logo
Italians and 'lo spread', an obsession whose time has passed

Italians and 'lo spread', an obsession whose time has passed

The Hindu21-05-2025

A previously unused English word crept into the Italian language during the euro zone debt crisis of 2011 as the country's borrowing costs soared to unsustainable levels.
Ever since then "lo spread", or the gap between the yield on Italian benchmark bonds and their German equivalents, has been brandished by politicians and the media alike as a symbol of national pride or shame, much like a sporting victory or defeat.
After the BTP-Bund gap took a rare dip below one percentage point, or 100 basis points (bps), Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni told parliament last week "this means Italy's government bonds are considered safer than German ones."
Her economy minister, aware the narrower spread in fact meant merely that Italian bonds were considered comparatively less unsafe than before, smiled and shook his head beside her.
Fourteen years ago the attention on the spread was justified. Germany's economy was the European powerhouse and the surge in Italian yields meant Rome had to pay huge sums to service its debt and risked losing market access altogether.
Times have changed, however, and many economists say that with German benchmark bond yields rising due to a planned spending splurge on defence and infrastructure, Italians' fixation with the BTP-Bund spread now makes far less sense.
"What matters for us is the level of interest rates, not the spread with Germany," said economist Tito Boeri, a former head of Italy's state pensions agency. "If German yields rise that doesn't help Italy's public accounts."
Interest burden
Rome spends some 90 billion euros ($101 billion) per year, or 4% of gross domestic product to service its 3 trillion euro public debt. With the yield on 10-year BTPs still above 3.5%, that implies a heavy burden on state coffers regardless of the narrow spread with Germany.
At around 135% of GDP, Italy's debt is proportionally the second-largest in the euro zone after Greece's, and it is forecast by the government to rise through 2026.
Analysts say Meloni's unambitious but relatively prudent economic policies have reassured markets, but the recent narrowing of the spread is mainly down to developments in Germany and the United States.
Economist Lorenzo Bini Smaghi, a former European Central Bank board member, said investors' waning appetite for U.S. Treasuries had benefited European bonds and particularly high-yielding paper such as Italy's.
"If I consider Europe as a safer bet, partly because I expect the dollar to fall, I'm going to invest in European bonds, especially those that offer higher returns," he said.
Italian bond yields are still the highest of any euro zone country, reflecting the risk-premium demanded by investors, and Mr. Boeri warned that market volatility linked to U.S. economic policy meant Rome had no reason for complacency.
Italy's 10-year yield of around 3.6% compares with 3.2% on equivalent Spanish bonds and 3.4% on Greek ones.
"We need to be very, very careful because what is happening on international government bond markets shows us the slightest mistake (in economic policy) can be costly," he said.
Flight to safety
Italy could come unstuck even without a mistake. Spread fluctuations very often reflect "risk-on" or "risk-off" market sentiment driven by international events, not Italian ones.
The BTP-Bund gap widened briefly but sharply, for example, after U.S. President Donald Trump announced swingeing trade tariffs on April 2, only to suspend many of them a week later.
"The spread widens when we see a flight to safety because Italy is not considered 'safety'," said Roberto Perotti, economics professor at Milan's Bocconi university.
A glance at the past shows the BTP-Bund spread has dipped below 100 bps under several Italian governments, sometimes surging shortly afterwards due to factors outside their control.
For much of 2009 the spread hovered between 80 and 100 bps under Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, before widening out to a peak of more than 570 bps in 2011 during the euro zone debt crisis, despite Rome following a broadly stable fiscal policy.
In 2021, under former ECB President Mario Draghi, it again narrowed to less than 100 bps only to widen to 250 the following year amid surging global inflation after the COVID-19 pandemic.
Mr. Perotti said it was understandable that Ms. Meloni should point to the narrow spread as a political success. But with Germany no longer seen as a pillar of fiscal restraint and stability, its value as an indicator had diminished.
"At the moment it doesn't have much meaning," he said.
($1 = 0.8890 euros)
(Reporting by Stefano Bernabei and Gavin Jones; Editing by Hugh Lawson)

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Chinese beauty brands explore foreign M&A to spur growth
Chinese beauty brands explore foreign M&A to spur growth

