False Philippine landslide posts misuse old clip from Taiwan
Viewed over 1.8 million times, the clip shows a mudslide rolling down the side of a mountain onto a road. Backhoes can be seen operating near the site.
The sound of people shouting in the Visayan language can be heard.
Image
Screenshot of false post taken on July 9, 2025, with a red X mark added by AFP
The clip spread on Facebook and elsewhere on TikTok with people seemingly worried about the disaster.
"Where is this in Pagadian, why is it not in the news?" one asked.
"That's what happens when there's a quarrying site," another said.
Although geological hazard map data of the city issued by the country's environment agency shows numerous areas are "highly susceptible" to landslides, the video in fact shows an incident in Taiwan (archived link).
Pagadian city Mayor Samuel Co issued a statement on his Facebook page on July 5, where he identified posts carrying the footage of the landslide as "entirely false" (archived link).
"We respectfully request the Pagadianon to maintain composure and exercise discretion by refraining from disseminating such unsubstantiated claims, as they may cause unnecessary public concern," he added, addressing the city's residents.
A reverse video search on Google found the clip has been circulating online since October 2022 on social media sites Weibo, Douyin and YouTube (archived here, here, here).
The sound of someone shouting "the whole slice of mountain is falling down" in Chinese -- not Visayan -- can be heard in the video clip. The Chinese-language caption of the Douyin post shared on October 17, 2022 reads "Landslide in the mountainous areas of Yilan in Taiwan".
Image
Screenshot comparison of the circulating footage on Facebook in the Philippines (left) and the clip shared on Douyin in 2022 (right)
Further keyword searches found news reports from Taiwan's Public Television Service and local broadcaster Formosa TV about landslides in Yilan County's Datong Township on October 16, 2022 (archived here, here, here, and here).
According to the reports, hundreds of residents were evacuated from the area after Typhoon Nesat caused massive landslides, particularly along Highway 7.
A check on Google and Bing maps shows a cavity on the side of a mountain along the old and new roads of Highway 7. It also shows rice paddies similar to the one seen on the circulating clip's foreground.
Image
Screenshot comparison of the clip shared on Douyin in 2022 (left) and an image on Google Maps taken in 2023 (right)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
AFP
13 hours ago
- AFP
Dramatic mudslide clip filmed in Japan, not Pakistan
"May Allah protect all of us from natural calamities. Amen," reads the Urdu-language caption of a Facebook video viewed more than 11,000 times since it was shared on August 16, 2025. The caption includes hashtags for areas in Pakistan's mountainous Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province where torrential monsoon rains have triggered deadly flooding and landslides (archived link). The video comprises several clips, with the first showing mud and debris crashing down a hillside. Image Screenshot of the false Facebook post captured on August 18, 2025, with a red X added by AFP Similar compilations were also shared on Instagram and X posts, as northern Pakistan was ravaged by an unusually intense monsoon season that has left more than 400 people dead (archived link). The monsoon season brings about three-quarters of South Asia's annual rainfall, which is vital for agriculture and food security but also causes widespread destruction. The rains that have battered Pakistan have caused flooding and landslides that have swept away entire villages, leaving many residents trapped in the rubble and hundreds missing. But the clip used at the beginning of the circulating compilation was not filmed in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. A reverse image search on Google using keyframes from the clip led to the same footage shared by Japanese outlet Sankei News on YouTube on July 3, 2021 (archived link). The longer footage in the old report is credited to wire agency EyePress. Its caption indicates it shows a mudslide sweeping through the Izusan neighbourhood of Atami, a town in Japan's Shizuoka prefecture, on July 3, 2021. Image Screenshot comparison of the falsely shared clip (left) and the Sankei News video (right) The video corresponds to Google Street View imagery of the town, located around 90 kilometres (55 miles) southwest of Tokyo (archived link). AFP reported that torrents of mud crashed through part of the town following days of heavy rain (archived link). The devastating landslide killed 27 people. The video has been misrepresented several times on social media as showing unrelated disasters. Other clips in the compilation depict raging floodwaters and buildings being toppled over. While AFP was unable to verify if they all show the impact of the monsoon rains on northern Pakistan in August 2025, at least one of the clips is several years old. The video of a muddy torrent furiously gushing across buildings has circulated on Facebook and YouTube since at least August 2022 (archived here and here). The latter post says it was taken in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa's Swat district. Image Screenshot comparison of the falsely shared clip (left) and the video posted in 2022 (right) Monsoon rains in 2022 submerged a third of the country and resulted in approximately 1,700 deaths. AFP reported at the time that many rivers in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa had burst their banks, demolishing scores of buildings including a 150-room hotel that crumbled into a raging torrent (archived link). Officials said that year's monsoon flooding affected more than 33 million people -- one in seven Pakistanis -- destroying or badly damaging nearly a million homes. AFP earlier debunked another false claim about the recent monsoon flooding in Pakistan here.
