More specialists shifting to private hospitals
Photo:
RNZ
More medical specialists are leaving the public health system - or reducing their hours - to work in private hospitals, according to Medical Council data.
A
report
just released by the senior doctors' union,
A Spreading Problem
, tracks the distribution of medical specialists between public and private work using that data for the period June 2022 to June 2024.
It shows:
Senior doctors
walked off the job
last week for an unprecedented 24-hour strike after eight months of deadlocked contract negotiations for the Association of Salaried Medical Specialists.
Health NZ has applied to the Employment Relations Authority to do facilitated bargaining to resolve the dispute.
The union said the "lowball" pay offer (which is capped at 1.5 percent of total remuneration), will mean the public system is unable to recruit new doctors, or stop the ones it already has from going overseas or to the private system.
The new report, which updates data published in ASMS' earlier report,
Creeping Privatisation,
notes Health NZ's own Health Workforce Plan 2023/24 acknowledged "FTE flight to the private sector in some areas …can limit public capacity".
The total medical workforce employed across the public, private and other sectors grew by 5.7 percent in the two years to June 2024, but growth was not evenly distributed.
While the specialist workforce was current divided approximately 70 percent public/ 30 percent private, the balance was shifting.
For small specialities, the loss of even a couple of senior doctors made a huge difference, according to the ASMS report.
"For example, paediatric surgery lost 1.7 FTEs between June 2022 and June 2024, but that represents a 9.1 percent reduction.
"Similarly, the loss of 3.1 FTEs in cardiothoracic surgery amounts to a 12.6 percent loss of cardiothoracic surgeons working in public hospitals."
Even specialities that saw gains in workforce numbers - that is 21 out of 36 areas of medicine - were often coming from "a relatively low numerical base".
"For example, dermatology and rehabilitation medicine are not available publicly in many parts of the country.
"While the increases in emergency medicine are relatively large, that workforce would need an additional 105 specialists to be proportionate with the Australian emergency medicine specialist workforce on a per capita basis in 2023."
The number of patients showing up at Emergency Departments grew 15.5 percent in June 2024 compared with the same period two years previously, while "complexity" (how ill those patients were) grew by 16.7 percent.
"At the same time, recent media reports show all hospital emergency departments failing to assess patients with imminently or potentially life threatening conditions within clinically acceptable timeframes."
Intensive care medicine would have needed an additional 57 specialists to be proportionate with Australia; obstetrics and gynaecology would have needed 31 specialists.
Fifteen of 36 specialities saw a shift in doctors from public to private.
"Collectively those 15 specialities saw an net loss of 25.6 FTEs in public hospitals, while the private/other sectors saw a net gain 177.9 FTEs."
Just over 31 percent of the total hours worked by medical specialists was spent in "Private/Other" services in 2024: mostly in private hospitals or clinical practice, but also universities and government departments.
For surgical specialities, more than a third (35.3 percent) of worked hours were spent in the private sector, and a further 3.5 percent were spent in other employment.
In dermatology, oral and maxillofacial surgery, palliative medicine and ophthalmology, there were more doctors working in private than in the the public system.
Orthopaedic surgeons and radiologists were split 50-50 between the two.
"The division of the specialist workforce across the public-private/other sectors would not necessarily be an issue if there was sufficient specialist workforce capacity to meet health need in the public system," the report said.
"The effects of the workforce split have to be seen in the context of workforce shortages in each speciality, where every specialist moving to the private sector can exacerbate the shortage in the public sector."
