In India's TV War Rooms, the ‘Generals' Were Loud, Facts Optional, and the Enemy Always in Retreat
Menu
हिंदी తెలుగు اردو
Home Politics Economy World Security Law Science Society Culture Editor's Pick Opinion
Support independent journalism. Donate Now
Media
In India's TV War Rooms, the 'Generals' Were Loud, Facts Optional, and the Enemy Always in Retreat
Sanjiv Krishan Sood
35 minutes ago
Now that a ceasefire has been announced, the curtain has come down. Sadly, this means the media may soon return to its usual programming: communal outrage, political vendettas, and panel discussions where decibel levels count more than insight.
Illustration: The Wire.
Real journalism holds power accountable
Since 2015, The Wire has done just that.
But we can continue only with your support.
Donate now
When Operation Sindoor began, India's television newsrooms went into overdrive. The usual suspects – political party spokespersons and loudmouth analysts – quietly stepped aside, making space for a fresh crop of self-styled defence experts, security analysts, and retired military personnel, suddenly back in demand.
This new cast did little to elevate the discourse. If anything, they took the absurdity to greater heights. Many had emerged from the obscurity of long retirements (your humble narrator included), summoned into studio lights and seated before frothing anchors chasing ratings.
Out came the long-unused three-piece suits, and with them, a sober tone – quickly abandoned as panelists launched into theatrical calls to 'annihilate Pakistan' and 'take back PoK.' Some confidently claimed that enemy generals were shivering in bunkers, while others cited unnamed sources to report that Pakistani leaders had chartered planes to send their families to the West.
One retired Major distinguished himself with rapid-fire verbal salvos at his Pakistani counterpart – missiles of rhetoric that would put BrahMos to shame. A moustachioed General, not to be outdone, turned his ire inward, lambasting India's political leadership for agreeing to a ceasefire. With a full-throated roar, he demanded that Pakistan be wiped off 'the face of the Atlas' – a cartographic flourish that surely left Mercator himself spinning in his grave.
Awards may not be in the offing, but these two certainly earned the unofficial title of TRP Commanders-in-Chief.
Meanwhile, news channels diligently kept the public 'informed.' One ran a breaking update announcing that the Prime Minister had arrived at his office – perhaps under the impression that citizens needed to be reassured that he does, in fact, have one. Others breathlessly reported that the Chiefs of Defence Staff were seen in combat uniforms, their attire now imbued with geopolitical symbolism.
When I mildly suggested to an anchor that we might be over-reading sartorial choices, my microphone was promptly muted.
A Hindi channel took things up a notch. Its star anchor – who has made a career out of camouflage cosplay – set up a war game scenario live on air. In a curious imitation of exercises at military academies, newly anointed security experts jostled to make their strategic points, mimicking the enthusiasm of young Captains attending their first Junior Command Course. That modern warfare has evolved well beyond the Cold War-era doctrines they once practised did not seem to bother anyone. The aim wasn't analysis – it was performance.
Fortunately, I was spared from participating. Another channel summoned me at the same time, eager for my 'expertise.' The anchor-general later published an 'appreciation' of the conflict, carefully constructing each scenario to end in Indian victory. Ironically, none of them foresaw the kind of operation that India actually carried out on the night of May 6 and 7, striking militant camps across the border.
What was missing, across channels, was verification. Reports about decimated Pakistani battalions, captured cities, and destroyed ports all relied on 'unnamed sources.' One channel confidently declared Indian troops were deep inside Pakistani territory – but couldn't say where from.
'Secrecy' was preserved in unintentionally comic fashion. Reporters were asked to go live 'from the ground,' but instructed not to disclose their location. 'Nilesh,' an anchor would begin, 'who is reporting from somewhere near Barmer, please tell us what you're seeing – without revealing where you are.' The sound of air raid sirens – played every few minutes for dramatic effect – added to the chaos. Eventually, the government had to step in and ask them to stop.
Perhaps the only thing the media was truly fair about was panic. They spread it equally on both sides of the border. Pakistani viewers were informed of impending annihilation; Indian viewers were told that multiple cities had come under air attack, and that the Nagrota Army base had suffered a fidayeen strike.
The entertainment value was undeniable. After years of avoiding television, I found myself tuning in – not for information, but for a good laugh. The coverage of Operation Sindoor could well qualify as 2025's most successful comedy series.
Now that a ceasefire has been announced, the curtain has come down. Sadly, this means the media may soon return to its usual programming: communal outrage, political vendettas, and panel discussions where decibel levels count more than insight.
Until then, those of us who survived the TV war games will quietly fold away our suits and wait for the next invasion – on screen.
Sanjiv Krishan Sood was additional director general of the BSF.
