SNP rebels plot to oust John Swinney as party leader after Hamilton by-election loss
It has been reported that 25 people were part of a summit which discussed Swinney's future.
Senior SNP figures met to plot the ousting of John Swinney as party leader in the wake of Hamilton by-election defeat.
The Herald has reported that 25 people were presented, with one claiming Swinney could face a leadership challenge this year unless he brings forward a new independence strategy within two weeks.
The First Minister is facing growing criticism after the SNP lost to Labour last week in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse.
Party figures believe he has no strategy for independence and are frustrated at a lack of boldness on domestic policy.
The rebels are reported to have met on Monday to discuss a possible leadership challenge.
An SNP insider said: 'NEC members better start looking for new hobbies unless the leadership announces a change of direction soon — because at this rate we are heading for a mass clear-out.
'It feels like Groundhog Day. The last time John was in charge he dropped independence, surrounded himself only by people who agreed with him, and pushed out the likes of Margo [McDonald] and anyone who challenged his devolutionist strategy.
'For those with short memories, that ended in a bruising defeat. If he stays, we will be heading for a repeat. What is left of the membership will not tolerate it.
'The ability to make the case for independence is not a desirable part of the job description — it is essential — and he has failed on probation.
'The Presbyterian schoolmaster might fly in Perthshire — but in the rest of Scotland it just does not land. Stabilising the party only works for a short time. There is no energy, no fire, no boldness, no long-term vision.'
SNP rules dictate that any member who can secure 100 nominations from 20 different branches ahead of conference can trigger a leadership vote.
Swinney was criticised for a by-election strategy which claimed the contest was a straight fight between the SNP and Reform, even though Labour ended up winning.
He was also SNP leader between 2000 and 2004, but was ousted after a leadership challenge by party member Bill Wilson.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
18 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Swinney begs rebels not to oust him
The SNP leader has pleaded with party rebels not to press ahead with a threatened leadership challenge after a shock by-election defeat. John Swinney, the First Minister, warned it would not be a 'good idea' for disaffected Nationalists to try and oust him at the SNP conference in October. Mr Swinney said he had helped the SNP 'recover from a very, very difficult situation' following the troubled final months of Nicola Sturgeon 's premiership and Humza Yousaf 's chaotic tenure. His plea came the day after it was reported that 25 senior SNP figures met on Monday evening to discuss removing Mr Swinney, barely a year after he succeeded Mr Yousaf. They warned that he risked facing a leadership challenge at the SNP conference in Aberdeen unless he comes up with a new strategy to achieve Scottish independence. Discontent with his leadership has surfaced after Labour pulled off a surprise victory in last week's Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election, which the SNP had been hot favourites to win. The defeat followed Labour's rout of the SNP in last year's general election, also under Mr Swinney's leadership. Alex Neil, a former Cabinet minister in Alex Salmond's and Ms Sturgeon's governments, said that Mr Swinney should be replaced. Mr Swinney is expected to face robust questions at a meeting of the party's ruling national executive committee on Sunday about his by-election campaign strategy, which focused on the claim that it was a straight fight between the SNP and Reform UK. The Guardian reported that he faced criticism about the strategy at a 'fractious' MSP group meeting on Tuesday, with one backbencher claiming he had 'panicked' at the rise of Reform, which finished a close third in the contest. Insiders also expect him to face pressure to come up with much clearer strategy for achieving independence, after he warned that support for separation would have to rise to more than 60 per cent to get another referendum. Under SNP rules, any member who can secure 100 nominations from 20 different branches ahead of party conference can trigger a leadership vote. Mr Swinney admitted that he had 'absolutely no idea' about whether he would face a challenge but said: 'I don't think that would be a good idea.' Speaking after First Minister's Questions at Holyrood, he said: 'I came into office to help the SNP recover from a very, very difficult situation in the spring of 2024, and I'm very focused on making sure that we make that recovery to be ready for the 2026 elections, and that's what's the focus of my thinking and my planning. 'I've obviously taken forward a number of steps over the course of the last 12 months to get the SNP into a better position.' He insisted that the SNP would not have even been in contention in the by-election before he took over, despite the party winning the seat in the 2021 Holyrood contest by 4,582 votes. Labour won the contest last week by 602 votes, after the SNP vote in the seat dropped by 17 points compared to 2021. Swinney worried 'not in the slightest' However, Mr Swinney said he was 'not in the slightest' worried about the internal briefing against him, and rejected criticism that he was not moving fast enough on independence. He said he had spent the first year of his leadership 'addressing the issues that people are immediately preoccupied by', such as the cost of living crisis. Mr Swinney said this was necessary to ensure 'we could get a hearing' from the public, but his 'phase two' plan was to 'open up a conversation about independence' ahead of next year's election. But Anas Sarwar, the Scottish Labour leader, said: 'Even John Swinney's MSPs are now openly rebelling against him with senior figures saying he has two weeks to come up with a new idea to save his job. John Swinney and the SNP are out of ideas, out of steam and out of time.' He told First Minister's Questions: 'One SNP MSP said about John Swinney, 'there is no energy, no fire, no boldness, no long-term vision' – they are right.' It is not thought that an MP or MSP will directly challenge Mr Swinney for the leadership ahead of the May 2026 election, but the rebels said a rank-and-file activist could come forward as a stalking horse. They warned that any contest would be 'hugely damning and damaging, and make the party look utterly ridiculous'.
