Triple murderer should get whole-life order for ‘exceptional' crimes, court told
Prosper was jailed for a minimum term of 49 years, less 188 days already spent in custody, in March after admitting killing his mother, Juliana Falcon, 48, sister Giselle Prosper, 13, and 16-year-old brother Kyle Prosper at their family flat in Luton, Bedfordshire, on September 13 2023.
The 19-year-old also admitted weapons charges after plotting a mass shooting at his former primary school in the town.
The Solicitor General has referred his sentence to the Court of Appeal as 'unduly lenient', claiming that he should be given a whole-life order, meaning that he would never be released.
If three senior judges rule that the sentence should be increased, Prosper would become the first person aged between 18 and 20 to be given a whole-life sentence.
Barristers for Prosper, who currently will not be released until at least his late 60s, told judges that the sentence 'cannot be said to be unduly lenient'.
Tom Little KC, for the Solicitor General, told the hearing in London: 'What the facts reveal is a case which, on any view, was exceptional, even in the context of a murder.'
He continued: 'It was a murder of three people, two of them were children, including the intended rape of the sister. That did not take place, but it had been intended.
'The murders were committed one after the other in their own home, heard by neighbours and each was aware they were being killed by their son or sibling, and one pleaded, that is the brother, for his life.'
He added: 'It was meant to achieve national and international notoriety.'
In written submissions, he said that a whole-life term was 'just punishment'.
He said: 'The age of the offender and his guilty pleas, although relevant to the ultimate decision, did not inexorably lead to or mean that this was a case in which a whole-life order was not appropriate.'
After shooting dead his siblings and mother, and stabbing his brother more than 100 times, Prosper hid for more than two hours before flagging down police officers in a nearby street and showing them where he had hidden a loaded shotgun and 33 cartridges near playing fields.
He had bought the firearm and 100 cartridges from a legitimate firearms dealer the day before the murders after forging a gun licence.
Rules were changed in 2022 to allow younger defendants aged 18 to 20 to receive whole-life orders.
Sentencing Prosper at Luton Crown Court in March, Mrs Justice Cheema-Grubb said that a whole-life term could only be given to someone in that age bracket if a court deemed 'that the seriousness of the combination of offences is exceptionally high'.
She stopped short of imposing a whole-life order in Prosper's case, as he was stopped from carrying out the school shooting, having murdered his family earlier than he intended after his mother woke up.
She continued that while he was 'indisputably a very dangerous young man', the risk to the public was met with a life sentence.
David Bentley KC, for Prosper, said on Wednesday that it was 'very difficult' to say how a 49-year sentence 'can be said to be unduly lenient'.
He said: 'The reality is that with the existing sentence, the earliest date he could actually be considered for parole is in his late 60s, and the dangerousness is covered by the life sentence.
'As the court knows, if he remains considered to be dangerous, he never comes out anyway, so a life sentence is a life sentence, and the minimum term simply provides a time when it can be reviewed.'
He continued: 'We accept that had it been someone aged 21 or over, the whole-life order would have been made.
'However, the judge, we say quite rightly, said this test is so high and there are factors here which allow her to stand back from that.'
He also said that Prosper 'voluntarily separated himself' from the weapon after deciding not to carry out the school shooting.
Prosper watched proceedings via a video link from HMP Belmarsh, at times with his head in his hands.
