France claims victory on EU online child protection guidelines
On Monday, the Commission unveiled much-anticipated guidelines for protecting minors online, as part of the Digital Services Act (DSA).
The initiative has drawn significant attention and backing from EU countries, industry, and children's rights groups, many of which have already set out their own positions in anticipation of the official DSA guidelines.
A French-led movement of EU countries seeking to ban social media for kids under 15 believes its position has been affirmed in the final Commission guidelines – a shift from an earlier draft, released in May, which did not clarify this issue.
"The European Commission has just confirmed the possibility for Member States to ban social networks for those under a certain age," French President Emmanuel Macron wrote in a triumphant post on X on Monday evening.
"This marks an important victory for France," added the country's digital minister, Clara Chappaz, in a press release which also stated that the guidelines have paved the way for banning social media for kids. Choose your own digital majority The final guidelines allow member countries to set their own so-called "digital majority" age, instead of establishing one at the EU level. On Monday, Tech Commissioner Henna Virkkunen said that creating an EU-wide digital majority is not possible due to "different cultures" and "differences between member states."
Danish Minister for Digital Affairs, Caroline Stage Olsen, who on Monday presented the guidelines alongside Virkkuen, stressed that age verification is "absolutely essential" – referencing the Commission's prototype age verification tool, which could underpin country-specific apps capable of restricting content deemed inappropriate for children.
EU lawmaker Christel Schaldemose, who is currently finalising a Parliamentary report on the protection of minors, also welcomed the Commission approach – saying she's "particularly glad that Member States retain the flexibility to implement their own age verification systems for social media."
However, she added that she would still like the Commission to adopt a "more ambitious stand on age verification" for social media platforms.
Children's rights groups also welcomed the guidelines. Manon Baert, from the 5Rights Foundation, said they "have the potential to make a real difference for children across Europe", adding: "Now companies must deliver."
But industry representatives are unhappy, with tech lobbies warning that allowing EU countries to decide their own digital majority age risks fragmentation.
"The door is still open for national laws, which is disappointing," said DOT Europe, a Brussels-based association representing Big Tech.
Meta, which has lobbied strongly for an EU-wide digital age majority alongside enhanced parental controls, also cautioned against introducing varying rules across countries.
(nl, aw)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Euractiv
3 hours ago
- Euractiv
The Brief – Why Europe has succumbed to Chinese whispers
In one of the more memorable scenes in Casablanca, a slick-haired Frenchman warns a well-heeled patron of Rick's Café Américain to 'be on guard'. 'I beg of you, monsieur, watch yourself… this place is full of vultures, vultures everywhere!' the Frenchman exclaims as he quietly lifts the unsuspecting man's wallet and walks off. The victim's naïveté makes it difficult to feel sorry for him – we all saw it coming. So it is with Europe these days, as it stumbles across the world stage, treating friends like vultures and vultures like friends. The tragedy of that wrongheadedness has rarely been as obvious as this week, as the EU struggles to formulate coherent policies on an array of flashpoints from Gaza to the war in Ukraine to U.S. trade talks. On Gaza, the bloc is hopelessly divided between countries that do not think Israel has the right to continue to wage war against Hamas, given the large number of civilian casualties, and those who believe that Europe has a moral duty to continue to back the Middle East's only democracy after the savagery of 7 October. At a meeting in Brussels on Tuesday, EU foreign ministers failed to resolve their differences over a proposal to effectively sanction Israel for its hard line on Gaza. Meanwhile, just hours after Donald Trump confirmed his willingness to arm Ukraine in the face of Russia's intensifying bombing campaign there, the EU was forced to postpone a decision over a new Russian sanctions package. The reason? Slovakia – a country that accounts for 0.7% of EU's GDP and about 1% of its population – is blocking it. On the tariff front, the picture is no less confused. After months of negotiations the Commission went into last weekend believing it had escaped Trump's wrath, only to be slapped with the threat of what would be a crippling 30% tariff regime on Saturday. It's easy to blame Trump's volatility and mercurial nature for the outcome. As ever, the truth is a little more complicated. It has since emerged that Brussels wasn't willing to go far enough