Mumbai comedy club ransacked after performer's joke about local politician
A mob violently ransacked a Mumbai comedy club and its building has been partly demolished after one of India's most prominent comedians performed a satirical song about a local ruling politician during a performance there.
Kunal Kamra has a reputation for his acerbic comedy which often pokes fun at political figures. Few comedians in India dare to make political jokes for risk of a backlash.
Kamra's standup routine, performed in Mumbai's well-known Habitat comedy club on Friday night, included a parody song about Eknath Shinde, the second most powerful figure in the Maharashtra state government.
The song referred to the deputy chief minister as a 'gaddar', meaning traitor, a reference to him switching his political allegiance in 2022 and helping to bring down the previous state government.
An online video of the routine prompted criticism from the leaders of Shinde's Shiv Sena party. On Sunday night about 20 Shiv Sena supporters descended on Habitat and began to smash it apart, throwing chairs, tearing down posters and breaking light fittings.
The police have arrested about 12 people for the incident, including the leader of Shiv Sena's youth faction, Rahul Kanal.
The Shiv Sena-led government sought to blame Kamra for the violence. Maharastra's chief minister, Devendra Fadnavis, claimed in the state assembly on Monday that people were free to perform standup comedy but added that 'freedom of expression has its own limitations. You cannot insult anyone.'
'There is no need to spare them,' said Fadnavis. 'We will not tolerate this and we will teach them a lesson.'
The state home minister, Yogesh Kadam, said the police were trying to trace Kamra and that the government would investigate Kamra's phone records and look into his bank account transactions to prove whether there was a 'mastermind' or political conspiracy behind his jokes.
Shiv Sena said they had also filed a police report against Kamra.
Kamra did not directly respond to the allegations. However, hours after the attack he posted a picture on Instagram showing him holding up a copy of the Indian constitution on stage, captioned: 'The only way forward…'
Ministers also claimed that the Habitat comedy club was 'illegal'. A demolition team from the local municipal council arrived at the venue on Monday and began demolishing part of the building on the grounds that part of it had been illegally constructed.
In a statement on Monday the venue said it was 'shocked, worried and extremely broken by the recent acts of vandalism targeting us. We have never been involved in the content performed by any artist.'
The venue said it was shutting down until 'we figure out the best way to provide a platform for free expression without putting ourselves and our property in jeopardy'.
Comedians and comedy venues have increasingly been caught in the crosshairs of India's shrinking space for freedom of expression since the rise of the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata party which has ruled for more than a decade. In Maharastra, Shiv Sena rules the state government in coalition with the BJP.
In 2021, a Muslim comedian was detained by police for weeks for alleged 'vulgar' jokes insulting Hindu gods despite never performing the standup routine. In the same year, the comedian Vir Das faced a backlash and police reports after a comedy monologue that dealt with politically sensitive issues.
Opposition politicians in Maharashtra condemned the violence and retaliation against Kamra. Shinde's former political ally, Aaditya Thackeray, said 'only an insecure coward' would react in such a way to a comedy song.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ITV News
33 minutes ago
- ITV News
Israel tells aid boat carrying Greta Thunberg to 'turn back' vowing to stop group entering Gaza
Israel's government has vowed to prevent an aid boat carrying Greta Thunberg and other activists from reaching the Gaza Strip. Defence Minister Israel Katz said that Israel wouldn't allow anyone to break its naval blockade of the Palestinian territory, which he said was aimed at preventing Hamas from importing arms. 