The shift towards private health services created "a double disadvantage for those who can't afford health insurance or to self-fund their care" - mostly Māori, Pacific Peoples and lower-income groups - who were already missing out on primary care due to cost.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
First public hearings into New Zealand's Covid-19 response to begin
The Royal Commission of Inquiry into Covid-19 is looking into the government's response to the pandemic and its effects. Photo: RNZ The first public hearings into New Zealand's Covid response get underway today - with a focus on lockdowns and vaccines. The Royal Commission of Inquiry into Covid-19 is looking into the government's response to the pandemic and its effects. It is the first time submissions will be heard publicly, with the sessions live-streamed. This week's hearings particularly concentrate on the impact of the extended lockdown in Auckland and Northland in 2021 and on vaccine mandates and safety. In a minute issued on the Inquiry's website chair Grant Illingworth KC said that would include the effect on "social division and isolation, health and education, and business activity. "We will also hear from experts about the key decisions and their consequences, and lessons to be learned from what happened." The hearings would be in secure hearing rooms, with commissioners, witnesses, lawyers and media present. There was no provision for public attendance beyond those submitting but the live streams would run and be available as recordings as well, the minute said. Witnesses would be questioned by lawyers helping the inquiry, and commissioners could ask questions. A second public hearing was due next month in Wellington. That was to hear from key decisions makers who "led and informed" the government's response to the pandemic. This Royal Commission was set up under the previous Labour government, but its brief was expanded under the current government, with Illingworth taking the chairing role. A report from the first phase was delivered last year. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Covid-19 Inquiry: Who is being 'excluded' from inquiry hearings
Photo: People with Long Covid are disappointed they will not be prioritised as part of public hearings about the government's pandemic response. Phase two of the Royal Commission of Inquiry into the official response to Covid-19 gets underway in Auckland on Monday, and will run until Thursday. It will hear from everyday people and their experiences of the government's decisions over vaccine use and lockdowns, including the extended lockdowns in Auckland and Northland. It will also hear from businesses and organisations affected. Long Covid Support Aotearoa spokesperson Catherine Appleby said she felt in choosing its focus, the inuiry had missed an opportunity to include the perspectives of people with post-Covid conditions. "A massive mistake really, to do that, because we were directly affected and our lives are still particularly affected as well." Appleby worked as a nurse at an urgent care centre when Covid-19 hit in 2020. Each day, after her shift, she would have to strip down her clothes on her doorstep, in the hope she wouldn't transmit Covid to her whānau. It's something many other healthcare practitioners did. In 2022, she caught Covid-19 herself. She returned to work thinking she was recovered, but the symptoms didn't go away. She reduced her hours of work in the hope it would improve things, but it didn't. "Finally, I just had to decide, and at that stage, I was over two and a half years into Long Covid, and I thought, "I'm looking down the barrel of non-recovery. If I want to have any chance of recovery, I just have to stop working completely." Auckland spent more than 100 days in lockdown starting in August 2021. Photo: 123RF Appleby explained there were significant effects on people with Long Covid. It often affects their ability to work, leading to loss of income, lack of financial and health system support, and impacts on social and family life, she said. She said thousands of people experience Long Covid across Aotearoa, all the more reason to include their voices in the hearings this week. "Covid is still around, and the Long Covid numbers are likely to increase. Even if you are immunized, the estimate is up to 10% of people who catch the infection will get Long Covid." Long Covid Support Aotearoa has called for an inquiry into the condition, much like the one held across the ditch in Australia between 2022 and 2023. A new Otago-led study, published in the International Journal of Paediatrics and Child Health, found that more than 20 per cent of children and young people in Aotearoa are experiencing significant, persistent health symptoms following Covid-19. Lead Author and Associate Professor from the University of Otago's Department of Public Health, Julie Bennett, said her team conducted interviews with nearly 4300 children (or their parents for those under 16) to understand their experiences and symptoms after Covid-19 infection. The symptoms included things like headaches, fatigue, coughs, and anxiety, which they didn't have before having Covid, she said. "They were also reporting that they were unable to attend school because of having these symptoms, or they were unable to attend things like going to sporting events or activities that they normally would be able to do. These symptoms weren't just happening; they were actually limiting their ability to be able to participate in life." Regarding New Zealand's response, Professor Bennett said having a proper pandemic plan in place is key. "We did manage to get together really quickly, a