Dietitian and Doctor Xand share message to anyone who has turmeric, ginger or chilli
Do you have these in your diet? If so, you may be dissapointed
Doctor Xand has revealed that the benefits you've read when it comes to spices may not be as beneficial as you think. Speaking to expert Laura Clark, known as The Menopause Dietitian, the pair delved into spices and their little-known benefits, urging others to add them to their diet - but to be careful.
On Dr Xand's Con or Cure series on the BBC, the doctor pondered the question 'do we need to add spices to our diet for our health?'. And whilst they can help, it may be more of a "con".
Clark explained: "Spices are really appealing because they're natural and we know that a lot of spices have powerful anti-inflammatory properties. They are rich antioxidants, and we're all about antioxidants because we know they help to protect us against disease, and they also help fight the ageing process."
Is turmeric worth adding to my diet?
"Turmeric is a really hyped one", according to Dr Xand, with Clark adding that the hype may not be justified. She said: "We're seeing this in supermarkets and cafés.
"We can buy shots of it. The active ingredient is a compound called curcumin", she revealed.
This compound is a naturally occurring substance classified as a curcuminoid - a group of bioactive compounds. It is a yellow polyphenolic pigment derived from the turmeric plant.
She continued "The idea is that this has really powerful antioxidant properties, so I suppose it can help protect against cardiovascular disease. It's very anti-inflammatory so there's lots of ways in which it can potentially help us.
"But the caveat is that actually turmeric itself, only 3% of it contains this active component." Citing studies which say turmeric is a powerhouse, she revealed that in these, many of them use a "curcumin extract which is 95% curcumin so you're getting much more power rather than the standard space that someone might have at home."
Dr Xand, who many may recognise from BBC Morning Live, replied: "So that leap between going 'it seems like turmeric does have important compounds and a diet high in turmeric in general is associated with good health' leads you down the road of going 'therefore the supplements are good'.
"But at that point it's an unregulated product that is definitely expensive and the evidence that will improve your health in a really specific, measurable way, is just not there and if it was, we'd give it out on the NHS."
The dietitian replied: "Exactly, yes. I think we have to take all these things with a pinch of salt, excuse the pun, and one of the ways I suppose in which herbs and spices can come into our lives to give us variety to help our gut health.
"And salt ironically, is our biggest modifiable dietary risk factor, so actually if we can get more spices with cooking, we can then reduce the amount of salt we add then brilliant, that's a win-win. But we cannot expect a turmeric shot to undo the amount of ultra processed food that we may end up eating later on in the day, for example."
Do chilli and cayenne pepper have health benefits
Clark told Xand that spicy foods such as chilli and cayenne pepper "are associated with potentially boosting metabolism". This is "because there is a heat that generated when we eat foods that contain them."
Like many of us, Dr Xand wondered if sweating from eating spicy food is equivalent to a workout. Unfortunately, the answer isn't that straightforward.
Clark observed that many people are eager to boost their metabolism, with the common belief that doing so can aid in weight loss and help maintain energy levels. "But context is key and the reality is that the claim that cayenne pepper can do that is not substantiated."
Dr Xand concluded: "Having a hot curry is not the same as going to the gym, that's a con. That's good. We are clear about that."
Is ginger good for me?
Highlighting "there's lots of medical literature on it" and "there seems to be very tantalising health potential for it", Dr Xand asked the expert whether it's worth having at all.
According to the dietitian: "It definitely helps our digestion in some way. It also has anti-informative properties, but again, to get to the level of ginger that's going to really have these therapeutic benefits, you need to be having quite a lot and that might not be very practical as a number one solution for how we're going to improve our health."
Concluding their health segment, Dr Xand summarised: "The bottom line is, by all means added spices to your meal, it will allow you to cut down on the salt, it will probably be good for your gut, it may all be good for your health in general, but that isn't the only or the most powerful way to affect your health."