Time of India

timean hour ago

  • Time of India

Chinese beauty brands explore foreign M&A to spur growth

Some of China's top beauty brands such as Proya and S'Young are exploring acquisitions of smaller foreign rivals to expand their portfolios and replicate the success of global leaders like L'Oreal or Estee Lauder amid slowing growth at home. While still relatively unknown internationally, these Chinese brands have found significant domestic success, even capturing market share from global players. But a prolonged property crisis and concerns about wage growth and employment security have dampened consumer spending in China - posing new challenges to their continued growth. Proya Cosmetics ' founder, Hou Juncheng, said last month that the company's 10-year plan aims to position the firm among the top ten globally, a goal that would require an annual revenue of at least 50 billion yuan ($7 billion). To do so, the Hangzhou-based Proya plans "to acquire some European brands with history and technology", local media reports cited Hou as telling shareholders at a meeting. Proya, which specialises in science-backed skincare at mass market price points, became the first Chinese beauty player to surpass 10 billion yuan in annual revenue in 2024. In comparison, Japan's Shiseido, currently ranked tenth globally, raked in $6.9 billion and market leader L'Oreal generated over $45 billion in revenue last year. S'Young and Ushopal , two prominent Chinese beauty groups, have already made strides in international acquisitions. S'Young owns French skincare brand Evidens de Beaute and U.S.-brand ReVive, while Ushopal added French brand Payot to a portfolio that includes British skincare label ARgENTUM and French fragrance Juliette has a gun. William Lau, a partner at Ushopal, said the company plans to acquire one to two new brands annually. Analysts say buying foreign brands can help Chinese beauty firms diversify revenue streams and reduce reliance on the domestic market, but they also note that some similar efforts by Chinese fashion groups had missed expectations in the past. The beauty and personal care market is projected to generate a revenue of $677.19 billion globally in 2025, versus $41.78 billion in China, German data provider Statista estimates. Chinese brands are likely to target premium-positioned European skincare, fragrance or haircare brands with valuations under $500 million, said Gregoire Grandchamp, co-founder of Next Beauty China, who has advised Chinese groups on global deals. "In coming years, there will be a big Chinese company that will be the Chinese L'Oreal, Estee Lauder, Shiseido, or Amorepacific," Grandchamp predicted. Global M&A 'Very Difficult' Acquisitions have long been a growth strategy for beauty giants. L'Oreal's $2.5 billion purchase of Australian brand Aesop in 2023 added a premium, natural cosmetics brand to its portfolio, while Estee Lauder's $2.8 billion acquisition of Tom Ford in 2022 helped boost its array of high-end perfumes. Chinese beauty brands aim to borrow from this M&A playbook, but there are concerns about their ability to operate brands outside their home turf. In the fashion space, state-owned textile giant Ruyi once made headlines for snapping up foreign brands and touting its ambition to become "China's LVMH" only to see those international deals unwound by creditors in a few short years. But Ushopal's Lau says these challenges are not unique to Chinese groups, citing examples like Shiseido's buyout of Drunk Elephant to L'Oreal's purchase of some Chinese brands that struggled to meet expectations. "Global acquisitions are very difficult" in general and part of the problem is that companies often try to localise brands too quickly after a deal, he said. "One of the reasons you buy a brand is because it's an amazing brand, so if you then redo the entire DNA of the brand, what's the point of buying it?" he added. Mark Tanner, founder and managing director of Shanghai-based marketing and research agency China Skinny, said: "Opening doors to the Chinese market and capital injections, rather than a wholesale management takeover" are more likely to succeed.