good group of people to be able to make decisions, and making really hard decisions, on the spur of the moment, often with little information, but trying to do it as evidence-based as they could." Instead of focusing on Long Covid, the hearings this week will cover Government decisions relating to lockdowns, vaccine mandates, and vaccine safety, and how these key decisions affected things like social division and isolation, health and education, and business activity. Hearings this week are part of phase two of the Royal Commission's Inquiry. Photo: Restaurant Association chief executive Marisa Bidois has been an outspoken voice on the economic toll that successive lockdowns have had on the hospitality industry, especially in Auckland. She said the restrictions saw multiple businesses close as a result, a hard hit on her industry. "If there were some different decisions made around the lockdowns, the restrictions in trading, we would still see some of those businesses operating today, no doubt." At the time, she was an outspoken voice, consistently advocating for change and raising suggestions on how businesses could survive while also balancing public health goals. She said that while the government's intention might have been to protect public health, the reality felt like a one-size-fits-all approach. "We did a significant amount of work around the ways to make, like contactless deliveries available at, say, alert level three. Feedback like this, at the time, was ignored, whereas if that would have been taken on board, businesses could have been operating sooner." Marisa Bidois said the last couple of years have been particularly tough on the hospitality industry. Photo: Supplied The Restaurant Association submitted its feedback in writing and is not currently scheduled to appear at the hearings. Still, Bidois is welcoming the chance for reflection. "It's such a critical opportunity to ensure that we learn lessons from that pandemic response so that we can be better prepared, better informed for anything that may come about in the future," she said. Phase one was originally announced in 2022 by then-Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern; it aimed to examine the lessons learned and help the country better prepare for future pandemics. The second phase was borne from National's coalition agreements with both ACT and NZ First. It will cover vaccine approval, safety, monitoring, and mandates; the imposition and maintenance of national and regional lockdowns; The procurement, development, and distribution of testing and tracing technologies and non-pharmaceutical public health material. Inquiry chair Grant Illingworth said this process was not about placing blame, but instead about learning. "We are instructed in our terms of reference to avoid legalistic and adversarial processes. We are instructed to try to achieve the purpose of the inquiry, which is not to judge people or to hold them up to public scorn." In 2022 hundreds of cars and a few thousand people descended on central Wellington and Parliament to protest against the Government's Covid-19 vaccine mandates. Photo: VNP / Phil Smith Covid-19 lockdowns and vaccines have been the subject of misinformation and controversy in the last few years. Illingworth explained that the hearings will be live-streamed on the Royal Commission's website, improving accessibility and transparency. "Obviously we are not in a position to wave a magic wand and ensure that New Zealand is united over this whole issue. But it is, of course, important for us to try to help New Zealand to come together so that we do have an united ability to stand up to any crises in the future." Part two of the public hearings will take place at the end of August in Wellington and will hear from those who were key decision makers during the pandemic. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
5 hours ago
- RNZ News
Long Covid voices 'excluded' from inquiry hearings
Photo: People with Long Covid are disappointed their voices will not be prioritised as part of public hearings about the government's pandemic response. Phase two of the Royal Commission of Inquiry into the official response to Covid-19 gets underway in Auckland today, and will run until Thursday. It will hear from everyday people and their experiences of the government's decisions over vaccine use and lockdowns, including the extended lockdowns in Auckland and Northland. It will also hear from businesses and organisations affected. Long Covid Support Aotearoa spokesperson Catherine Appleby said she felt in choosing its focus, the inuiry had missed an opportunity to include the perspectives of people with post-Covid conditions. "A massive mistake really, to do that, because we were directly affected and our lives are still particularly affected as well." Appleby worked as a nurse at an urgent care centre when Covid-19 hit in 2020. Each day, after her shift, she would have to strip down her clothes on her doorstep, in the hope she wouldn't transmit Covid to her whānau. It's something many other healthcare practitioners did. In 2022, she caught Covid-19 herself. She returned to work thinking she was recovered, but the symptoms didn't go away. She reduced her hours of work in the hope it would improve things, but it didn't. "Finally, I just had to decide, and at that stage, I was over two and a half years into Long Covid, and I thought, "I'm looking down the barrel of non-recovery. If I want to have any chance of recovery, I just have to stop working completely." Auckland spent more than 100 days in lockdown starting in August 2021. Photo: 123RF Appleby explained that there are significant impacts on