ITV News
20 minutes ago
- ITV News
MPs demand Government not to weaken ‘Hillsborough Law' when bill is passed
MPs have urged the Government not to weaken a law designed to prevent cover-ups in the wake of major disasters, as they call for the "Hillsborough Law" to be passed as soon as possible. Labour MP Clive Efford warned Commons Leader and Manchester Central MP Lucy Powell that the Public Authorities Accountability Bill, which will include the 'Hillsborough Law', should not be changed under pressure from Whitehall. Mr Efford asked for it to be passed before the end of July. Meanwhile his party colleague Liverpool and West Derby MP Ian Byrne asked for the Bill to be 'worthy of the name'. The proposed law would require public bodies to have a duty of candour, meaning they would need to co-operate with official inquiries and tell the truth in the aftermath of major disasters – or face criminal sanctions. A previous deadline set by Labour, that the Bill would be passed before the anniversary of the Hillsborough disaster in April, has been missed. The Government had said it needed more time to finalise the Bill. A draft Bill has been criticised by campaigners, including the Hillsborough Law Now group, for not containing pledges previously made – including the duty of candour. In March it was reported that a meeting between Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and campaigners had been cancelled, with claims officials were attempting to have the contents of the Bill watered down. Mr Byrne told the Commons: 'The Prime Minister promised my city and all those affected by state cover-ups that the Hillsborough Law would be introduced before April 15 of this year – the 36th anniversary of the Hillsborough disaster. 'Almost two months have passed since the Prime Minister missed that deadline. 'This is particularly disappointing, since there is a draft Hillsborough Law ready to go, written by legal experts, endorsed by survivors, families, campaigners and proposed in Parliament by Andy Burnham.' The Liverpool West Derby MP added that 'a failure to introduce a Hillsborough Law worthy of the name will be seen as a continuation of the betrayal of families and survivors of Hillsborough and all those affected by state cover-ups'. Lucy Powell said the Government was 'working at pace' and was co-operating with families and their representatives. She said: 'At these times, we always remember those affected by the Hillsborough disaster but particularly the plight that they have faced ever since to fight for justice and fight for accountability.'
