The double-whammy bill natural gas users have to pay
The four-year contingency fund to subsidise new fossil fuel fields was announced by Resources Minister Shane Jones at last month's Budget.
Just weeks later, the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment revealed that our natural gas supply is running out faster than previously thought, with latest data showing reserves have fallen 27 percent from last year.
But any new developments will take years, and gas households already face surging costs, says Paul Fuge, manager of Consumer New Zealand's Powerswitch.
Residential consumers make up only 4 percent of the country's total gas use and Fuge says it won't be running out in the near future. But that is no consolation for gas customers who are being hit in the pocket twice.
'It costs more to have gas than electricity so an electricity-only house is much cheaper to run than a gas-electricity house because you can substitute all your gas appliances for electric appliances … but you can't run a TV on gas or your lights on gas,' says Fuge.
That means gas customers have to have an electricity connection, which means double the costs of the infrastructure – gas pipes and electricity lines – needed to deliver the energy to people's homes.
Gas customers are also locked out of cheaper electricity plans because most gas suppliers also demand that customers take their electricity. The companies that provide cheap electricity don't provide gas, Fuge says.
Add to that the phasing out of low electricity charges for low users, which was a benefit for gas customers.
'What that means is people's electricity connections for the low users are getting more expensive every year over five years and that disadvantages gas customers,' he says.
Customers who are renters are stuck with gas, as are people on low incomes because they can't afford to switch, Fuge says.
He explains to The Detail why he thinks thousands of new households have connected to gas in recent years, despite rising prices.
'I wonder if it's when people are building new houses, developers may be putting in gas for various reasons.'
The Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment does not have specific figures for new connections but based on rising residential use, Fuge calculates that the number of household connections has increased by around 18,000 since 2019, to 290,000.
Residential customers make up the smallest proportion of gas use. According to industry group GasNZ more than half a million New Zealand homes and businesses rely on gas and Liquified Petroleum Gas (LPG).
There are 300 large industrial gas customers, from methanol exporter Methanex to dairy plants and wood processors.
Newsroom senior political reporter Marc Daalder says the large industrial users are more imperilled by the declining gas supply, as well as the electricity generators that rely on gas.
He says the coalition's plans to repeal a ban on new oil and gas exploration will not solve our dwindling gas supplies any time soon.
'The fastest we've had from a conversion from finding that gas to producing that gas is 10 years and it's hard to say in 2035 we know exactly what our gas needs are going to look like.
'The reality is they're probably going to be a lot lower because we're going to be electrifying everything and some of the industries that we've got that rely on gas are going to be electrifying or closing down.'
The other option is finding more gas in the existing fields which has been going on consistently and continually for many years, including since the exploration ban was put into place.
'About a billion dollars has been spent trying to find extra gas in those existing fields and there have been a few minor successes but nothing major.'
However, two fields are showing potential new gas finds, which the $200-million government co-investment fund could boost.
'Shane Jones would really like for the Government to be able to completely revitalise the gas industry and send people out looking for brand new gas in brand new places. The reality is we haven't found any gas in a brand new place for two decades or longer,' says Daalder.
'It's not like the Gulf of Mexico where there is all this gas sitting there. The resource probably isn't that strong; $200 million isn't going to suddenly make it commercial to take that big of a gamble.'
Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail here.
You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
12 hours ago
- RNZ News
Australia could be about to leapfrog NZ on climate targets
Resources Minister Shane Jones. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii A conservative Australian politician turned climate leader has told New Zealand ministers it is in their interests to do more on climate change. Australian climate change authority chair Matt Kean - a former top minister for the New South Wales Liberal Party - met with Resources Minister Shane Jones and Energy and Climate Change Minister Simon Watts while he was in New Zealand to attend the Green Property Summit. "My message to them was we want to encourage them, we want to support them and we want to share ideas about how we could lower cost of living pressure for New Zealand households and business, how we could create new jobs and opportunities for New Zealand at the same time as reducing emissions," he said. "My message to conservatives both in Australia and abroad is when it comes to taking action on climate change, if you do it in an economically rational way there is also a political dividend to be gained." Australia could be about to leapfrog New Zealand on the ambition of its climate targets, as it bids to win the right to host the COP31 global climate summit in 2026 . New Zealand's international climate target for 2030 - cutting emissions by 50 percent - is currently ahead of Australia's 43 per cent target, with both countries using 2005 as a base year. But New Zealand has adopted a target for 2035 of cutting planet-heating gases by 51-55 percent, only slightly above its 2030 target, while the Australian climate change authority has