on China by, in the words of one senior EU official, agreeing to a Trump demand that the bloc 'follow us 100% on what we do on China'. Leopoldo Rubinacci, the Commission official, went on to say: 'I don't think, as a matter of principle, that the European Union should follow examples. I think that the European Union should set its own examples.' The example Europe has set on China is hardly one others should emulate. With Beijing, Europe has slipped on the proverbial Chinese finger trap: Resistance only makes the pain worse. Even as Europe allowed the Chinese to steal most of their intellectual property, European industry – especially the Germans – built up such a heavy dependency on China that it would be impossible to head for the exits, no matter what Trump threatens. That bitter reality explains why the EU ended up in a place where it devotes much its diplomatic energy and moral outrage to castigating a liberal country of 10 million defending itself against terrorism, while saying virtually nothing about the real-life concentration camps China's authoritarian regime has erected in Xinjiang to 're-educate' Uyghurs. It's also why Europe says nothing about China's crackdown in Hong Kong, nothing about the Chinese Communist Party's systematic suppression of Tibet and little about Taiwan. That's where the Casablanca metaphor falls apart. Unlike the hapless gentleman at Rick's, Europe knows exactly who the vultures are; it just lacks the moral clarity and courage to face them down. The Roundup Bigger budget? – The next Multiannual Financial Framework aims to answer mammoth challenges. Can it deliver or will member states savage the Commission proposal? W(h)ining about a trade war – Europe's wine sector has condemned the European Commission's plan to make wine part of its €72 billion push-back against US exports. Meaty veggislation – A draft proposal by the European Commission seeks to restrict the use of traditional meat terms for plant-based products but does not go as far as banning widely used terms such as 'steak', 'burger', and 'sausage'. Across Europe Iranian espionage, German extradition – Denmark extradited a Danish national accused of spying on Jewish Institutions in Berlin on behalf of Iran to Germany, where he could face up to 10 years in prison. Keeping kids off social media – France declared victory in its efforts to ban social media for children under 15 after the Commission unveiled guidelines to protect minors online. Patriot purchase – Denmark and the Netherlands are looking to participate in Donald Trump's plan for Europe to buy American weapons for Ukraine. It is not clear how fast deals can be made.
Euractiv
4 hours ago
- Euractiv
LIVE: Countdown to the EU's next seven-year budget
Euractiv Jul 15, 2025 19:02 1 min. read Live Blog A Live Blog Posting is a Blog Posting intended to provide a rolling textual coverage of an ongoing event through continuous updates. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen is set to present the bloc's next seven-year budget – the multiannual financial framework or MFF – on 16 July. Euractiv dives deep into what's going on and what that means for the future of Europe – from agrifood to tech, from defence to the economy.
Euractiv
4 hours ago
- Euractiv
Major blow to Pornhub as France's highest court re-introduces age verification
France's state council has overruled a Paris administrative court ruling to suspend a government decree on 15 July – meaning that all porn websites offering services in France must verify their users' age. The ruling from the state council on Tuesday comes only weeks after the Paris administrative court suspended a governmental decree requiring age verification for EU-based porn websites in June. Today's decision is the latest development in the dispute championed by French Digital Minister Clara Chappaz, affecting adult websites including Pornhub, YouPorn and Redtube which are owned by Cyprus-based company Aylo as well as xhamster-owner Hammy Media. "The State Council has decided: the law has to be followed," wrote Chappaz on X. But the council's ruling only suspends the June court decision and does not pre-empt the forthcoming preliminary ruling from the Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU). The CJEU must determine whether the French government's decree requiring EU-based porn companies to comply with national law conflicts with EU law. In short, this is merely a temporary victory for Chappaz, as the CJEU could still annul the French government's decree for failure to comply with EU law. It remains unclear whether Aylo will shut down its websites in France, as it did in June to protest enforcement of the French SREN law – the law the government decree aimed at enforcing. The European Commission on Monday proposed new guidelines to protect minors online. France claimed victory, saying the Commission's proposal enshrined its own approach mandating age verification for accessing pornographic website throughout the EU. Aylo did not respond to a request for a comment at the time of reporting. (vib)
