Head local Chris Hemsworth and his wife, Elsa Pataky, are about to welcome some deep-pocketed new neighbours to the area after the next-door resort-style compound sold for about $36 million. The sale of the sprawling property called Ohana has clocked a NSW North Coast record for its Sydney-based owners, former Rich Lister and the former chairman of deep-water oil-drilling business Benthic Geotech, Russell Staley and his wife, Jennifer.
