In India's TV War Rooms, the ‘Generals' Were Loud, Facts Optional, and the Enemy Always in Retreat
Menu
हिंदी తెలుగు اردو
Home Politics Economy World Security Law Science Society Culture Editor's Pick Opinion
Support independent journalism. Donate Now
Media
In India's TV War Rooms, the 'Generals' Were Loud, Facts Optional, and the Enemy Always in Retreat
Sanjiv Krishan Sood
35 minutes ago
Now that a ceasefire has been announced, the curtain has come down. Sadly, this means the media may soon return to its usual programming: communal outrage, political vendettas, and panel discussions where decibel levels count more than insight.
Illustration: The Wire.
Real journalism holds power accountable
Since 2015, The Wire has done just that.
But we can continue only with your support.
Donate now
When Operation Sindoor began, India's television newsrooms went into overdrive. The usual suspects – political party spokespersons and loudmouth analysts – quietly stepped aside, making space for a fresh crop of self-styled defence experts, security analysts, and retired military personnel, suddenly back in demand.
This new cast did little to elevate the discourse. If anything, they took the absurdity to greater heights. Many had emerged from the obscurity of long retirements (your humble narrator included), summoned into studio lights and seated before frothing anchors chasing ratings.
Out came the long-unused three-piece suits, and with them, a sober tone – quickly abandoned as panelists launched into theatrical calls to 'annihilate Pakistan' and 'take back PoK.' Some confidently claimed that enemy generals were shivering in bunkers, while others cited unnamed sources to report that Pakistani leaders had chartered planes to send their families to the West.
One retired Major distinguished himself with rapid-fire verbal salvos at his Pakistani counterpart – missiles of rhetoric that would put BrahMos to shame. A moustachioed General, not to be outdone, turned his ire inward, lambasting India's political leadership for agreeing to a ceasefire. With a full-throated roar, he demanded that Pakistan be wiped off 'the face of the Atlas' – a cartographic flourish that surely left Mercator himself spinning in his grave.
Awards may not be in the offing, but these two certainly earned the unofficial title of TRP Commanders-in-Chief.
Meanwhile, news channels diligently kept the public 'informed.' One ran a breaking update announcing that the Prime Minister had arrived at his office – perhaps under the impression that citizens needed to be reassured that he does, in fact, have one. Others breathlessly reported that the Chiefs of Defence Staff were seen in combat uniforms, their attire now imbued with geopolitical symbolism.
When I mildly suggested to an anchor that we might be over-reading sartorial choices, my microphone was promptly muted.
A Hindi channel took things up a notch. Its star anchor – who has made a career out of camouflage cosplay – set up a war game scenario live on air. In a curious imitation of exercises at military academies, newly anointed security experts jostled to make their strategic points, mimicking the enthusiasm of young Captains attending their first Junior Command Course. That modern warfare has evolved well beyond the Cold War-era doctrines they once practised did not seem to bother anyone. The aim wasn't analysis – it was performance.
Fortunately, I was spared from participating. Another channel summoned me at the same time, eager for my 'expertise.' The anchor-general later published an 'appreciation' of the conflict, carefully constructing each scenario to end in Indian victory. Ironically, none of them foresaw the kind of operation that India actually carried out on the night of May 6 and 7, striking militant camps across the border.
What was missing, across channels, was verification. Reports about decimated Pakistani battalions, captured cities, and destroyed ports all relied on 'unnamed sources.' One channel confidently declared Indian troops were deep inside Pakistani territory – but couldn't say where from.
'Secrecy' was preserved in unintentionally comic fashion. Reporters were asked to go live 'from the ground,' but instructed not to disclose their location. 'Nilesh,' an anchor would begin, 'who is reporting from somewhere near Barmer, please tell us what you're seeing – without revealing where you are.' The sound of air raid sirens – played every few minutes for dramatic effect – added to the chaos. Eventually, the government had to step in and ask them to stop.
Perhaps the only thing the media was truly fair about was panic. They spread it equally on both sides of the border. Pakistani viewers were informed of impending annihilation; Indian viewers were told that multiple cities had come under air attack, and that the Nagrota Army base had suffered a fidayeen strike.
The entertainment value was undeniable. After years of avoiding television, I found myself tuning in – not for information, but for a good laugh. The coverage of Operation Sindoor could well qualify as 2025's most successful comedy series.
Now that a ceasefire has been announced, the curtain has come down. Sadly, this means the media may soon return to its usual programming: communal outrage, political vendettas, and panel discussions where decibel levels count more than insight.
Until then, those of us who survived the TV war games will quietly fold away our suits and wait for the next invasion – on screen.
Sanjiv Krishan Sood was additional director general of the BSF.
This piece was first published on The India Cable – a premium newsletter from The Wire & Galileo Ideas – and has been updated and republished here. To subscribe to The India Cable, click here.