The National
34 minutes ago
- The National
Mairi McAllan on being back and tackling Scotland's housing emergency
Returning to work after close to a year of maternity leave, the SNP MSP for Clydesdale was immediately summoned to Bute House by the First Minister and appointed Housing Secretary. 'Mairi McAllan has been tasked with tackling the housing emergency,' John Swinney said afterwards. 'Including ensuring we have energy efficient homes to help bring down bills and tackle the climate emergency. These are two of the biggest challenges facing people across the country.' READ MORE: UK Government announces £200m funding for Scottish Acorn carbon capture project And as the party is looking to reset after a tough by-election loss in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse and with the 2026 Holyrood election on the horizon, the 32-year-old has also been appointed to the unofficial role of lead minister for media interviews. It's further confirmation of how highly the SNP think of McAllan – who has often been tipped to be a future party leader. When The National spoke with McAllan on Wednesday afternoon in her office in Holyrood, she didn't confirm nor deny whether she harboured such ambitions. 'I have worked closely with leaders of our party and leaders of our government. I have seen up close how grueling and demanding the job is, and it's not something that should ever be taken on lightly,' she said. 'And I do not spend my days thinking about becoming leader of the SNP. However, the SNP means the world to me, pursuit of Scottish independence means the world to me. So, right now, my job is to support the man that I back 100% to be leader, but it's flattering to have those things said nonetheless.' In any case, tackling the housing emergency will certainly be no mean feat for McAllan – with the potential to make or break any future leadership bid. When it was declared by the Scottish Government in May last year, homelessness was already at a record high with house building slowing down. Sat in front of a stack of papers and notes just hours after she was announced as Housing Secretary, McAllan said she is a minister who 'really likes to get into the details of things'. 'Particularly before I pontificate about what needs to be done,' she added. 'But it strikes me that there's funding and planning issues to be looked at, and then there's legal issues to be considered as well. And, obviously, there's a bill that's quite well through just now which I'll be assessing very closely.' The Housing Bill is currently at Stage 2, with MSPs set to debate amendments in the coming months. It includes plans to cap rent rises at a maximum of 6% for tenants living in rent control areas. But Scotland's housing woes and homelessness crisis will need much more than that. Since the emergency was declared, figures have suggested it has only gone downhill. READ MORE: SNP minister responds to 'secret meeting to discuss John Swinney leadership' reports For example, data released earlier this year showed there were a mammoth 17,424 households in Scotland assessed as being either homeless or threatened with homelessness in the six-month period from April 1 to September 30, 2024. Housebuilding in Scotland has also plummeted, with nearly 4000 fewer homes in supply in 2023-24, compared to the year before. McAllan said she "will not accept things not improving". "I think it is a bit like turning a tank around sometimes though, but I want to see quick progress," she added. McAllan also said the housing brief becoming a Cabinet position for the first showed the 'importance' the Scottish Government is placing on the issue. 'It has been an issue that the SNP have prioritised since we came into government and that's backed by statistics,' she claimed. 'We know that, per 10,000 head of population, affordable housing supply is 47% higher in Scotland than it is in England since we came into government, but clearly there is lots to be done.' The Scottish Government previously pledged to build 110,000 affordable homes by 2032, but some, including Labour, have said they are not on track. For the last three years between 9500 and 10,400 new affordable homes were completed per year, with the most recent Scottish Budget statement pledging funding that would apparently enable a further 8000. (Image: free) 'I want to discuss with my officials where exactly we are on that,' McAllan said. 'But it's my priority that it continues to happen and we continue to build and deliver new properties.' She added: 'But I'm not going to wait for that slightly longer term piece of work to be done because there are disused properties that can be brought back into use much more quickly and with less money whilst we build and deliver them. 'So, there's no one answer. But I want to understand the full spectrum of options and make sure that each of them is working as fast as they can. McAllan, when pressed on some of the homelessness figures – specifically surrounding the amount of children living in temporary accommodation – admitted that it was 'unacceptable'. Scottish Government data revealed that as of September 30 last year, there were a record 10,360 children living in temporary accommodation. 'It's completely unacceptable. In my view, and I'm sure this is one shared by the First Minister, a home and a roof over someone's head that they can be comfortable in is a fundamental aspect of both a dignified life and a successful life,' she said. 'The First Minister making this a Cabinet post is because he understands how connected it is with his principal goal of eradicating child poverty, but stimulating our economy at the same time and tackling the climate emergency.' McAllan added: 'So, I can't wait actually to get started, to get to know all of the actors in the industry, to understand what's been working to date, because I will defend the Scottish Government's record, but we now need to ramp up our actions rapidly in order to be commensurate with the scale of the challenge.' Angela Eagle – the UK Government's immigration minister – had been invited to a meeting in April with representatives from Glasgow City Council, the Scottish Government, and the Scottish Refugee Council. It comes amid concerns that the amount of refugees declaring as homeless is putting 'unprecedented pressure' on the local authority. But it went ahead without her after the minister's visit was cancelled last minute, with repeated calls from the SNP-led Glasgow Council for a follow-up meeting then ignored according to the city's homelessness lead Allan Casey. Asked about this, McAllan said the UK Government are 'far from where they need to be' on the issue. And asked whether she will be writing to the UK Government to call for a meeting, she responded: 'Absolutely'. 'For the whole of Scotland, I want to have a good working relationship with the UK ministers that are responsible. I haven't spoken to them yet because I was only appointed a few hours ago, but that will be something that I'll be looking to do.' She added: 'The UK Government, Scottish Government and local government need to be tied in very closely in order to make this work.'
