Judge grants release of ex-49ers Dana Stubblefield
A judge granted the release of former 49er Dana Stubblefield from prison.
His release comes after an appeals court overturned his rape conviction in December.
The appeals court overturned the conviction after determining that prosecutors made racially discriminatory statements during his trial.
SAN JOSE, Calif. - Former 49ers star Dana Stubblefield will be freed from prison after an appeals court granted his petition for release.
What they're saying
"Finally, an innocent man is no longer sitting in a cage away from his family," said his attorney, Kenneth Rosenfeld. "The Court of Appeals issued a forceful, unanimous ruling proving bias in Dana's case. And their ruling was only the tip of the iceberg – the entire trial was infected with error and bias from the start."
Stubblefield's 2020 rape conviction was overturned by the Sixth District Court of Appeal in December after determining prosecutors made racially discriminatory statements during his trial.
He remained in custody until a hearing Friday morning, where his attorney asked a judge to approve a motion for his release, which was granted. He is expected to be released by Saturday.
Prosecutors could have asked the court to stay their decision so they could appeal to the state Supreme Court or refile the charges.
The backstory
The retired football player was sentenced to 15 years to life for the rape of a woman in 2015, whom prosecutors said he lured to his home with the promise of a babysitting job.
The woman reported to police that Stubblefield raped her at gunpoint, then gave her $80 and let her go. DNA evidence matched that of Stubblefield, according to a report from the Morgan Hill Police Department.
The appeals court found that prosecutors violated the California Racial Justice Act of 2020, a law passed during a summer of protest over the police killing of George Floyd. The measure bars prosecutors from seeking a criminal conviction or imposing a sentence on the basis of race.
Prior to the law, defendants who wanted to challenge their convictions on the basis of racial bias had to prove there was "purposeful discrimination," a difficult legal standard to meet.
The appeals court said prosecutors used "racially discriminatory language" that required them to overturn Stubblefield's conviction.
During the trial, prosecutors said Morgan Hill police never searched Stubblefield's house and never introduced a gun into evidence, saying it was because he was a famous Black man and it would "open up a storm of controversy," according to the appellate decision.
By saying Stubblefield's race was a factor in law enforcement's decision not to search his house, prosecutors implied the house would've been searched and a gun found had Stubblefield not been Black, the appeals court said.
Defense attorneys said there was no rape, and Stubblefield said the woman consented to sex in exchange for money.
The Source
The Law Offices of Allen Sawyer.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
19 minutes ago
- Yahoo
What to know about Maryvale High School, where stabbing left student dead
On Aug. 19, a student at Maryvale High School died after a stabbing in a classroom. Phoenix officers responded to the west Phoenix school at about 10:54 a.m. after receiving a call about a stabbing and found a boy with multiple stab wounds, court documents said. The boy was taken to St. Joseph's Hospital, where he was pronounced dead at noon, court documents said. He was identified by police as Michael Montoya II, 16. Chris Aguilar, 16, has been charged with second-degree murder, according to court documents. A girl told police she saw Aguilar pull out a pocketknife before stabbing Montoya three times, according to court records. Another person saw Aguilar drop the knife outside the classroom, the records said. A school security guard collected a four-inch folding knife that had Aguilar's name etched on the handle and placed it in the principal's office, court records said. Teens at the school told police that Montoya had robbed Aguilar of a firearm, with one saying that Aguilar and his twin brother talked about killing Montoya after the alleged robbery, according to court records. Here's what to know about Maryvale High School, which is part of the Phoenix Union High School District. Where is Maryvale High School? Maryvale High School is located at 3415 N. 59th Ave. in west Phoenix. It is at the corner of North 59th Avenue and West Osborn Road. How many students attend Maryvale High School? Maryvale High School has a student body of roughly 2,700 students. Over 90% of Maryvale High School's student body is Hispanic, a slightly larger share than the 81% Hispanic student makeup of the district overall, according to state data. Black students are the second largest demographic at Maryvale High School, at 4%. The school's attendance boundaries encompass a portion of west Phoenix. The boundaries are not a perfect square but run from 43rd Avenue