Italy's Safilo reaches deal for sale of sun lens maker Lenti to Kering
Italy's Safilo reaches deal for sale of sun lens maker Lenti to Kering

Time of India

timean hour ago

  • Time of India

Italy's Safilo reaches deal for sale of sun lens maker Lenti to Kering

Kering Eyewear has agreed to buy sunglass lens maker Lenti , from Italy's Safilo , the two companies said on Tuesday. European luxury groups are increasingly focusing on their eyewear businesses to boost revenue in face of an more challenging environment and are tightening their grip on production capacity. Gucci-owner Kering started its in-house eyewear division more than ten years ago, and makes glasses for its own labels including Saint Laurent, Balenciaga and Cartier. Safilo had achieved full control of Lenti - based in the northern Italian city of Bergamo - in 2016 in a move aimed at strengthening its offer in the sun lenses business. "This transaction marks a significant step for Safilo Group as it continues to refine its portfolio within the eyewear industry ," Safilo said in a statement. Kering said separately that the deal "is another milestone in the ongoing industrial development strategy, representing an opportunity for the company to establish in-house capabilities for the development of Made in Italy sun lenses." The groups did not disclose financial details of the sale.

India and EU committed to having Free Trade Agreement by end of this year, says Finnish envoy
India and EU committed to having Free Trade Agreement by end of this year, says Finnish envoy

Indian Express

timean hour ago

  • Indian Express

India and EU committed to having Free Trade Agreement by end of this year, says Finnish envoy

Leaders on the Indian side and European side are now committed to the goal of having a Free Trade Agreement (FTA) by the end of this year and there is a good chance that this goal can be achieved, said Finland's Ambassador to India Kimmo Lähdevirta here on Monday. The Finnish Ambassador made these remarks while inaugurating the Finnish embassy's Honorary Consulate in Gujarat at Arvind Limited's Corporate Office in Ahmedabad city's Naroda. Vice president of Arvind Limited, Kulin Lalbhai, who has been appointed as the Honorary Consul of Finland was also present on the occasion. After inaugurating the Honorary Consulate, the Finnish ambassador interacted with media persons. When asked about the recent visit of a delegation of the European Union (EU), prospects of FTA between India and EU and how soon could it be concluded, Lähdevirta said, 'It really was historic. The whole collegium of the EU Commission visited India. It was a historic visit. I think it also created good momentum for the negotiations to go ahead. I think both leaders — on the European and Indian side are now committed to the goal of having an agreement by the end of this year. Of course, it still requires a lot of work. But I do believe that there is a good chance that this goal can be achieved…at the moment, I would say that the momentum and prospects are very good.' In a brief speech after inaugurating the Honorary Consulate, Lähdevirta said, 'Last year Finland and India celebrated 75 years of diplomatic relations, and Finns have been present in India for at least as long as that even longer actually. Many Finnish companies have established their presence here in India, collaborating, manufacturing and innovating for decades with Indian partners, and they are here to stay.' 'The decision to open our Honorary Consulate here is a reflection of the deepening Finnish–Indian partnership, and growing business interest. Finnish companies are contributing to the state's growth and development goals through world-class technologies, sustainable solutions, and investments,' he added. 'In Gujarat, our cooperation has traditionally focused on energy, but today, Finnish companies are engaged across multiple sectors: clean energy, circular economy, skilling, smart infrastructure, and sustainable design. And Gujarat – with its world-class infrastructure, business-friendly environment, and innovation-oriented institutions – offers an ideal environment for these collaborations to flourish,' he further added. According to the Finnish ambassador, there are over 100 companies operating in India and about 10 of them are active in Gujarat. He also said that the overall annual trade between India and Finland is around three billion Euros which includes trade in goods and services. He added that Finland's export to India is more on the goods side and India's export to Finland is more on the services side. He invited the people of Gujarat to 'visit, explore and invest in Finland'. In the context, he also said that Finland is going to organise a roadshow in Helsinki next autumn to let people know about current India as well. He said that Finland wants to attract Indian students and healthcare personnel. Speaking on the occasion, Kulin Lalbhai said, 'With this sort of opportunity and platform… of being a part of a dialogue with a country as exciting as Finland, it personally also projects an opportunity for me to get new exposure and try and contribute to this great relationship. And as Honorary Consul, there will be multiple things that I hope to work on. One of course is to bring Finnish companies and companies here together. It's a complementary economy, skill sets that we can bring together. We have started meeting many companies one on one and we hope to deepen these relationships and bring a lot of positives to both sides of the equation.' In reply to a question, Lalbhai said that there are more than 20,000 Indians who are living in Finland and over 20 Indian companies have established operations there.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store