Italians and 'lo spread', an obsession whose time has passed
A previously unused English word crept into the Italian language during the euro zone debt crisis of 2011 as the country's borrowing costs soared to unsustainable levels.
Ever since then "lo spread", or the gap between the yield on Italian benchmark bonds and their German equivalents, has been brandished by politicians and the media alike as a symbol of national pride or shame, much like a sporting victory or defeat.
After the BTP-Bund gap took a rare dip below one percentage point, or 100 basis points (bps), Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni told parliament last week "this means Italy's government bonds are considered safer than German ones."
Her economy minister, aware the narrower spread in fact meant merely that Italian bonds were considered comparatively less unsafe than before, smiled and shook his head beside her.
Fourteen years ago the attention on the spread was justified. Germany's economy was the European powerhouse and the surge in Italian yields meant Rome had to pay huge sums to service its debt and risked losing market access altogether.
Times have changed, however, and many economists say that with German benchmark bond yields rising due to a planned spending splurge on defence and infrastructure, Italians' fixation with the BTP-Bund spread now makes far less sense.
"What matters for us is the level of interest rates, not the spread with Germany," said economist Tito Boeri, a former head of Italy's state pensions agency. "If German yields rise that doesn't help Italy's public accounts."
Interest burden
Rome spends some 90 billion euros ($101 billion) per year, or 4% of gross domestic product to service its 3 trillion euro public debt. With the yield on 10-year BTPs still above 3.5%, that implies a heavy burden on state coffers regardless of the narrow spread with Germany.
At around 135% of GDP, Italy's debt is proportionally the second-largest in the euro zone after Greece's, and it is forecast by the government to rise through 2026.
Analysts say Meloni's unambitious but relatively prudent economic policies have reassured markets, but the recent narrowing of the spread is mainly down to developments in Germany and the United States.
Economist Lorenzo Bini Smaghi, a former European Central Bank board member, said investors' waning appetite for U.S. Treasuries had benefited European bonds and particularly high-yielding paper such as Italy's.
"If I consider Europe as a safer bet, partly because I expect the dollar to fall, I'm going to invest in European bonds, especially those that offer higher returns," he said.
Italian bond yields are still the highest of any euro zone country, reflecting the risk-premium demanded by investors, and Mr. Boeri warned that market volatility linked to U.S. economic policy meant Rome had no reason for complacency.
Italy's 10-year yield of around 3.6% compares with 3.2% on equivalent Spanish bonds and 3.4% on Greek ones.
"We need to be very, very careful because what is happening on international government bond markets shows us the slightest mistake (in economic policy) can be costly," he said.
Flight to safety
Italy could come unstuck even without a mistake. Spread fluctuations very often reflect "risk-on" or "risk-off" market sentiment driven by international events, not Italian ones.
The BTP-Bund gap widened briefly but sharply, for example, after U.S. President Donald Trump announced swingeing trade tariffs on April 2, only to suspend many of them a week later.
"The spread widens when we see a flight to safety because Italy is not considered 'safety'," said Roberto Perotti, economics professor at Milan's Bocconi university.
A glance at the past shows the BTP-Bund spread has dipped below 100 bps under several Italian governments, sometimes surging shortly afterwards due to factors outside their control.
For much of 2009 the spread hovered between 80 and 100 bps under Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, before widening out to a peak of more than 570 bps in 2011 during the euro zone debt crisis, despite Rome following a broadly stable fiscal policy.
In 2021, under former ECB President Mario Draghi, it again narrowed to less than 100 bps only to widen to 250 the following year amid surging global inflation after the COVID-19 pandemic.
Mr. Perotti said it was understandable that Ms. Meloni should point to the narrow spread as a political success. But with Germany no longer seen as a pillar of fiscal restraint and stability, its value as an indicator had diminished.
"At the moment it doesn't have much meaning," he said.