on the east to 63rd Avenue on the west, and from Camelback Road on the north to McDowell Road on the south. Phoenix Union High School District has a student population of over 26,700 students, making it one of the largest school districts in metro Phoenix. The district has 24 schools, 3,500 employees and covers 220 square miles of Phoenix, according to the district's website. How does Maryvale High School perform academically? Maryvale High School is a B-rated school, according to the state's school report card. Fifteen percent of its student body is proficient in English Language Arts compared to the state's 40% and the district's 18%, according to state assessment data. Eight percent of the Maryvale High School student body is proficient in math compared to the state's 32% and the district's 13% according to test scores. What security measures does Maryvale High School have in place? Phoenix Union installed advanced weapons detection systems on all of its campuses earlier this year, according to the district's website. Maryvale High School was one of two schools to pilot that program beginning in November 2023. The district found success in deterring weapons on campus during its testing in Maryvale High School, according to a report from the district. After protests in 2020, Phoenix Union decided to end its contract with Phoenix police for on-campus officers. The district then reversed that decision in 2023 and brought officers back to campuses. Maryvale High School had an officer on campus on Aug. 19, according to court records, police and the district. In a document submitted by the district for a grant application to the Arizona Department of Education to place police officers in Phoenix Union campuses, the district stated that weapons such as knives and guns were rising in prevalence. Are Maryvale High School students in class this week? In-person classes at Maryvale High School were canceled for the rest of the week. Perry Vandell contributed reporting. Coverage of education solutions on and in The Arizona Republic is partially supported by a grant from the Arizona Local News Foundation's Arizona Community Collaborative Fund. This article originally appeared on Arizona Republic: What to know about Maryvale High School, where stabbing left teen dead
Yahoo
19 minutes ago
- Yahoo
New York court throws out $527 million penalty in Trump civil fraud case
A panel of justices on a New York appellate court threw out the half-billion-dollar penalty in the civil fraud case against President Trump and others on Thursday, ruling that the fine was "excessive" while saying they were divided on the merits of the case. One of the justices on the Appellate Division, First Judicial Department wrote that the penalty, known as a disgorgement, against Mr. Trump, two of his sons and other executives and their company was "an excessive fine barred by the Eighth Amendment." In February 2024, a New York judge ordered Mr. Trump and his codefendants to pay the state nearly $364 million in "ill-gotten gains" and millions more in interest dating back years, a total that has since ballooned to about $527 million. Judge Arthur Engoron's judgment left Mr. Trump on the hook for nearly 98% of the total. New York Attorney General Letitia James said in a statement Thursday that her office will appeal the decision to the Court of Appeals, the state's highest court. Her statement lauded one aspect of the ruling, which left in place sanctions barring Mr. Trump from serving as an officer or director of any corporation or other legal entity in the state for three years. His sons, Eric Trump and Donald Trump Jr., were banned for two years. "The court upheld the injunctive relief we won, limiting Donald Trump and the Trump Organization officers' ability to do business in New York. It should not be lost to history: yet another court has ruled that the president violated the law, and that our case has merit," James said. Mr. Trump hailed the decision in a post on Truth Social, claiming "TOTAL VICTORY," despite the limited nature of the ruling. "I greatly respect the fact that the Court had the Courage to throw out this unlawful and disgraceful Decision that was hurting Business all throughout New York State," Mr. Trump wrote. James first brought the case in 2022, alleging Mr. Trump oversaw a scheme to deliberately mislead companies he was in business with about the values of properties and Mr. Trump's overall net worth. Mr. Trump's lawyers have long argued that the civil case was driven by politics. But Engoron disagreed, ruling in February 2024 that Trump and his codefendants had misrepresented his wealth and inflated the valuations of his properties by hundreds of millions of dollars over the course of a decade. The state said the scheme was intended to trick banks and insurers into offering more favorable deal terms. The president appealed the judgment, and the five-justice appellate panel heard arguments in September 2024. At least two of the