people with Long Covid. It often affects their ability to work, leading to loss of income, lack of financial and health system support, and impacts on social and family life, she said. She said thousands of people experience Long Covid across Aotearoa, all the more reason to include their voices in the hearings this week. "Covid is still around, and the Long Covid numbers are likely to increase. Even if you are immunized, the estimate is up to 10% of people who catch the infection will get Long Covid." Long Covid Support Aotearoa has called for an inquiry into the condition, much like the one held across the ditch in Australia between 2022 and 2023. A new Otago-led study, published in the International Journal of Paediatrics and Child Health, found that more than 20 per cent of children and young people in Aotearoa are experiencing significant, persistent health symptoms following Covid-19. Lead Author and Associate Professor from the University of Otago's Department of Public Health, Julie Bennett, said her team conducted interviews with nearly 4300 children (or their parents for those under 16) to understand their experiences and symptoms after Covid-19 infection. The symptoms included things like headaches, fatigue, coughs, and anxiety, which they didn't have before having Covid, she said. "They were also reporting that they were unable to attend school because of having these symptoms, or they were unable to attend things like going to sporting events or activities that they normally would be able to do. These symptoms weren't just happening; they were actually limiting their ability to be able to participate in life." Regarding New Zealand's response, Professor Bennett said having a proper pandemic plan in place is key. "We did manage to get together really quickly, a good group of people to be able to make decisions, and making really hard decisions, on the spur of the moment, often with little information, but trying to do it as evidence-based as they could." Instead of focusing on Long Covid, the hearings this week will cover Government decisions relating to lockdowns, vaccine mandates, and vaccine safety, and how these key decisions affected things like social division and isolation, health and education, and business activity. Hearings this week are part of phase two of the Royal Commission's Inquiry. Photo: Restaurant Association chief executive Marisa Bidois has been an outspoken voice on the economic toll that successive lockdowns have had on the hospitality industry, especially in Auckland. She said the restrictions saw multiple businesses close as a result, a hard hit on her industry. "If there were some different decisions made around the lockdowns, the restrictions in trading, we would still see some of those businesses operating today, no doubt." At the time, she was an outspoken voice, consistently advocating for change and raising suggestions on how businesses could survive while also balancing public health goals. She said that while the government's intention might have been to protect public health, the reality felt like a one-size-fits-all approach. "We did a significant amount of work around the ways to make, like contactless deliveries available at, say, alert level three. Feedback like this, at the time, was ignored, whereas if that would have been taken on board, businesses could have been operating sooner." Marisa Bidois said the last couple of years have been particularly tough on the hospotality industry. Photo: Supplied The Restaurant Association submitted its feedback in writing and is not currently scheduled to appear at the hearings. Still, Bidois is welcoming the chance for reflection. "It's such a critical opportunity to ensure that we learn lessons from that pandemic response so that we can be better prepared, better informed for anything that may come about in the future," she said. Phase one was originally announced in 2022 by then-Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern; it aimed to examine the lessons learned and help the country better prepare for future pandemics. The second phase was borne from National's coalition agreements with both ACT and NZ First. It will cover vaccine approval, safety, monitoring, and mandates; the imposition and maintenance of national and regional lockdowns; The procurement, development, and distribution of testing and tracing technologies and non-pharmaceutical public health material. Inquiry chair Grant Illingworth said this process was not about placing blame, but instead about learning. "We are instructed in our terms of reference to avoid legalistic and adversarial processes. We are instructed to try to achieve the purpose of the inquiry, which is not to judge people or to hold them up to public scorn." In 2022 hundreds of cars and a few thousand people descended on central Wellington and Parliament to protest against the Government's Covid-19 vaccine mandates. Photo: VNP / Phil Smith Covid-19 lockdowns and vaccines have been the subject of misinformation and controversy in the last few years. Illingworth explained that the hearings will be live-streamed on the Royal Commission's website, improving accessibility and transparency. "Obviously we are not in a position to wave a magic wand and ensure that New Zealand is united over this whole issue. But it is, of course, important for us to try to help New Zealand to come together so that we do have an united ability to stand up to any crises in the future." Part two of the public hearings will take place at the end of August in Wellington and will hear from those who were key decision makers during the pandemic. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