The Lady Chief Justice Baroness Carr, Mr Justice Wall and Mr Justice Goss could give judgment later on Wednesday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
25 minutes ago
- Yahoo
UK fears new summer of unrest, year after Southport riots
Concern is mounting that recent violent anti-immigrant protests could herald a new summer of unrest, a year after the UK was rocked by its worst riots in decades. Police have arrested 16 people since protests flared last week outside a hotel housing asylum seekers in the town of Epping, northeast of London. In one demonstration, eight police officers were injured. The unrest was "not just a troubling one-off", said the chairwoman of the Police Federation, Tiff Lynch. "It was a signal flare. A reminder of how little it takes for tensions to erupt and how ill-prepared we remain to deal with it," she wrote in the Daily Telegraph. Protestors shouted "save our children" and "send them home", while banners called for the expulsion of "foreign criminals". Cabinet minister Jonathan Reynolds on Thursday urged people not to speculate or exaggerate the situation, saying "the government, all the key agencies, the police, they prepare for all situations. "I understand the frustrations people have," he told Sky News. The government was trying to fix the problem and that the number of hotels occupied by asylum seekers had dropped from 400 to 200, he added. The issue of thousands of irregular migrants arriving in small boats across the Channel, coupled with the UK's worsening economy, has triggered rising anger among some Britons. Such sentiments have been amplified by inflammatory messaging on social networks, fuelled by far-right activists. Almost exactly a year ago on July 29, 2024, three young girls were stabbed to death in a frenzied attack in northwestern Southport. The shocking killings stoked days of riots across the country after false reports that the killer -- a UK-born teenager whose family came to the country from Rwanda after the 1994 genocide -- was a migrant. Nearly 24,000 migrants have made the perilous journey across the Channel so far in 2025, the highest-ever tally at this point in a year. The issue has become politically perilous, putting pressure on Labour Prime Minister Keir Starmer's centre-left government, as the anti-immigrant, far-right Reform UK party rises in the polls. - 'More unrest likely' - The Epping protests were stirred after a 38-year-old asylum seeker, who only arrived in Britain in late June, was arrested and charged with three counts of sexual assault. Images from the protests have gone viral on social networks, mirroring what happened last July. But Epping residents have maintained that the protests are being fuelled by people from outside the community. "These violent scenes ... are not Epping, and they are not what we stand for," the Conservative MP for Epping, Neil Hudson, told parliament Monday. While calm was restored to Epping, a middle-class suburban town with a population of 12,000, tensions remain palpable. "This is the first time something like this has happened," one local who lives close to the Bell Hotel told AFP, asking not to be named. "The issue is not the hotel, but extremists applying a political ideology," he added. Late on Thursday, the hotel, cordoned off behind barriers, was again the centre of a protest involving dozens of people, with police making one arrest. With another protest expected on Sunday, the local council voted through a motion to demand the government no longer house asylum seekers at the hotel. The UK is "likely to see more racist riots take place this summer", said Aurelien Mondon, politics professor and expert on far-right and reactionary discourse at Bath University. Anti-immigrant protests have already erupted elsewhere, with demonstrations in the southeastern town of Diss in Norfolk outside a similar hotel on Monday. Last month, clashes flared for several days in the town of Ballymena in Northern Ireland after two teenagers with Romanian roots were arrested for the alleged attempted rape of a young girl. - 'Civil disobedience' - "It is well documented that many of the protests we are witnessing are not the result of grassroots, local movements," Mondon said. "Social media plays a role and facilitates coordination amongst extreme-right groups," but it is "also crucial not to exaggerate" its power, he added. High-profile far-right activist Tommy Robinson, who was blamed for stoking the Southport unrest, announced he would be in Epping on Sunday, before later seeming to scrap the plan. The firebrand anti-Islam campaigner has just been freed from jail after spreading fake news about a Syrian immigrant, but faces trial on a separate issue in 2026. "I don't think anybody in London even understands just how close we are to civil disobedience on a vast scale," said Reform leader Nigel Farage. "Most of the people outside that hotel in Epping weren't far right or far left," he said, they "were just genuinely concerned families". mct-ebl/jkb/jj/lb
CBS News
10 hours ago
- CBS News
Woman stabbed at apartment complex near Miami Lakes, MDSO says
A woman was airlifted to the Ryder Trauma Center after she was stabbed at an apartment complex early Thursday morning, according to the Miami-Dade Sheriff's Office. They said around 8:45 a.m. a call came in about a stabbing at the Natura Gardens apartment complex at NW 172 Street and NW 94 Court, just west of I-75 near Miami Lakes. When deputies arrived, they found a woman lying on the ground with at least one stab wound, sheriff's investigators said. She was rushed to Jackson Memorial Hospital where she is listed as stable. Investigators have focused their attention on a second floor apartment. Sheriff's investigators said the person who stabbed her left the scene before deputies arrived. They added that the woman knows who that person is, but it is unclear what sort of relationship they have.
CBS News
10 hours ago
- CBS News
Homicide investigation underway in Des Plaines, Illinois after man dead in car
Homicide investigation underway in Des Plaines, Illinois, after a man was found shot and killed in a car on Wednesday. According to Des Plaines police, officers responded to a report of a shooting around 4:25 p.m. in the 900 block of North Avenue. Police said officers found a man dead with a gunshot wound seated in a parked car. Police identified the man as Joseph Kalamaris, 33, from Rosemont, Illinois. According to police, a family member found Kalamaris and called 911. Des Plaines police confirmed there is no threat to the public, and they are investigating.