AFP
13-08-2025
- AFP
Visuals of old jet crash misrepresented as recent Bangladesh air tragedy
"The way the Air Force training plane crashed and fell on Milestone School and College in Uttara," reads a Bengali-language Facebook post shared on July 21, 2025. The clip shows a fighter jet with its tail on fire spiralling into a body of water as two persons are seen ejecting from the aircraft. Image Screenshot of the false post, taken on August 13, with a red X added by AFP The clip circulated in similar Facebook posts after a fighter jet slammed into the private Milestone School and College in capital city Dhaka just as pupils had been let out of class on July 21, 2025 (archived link). The tragic crash left at least 33 people dead, mostly children, and injured more than 170 people -- some still undergoing treatment at various hospitals in Dhaka (archived link). But the video does not show the recent disaster. A reverse image search on Google using keyframes from the footage led to a video published on the verified YouTube channel of local media outlet The Daily Star on May 9, 2024 (archived link). "How the plane caught fire and crashed into the Karnaphuli River", its caption said. Image Screenshot comparison of the clip shared in false post (L) and The Daily Star YouTube report Local media organisation Prothom Alo also published the video in its report about the crash on May 9, 2024. Both pilots -- wing commander Sohan Hasan Khan and squadron leader Asim Jawad -- ejected from the jet and landed in the river, though Jawad died later at a hospital (archived link). The Bangladesh Air Force said that after the plane caught fire, the pilots were able to maneuver the plane from a densely populated area near the airport to a sparsely populated area to avoid major damage (archived link). AFP has debunked misinformation around the recent Bangladesh jet crash here.
AFP
12-08-2025
- AFP
Images of people setting bottles of food adrift towards Gaza are AI-generated
"Egyptians set food adrift in the sea in an effort to help Gaza," reads part of a Malay-language Facebook post shared on July 25, 2025. The post continues: "In an effort to help the people of Gaza, Egyptians filled one- and two-litre bottles with dry food such as rice, beans, and lentils before releasing them into the Mediterranean Sea in the hope that they would reach the shores of Gaza." The accompanying image appears to show a group of people releasing plastic bottles filled with rice or flour into the sea. Image Screenshot of the false Facebook post captured on August 7, 2025, with a red X added by AFP The image was also passed off as genuine elsewhere on Facebook and in other languages such as Italian, French, and Arabic. A similar claim surfaced in a Bengali-language Facebook post on July 27, 2025 with an image of several bottles filled with food and notes floating in water. "May Almighty's divine power deliver this to the hungry people of Gaza," reads the caption. Image Screenshot of the false Facebook post captured on August 7, 2025, with a red X added by AFP The image also circulated elsewhere on Facebook, and some users appear to believe the picture is genuine. One user wrote, "Hopefully it reaches the people of Gaza..." "Thank you.. may Allah bless you for your efforts," another commented. The pictures circulated online as Palestinians scrambled for basic supplies after Israel imposed a near-total blockade on March 2. UN agencies warned that Gaza was "on the brink of a full-scale famine", while the health ministry in the Hamas-run territory said the Palestinian death toll in the nearly 22-month war had topped 60,000 (archived link). The war was sparked by Hamas's October 2023 attack on Israel, which resulted in the deaths of 1,219 people, the majority civilians, based on an AFP tally of official figures. Israel began allowing a small trickle of aid to enter the densely populated territory in late May -- having imposed a total blockade in March after ceasefire talks broke down -- and started a series of "tactical pauses" while allowing deliveries from aid trucks and airdrops in Gaza. Although there have been media reports of a genuine symbolic initiative launched by "Egyptian citizens horrified by the images of famine", the images circulating online contain visual inconsistencies indicating they were AI-generated (archived here and here). Visual inconsistencies An analysis carried out using the Hive image verification tool on the image of people dropping the bottles into the water concluded that there was a 99.9 percent probability that these visuals were made by AI. Image Screenshot of the misleading post taken on Facebook on August 7, 2025 (left) and the result of the Hive tool (right) with colored boxes added by AFP The image also features a hand with a distorted thumb in the foreground, fully filled bottles floating improbably on the sea which defies the laws of physics, and people all facing the same direction unnaturally -- hallmarks of AI-generated images. While there is no foolproof method to spot AI-generated media, identifying watermarks and visual inconsistencies can help, as errors still occur despite the meteoric progress in generative AI. The plastic bottles in the second falsely shared image also appear to float unnaturally on the water's surface, while the size of the items contained in the bottles appears larger than the opening of the container. Image Visual inconsistencies of the false video highlighted by AFP AFP has debunked other posts of the Israel-Gaza conflict that falsely presented AI-generated images and videos here.