justices seemed skeptical of the size of the judgment. One called it "immense" and "troubling." Mr. Trump was represented during the September proceeding by D. John Sauer, who is now the solicitor general. The court's ruling In a complex 323-page series of opinions on Thursday, the justices wrote that they were deeply divided, with two saying a new trial should be ordered and one writing that the case should be tossed altogether. A majority of four justices settled on an alternate path: vacating the massive financial penalty without resolving the merits of the case. The penalty, as one wrote, "was far from a reasonable approximation" of the amount that was warranted. Justice David Friedman, who dissented from the majority, noted that two of the four justices who voted to vacate the penalty "do not actually agree with the resolution of the appeal for which they are voting." "I find it remarkable that, although a three-justice majority of this five-justice panel believe that the judgment in favor of the Attorney General should not stand … the result of the appeal is the affirmance of the judgment, albeit as modified to eliminate the disgorgement award," Friedman wrote. "To draw a sports analogy, it is as if a team is awarded a touchdown without crossing the goal line," he continued. Justices John Higgitt and Llinét Rosado said they would have preferred to order a new trial, but would join the majority "with great reluctance." "Under the truly extraordinary circumstances here, where none of the writings enjoys the support of a majority, we are moved to take this action to permit this panel to arrive at a decision and to permit the parties and the Court to avoid the necessity of reargument," they wrote. "We must therefore agree with Justice Friedman in his observation that a remarkable situation has necessitated a remarkable solution." The appellate court typically issues decisions within a few months of arguments, but the intricacy of the legal issues at hand seems to have delayed a final ruling. Sources on both sides of the dispute expressed surprise to CBS News about the length of the wait for a resolution, as the seasons changed and the court drew closer to a year without word from the court. James' office has defended the punishment, saying it accurately reflected the size of Mr. Trump's profits from fraud. Engoron wrote in his ruling that documents in evidence prove "over and over again" that the defendants falsely inflated Mr. Trump's wealth and reported those fraudulent numbers to business partners. He said Mr. Trump's "complete lack of contrition and remorse borders on pathological," and said his company gave their accountants "blatantly false financial data." Despite overturning the judgment, the appellate panel concluded that Engoron "was even-handed at trial, and allowed both sides to 'make their case.'" Mr. Trump testified during a bench trial in the case, in November 2023, blaming his employees and others while also insisting his books were kept appropriately. Accused of falsely inflating his wealth, Mr. Trump claimed the opposite was true, saying his company "underestimated" the value of his properties. "The numbers you are talking about here is, you know, they are very big numbers, very, very big. Far bigger — the values are far bigger than what is on the financial statement," Mr. Trump said, later adding, "billions of dollars more." Engoron concluded that testimony by Mr. Trump, his sons and other Trump Organization executives was not credible. A majority of the appellate panel agreed with that determination, as well as another related to Mr. Trump's former lawyer and "fixer" Michael Cohen, who testified against Mr. Trump. "We defer to the court's findings that the testimony of President Trump, Donald Trump, Jr., Eric Trump, Jeffrey McConney and Allen Weisselberg were not credible, and that the testimony of Michael Cohen was credible," the court said. Trump responds after New York court tosses $527 million civil fraud penalty What to expect from a potential California redistricting special election Powell addressing Jackson Hole forum as pressure mounts for interest rate cut
CNN
an hour ago
- CNN
Democrats vow to fight back against TX GOP redistricting effort
Democrats vow to fight back against TX GOP redistricting effort Texas Republicans are poised to pass a new congressional map backed by President Donald Trump that will create five more GOP-leaning House districts in time for next year's midterm elections. CNN's Arlette Saenz reports from Austin about how Gov. Gavin Newsom is vowing to fight back. 01:35 - Source: CNN Vertical Politics of the Day 15 videos Democrats vow to fight back against TX GOP redistricting effort Texas Republicans are poised to pass a new congressional map backed by President Donald Trump that will create five more GOP-leaning House districts in time for next year's midterm elections. CNN's Arlette Saenz reports from Austin about how Gov. Gavin Newsom is vowing to fight back. 01:35 - Source: CNN NY appeals court voids nearly $500m penalty against Trump A New York appeals court has thrown out the roughly half-billion dollar judgment against President Donald Trump in the civil fraud case brought by the state's attorney general. CNN's Elie Honig reports. 