'To the antisemitic Greta and her fellow Hamas propagandists — I will say this clearly: You should turn back, because you will not make it to Gaza,' he said in a statement. Thunberg, a climate campaigner, is among 12 activists aboard the Madleen, which is operated by the Freedom Flotilla Coalition. The vessel departed Sicily on June 1, on a mission that aims to break the sea blockade of Gaza and deliver humanitarian aid, while raising awareness over the growing humanitarian crisis 20 months into the Israel-Hamas war. The activists had said they planned to reach Gaza's territorial waters as early as June 8. Rima Hassan, a French member of the European Parliament who is of Palestinian descent, is among the others onboard. She has been barred from entering Israel because of her opposition to Israeli policies toward the Palestinians. After a 2½-month total blockade aimed at pressuring Hamas, Israel started allowing some basic aid into Gaza last month, but humanitarian workers have warned of famine unless the blockade is lifted and Israel ends its military offensive. An attempt last month by Freedom Flotilla to reach Gaza by sea failed after another of the group's vessels was attacked by two drones while sailing in international waters off Malta. The group blamed Israel for the attack, which damaged the front section of the ship. Israel and Egypt have imposed varying degrees of blockade on Gaza since Hamas seized power from rival Palestinian forces in 2007. Critics of the blockade say it amounts to collective punishment of Gaza's roughly 2 million Palestinians. Israel sealed Gaza off from all aid in the early days of the war ignited by the Hamas-led attack on southern Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, but later relented under U.S. pressure. In early March, shortly before Israel ended a ceasefire with Hamas, the country again blocked all imports, including food, fuel and medicine. Hamas-led militants killed around 1,200 people, mostly civilians, in the Oct. 7 attack and abducted 251 hostages, more than half of whom have since been released in ceasefire agreements or other deals. Hamas is still holding 55 hostages, more than half of them believed to be dead. Israel's military campaign has killed more than 54,000 Palestinians, according to the Gaza Health Ministry, which has said women and children make up most of the dead. It doesn't say whether those killed are civilians or combatants. The war has destroyed vast areas of Gaza and displaced around 90% of the territory's population, leaving people there almost completely dependent on international aid.
Daily Mirror
5 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Sir Nick Faldo takes swipe at UK while bragging about Donald Trump friendship
Multimillionaire golfer Nick Faldo, who was knighted for services to sport, told how he has no plans to return to Britain after taking a recent stroll down Eton High Street Sir Nick Faldo has criticised the UK using one of the nation's wealthiest high streets to attack his homeland while simultaneously praising life in his pal Donald Trump's America. The multimillionaire golfer, who was knighted for services to sport, told how he has no plans to return to Britain after taking a recent stroll down Eton High Street. 'We walked down Eton High Street because we used to live near there and it's looking a bit rough,' he said. 'You know, things have gone down. The shops are closing, there's boarded up windows and I'm disappointed to see that the country is struggling, to be honest. And, I mean, that's a shame.' The six-time major winner then boasted about his friendship with Trump before praising his adopted America, where he lives with his fourth wife, Lindsay De Marco. The former topless dancer is an ardent fan of the controversial president, often posting her support of him on the couple's Instagram page. When asked about Trump's America, Faldo, 67, told the Telegraph: 'You've got to say the attitude [in the US] is good. It's back to the good old psychology of life. You've got to be seeing good things and saying good things. Self-hypnosis is really powerful, you know?' His gushing praise of Trump's leadership came as America is currently teetering on the edge of recession, where grocery prices are spiralling due to the US leader's unhinged tariffs, and democracy is under siege from the president's attacks. Despite accepting a knighthood and continuing to use the 'Sir' title, Faldo said he has no intention of returning to the UK, choosing instead to spend his time in Montana, where he lives on a farm with his wife. Last year, the couple attended a Trump campaign rally during which the US leader spoke about the golfer while on stage. Addressing supporters in August, he said: "This guy is a major golfer. He is a major friend of mine. One of the best ever. They knighted him in England or the UK. And he just knew how to win. He could take people, he'd play the best players in the world, and they always folded in front of him. In fact, I think I need to bring him into government 'cause we like to get other people to fold. And his nickname is Foldo (sic) because he makes everyone, but his name is Faldo. Nick Faldo and his beautiful wife, Lyndsay. Where is Nick?" Trump then turned to point to the retired golfer who was sitting several rows back from the podium. "That guy can play golf," Trump added. "He's won six majors and many, many tournaments, and he's one of the greatest golfers ever. It's an honour, as a golfer. You are a piece of work. He's a tough cookie, too. You talk about a tough cookie. That's a tough cookie." Now, Faldo has spoken about his friendship with Trump, boasting about their relationship. 