Make a contribution to Independent Journalism
Related News
Live: India, Pakistan Continuing Confidence-Building Measures to Reduce Level of Alertness
Petition Urging Indians, Pakistanis to Reject Division and Hate Gets Over 5,500 Signatures
Habits of Thought in the Time of Terrorism and War
J&K: For Residents Who Live Near the LoC, Life Is Now a Living Nightmare
The Path Forward For India and Pakistan Should Be Shaped By Peace, Not By Excitement Over War Games
The Wire Wrap | 'Mediator' Trump in India-Pakistan Ceasefire and More
High-Stakes Nuclear Poker: How Pakistan's Deterrent Still Checks India—Even After Operation Sindoor
BSF Jawan Who Was Captured by Pakistan in April Released, Handed Over to Indian Authorities
Army Commanders Have 'Full Authority' to Counter Future Ceasefire Violations: Military
View in Desktop Mode
About Us
Contact Us
Support Us
© Copyright. All Rights Reserved.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
33 minutes ago
- India Today
US reaffirms support to India in fight against terror after Op Sindoor outreach
The US reaffirmed its strong support for India's fight against terrorism and the bilateral strategic partnership during the visit of an Indian all-party parliamentary delegation last week, the State Department multi-party delegation led by Congress MP Shashi Tharoor met the US Deputy Secretary of State Christopher Landau last week in Department Spokesperson Tammy Bruce said at a press briefing on Tuesday that Landau reaffirmed the US' strong support of India in the fight against terrorism and the strategic partnership between the two The delegation visited the US as part of the government's global outreach efforts after Operation Sindoor. India launched the operation in retaliation to the April 22 Pahalgam terror attack that claimed 26 to a question, Bruce said that a Pakistani parliamentary delegation led by Bilawal Bhutto Zardari met officials of the State Department, including Under Secretary for Political Affairs Allison Hooker, during its visit to Washington last reiterated US support for the ongoing cessation of on-ground hostilities '– as you might imagine, thank God – between India and Pakistan', Bruce said, adding that they also discussed important issues about the US-Pakistan bilateral relationship, including counterterrorism cooperation. 'So that meeting occurred.'When asked if the US received any assurance from Pakistan that it will take action against terrorists, Bruce said she was not going to discuss the details of those response to a question about President Donald Trump offering to 'mediate' on the issue of Kashmir, Bruce said, 'Well, I – obviously, I can't speak to what's on my mind or the plans of the President. What I do know is that I think we all recognise that President Trump, in each step that he takes, is made to solve generational differences between countries, generational war."Bruce added that it should not "surprise" anyone that he would want to "manage" something like that.'So, while I can't speak to his plans, the world knows his nature, and I can't speak to any details of what he might have in that regard, but it is an exciting time if we can get to a point in that particular conflict." Bruce said, adding that it is a "very interesting time.'India has rejected any mediation related to the dispute on Jammu and Kashmir with Pakistan and maintains that Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh are and will always remain an "integral" part of the InMust Watch
News18
39 minutes ago
- News18
Pakistani Flag Seized By Kerala Police From Church Event, FIR Filed Against Organiser
Kerala Police have seized a Pakistani flag allegedly used during prayers for nations at an auditorium in Udayamperoor, Ernakulam district. The flag was confiscated from the auditorium near the Udayamperoor police station. A case has been registered against the auditorium owner, Deepu Jacob, leader of a prayer group called Jesus Generation. Jacob, originally from Puthiyakavu, is currently absconding and unreachable. Sources suggest he purchased the flag from China.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Decisive advantage in modern warfare lies in ability to see first, farthest, most accurately: Air Marshal Ashutosh Dixit
Live Events (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel New Delhi: Air Marshal Ashutosh Dixit , Deputy Chief of Air Staff, on Wednesday highlighted the strategic role of surveillance and electro-optic systems in the current combat scenarios and said that the decisive advantage in modern warfare lies in the ability to see first, see farthest, and see most parallels from recent global conflicts--including the Armenia-Azerbaijan war , the Russia-Ukraine conflict , and the ongoing Israel-Hamas hostilities--Air Marshal Dixit noted that superior situational awareness has consistently tipped the balance in favour of the side with better eyes on the at the Surveillance and Electro Optics India seminar, Air Marshal Dixit said, "When we look at global conflicts commencing from Armenia-Azerbaijan to Russia-Ukraine and Israel-Hamas, and to our own experiences in Operation Sindoor , one truth emerges with crystal clarity: the side that sees first, sees farthest and sees most accurately, prevails.""This axiom has guided military thinking for centuries, but never has it been more relevant than in our current era of precision warfare and multi-domain operations," he Air Marshal referred to Operation Sindoor as a demonstration of India's readiness to adapt to these evolving realities."This brings me to the critical importance of deep surveillance in contemporary warfare. The lessons from Operation Sindoor have reinforced what military strategists have long understood but perhaps not fully appreciated until now. Modern warfare, thanks to technology, has fundamentally altered the relationship between distance