01:25 - Source: CNN Vance, Miller and Hegseth face loud protests during visit with National Guard Vice President JD Vance, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and White House deputy chief of staff Stephen Miller were met with loud protests while they were chatting with more than a dozen National Guard troops at Union Station in Washington, D.C. 00:41 - Source: CNN 'This is absolutely overreach': Black mayors criticize Trump's troop deployment in DC Savannah Mayor Van Johnson joins other Black mayors criticizing the Trump administration for deploying the National Guard in Washington, DC. 01:27 - Source: CNN Mexican brothers arrested, one tased by federal agents Two brothers from Mexico were arrested by federal agents on Friday in Norwalk, Connecticut. Video shows two officers aggressively tugging Leonel Chavez's arm while he sits inside a car before saying he is under arrest. A second video filmed by a passerby shows Chavez's brother, Ricardo, running away from an agent before getting tased, prompting him to suddenly collapse on the ground. The DHS told CNN in a statement that ICE agents were operating in Norwalk last week, but they did not specify whether it was ICE officers who arrested the Chavez brothers. 01:58 - Source: CNN MAGA merch stocked in room near Oval Office President Donald Trump was seen in a social media video and photo showing off "Trump 2028" hats and a wall stocked with merch to the leaders of foreign countries at the White House. 01:13 - Source: CNN Forty-day Target boycott leader seeks changes of 'substance' CNN Senior National Correspondent Ryan Young speaks to Atlanta-area megachurch pastor Rev. Jamal Bryant, who earlier this year led a boycott of Target stores for the forty-day Christian season of Lent. Bryant says the retailer's reversal of DEI policies is a "stark betrayal" of its Black customers, and simply replacing the CEO is not enough. 03:14 - Source: CNN Assistant attorney general arrested outside Newport restaurant Newport police released bodycam footage of Special Assistant Attorney General Devon Hogan Flanagan and her friend being arrested in Rhode Island. The officers responded to a call from a restaurant regarding an "unwanted party." Flanagan has been charged with willful trespass, and her friend is being charged with disorderly conduct, willful trespass, and resisting arrest. 02:30 - Source: CNN Abby Phillip responds to Jillian Michaels' false claims on slavery CNN's Abby Phillip responds to fitness expert Jillian Michaels' claims that President Donald Trump is not "whitewashing" slavery by attacking exhibits at the Smithsonian museums that he says focus too much on the subject. 02:23 - Source: CNN Trump refers to himself as a 'war hero' when calling Netanyahu one During an interview on 'The Mark Levin Show,' President Donald Trump called Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu a 'war hero' and said he is one too after US strikes on Iranian nuclear sites earlier this year. Former GOP Rep. Adam Kinzinger joins CNN's Erin Burnett to discuss. 01:02 - Source: CNN Will Epstein files becoming public give us any new details? The House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform intends to make public some files it subpoenaed related to the Jeffrey Epstein case, though it will first redact them to shield victims' IDs and other sensitive matters. 01:51 - Source: CNN Texas Democrats return as GOP pushes ahead with redistricting Texas Democrats returned to Austin to cheers and applause after a 15-day protest against the GOP's new congressional maps, which could give the Republicans an additional five US house seats. 01:14 - Source: CNN Why a confirmed date for a Putin-Zelensky meeting is so critical While the White House insists President Donald Trump wants to broker peace between Russia and Ukraine as soon as possible, President Vladimir Putin has not committed to a meeting with President Volodymyr Zelensky. CNN Senior White House Correspondent Kristen Holmes breaks down why setting an exact date is critical. 01:12 - Source: CNN Texas Democrat spends night on House floor Rep. Nicole Collier (D-TX) spent the night on the Texas House floor in protest after refusing a Republican demand to be placed under the watch of the state Department of Public Safety. CNN's Arlette Saenz reports. 01:19 - Source: CNN Russian media reacts positively to Trump-Putin Summit Russian state TV gave a positive coverage of the outcome of the Trump-Putin summit in Alaska, celebrating the handshake between the two leaders. Russian officials also stated that the meeting resulted in progress on sanctions and opened up room for future negotiations. CNN's Fred Pleitgen reports. 01:23 - Source: CNN