Clark replied: "Absolutely. They are a piece of the puzzle, and like I always say, we have to look at the bigger picture."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
32 minutes ago
- BBC News
Shropshire blood donors frustrated by lack of appointments
People in Shropshire have said they are "very frustrated" by a campaign for more blood donors, as they are finding it near-impossible to find somewhere to donate themselves. It comes as the NHS warned it continued to face a "challenging" blood shortage, and called for 200,000 new donors to sign from Wellington is close to donating 100 pints of blood, but said she "just can't see [the milestone] happening" as she cannot find anywhere nearby to donate. NHS Blood and Transplant said it still hosted donation sessions in Shrewsbury and Telford, offering around 5,600 appointments per year. There are 27 permanent donor centres in England, including seven in London alone and two in the West Midlands - Birmingham and NHS's Give Blood website encourages potential donors to book appointments for these Birmingham centre is closed on Sundays, and the Stoke facility does not open at all at the weekend. Some would-be donors from Shropshire, particularly those with full-time jobs, have told the BBC this makes it difficult to donate. 'A bit miffed' "I've been a blood donor for years and years," Ann, who did not want her surname to be used, told BBC Radio Shropshire. She added that she previously donated blood regularly in Shifnal and Telford before sessions were cut. "I just can't get an appointment locally," she said, noting that her last two appointments had been cancelled last-minute. "I feel a bit miffed, basically."Ann added that she felt "a bit annoyed" by the new calls for more donors when regular donors like her were unable to get appointments. Peter Williams, from Waters Upton, recalled the ease of donating blood when he was an apprentice at GKN Sankey in Telford in 1970."The blood wagons used to come round - seven-and-a-half tonne vans they were," he recalled."They'd set up in the ballroom with 50 or 60 beds [...] Hundreds of [workers] must have gone through there each day."Mr Williams noted that he "doesn't know any blood donors" in Shropshire anymore. Jeff Lawrence from Shrewsbury said he was keen to donate blood as "quite a few people have probably helped me in the past, and I'd like to repay the favour.""There aren't many places you're able to give blood, unfortunately."Mr Lawrence said he wants to see more local places made available for donating blood."Less places means less donations, and less donations for people who need it." Tim Dalton, who lives near the Shropshire-Staffordshire border, said the campaign for more donors made him feel "very angry and very frustrated."When trying to book a donation slot, Mr Dalton said "any appointment offered was always in Birmingham or Wolverhampton, but very difficult to get to and always far into the future." Darren Bowen, Assistant Director for Blood Supply Chain at NHS Blood and Transplant, stated that the service "currently [hosts] blood donation sessions in both Shrewsbury and Telford, offering around 5,600 appointments per year."He continued: "We are incredibly grateful to all donors across Shropshire for their unwavering support in ensuring our sessions remain consistently well attended."While our community sessions across the county do get booked up quickly, we are currently appealing for people who live or work near one of our donor centres in towns and cities to help fill these venues where we have greatest availability." Follow BBC Shropshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
Sky News
38 minutes ago
- Sky News
'I don't think Britain's working well': Mum pays £250 for son's tooth removal - because of a one-year wait on the NHS
Three-year-old Eddie laughs as he whizzes down a slide. His mother Jodie Poole is relieved to see him smiling. A few weeks ago, he developed a painful abscess in his mouth. After being told there'd be up to a year's wait for the NHS to remove the affected tooth, Jodie paid around £250 for it to be done privately. An example, she says, of how public services are letting down families like hers. "I feel like I'm paying twice," she says. "I'm paying through my taxes, the money that I should be paying, and then I'm paying extra money that looks quite expensive because I can't get the things that we need that we should do for our taxes." As Chancellor Rachel Reeves decides how much to fund each of the public services that people across the country rely on for their everyday needs, it's people like Jodie who'll need persuading that they're getting a return for their taxes. There'll be winners and losers, with health and defence set to be prioritised. Jodie works as a childminder and runs a mother and toddler group in Peterborough, Cambridgeshire, which is where we met her for a chat. She voted for Labour at the last general election but has been disappointed so far. "I don't think Britain's working well for anyone right now," is her verdict on the state of public services. 