logo
In India's TV War Rooms, the ‘Generals' Were Loud, Facts Optional, and the Enemy Always in Retreat

In India's TV War Rooms, the ‘Generals' Were Loud, Facts Optional, and the Enemy Always in Retreat

The Wire16-05-2025

Menu
हिंदी తెలుగు اردو
Home Politics Economy World Security Law Science Society Culture Editor's Pick Opinion
Support independent journalism. Donate Now
Media
In India's TV War Rooms, the 'Generals' Were Loud, Facts Optional, and the Enemy Always in Retreat
Sanjiv Krishan Sood
35 minutes ago
Now that a ceasefire has been announced, the curtain has come down. Sadly, this means the media may soon return to its usual programming: communal outrage, political vendettas, and panel discussions where decibel levels count more than insight.
Illustration: The Wire.
Real journalism holds power accountable
Since 2015, The Wire has done just that.
But we can continue only with your support.
Donate now
When Operation Sindoor began, India's television newsrooms went into overdrive. The usual suspects – political party spokespersons and loudmouth analysts – quietly stepped aside, making space for a fresh crop of self-styled defence experts, security analysts, and retired military personnel, suddenly back in demand.
This new cast did little to elevate the discourse. If anything, they took the absurdity to greater heights. Many had emerged from the obscurity of long retirements (your humble narrator included), summoned into studio lights and seated before frothing anchors chasing ratings.
Out came the long-unused three-piece suits, and with them, a sober tone – quickly abandoned as panelists launched into theatrical calls to 'annihilate Pakistan' and 'take back PoK.' Some confidently claimed that enemy generals were shivering in bunkers, while others cited unnamed sources to report that Pakistani leaders had chartered planes to send their families to the West.
One retired Major distinguished himself with rapid-fire verbal salvos at his Pakistani counterpart – missiles of rhetoric that would put BrahMos to shame. A moustachioed General, not to be outdone, turned his ire inward, lambasting India's political leadership for agreeing to a ceasefire. With a full-throated roar, he demanded that Pakistan be wiped off 'the face of the Atlas' – a cartographic flourish that surely left Mercator himself spinning in his grave.
Awards may not be in the offing, but these two certainly earned the unofficial title of TRP Commanders-in-Chief.
Meanwhile, news channels diligently kept the public 'informed.' One ran a breaking update announcing that the Prime Minister had arrived at his office – perhaps under the impression that citizens needed to be reassured that he does, in fact, have one. Others breathlessly reported that the Chiefs of Defence Staff were seen in combat uniforms, their attire now imbued with geopolitical symbolism.
When I mildly suggested to an anchor that we might be over-reading sartorial choices, my microphone was promptly muted.
A Hindi channel took things up a notch. Its star anchor – who has made a career out of camouflage cosplay – set up a war game scenario live on air. In a curious imitation of exercises at military academies, newly anointed security experts jostled to make their strategic points, mimicking the enthusiasm of young Captains attending their first Junior Command Course. That modern warfare has evolved well beyond the Cold War-era doctrines they once practised did not seem to bother anyone. The aim wasn't analysis – it was performance.
Fortunately, I was spared from participating. Another channel summoned me at the same time, eager for my 'expertise.' The anchor-general later published an 'appreciation' of the conflict, carefully constructing each scenario to end in Indian victory. Ironically, none of them foresaw the kind of operation that India actually carried out on the night of May 6 and 7, striking militant camps across the border.
What was missing, across channels, was verification. Reports about decimated Pakistani battalions, captured cities, and destroyed ports all relied on 'unnamed sources.' One channel confidently declared Indian troops were deep inside Pakistani territory – but couldn't say where from.
'Secrecy' was preserved in unintentionally comic fashion. Reporters were asked to go live 'from the ground,' but instructed not to disclose their location. 'Nilesh,' an anchor would begin, 'who is reporting from somewhere near Barmer, please tell us what you're seeing – without revealing where you are.' The sound of air raid sirens – played every few minutes for dramatic effect – added to the chaos. Eventually, the government had to step in and ask them to stop.
Perhaps the only thing the media was truly fair about was panic. They spread it equally on both sides of the border. Pakistani viewers were informed of impending annihilation; Indian viewers were told that multiple cities had come under air attack, and that the Nagrota Army base had suffered a fidayeen strike.
The entertainment value was undeniable. After years of avoiding television, I found myself tuning in – not for information, but for a good laugh. The coverage of Operation Sindoor could well qualify as 2025's most successful comedy series.
Now that a ceasefire has been announced, the curtain has come down. Sadly, this means the media may soon return to its usual programming: communal outrage, political vendettas, and panel discussions where decibel levels count more than insight.
Until then, those of us who survived the TV war games will quietly fold away our suits and wait for the next invasion – on screen.
Sanjiv Krishan Sood was additional director general of the BSF.
This piece was first published on The India Cable – a premium newsletter from The Wire & Galileo Ideas – and has been updated and republished here. To subscribe to The India Cable, click here.
Make a contribution to Independent Journalism
Related News
Live: India, Pakistan Continuing Confidence-Building Measures to Reduce Level of Alertness
Petition Urging Indians, Pakistanis to Reject Division and Hate Gets Over 5,500 Signatures
Habits of Thought in the Time of Terrorism and War
J&K: For Residents Who Live Near the LoC, Life Is Now a Living Nightmare
The Path Forward For India and Pakistan Should Be Shaped By Peace, Not By Excitement Over War Games
The Wire Wrap | 'Mediator' Trump in India-Pakistan Ceasefire and More
High-Stakes Nuclear Poker: How Pakistan's Deterrent Still Checks India—Even After Operation Sindoor
BSF Jawan Who Was Captured by Pakistan in April Released, Handed Over to Indian Authorities
Army Commanders Have 'Full Authority' to Counter Future Ceasefire Violations: Military
View in Desktop Mode
About Us
Contact Us
Support Us
© Copyright. All Rights Reserved.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Students living in U.S. being repeatedly mistreated but PM Modi is silent: Congress
Students living in U.S. being repeatedly mistreated but PM Modi is silent: Congress