This piece was first published on The India Cable – a premium newsletter from The Wire & Galileo Ideas – and has been updated and republished here. To subscribe to The India Cable, click here.
Make a contribution to Independent Journalism
Related News
Live: India, Pakistan Continuing Confidence-Building Measures to Reduce Level of Alertness
Petition Urging Indians, Pakistanis to Reject Division and Hate Gets Over 5,500 Signatures
Habits of Thought in the Time of Terrorism and War
J&K: For Residents Who Live Near the LoC, Life Is Now a Living Nightmare
The Path Forward For India and Pakistan Should Be Shaped By Peace, Not By Excitement Over War Games
The Wire Wrap | 'Mediator' Trump in India-Pakistan Ceasefire and More
High-Stakes Nuclear Poker: How Pakistan's Deterrent Still Checks India—Even After Operation Sindoor
BSF Jawan Who Was Captured by Pakistan in April Released, Handed Over to Indian Authorities
Army Commanders Have 'Full Authority' to Counter Future Ceasefire Violations: Military
View in Desktop Mode
About Us
Contact Us
Support Us
© Copyright. All Rights Reserved.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Lt Gen Rajiv Ghai promoted as deputy Chief of Army Staff
Lt Gen Rajiv Ghai has been elevated to the post of Deputy Chief of Army Staff (Strategy), a role under which all operational verticals of the Indian Army report to the Deputy Chief of Army Staff (Security), news agency ANI reported. He will also continue to serve as the Director General of Military Operations (DGMO). Last week, Lt Gen Ghai, a key figure in military briefings on Operation Sindoor, was awarded the Uttam Yudh Seva Medal (UYSM) by President Droupadi Murmu. He led military operations for Operation Sindoor, launched on May 7, in retaliation for the April 22 terror attack in Pahalgam, Jammu and Kashmir, which killed 26 people. The operation targeted nine terror sites in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir. At a press conference on May 11, Lt Gen Ghai revealed that his Pakistani counterpart had proposed a ceasefire during an interaction on May 10, which led to both sides agreeing to halt hostilities. Clarifying media reports, the Indian Army later stated that the ceasefire agreed upon in the DGMO talks on May 12 has no expiry date. 'No DGMO talks are scheduled today. As far as the continuation of a break in hostilities... There is no expiry date to it,' the Army said. (This is a developing story. Please check back for updates)
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Espionage case: Hisar court extends social media influencer's judicial custody
Hisar, A local court on Monday extended the judicial custody of social media influencer Jyoti Malhotra and fixed her case's hearing on June 23. The 33-year-old YouTuber appeared before the court of Hisar Judicial Magistrate Sunil Kumar through video conferencing on Monday which extended her judicial custody by two weeks. "The court has extended her judicial custody and fixed June 23 for the next hearing in this case," her lawyer Kumar Mukesh said. Hisar Police arrested Malhotra on suspicion of espionage on May 16. She was subsequently remanded to five days of police custody by the court. Following the completion of the remand, the court extended it by four more days on the police's plea for further questioning. On May 26, the court remanded her to judicial custody for 14 days. Malhotra, who hails from the city, ran a YouTube channel "Travel with JO". She was arrested at the New Aggarsain Extension and booked under provisions of the Official Secrets Act and the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. Hisar Police previously said no evidence had emerged to indicate Malhotra had access to any military- or defence-related information but claimed she was in contact with some people, aware that they were Pakistani Intelligence Operatives . Police sources said she was in touch with Ehsan-ur-Rahim alias Danish, a staffer at the Pakistani High Commission, since November 2023. India expelled Danish on May 13 for allegedly indulging in espionage. The police have claimed Pakistani intelligence operatives were developing Malhotra as an asset. Punjab Police recently said Punjab-based YouTuber Jasbir Singh, who was arrested on espionage charges on June 4, was in close contact with Malhotra. Singh, who was found to be associated with a PIO, was in touch with a Pakistan High Commission official who was recently expelled from New Delhi on charges of spying and had met Pakistan Army officials during one of his three visits to the neighbouring country, Punjab Police said previously. After Malhotra's arrest, Singh attempted to erase all traces of his communications with these PIOs to avoid detection, Punjab Police added.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
11 years that changed the dimensions of governance