($1 = 0.8890 euros)
(Reporting by Stefano Bernabei and Gavin Jones; Editing by Hugh Lawson)
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Mint
15 minutes ago
- Mint
Hong Kong Pensions Plan to Cut Treasuries If US Loses AAA Rating
Hong Kong's pension fund managers have formed a preliminary plan to sell down their Treasury holdings within as soon as three months if the US loses its last recognized top credit rating, according to people familiar with the matter. Industry groups including the Hong Kong Investment Funds Association and the Hong Kong Trustees' Association discussed the proposal with the pensions regulator on Wednesday, the people said, asking not to be identified as the meeting was private. Under local regulations, managers of the city's HK$1.3 trillion Mandatory Provident Fund system can only invest more than 10% of their funds in Treasuries if the US has a AAA or equivalent rating from an approved agency. The downgrade of US sovereign debt by Moody's Ratings last month left Japan's Rating & Investment Information Inc. as the only remaining approved firm with the highest score. While R&I has said it isn't considering cutting its US rating, the Mandatory Provident Fund Schemes Authority last month urged pension fund managers to draw up 'contingency plans' in case of a downgrade. London Stock Exchange Group's FTSE Russell, which runs the MPF World Government Bond Index, a key benchmark that pension fund managers widely use for exposure to Treasuries, formulated an analysis of the divestment plan at the request of the industry groups earlier this month, according to the people. Ka Shi Lau, chair of Hong Kong Trustees' Association, said a deck of materials on the potential impacts and analysis was given to the regulator. Lau also confirmed Wednesday's meeting. Representatives from the MPF Schemes Authority and FTSE Russell declined to comment. The Hong Kong Investment Funds Association didn't respond to a request for comment. The situation highlights the risks of the US falling foul of the unusually strict investment mandates governed by Hong Kong regulations. The bulk of global investors don't require the top-tier rating to invest freely in US Treasuries, minimizing the risk of forced sales. While any potential forced sales in Hong Kong are unlikely to materially rock the global market for US Treasuries given its size and liquidity, it's a headache for portfolio managers who must contemplate an overhaul of their investment strategies. For funds focusing exclusively on government debt, options are limited given the lack of large issuers comparable to the US. Concerns about demand for long-end Treasuries have caused the yield on 30-year bonds to spike to some of the highest levels since 2023. An auction on Thursday will be closely watched for clues about investor appetite at a time when the Trump administration's tax-and-spending bill is expected to swell the nation's debt. Under the plan, the weighting of Treasuries in FTSE Russell's bond index would need to fall considerably if R&I downgrades US debt. US government bonds make up the biggest portion at 46.37%, followed by China, France, Japan and Germany. To provide a buffer against market fluctuations, Treasuries would need to be kept at around 9% of the benchmark to avoid breaching the 10% limit, the people said. Pension fund managers proposed to be given three to six months to rebalance positions in the event of a downgrade, the people said. Allocations would shift to other sovereign bonds of issuers with AAA ratings, and those with large market values, the people added. Germany and Singapore, which are in the FTSE index, are rated AAA by major agencies. Potential impacts of the reallocation were included in the materials shown to the regulator, the people added. The bond gauge has returned an annualized 1.03% on a hedged basis since inception. Pension fund managers had earlier asked the authority to reconsider the rule. But the regulator pushed back with its request for trustees to develop contingency plans and make 'timely and orderly' adjustments to their asset allocations in response to possible market developments. The MPF, introduced in 2000, has more than 4 million contributing members, with various financial institutions managing funds under the system. This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.