The Hindu

time30 minutes ago

  • The Hindu

Students living in U.S. being repeatedly mistreated but PM Modi is silent: Congress

The Congress on Tuesday (June 10, 2025) slammed the government after a video emerged showing an Indian student being handcuffed and pinned to the floor at a U.S. airport, and demanded that Prime Minister Narendra Modi should immediately talk to President Donald Trump to appeal for intervention on the 'mistreatment' of Indians in America. Congress leaders shared the video and pictures of an Indian student handcuffed and pinned to the floor at U.S.'s Newark Airport before he was allegedly deported. The Consulate General of India in New York has said it is in touch with local authorities after the video surfaced online showing the young Indian man being handcuffed and allegedly being deported. 'We have come across social media posts claiming that an Indian national is facing difficulties at Newark Liberty International Airport. We are in touch with local authorities in this regard,' the Indian Consulate said in a post on X. U.S. crackdown on students | What are New Delhi's options | Worldview Congress general secretary in-charge communications Jairam Ramesh alleged that the Modi Government is continuously failing to protect the honour of India and Indians. 'For the first time in history, a foreign head of state has declared ceasefire between India and Pakistan in India's absence. US President Trump is continuously claiming to have ensured a ceasefire by pressuring India,' Mr. Ramesh said in his post in Hindi on X. 'For the past one year, Indian citizens and students living in America are being repeatedly mistreated but Prime Minister Modi is maintaining silence or it should be assumed that he is unable to muster the courage to speak,' Mr. Ramesh said. He is the Prime Minister of India, it is his most important responsibility to protect the honour and respect of India and Indians, Mr. Ramesh asserted. 'We demand that Prime Minister Modi should immediately talk to President Trump and appeal for intervention on the mistreatment and atrocities being committed against Indians in America,' he said. Congress' media and publicity department head Pawan Khera tagged a post on X carrying the video, which was posted online by an Indian-American social entrepreneur Kunal Jain. The video shows the Indian man pinned to the ground by Port Authority Police and being handcuffed. 'I witnessed a young Indian student being deported from Newark Airport last night — handcuffed, crying, treated like a criminal. He came chasing dreams, not causing harm. As an NRI, I felt helpless and heartbroken. This is a human tragedy,' Mr. Jain said in his post. Tagging Mr. Jain's post, Mr. Khera said, 'This is too painful, too humiliating and too distressing to watch. As a country, why should we tolerate this humiliation?' 'From the days where we showed the muscle to the U.S. during the Devyani Khobragade issue to now seeing our citizens being treated like animals, do we have no goodwill left in the world?' the Congress leader said.

Meghalaya Minister demands apology from families of Sonam, Raja Raghuvanshi for ‘tarnishing' State's image
Meghalaya Minister demands apology from families of Sonam, Raja Raghuvanshi for ‘tarnishing' State's image

The Hindu

time30 minutes ago

  • The Hindu

Meghalaya Minister demands apology from families of Sonam, Raja Raghuvanshi for ‘tarnishing' State's image