Keshav Upadhye, a young, dynamic and prominent face, has been working with the Bharatiya Janata Party for over two decades. In 2014, the then state president Devendra Fadnavis had appointed Upadhye as the spokesperson in his team. Owing to his journalistic background and better understanding of the socio-economic issues of the state, Upadhye made a mark as a spokesperson in a short span. He articulates the views of the party and aggressively defends the party on various platforms including the Marathi and Hindi national news channels. Keshav Upadhye worked for the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP) and after completing his degree in Journalism from Ranade Institute, Pune, he began his career as a journalist with daily Pudhari, Loksatta and Mumbai Tarun Bharat. Knowing the pulse of the news, he writes on varied topics and on various platforms like the newspapers, blogs and other social media platforms. He was involved in two study groups formed by the Rambhau Mhalgi Prabodhini in 2006 to study the naxalite movement and its adverse impact on the development of Chhatisgarh. The Prabodhini later published this report. He was also a part of the Prabodhini's fact-finding committee formed to study the Solapur riots. LESS ... MORE Recently watched an interview of renowned industrialist and chairman & managing director of Bharat Forge, Baba Kalyani. In this interview, he has narrated his experience of the Narendra Modi government at the Centre. In this interview, he says, 'A few years ago, Bharat Forge Company had developed a gun. We contacted the defence forces officials to test this gun. We requested them to provide a range to test this gun. This request was immediately rejected. At the same time, we were also ridiculed. Through my personal contacts, I got this gun tested in America. In 2016, we had placed this gun at the arms exhibition in Delhi. The then defence minister Manohar Parrikar saw this gun. He immediately called us. In the discussion that took place at that time, I shared my experience when I met the defence forces officials to test the gun. Parrikar immediately called the concerned officials and took them to task. In the same meeting, he ordered the provision of ranges to the defence forces for testing weapons of private manufacturers. Since then, India's defence manufacturers have seen good times in manufacturing weapons and ammunition. This is why India's arms exports have reached Rs 23,622 crore.' Mr. Kalyani's experience provides a clear picture of the changes that have occurred during the 11-year rule of the Modi government. In the last 11 years, the Modi government has completely changed the parameters of who should exercise power and how to exercise it. While radically changing the culture of politics and state administration, the Modi government has created new standards of good governance. The Modi government has consistently presented its work without forgetting that it is accountable to the people who have entrusted it with the responsibility of running the country. Prime Minister Modi and Union Home Minister Amit Shah have personally presented their government's progress report before the public on many platforms. In these 11 years, we have fulfilled the aspiration of ordinary Indians of a 'Safe India, Prosperous India' and introduced a new India to the world. After the attack on tourists in Pahalgam, the Modi government carried out decisive operations and destroyed terrorist bases operating in and supported by Pakistan. As soon as the Pakistani government tried to give a reply to India's action, the Indian Army dealt Pakistan such a befitting blow that Pakistan's warlords and rulers had to bow down before India. The Pakistan that tried to enter Indian territory was humiliated to core when a befitting reply was given to the Pakistani terrorists. Indian-made weapons played a valuable role in this 'Operation Sindoor'. Systems like 'Akashteer', which releases swarms of drones carrying 5-10 kg of explosives, are the achievements of the Modi government. It is an achievement of the Modi government that India is moving towards becoming completely self-reliant in its defence capability due to the emphasis on defence manufacturing under the 'Make in India' campaign. In the last 11 years, the Modi government has shown the world that India can build a world-class defence system. In the last year, the Modi government has also shown its resolve by taking important decisions like the Waqf Amendment Bill. In the first 100 days of Government 3.0, infrastructure development projects worth Rs 3 lakh crore were launched. This includes the Vadhavan Port in Maharashtra. A Rs 49 thousand crore scheme has also been launched to connect 25 thousand villages that have never been connected by road till now. The Modi government's commitment to service, good governance and welfare of the poor is evident in many decisions taken by them which had remained neglected until now like making income up to Rs 12 lakh tax-free for the middle class, increasing 75,000 new seats in medical colleges, removing export value on onion and basmati rice, increasing the support price of kharif crops from Rs 100 to Rs 550, a package of Rs 2 lakh crore for the youth, increasing capital expenditure to Rs 11 lakh 11 thousand crore, and providing free medical treatment up to Rs 5 lakh to citizens above 70 years of age under the Ayushman Vay Vandana Yojana. Over 50 lakh Lakhpati Didis have been registered in the last year. Since the launch of this initiative, 1.25 crore women have become Lakhpati Didis. The Swachh Bharat Abhiyan created a cleanliness movement and everyone was able to see how it transformed the country. The country's metro network has expanded beyond 1,000 kilometers in the last 11 years. India was a toy importer before 2014. In 2023-24, India exported toys worth $152.34 million. The innovative idea of starting freight transport on rivers like the Ganges has been a great success. The Goods and Services Tax (GST) has generated a revenue of Rs 2 lakh crore. The Modi government's schemes like Jan Dhan, Ujjwala, and PM Awas Yojana have brought about revolutionary changes in the lives of the poor. I take this opportunity to express my confidence and belief that India's development chariot will run even faster in the next 4 years. Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email Disclaimer Views expressed above are the author's own.
