Zillow sued by Homes.com owner CoStar for 'massive' copyright violations
The complaint filed in Manhattan federal court seeks unspecified compensatory and punitive damages, which Arlington, Virginia-based CoStar estimated could exceed $1 billion.
CoStar, whose real estate listing websites also include Apartments.com and LoopNet.com, accused Seattle-based Zillow of exploiting the photos, many of which contain watermarks, to boost its rental listings business.
Zillow did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
According to the complaint, Zillow uses CoStar's photos to induce property managers and landlords to "claim" properties that are not actively listed for rent, and then sells advertising packages and tools to generate revenue.
CoStar said Zillow also distributes some photos under syndication agreements to rival portals Realtor.com and Redfin, owned respectively by News Corp and Rocket Cos.
Zillow's "free-riding" on the photos results in infringement "on a massive scale, however measured," CoStar said.
CoStar said it provides limited licenses of its photos to real estate professionals and does not allow sublicensing.
In 2019, CoStar obtained a $500 million judgment against the bankruptcy estate of real estate listing platform Xceligent over the publication of 38,489 copyrighted photos, court records show. Xceligent had filed to liquidate two years earlier.
CoStar threatened to sue Realtor.com and Redfin if they do not remove its copyrighted photos.
In June, Compass, the largest U.S. residential real estate brokerage by sales volume, sued Zillow for allegedly trying to monopolize private home listings, violating federal antitrust law. Zillow has called Compass' claims unfounded.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
6 hours ago
- CNA
US trade advisor says Trump tariff rates unlikely to change
WASHINGTON: New US tariff rates are "pretty much set" with little immediate room for negotiation, US President Donald Trump's trade advisor said in remarks aired Sunday (Aug 3), also defending the president's politically driven levies against Brazil. Trump, who has wielded tariffs as a tool of American economic might, has set tariff rates for dozens of economies, including the European Union, at between 10 and 41 per cent, come August 7, his new hard deadline for the duties. In a pre-taped interview broadcast Sunday on CBS's "Face the Nation," US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer said "the coming days" are not likely to see changes in the tariff rates. "A lot of these are set rates pursuant to deals. Some of these deals are announced, some are not, others depend on the level of the trade deficit or surplus we may have with the country," Greer said. "These tariff rates are pretty much set." Undoubtedly, some trade ministers "want to talk more and see how they can work in a different way with the United States," he added. But "we're seeing truly the contours of the president's tariff plan right now with these rates." The US had announced hiked tariff rates on dozens of trade partners, which will kick in on August 7 instead of August 1, which had previously been touted as a hard deadline. Among the countries facing steep new levies is Brazil. South America's largest economy is being hit with 50 per cent tariffs on exports to the United States -- albeit with significant exemptions for key products such as aircraft and orange juice. Trump has openly admitted he is punishing Brazil for prosecuting his political ally Jair Bolsonaro, the ex-president accused of plotting a coup in a bid to cling to power. The US president has described the case as a "witch hunt." Greer said it was not unusual for Trump to use tariff tools for geopolitical purposes. "The president has seen in Brazil, like he's seen in other countries, a misuse of law, a misuse of democracy," Greer told CBS. "It is normal to use these tools for geopolitical issues." Trump was "elected to assess the foreign affairs situation... and take appropriate action," he added. Meanwhile, White House economic advisor Kevin Hassett said that while talks are expected to continue over the next week with some US trade partners, he concurred with Greer's tariffs assessment in that the bulk of the rates "are more or less locked in." Asked by the host of NBC's Sunday talk show "Meet the Press with Kristen Welker" if Trump could change tariff rates, should financial markets react negatively, Hassett said: "I would rule it out, because these are the final deals." Legal challenges have been filed against some of Trump's tariffs, arguing he overstepped his authority. An appeals court panel on Thursday appeared sceptical of the government's arguments, though the case may be ultimately decided at the Supreme Court.
CNA
2 days ago
- CNA
Meta to share AI infrastructure costs via $2 billion asset sale
Meta Platforms is pressing ahead with efforts to bring in outside partners to help fund the massive infrastructure needed to power artificial intelligence, disclosing plans in a filing on Thursday to offload $2 billion in data center assets as part of that strategy. The strategy reflects a broader shift among tech giants — long known for self-funding growth — as they grapple with the soaring cost of building and powering data centers to support generative AI. The social media giant said earlier this week that it was exploring ways to work with financial partners to co-develop data centers to help finance its massive capital outlay for next year. 'We're exploring ways to work with financial partners to co-develop data centers,' Meta Chief Finance Officer Susan Li said on a post-earnings conference call on Wednesday. While the company still expects to fund much of its capital spending internally, some projects could attract 'significant external financing' and offer more flexibility if infrastructure needs shift over time, Li said. The company did not have any finalized transactions to announce, she said. The disclosure in Meta's quarterly filing, however, signals that plans are firming up. In its quarterly filing on Thursday, Meta said it had approved a plan in June to dispose of certain data center assets and reclassified $2.04 billion worth of land and construction-in-progress as "held-for-sale". These assets were expected to be contributed to a third party within the next twelve months for co-developing data centers. Meta did not record a loss on the reclassification, which values the assets at the lower of their carrying amounts or fair value less costs to sell. As of June 30, total held-for-sale assets stood at $3.26 billion, according to the filing. Meta declined to comment for this story. CEO Mark Zuckerberg has laid out plans to invest hundreds of billions of dollars into constructing AI data center 'superclusters' for superintelligence. 'Just one of these covers a significant part of the footprint of Manhattan,' he said. The Instagram and WhatsApp owner on Wednesday raised the bottom end of its annual capital expenditures forecast by $2 billion, to $66 billion to $72 billion.
CNA
2 days ago
- CNA
Kugler Resigns From Fed, Opening Door to Trump Appointment
WASHINGTON: Federal Reserve Governor Adriana Kugler will step down from her post on Aug 8, the US central bank said Friday (Aug 1), creating a vacancy that could allow President Donald Trump to begin reshaping the Fed's leadership amid tensions over interest rate policy. Kugler, who joined the Fed in September 2023, was originally set to serve until January 2026. The central bank said she will return to Georgetown University as a professor next autumn. Kugler did not attend this week's Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) meeting, a move Fed watchers described as unusual. The central bank did not provide further comment on her early exit. Her resignation comes as Fed Chair Jerome Powell's term nears its May 2026 end. Trump, who has long criticized Powell and the Fed for maintaining high interest rates, has threatened to remove Powell and could use Kugler's vacancy to elevate a preferred candidate. Trump will now nominate a new governor to serve the remainder of Kugler's term. The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment on who might be chosen. In a resignation letter to Trump, Kugler said: 'I am proud to have tackled this role with integrity, a strong commitment to serving the public, and with a data-driven approach strongly based on my expertise in labor markets and inflation.' Kugler's tenure was marked by the Fed's efforts to bring inflation under control through aggressive rate hikes. While inflation has recently moved closer to the Fed's 2% target, the central bank's high rates have become a source of political friction. At its latest meeting this week, the Fed left interest rates unchanged at 4.25% to 4.5%, opting to observe the economic effects of Trump's sweeping tariff increases before adjusting policy. Two FOMC members dissented, urging an immediate rate cut due to rising risks to the labor market and the belief that tariff-driven inflation would be temporary.