consulted on a target of between 65 and 75 per cent. Kean described New Zealand's ambition as "largely static". Australian climate change authority chair Matt Kean. Photo: Supplied / Climate Change Authority He could not divulge where Australia would land on its 2035 target but he said beating New Zealand - and then some - should be achievable and good for Australia. "Obviously Australia wants to do its bit to meet this challenge, but we also think it's in our economic interests to grab the capital that is available internationally to build the industries and opportunities that Australia wants to realise for the future," Kean said. "Our national interests as a country on the front line of the impacts climate change are to be part of a global effort to reduce emissions, but it's also in our national interests to build industries, attract investments and create jobs as a result of this global economic transition." He said the same applied to New Zealand, and he hoped to see more competition between the countries on climate action. "There's always been a healthy and friendly rivalry between our two countries on the sporting field and hopefully that expands to meeting climate challenges." Kean said he was grateful for the chance to meet Jones and other government ministers and MPs. He was supportive of a proposal for government subsidies for New Zealand homeowners to replace their gas and inefficient heaters with heat pumps, which the Green Building Council said would save the country $1.5 billion a year . Australia had its own challenges with gas availability, but unlike New Zealand it had subsidies for alternatives such as residential solar panels, electric storage batteries and hot water heat pumps. Building Council chief executive Andrew Eagles told Morning Report that although New Zealand households were making progress in the adoption of heat pumps and decreasing purchases of gas hot water systems, commercial and residential natural gas/LPG consumption was still climbing - leaving some gas-reliant businesses facing closure. "It's a huge talking point in Australia as well, we've got more gas than pretty much anywhere else on Earth but because it's all contracted offshore there's a shortage of gas for Australian businesses and families and that's putting enormous pressure on household bills," said Kean. "We were trying to share some of our learnings from our time in government and how we addressed it and also to hear where the New Zealand government was coming from as well." He said governments had a role to play in the energy market. "In Australia, my preference was always for less government intervention but we had to look at what government not being involved could look like, and certainly in the energy transition the private sector wouldn't always take on the risk that was required," he said. "The government putting the policies in place that facilitated the private sector meant savings for business, savings for households and a better outcome." RNZ has approached Jones' office for comment. Australia has overtaken New Zealand for EV sales on the back of more supportive government policy and has long been ahead on rooftop solar with almost a third of households having solar panels. However its electricity sector as a whole still burns much more coal and gas than New Zealand's. Australia's international climate targets do not cover its fossil fuel exports, because the coal and gas it produces for export are burned elsewhere. That's in contrast to New Zealand's export dairy sector, which produces most of its emissions inside New Zealand. (However international flights for tourism are excluded from New Zealand's targets). As one of the world's biggest coal and gas exporters, Australia's fossil fuel exports produce around three times as much climate-heating gases as activities within Australia, according to one study . A landmark opinion from the International Court of Justice has declared major fossil fuel producers could be liable for reparations to countries damaged by climate change. Kean said Australia needed to be ready to replace its fossil fuel exports. "The reality is the fossil fuels we are exporting are not going to be at the same level of demand as is currently the case, so we need to prepare for this transition and start to build other exports that can continue to grow Australia's GDP," he said. He said Australia had "periodic table" of elements in its ground to draw on. "We recognise that China, Korea, Japan, some of our big takers of Australia's fossil fuel, are changing the things they want to use to power their economies and the reality is we're really well placed to meet their new needs, because of our abundant renewable energy resources." Kean said his message of saving money and energy while cutting emissions received a good reception from Jones, a minister who has previously described climate concern as "hysteria" . Kean was a member of the conservative Liberal Party and former New South Wales Treasurer and Energy minister before chairing the climate change authority. He said his message to conservatives in Australia and New Zealand was that there were political dividends to be gained from progressive action on climate change. "In the state of New South Wales where I hail from, the forward-thinking climate policies that the conservative government put in place have now been adopted by the progressive government, so the policies are surviving political cycles, and what we have been seeing at a national level is the party that advocated for stronger action on climate change get a huge and thumping majority, whereas the conservative party that looked to backslide when it came to climate action lost a whole lot of seats in their traditional heartland to climate friendly independents." The climate authority's final recommendation on Australia's 2035 target is due to be provided to Australian Climate and Energy Minister Chris Bowen within the next month. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Otago Daily Times
a day ago
- Otago Daily Times
Are students being priced out of Dunedin?