Meghalaya Minister Alexander Laloo Hek on Tuesday (June 10, 2025) demanded an apology from the families of both Sonam and Raja Raghuvanshi for allegedly 'tarnishing' the image of the State and its people, as the investigation is underway in the murder case. Speaking to ANI, Meghalaya Minister Alexander Laloo Hek said, 'We are thankful to the Meghalaya police for the breakthroughs in the ongoing investigation of the Raja Raghuvanshi murder case. Now we are seeking an apology from Sonam and Raja Raghuvanshi's families for tarnishing the image of Meghalaya and its people. We will file a case of defamation if they don't comply.' 'The accused will be brought here since the incident took place in the State. We do not have any issue if they want to hand over the case to the State police, central police or the probe agency, but the truth has already prevailed,' said the Minister. The family of Raja Raghuvanshi had earlier written a letter to Prime Minister Narendra Modi requesting a CBI inquiry into the matter. Raja Raghuvanshi and his wife, Sonam, went missing during their honeymoon in the northeastern state. The couple was last seen on May 23. Later, on June 2, Raja's body was found in a gorge at Sohrarim near Cherrapunji in Meghalaya. Sonam Raghuvanshi was later found near a dhaba on the Varanasi-Ghazipur main road. Sonam had allegedly hired killers to get rid of her husband during their honeymoon in Meghalaya, just days after their marriage in Indore, they said. Four of them have been arrested. Sohra tourist guide satisfied as police arrest suspects A local tourist guide who alerted police about the presence of three unidentified men accompanying newlyweds Raja and Sonam Raghuvanshi on the day they went missing last month said he is satisfied that his information helped crack the case. Albert Pde, the guide at Mawlakhiat, told PTI, 'I am happy that the criminals are finally behind bars. We stand vindicated. Those who tried to tarnish the image of Sohra and its people as violent have now been exposed,' said a visibly relieved Pde. Mr. Pde had said he saw the couple accompanied by three male tourists as they were climbing over 3,000 steps from Nongriat to Mawlakhiat around 10 am on May 23. According to the guide, 'the four men, including Raja, were walking ahead while the woman was behind. The four men conversed in Hindi,' he said, admitting that he was not very conversant in the language. Mr. Pde had initially offered his services to walk them to Nongriat on May 22, but they politely refused and hired another guide identified as Bha Wansai, who dropped them at Shipara homestay.

UP CM Yogi Adityanath highlights govt achievements as PM Modi completes 11 years in office
UP CM Yogi Adityanath highlights govt achievements as PM Modi completes 11 years in office

India Gazette

time31 minutes ago

  • India Gazette

UP CM Yogi Adityanath highlights govt achievements as PM Modi completes 11 years in office

Lucknow (Uttar Pradesh) [India], June 10 (ANI): Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath on Tuesday inaugurated an exhibition at the BJP office in Lucknow as Prime Minister Narendra Modi completed 11 years in office. Deputy Chief Minister Keshav Prasad Maurya and Brajesh Pathak were also present. Highlighting the Modi government's achievements in the last 11 years, UP CM Yogi asserted that good governance and welfare of the poor will be remembered as a golden era that built a developed India and a self-reliant nation. 'Welcome to today's event commemorating Prime Minister Modi's 11-year tenure in service, good governance, and the welfare of the poor,' CM Yogi said, addressing the event. 'Modi ji's 11-year term in service, good governance, and poor welfare will be remembered as a golden era that built a developed India and a self-reliant nation,' he added. He asserted that over these eleven years, PM Modi strengthened India's growth on the global stage, giving the country an international identity and making it a symbol of trust. Further taking a dig at the Opposition Congress over unstable administrations, he said, 'Due to Congress-led governments and other unstable administrations in the sixty-five years following independence, the common citizen's trust was broken, and India's global image was tarnished. But over the past 11 years, under PM Modi's leadership, a corruption-free, appeasement-free, unified India has been realised.' He emphasised that during this period, India has forged a new identity in social welfare, good governance, economy, and security. 'Government transparency and accountability towards the public have become distinguishing hallmarks. A new harmony between development and heritage has been created,' the Uttar Pradesh CM added. Stressing PM Modi's idea of 'Sabka Sath Sabka Vikas', UP CM said that the Mantra have become the face of the government. 'Now, benefits are delivered not by who someone is, but impartially--and 'Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas' (together with all, development for all) has become the new face of governance,' he added. He pointed out the steps taken by the NDA government's action against terrorism, highlighting the recent actions during Operation Sindoor. 'Now, we have changed our nature concerning our response to terrorism, which was before 2014 - that India favours peace. PM Modi, by giving a new normal, has changed the entire concept - we will live in peace with friends, but if someone imposes war on us, induces terrorism in our country and is a threat to our security, the response will be surgical strike, air strike and Operation Sindoor - we have shown it with made-in-India and the world has realised India's strength - just a few days back,' he added. He also mentioned the abrogation of Article 370: 'Article 370, which was imposed since 1952, was repealed by our government. And India's integrity was reinforced--from Kashmir to Kanyakumari.' Referring to the works done in the agriculture sector, he said that the double-engine government has benefited the farmers and the agri-industry. 'Before 2017, sugar mills in Uttar Pradesh were shutting down. Between 1996 and 2017, there were due payments after 22 years, but in just the last 7 years, an additional Rs 71,000 crore has been paid. This is the guarantee of a 'double-engine' government,' he said. He also pointed out schemes launched by the government intended to empower women, such as the 'Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao' campaign, 33 per cent reservation for women in legislatures, the abolition of Triple talaq, granting freedom to women, and the 'Lakhpati Didi' scheme for women entrepreneurs. (ANI)

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store