'He always calls me Nicky,' the golfer said of the businessman, recalling the frequency of their conversations. 'So when I started TV, out of the blue, a Monday after a tournament, I remember I was down hitting golf balls, and it's Donald, back when he was just a businessman,' he added. ''Nicky,'' Faldo said, impersonating Trump. Nicky, how did he blow that tournament? You wouldn't have done that, Nicky. You'd have done this, you'd have done that, Nicky.' Over ten years, that happened two or three times a year out of the blue.' Faldo revelled in the idea of calling Trump, treating the president as a party trick. 'For fun, I could be anywhere in the world and if somebody was talking about this and that, I'd say: 'I'll call him'. And I always get through. Honestly. One hundred per cent of the time,' he said. He went on to reveal an anecdote about ignoring a phone call from the president during the 2019 Masters, while on live television. 'It's the 2019 Masters. Tiger's just won... one of the ladies from CBS leans over to me and goes, 'I have a call from the president of the United States for you, sir...'' 'I say, 'Oh, tell him to call me on Monday.' She goes, 'no, it's the president of the United States'. It's fine, tell him that I'm busy, I'm on with (sports presenter Jim) Nantz!.' So anyway, about 4pm... my phone rings and I've got the president of the United States on the line. I've got Donald saying, 'Nicky, Nicky, how did he win this? How did he win this? How did he do that?' I go back: 'Do you realise that I'm live on flipping TV. Do you mind?' So my claim to fame is that he called two golfers on that day, and Tiger was second.' Faldo's praise for Trump comes as the president's bizarre tariffs hammer US households and his administration flouts laws and the constitution to impose the US leader's will. His wife has made no secret of her love for the former businessman, often posting on social media her support. Last year, following a failed assassination attempt on Trump, she posted a picture of him as he raised his hand in defiance. She wrote alongside the picture: "This is the only man I want leading our country." Before Joe Biden dropped out of the race, she often criticised the then-US leader. She has long held conservative views. Her fifth of seven husbands was multi-millionaire US businessman Scott Sangalli. As Mrs Sangalli, the couple, who were close to failed Presidential candidate Mitt Romney, used his wealth to support the Republican party while indulging Lindsay in her love of politics. Thirteen years ago, after running for office herself, she won the title of Mrs Conservative US. On winning the title, Lindsay, who is a convicted drug felon, said: "One side or size doesn't fit all, and the liberal agenda isn't for everyone. "The pageant sends out the message to women that being a conservative woman or young lady is a choice like any other. If it's their choice, then they should embrace it, and the Conservative US Pageant is the perfect place to showcase conservative women of all ages and to celebrate conservatism in America."
The National
10 hours ago
- The National
SNP 'demeaned themselves' with focus on Reform UK at by-election
Speaking to the Sunday National, the University of Strathclyde's Dr Michael Higgins said that the communication around the by-election, in terms of both the media coverage and political parties' output, had been 'dominated to some extent by Reform UK' who had made the vote 'about race'. Voters in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse went to the polls on Thursday to elect a new MSP, with Scottish Labour's Davy Russell emerging as the winner when the vote was called in the small hours of Friday. In the wake of the SNP's loss, party activists told The National that concerns raised about a campaign focused on opposing Reform UK rather than unpopular Labour Government policies had been dismissed by party bosses. READ MORE: John Curtice issues verdict on Hamilton by-election after 'surprise' result Dr Higgins similarly said that focusing on Farage – as First Minister John Swinney did with his claim that the by-election contest was a two-horse race between Reform and the SNP – had been a 'miscalculation'. 'I think that Nigel Farage is better ignored,' the political communications expert went on. 'I think people who are serious political players – whether you're on the side of the Conservatives or the Greens or Labour or the Scottish National Party, all of them are contributing, all of them are long-standing, democratic institutions that make a considerable and valuable contribution to political culture. 