Dunedin students believe they are getting a raw deal as rents continue to climb, and housing conditions fail to meet their basic needs. Recent data shows rent costs in Dunedin have climbed by almost 9% since May last year, compared to a national drop of 2.7%, and Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment this year found multiple landlords breaching healthy homes legislation in the student quarter. The Otago Daily Times visited flats around the University of Otago yesterday and found students were having to make sacrifices if they wanted to live close to the campus. Second-year genetics student Jupiter Gordon, of Dunedin, said she was paying $214 a week for her flat and it was "ridiculous". While the heating situation at her house was legal, it was not warm, she said. The lights flickered all the time, and they were never fixed. Her student allowance covered her rent, but it was a stretch buying groceries and paying for power. She often got produce from her grandparents to avoid spending more money on food. There were not many flats available for under $200 per room next year and she was considering moving home to live with her parents. Third-year Bachelor of Arts and Commerce student Harriet Sinclair, of Arrowtown, said she was paying $180 for her room in a student rental with five flatmates. She was happy with her flat for this year, but finding a four-person flat for next year was a bit of a struggle. A flat she viewed yesterday looked good in the photos, but at the viewing she found cracks in the ceiling. Second-year Bachelor of Commerce students Xanthea Greaves and Emily Jones paid $200 and $220 respectively per week for their flats, but they did not mind because they were good warm flats. Miss Jones said she was paying a similar rate to what her friends in Christchurch were paying and felt she had a fair deal. She knew the housing was not great in Dunedin when she moved to the city, but it was worth it because of the "student experience". Dunedin tenant Zoe Eckhoff, who shared her horror flatting experience with the ODT last month, said there was a big power imbalance between tenants and landlords. "There's a feeling you have to audition for your landlord rather than the other way around." The housing situation in Dunedin just did not work. The quality of the properties was not up to scratch for students who did not want to engage in the party culture. Students were vulnerable because they had no idea what they were supposed to be looking for when signing a tenancy agreement, she said. Otago University Students' Association president Liam White said students were paying too much for flats that did not meet their basic needs. Students were feeling the pinch with expensive rental prices, and he believed it was now a factor that was significantly affecting people's choices to study in Dunedin, on top of the general costs of living being so high. The OUSA was handing out a record number of food bags every month, he said. "It is really simple that it is becoming far too expensive to be a student." 'Sometimes you can't even focus on your schoolwork' Second-year computer science student Ambrosia Hardie and second-year law student Karis O'Brien, both from Auckland, do not feel they are getting good value for the money they pay for their North East Valley flat. The University of Otago students pay $175 and $195 respectively per week for their rental. "Our house is absolutely freezing and we get no sun," Miss Hardie said. They had to open windows and doors to get warm air to flow through their flat because it was colder inside than outside. The cold had an impact on her mental health because it made it harder to get out of bed in the morning and do things, she said "It makes life a bit more depressing, I'd say. "Sometimes you can't even focus on your schoolwork," Miss Hardie said. For next year the pair were looking for flats with double-glazed windows that met healthy standards, but they were a lot more expensive. They had found a suitable contender, but it was $300 each per week to rent. Her family were worried for her and her father had tried convincing her to move back to Auckland to live in cheaper accommodation that was not so cold or making her sick, Miss Hardie said. The pair both worked on weekends to make ends meet, but also because their workplaces were warmer than their flat, she said. "It is painful. Like, you've got no extra money."
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Flat conditions leave some unimpressed
Dunedin students believe they are getting a raw deal as rents continue to climb, and housing conditions fail to meet their basic needs. Recent data shows rent costs in Dunedin have climbed by almost 9% since May last year, compared to a national drop of 2.7%, and Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment this year found multiple landlords breaching healthy homes legislation in the student quarter. The Otago Daily Times visited flats around the University of Otago yesterday and found students were having to make sacrifices if they wanted to live close to the campus. Second-year genetics student Jupiter Gordon, of Dunedin, said she was paying $214 a week for her flat and it was "ridiculous". While the heating situation at her house was legal, it was not warm, she said. The lights flickered all the time, and they were never fixed. Her student allowance covered her rent, but it was a stretch buying groceries and paying for power. She often got produce from her grandparents to avoid spending more money on food. There were not many flats available for under $200 per room next year and she was considering moving home to live with her parents. Third-year Bachelor of Arts and Commerce student Harriet Sinclair, of Arrowtown, said she was paying $180 for her room in a student rental with five flatmates. She was happy with her flat for this year, but finding a four-person flat for next year was a bit of a struggle. A flat she viewed yesterday looked good in the photos, but at the viewing she found cracks in the ceiling. Second-year Bachelor of Commerce students Xanthea Greaves and Emily Jones paid $200 and $220 respectively per week for their flats, but they did not mind because they were good warm flats. Miss Jones said she was paying a similar rate to what her friends in Christchurch were paying and felt she had a fair deal. She knew the housing was not great in Dunedin when she moved to the city, but it was worth it because of the "student experience". Dunedin tenant Zoe Eckhoff, who shared her horror flatting experience with the ODT last month, said there was a big power imbalance between tenants and landlords. "There's a feeling you have to audition for your landlord rather than the other way around." The housing situation in Dunedin just did not work. The quality of the properties was not up to scratch for students who did not want to engage in the party culture. Students were vulnerable because they had no idea what they were supposed to be looking for when signing a tenancy agreement, she said. Otago University Students' Association president Liam White said students were paying too much for flats that did not meet their basic needs. Students were feeling the pinch with expensive rental prices, and he believed it was now a factor that was significantly affecting people's choices to study in Dunedin, on top of the general costs of living being so high. The OUSA was handing out a record number of food bags every month, he said. "It is really simple that it is becoming far too expensive to be a student."