and vulnerability," he said."It has given a new meaning to simultaneity and non-linearity. The existing principles of war are being challenged, and new ones are emerging. Earlier, the horizon marked the limit of immediate threat. Today, precision-guided munitions like SCALP, BrahMos and HAMMER have rendered geographical barriers almost meaningless, as strikes with BVR AAMs and supersonic AGMs have become commonplace."Air Marshal Dixit said that the rapidly advancing domain of surveillance and electro-optics is no longer just an operational enabler but has emerged as the very foundation of contemporary military on the significant transformation in the field, Air Marshal Dixit noted that these technologies have shifted from being supplementary force multipliers to becoming central to how nations plan, execute, and dominate in future conflicts."As someone who has witnessed this transformation firsthand, I can attest that we stand at the cusp of a revolution that will redefine how we perceive, process and project power in the 21st century," he said, "When weapons can strike targets hundreds of kilometres away with pinpoint accuracy, he traditional concepts of front, rear and flanks combat zones and depth areas all become irrelevant. What we call the front and the theatre merge into one. This new reality demands that we extend our surveillance envelope far beyond what previous generations could have even imagined. We must detect, identify and track potential threats not when they approach our borders, but when they are still in their staging areas, airfields and bases, deep within adversary territory. This existed as a concept even earlier but today we have the means to realise it."Adding further, he said, "The compressed timelines of modern warfare amplify this need. When hypersonic missiles can traverse hundreds of kilometres in minutes and drone swarms can reach their targets before traditional decision-making processes can respond, real-time or near-real-time surveillance becomes not just advantageous but essential for survival."Air Marshal Dixit said that the speed of modern weapons has fundamentally altered the OODA loop, compressing it from hours to minutes, sometimes even seconds, and this new reality is being shaped by mega satellite constellations that are revolutionising battlefield awareness."The fusion of Electro-Optical, SAR and SIGINT capabilities now enables a 24x7 dynamic, persistent and predictive mosaic of the battlefield. We no longer merely observe; we anticipate, predict and pre-empt," he said."As we look to the future, it becomes clear that government efforts alone cannot meet the pace of technological change we face. This is where our private sector emerges as a critical partner in our surveillance evolution. The dynamism, innovation and agility that characterise India's technology companies are precisely what we need to maintain our edge in this rapidly evolving domain. We need our private sector to push the boundaries in several critical areas. Integration of AI with electro-optic systems has the potential to revolutionise surveillance capabilities. AI-driven imaging seekers, automated threat recognition and predictive analytics can transform passive monitoring into active. and intelligent surveillance that anticipates rather than merely observes," he added, "The development of multispectral, all-weather surveillance systems that can operate effectively in our diverse geographical and climatic conditions is essential. From the Siachen glacier to the hot arid deserts down to the Indian Ocean, our surveillance systems must maintain effectiveness across all environments. We also need scalable and interoperable systems that can seamlessly integrate with existing military networks while remaining flexible enough to accommodate future technologies. The days of standalone, siloed systems are behind us. The future belongs to networked, collaborative platforms that multiply rather than merely add capabilities."Speaking at the seminar on national security, Lieutenant General Vineet Gaur, DG Capability Development, underscored the critical role of advanced surveillance in contemporary warfare."In today's modern era, advanced surveillance is not a luxury but a necessity. We witnessed its significance during the Kargil conflict, and its relevance has only grown in today's evolving security landscape," he further emphasised the increasing importance of space-based surveillance, particularly as the Indian Air Force undergoes a transformative phase."We are set to launch 52 satellites in the coming year, out of which 31 will be built by private sector firms," he revealed. These satellites will be equipped with cutting-edge camera lenses, advanced sensors, and a suite of modern technologies to enhance India's situational awareness and defence Vice Marshal Tejpal Singh highlighted the indispensable role of advanced surveillance and technology in modern warfare, stating that enhanced battlefield imagery and superior monitoring capabilities have become vital components of military success."Advanced surveillance is no longer optional--it is essential in any modern conflict," he said. "Clearer imagery and stronger surveillance systems provide a critical edge on the battlefield."He further stressed that Intelligence, Surveillance, and Reconnaissance (ISR) has emerged as a key element in today's combat environment."ISR is central to modern-day warfare, and Remotely Operated Systems (ROS) serve as its backbone," he explained, adding that the importance of these systems has been demonstrated in the ongoing Russia-Ukraine to developments in West Asia, Air Vice Marshal Singh pointed to the use of unmanned aerial attack systems in Yemen, which have drawn global attention."These examples show that ISR capabilities are vital for achieving dominance in today's contested airspace," he said.