'I don't think they have a clue' Running around with the younger children is seven-year-old LJ. It's the middle of the school day, but her mother Rachel Lawrence, 46, explains she no longer attends school due to concerns her additional needs weren't being met. She believes funding for education needs to be prioritised. "My daughter's home educated because they can't keep up with the SEN (special educational needs) needs of children," she says. Rachel used to work in a care home but had to give up due to childcare demands. She now works three jobs to pay the bills. She can't remember exactly how long LJ has been on a waiting list for an autism assessment but says it's been "years". As well as schools, she wants her taxes to be spend on extra funding for the NHS and more money for the police. "I think they seem to be very underfunded as well," she says. "Here, there's thefts all the time." She believes government ministers are out of touch with what life is really like. "I don't think they have a clue," she says. "They're too high up to kind of see what's happening to what I would call us little people down here". Hard to book appointments with GP In a nearby cafe, Eddie Bromley, 72, is enjoying a morning coffee. Asked if he's happy with local services, he shakes his head. "You can't ring your doctor up now and say, 'Can I book an appointment?'" he says. He dislikes being told to book online. "For a lot of people, you know, that's difficult," he says. Local pharmacist, Kishore Banda says inability to book GP appointments when they're needed is the biggest complaint he hears from customers. He says people then seek help at A&E departments instead. "At the end of the day it will cost more for the NHS," he says. But among the steady stream of people coming in to collect prescriptions we found people supportive of at least some of what they're hearing from the government. Whitney stops to chat briefly. " I'm quite alright with everything at the moment, obviously that's not the same for everyone," she says. Michael Lamb, who is in his 80s, thinks prioritising defence spending is key. "I can see a third world war coming," he says, genuinely concerned. The chancellor has talked about tough choices when it comes to deciding how to allocate spending. It's clear, here in Peterborough, that it will be impossible to please everyone.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Birmingham clinic's mental health services require improvement
NHS mental health provision in Birmingham still requires improvement, inspectors staff at the Reaside Clinic, a mental health clinic in Rednal, had not received all the appropriate and necessary training, a report from the Care Quality Commision said, and staff did not always involve patients in assessing their needs. The overall rating for Birmingham and Solihull Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust was requires the trust was judged to be good for being caring, well-led and responsive. The CQC said bosses needed to do more work to ensure patients received safe and effective care that met their needs. The inspection team visited the medium secure unit to check up on improvements the trust was told to make at a previous clinic provides assessment, treatment and rehabilitation to people with severe mental health problems across seven said there had been some improvements which meant the service was no longer in breach of regulations related to governance and oversight, but inspectors found two further breaches of regulations during their inspection in related to person-centred care and qualified staffing, they inspection team also visited the forensic intensive recovery and support teams (FIRST) following a serious incident which the trust had the forensic service - and the ratings for how safe and effective the service was - was found to require improvement. Amanda Lyndon, CQC deputy director of operations in the Midlands, said people had a mixed experiences of receiving care and treatment at Reaside."Some people told us that staff weren't always kind and caring," she said."However, people felt safe on the wards and knew who to speak to if they had any concerns."She said inspectors were told staff had cancelled some escorted leave outside of the unit due to low staffing levels, and that staff were sometimes too busy to support said they were told there were fewer activities on one ward following the departure of an activity worker, but that the trust had said it had plans to address this."Leaders at Birmingham and Solihull Mental Health NHS need to focus on improving the effectiveness of people's care by making sure their individual needs are taken into account," she said."There are many positive findings at FIRST they can look to emulate at Reaside, and build on to make care consistently safer for people at all services." Follow BBC Birmingham on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