Mint
17 minutes ago
- Mint
Piyush Goyal sets TEPA roadmap, urges Swiss industry to tap India's growth
Union commerce and industry minister Piyush Goyal has laid out a forward-looking action plan for implementing the Trade and Economic Partnership Agreement between India and the European Free Trade Association (EFTA) during high-level meetings with Swiss leadership. The plan places innovation, regulatory alignment, and skill development at the core of the future collaboration, the commerce ministry said in a statement on Wednesday. Goyal, currently on a five-day official visit to Switzerland and Sweden to bolster economic and trade ties with key European partners, addressed over 1,000 delegates at the 18th Swissmem Industry Day on Tuesday. He invited Switzerland's mechanical and precision industries to deepen their engagement with India during his two-day visit to the country. 'During the visit, Goyal held productive meetings with top leadership from the Swiss government and industry, aimed at reinforcing strategic synergies and unlocking new avenues for trade, investment, and innovation-led growth,' the statement said. 'He met with federal councillor Guy Parmelin, head of the federal department of economic affairs, education and research (EAER), and state secretary Helene Budliger Artieda to chart a forward-looking roadmap for TEPA implementation. Discussions focused on regulatory cooperation, skills development, innovation partnerships, and mechanisms to facilitate faster investment decision-making,' it added. Last March, India and the four-nation EFTA signed a free trade deal to integrate and strengthen supply chains, attract investments and generate new business opportunities. The EFTA comprises Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway, and Switzerland. The EFTA has also made a binding commitment to invest $100 billion in India and create one million direct jobs in the next 15 years. The TEPA with the EFTA was the third major trade deal finalized by the Modi government since early 2022, after signing separate bilateral agreements with the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and Australia. India has since then completed a trade agreement with the UK and is in the process of completing one with the European Union and the US. Meanwhile, during his latest visit to Switzerland, Goayl engaged extensively with Swiss industry leaders across sectors, including biotech and pharma, healthcare, precision engineering, defence, and emerging technologies. In his sectoral roundtables and bilateral meetings, he highlighted India's growing economic strength, policy stability, and the government's commitment to creating a conducive and facilitative ecosystem for global investors, the commerce ministry said. 'In his keynote address, Goyal invited Swiss companies, including SMEs and deep-tech innovators, to scale up investments in India by leveraging the new trade architecture offered by the TEPA,' the statement said. 'He spoke about India's demographic dividend, globally recognised engineering talent, and robust supply chains, encouraging Swiss industry to anchor R&D, establish local manufacturing bases, and co-create technologies for the Global South,' it added. A standout moment from the visit was the swift resolution of a facilitation request by Endress+Hauser, a global process automation firm with expanding operations in India, the ministry said. The company flagged an issue regarding land availability near its Maharashtra facility, it said, adding that within hours, the matter was resolved through coordinated action by Goyal and Indian authorities—an outcome industry leaders hailed as a model of responsive and investor-friendly governance. In Sweden, Goyal will co-chair the 21st Session of the Indo-Swedish Joint Commission for Economic, Industrial, and Scientific Cooperation (JCEISC) alongside Benjamin Dousa, minister for international development cooperation and foreign trade. He is also scheduled to hold bilateral meetings with minister Dousa and state secretary Hakan Jevrell to strengthen the already robust economic partnership and explore new avenues for collaboration, in line with India's long-term growth ambitions and global strategic priorities.


Mint
17 minutes ago
- Mint
UniCredit's Orcel Rules Out Commerzbank Bid at Current Price
(Bloomberg) -- UniCredit SpA Chief Executive Officer Andrea Orcel effectively ruled out making an offer for Commerzbank AG at the current price, saying such a move wouldn't add value after a rally in the stock. 'We are far away' from a takeover offer, Orcel said in an interview with CNBC on Wednesday. 'Secondly, in our opinion, the share price has gone well beyond the fundamentals.' Orcel said previously that he may wait until 2027 before deciding on an all-out takeover offer, after a rally in the stock made a potential deal more expensive and the German government expressed opposition. Shares of Commerzbank have more than doubled in value since UniCredit first unveiled that it had built a major stake, as the smaller rival boosted payouts to investors in an effort to defend itself. While the higher Commerzbank share price translate into a financial gain for UniCredit, Orcel has said he needs to be convinced that the rally is justified before deciding on a strategic transaction. 'There is a lot of activity which is directed at keeping the share price' high, the CEO said in the interview. 'But we are patient, because that activity eventually will run into losses.' Orcel Delays Commerzbank Decision Further as Obstacles Mount Orcel separately told at a Goldman Sachs Group Inc. conference on Wednesday that he expects to have all required authorizations by the end of this month to convert the derivatives he used to build part of the Commerzbank stake into shares. That would give UniCredit close to 30% of the German lender. 'We'll see if we consolidate the 30%,' Orcel said at the conference. If UniCredit decides to do so, 'that 30% stake comes with rights and influence.' He said UniCredit had earned the right to be patient with its stake and take its time, but cautioned that a continued stalemate wasn't in the interest of either side. 'If no one wants to talk, then we are going to have a situation where we are stalling for a long period of time, and I don't think that is in the best interest of Germany, in the best interest of Commerzbank, and not for us,' Orcel said. More stories like this are available on