logo
Triple murderer should get whole-life order for ‘exceptional' crimes, court told

Triple murderer should get whole-life order for ‘exceptional' crimes, court told

Yahoo16-07-2025
Triple murderer Nicholas Prosper should be given a whole-life order for the 'exceptional' killings of his mother and two siblings, the Court of Appeal has heard.
Prosper was jailed for a minimum term of 49 years, less 188 days already spent in custody, in March after admitting killing his mother, Juliana Falcon, 48, sister Giselle Prosper, 13, and 16-year-old brother Kyle Prosper at their family flat in Luton, Bedfordshire, on September 13 2023.
The 19-year-old also admitted weapons charges after plotting a mass shooting at his former primary school in the town.
The Solicitor General has referred his sentence to the Court of Appeal as 'unduly lenient', claiming that he should be given a whole-life order, meaning that he would never be released.
If three senior judges rule that the sentence should be increased, Prosper would become the first person aged between 18 and 20 to be given a whole-life sentence.
Barristers for Prosper, who currently will not be released until at least his late 60s, told judges that the sentence 'cannot be said to be unduly lenient'.
Tom Little KC, for the Solicitor General, told the hearing in London: 'What the facts reveal is a case which, on any view, was exceptional, even in the context of a murder.'
He continued: 'It was a murder of three people, two of them were children, including the intended rape of the sister. That did not take place, but it had been intended.
'The murders were committed one after the other in their own home, heard by neighbours and each was aware they were being killed by their son or sibling, and one pleaded, that is the brother, for his life.'
He added: 'It was meant to achieve national and international notoriety.'
In written submissions, he said that a whole-life term was 'just punishment'.
He said: 'The age of the offender and his guilty pleas, although relevant to the ultimate decision, did not inexorably lead to or mean that this was a case in which a whole-life order was not appropriate.'
After shooting dead his siblings and mother, and stabbing his brother more than 100 times, Prosper hid for more than two hours before flagging down police officers in a nearby street and showing them where he had hidden a loaded shotgun and 33 cartridges near playing fields.
He had bought the firearm and 100 cartridges from a legitimate firearms dealer the day before the murders after forging a gun licence.
Rules were changed in 2022 to allow younger defendants aged 18 to 20 to receive whole-life orders.
Sentencing Prosper at Luton Crown Court in March, Mrs Justice Cheema-Grubb said that a whole-life term could only be given to someone in that age bracket if a court deemed 'that the seriousness of the combination of offences is exceptionally high'.
She stopped short of imposing a whole-life order in Prosper's case, as he was stopped from carrying out the school shooting, having murdered his family earlier than he intended after his mother woke up.
She continued that while he was 'indisputably a very dangerous young man', the risk to the public was met with a life sentence.
David Bentley KC, for Prosper, said on Wednesday that it was 'very difficult' to say how a 49-year sentence 'can be said to be unduly lenient'.
He said: 'The reality is that with the existing sentence, the earliest date he could actually be considered for parole is in his late 60s, and the dangerousness is covered by the life sentence.
'As the court knows, if he remains considered to be dangerous, he never comes out anyway, so a life sentence is a life sentence, and the minimum term simply provides a time when it can be reviewed.'
He continued: 'We accept that had it been someone aged 21 or over, the whole-life order would have been made.
'However, the judge, we say quite rightly, said this test is so high and there are factors here which allow her to stand back from that.'
He also said that Prosper 'voluntarily separated himself' from the weapon after deciding not to carry out the school shooting.
Prosper watched proceedings via a video link from HMP Belmarsh, at times with his head in his hands.
The Lady Chief Justice Baroness Carr, Mr Justice Wall and Mr Justice Goss could give judgment later on Wednesday.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Police searching for suspect in the killings of a couple found dead at an Arkansas park
Police searching for suspect in the killings of a couple found dead at an Arkansas park

CNN

time5 minutes ago

  • CNN

Police searching for suspect in the killings of a couple found dead at an Arkansas park

Police are searching for an unknown suspect in the killings of Clinton David Brink, 43, and Cristen Amanda Brink, 41, according to a release from Arkansas State Police Sunday. The Brinks were hiking in the Devil's Den State Park with their daughters, ages 7 and 9, who were not injured in the attack. The girls are safe with family members, police said. The park is in a remote and rural area, where the terrain is 'rugged, vegetation is thick and there is no cellphone service,' police said. Police were notified of the suspected double homicide around 2:40 p.m. Saturday. The suspect is described as a White male of medium build. Investigators said they believed he was wearing a long-sleeved shirt with sleeves rolled up, dark pants, a dark ballcap, sunglasses and fingerless gloves. He was carrying a black backpack and seen driving towards the park exit in a black four-door sedan that may have been a Mazda with its license plate covered by tape, police said. The vehicle may have been travelling on State Highway 170 or State Highway 220 near the park. The area has been cordoned off and police have asked visitors to the park to share any images they might have of the suspect from the park Saturday. Local residents have also been asked to check security and game camera footage. Police have increased law enforcement presence at state parks, said Shea Lewis, secretary of the Arkansas Department of Parks, Heritage and Tourism in the release. 'We are deeply saddened by the tragic events that occurred at Devil's Den State Park. Our hearts are with the victims' loved ones during this incredibly difficult time. The safety of our visitors and staff is our highest priority, and we are working closely with Arkansas State Police and various law enforcement officials as the investigation continues,' the statement read. The Brinks family had recently moved to Prairie Grove from another state, police added.

Massachusetts man recounts trying to fight off carjacking suspect later caught in Rhode Island
Massachusetts man recounts trying to fight off carjacking suspect later caught in Rhode Island

CBS News

time6 minutes ago

  • CBS News

Massachusetts man recounts trying to fight off carjacking suspect later caught in Rhode Island

A carjacking suspect was arrested in Rhode Island Friday night after police said he stole a man's car from his driveway in Newburyport, Massachusetts earlier in the day. At around 3 p.m. on Friday, 77-year-old Michael Doyle said he was returning home and getting out of his car on High Street when a man, now identified by police as 46-year-old David Agneta, walked onto his driveway and started making demands. "He said, 'Give me those keys' and I said no," said Doyle. He claimed Agneta then grabbed his hand "and we were having kind of a tug of war, I guess, because I was still in shock. And the keys slipped out of my hand or his and I fell over backwards with my bad knee." Agneta then allegedly shoved Doyle to the ground, took his keys and drove off with his car. Doyle said he was unable to fight back because he recently had knee replacement surgery. "I was on my back and I couldn't get up if I wanted to," recalled Doyle. "My wife threw a bucket of water at him but of course that didn't help much." Police said Doyle was treated at the scene by paramedics. "Thank god he wasn't armed because I was hopeless," said Doyle. "He could have stabbed me 15 times. Never in my wildest dreams did I expect someone to come walking across my lawn with malice in his mind." Rhode Island State Police arrested Agneta more than 100 miles away from Newburyport in Exeter, Rhode Island Friday night and charged him with possession of a stolen motor vehicle. Newburyport Police have charged him with two counts of carjacking and assault and battery on an elderly or disabled person. Agneta is expected to be arraigned in court Monday morning in Rhode Island. He'll be brought back to Massachusetts at a later date to be arraigned on those charges.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store