'I think they demean themselves by comparing themselves or responding to the interventions of individuals such as Nigel Farage, who is not a politician but a snake oil salesman.' Dr Higgins was one of the political experts to attend Swinney's anti-far-right summit, convened in Glasgow in April, from which Reform UK were explicitly excluded. READ MORE: The 2 steps Scotland can take to defeat the far-right for good Asked if that conference had also been a 'miscalculation' by allowing Farage to present himself as anti-establishment, Dr Higgins said that had been a different case. 'I think it was a legitimate response to concerns that are shared across the political spectrum,' he told the Sunday National. Outside that conference, demonstrations were held by both Reform UK and the fascist-adjacent fringe group A Force for Good, led by Holocaust-denier Alistair McConnachie. Dr Higgins noted that the Reform UK activists had been 'very keen indeed to distance themselves' from the extremists, and said the party had an obligation to ensure that its messaging did the same. Holocaust denier Alistair McConnachie speaks outside the anti-far-right summit in Glasgow (Image: PA) Ahead of the vote, Reform UK paid around £25,000 to push a 'race-baiting' advert on Facebook and Instagram which falsely claimed Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar had said he wanted to 'prioritise the Pakistani community'. It was ultimately seen more than one million times by voters in the constituency. The advert used footage from 2022 which had been unearthed by an anonymous far-right account on Twitter/X just two weeks before Reform UK began paying for extracts of the same video to be promoted on Facebook. Asked if this was a coincidence or perhaps evidence of a rhetorical pipeline from the far right to Reform UK, Dr Higgins said: 'You're quite right in saying that is extremely coincidental, and those sorts of coincidences are to be avoided in the future.' The advert was widely condemned – with Sarwar calling Farage a 'pathetic, poisonous little man' and First Minister John Swinney labelling it 'blatantly racist' and 'unacceptable' – but became a key story of the by-election. Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar was targeted by a 'racist' campaign advertDr Higgins said that in terms of issues which defined the campaign, 'you need to talk about race'. 'I think it's really, really unfortunate in a Scottish context – I think it's unfortunate in a context anywhere – but they made it about race and immigration,' he went on. 'The social media post grossly misrepresented something that Anas Sarwar said. It was simply untrue, but that doesn't matter to parties such as Reform UK and Donald Trump and the populist right. 'They'll happily just try out a line and whether it's true or not, it will stick to the wall, it will stick with their constituency.' Dr Higgins said that while he would not 'characterise Reform IK's social media posts as racist, I think that they may well appeal to members of the electorate who are racist'. 'Of all the parties that are serious contenders, Reform UK are the party that will appeal most to those who are very hostile to immigration and racist.' READ MORE: Scottish independence 'already begun' as UK political culture diverges, expert says The political communications expert and author, who has written extensively on populism and the right, said that the Hamilton by-election had seen Reform UK 'setting out their stall in a national context', suggesting that similar tactics will be deployed ahead of the full Holyrood elections in May 2026. However, he further said that Reform UK's 26% vote share – which his University of Strathclyde colleague Professor John Curtice described as a 'surprise' due to being notably higher than the party is polling – may not be reflected in the full 2026 elections. 'People tend to vote in by-elections in ways that they wouldn't vote in a general election, knowing that they're not voting to constitute the government of the day,' Dr Higgins said. 'Disillusionment's really important. Most people who are not spending their days immersed in politics and are simply annoyed at both the SNP Government in Scotland and the Labour Government in the UK may be disillusioned, may not wish to vote Conservative, and may see Reform UK as a way of registering that disillusionment.' Reform UK leader Nigel Farage campaigned in Scotland before the by-election (Image: Ben Whitley) He added: 'I think Nigel Farage will burn himself out in terms of his interest to the media. There's only so much attention that can be given to Farage.' The wheels did seem to come off Reform UK's bus slightly on the day of the by-election, when their party chair Zia Yusuf resigned after an MP raised what he called the 'stupid' question of a ban on the burqa at Prime Minister's Questions. Whether Farage's party can keep their momentum going into 2026 – or more crucially for them, the 2029 General Election – may depend on how the other parties respond. Can the SNP find a message which is not simply 'lock out Reform UK'? If the Hamilton by-election is a warning, they will have to.
