Opinion: Dealing directly with the unhinged neighbour
Opinion
In the end, the encounter was described as cordial. Tense, yes, but respectful. Some even went so far as to call it productive.
For Canadians, the most meaningful outcome of the first face-to-face meeting between Prime Minister Mark Carney and U.S. President Donald Trump might be that it was largely uneventful — noteworthy for its general absence of blowups, tirades, insults or outright lies from a serially erratic leader who is known for producing all of those things in abundance.
Tuesday's get-together at the White House was described by Trump himself as 'friendly,' and while it did not produce anything in the way of definitive declarations regarding Canada-U.S. relations and the ongoing Trump-initiated tariff dispute that continues to impact both nations' economies, it can fairly be argued it did accomplish a positive reset of the intentions and emotions informing the cross-border alliance.
The Canadian Press
Prime Minister Mark Carney
If it's true — and it most certainly is — the Liberals won the federal election on the strength of their pitch that Carney is the leader best suited to deal with the challenges posed by Trump's scattershot antics, then Tuesday's event would have to be considered a triumph of managed expectations and mostly muted diplomatic restraint.
One can't help wondering what the prime minister was anticipating as he arrived at the White House, and whether his hopes were achieved by the time he exited.
In just a weekend's worth of news cycles leading up to their meeting, Carney would necessarily have watched and taken note as Trump: a) posted on social media (and then denied responsibility for) an AI-generated picture of himself as the next pope, b) mused about reopening the long-shuttered Alcatraz prison to 'house America's most ruthless and violent Offenders,' c) pledged to impose a 100 per cent tariff on movies produced outside the U.S. (a nonsensical notion, given the ethereal logistics and economics of film production) and d) continued his out-loud ruminations about annexing Canada as the 51st U.S. state.
Even with Carney actually en route to their crucial first meeting, the president could not restrain himself from further trolling Canada on his Truth Social platform, posting (inaccurately) that the U.S. 'subsidizes' Canada by US$200 billion annually and that 'We don't need their Cars, we don't need their Energy, we don't need their Lumber, we don't need ANYTHING they have … (and) They, on the other hand, need EVERYTHING from us!'
Armed, as he must have been, with a clear understanding of who and what awaited him in the Oval Office, Carney delivered a virtuoso performance, opening with a deftly measured statement that sounded very much like a compliment — 'Thank you for your hospitality and, above all, your leadership; you're a transformational president…' — but was really nothing more than a recitation of fact that left open to the listener just exactly what Trump is transforming, and (for better or worse) how.
Winnipeg Free Press | Newsletter
Winnipeg Jets Game Days
On Winnipeg Jets game days, hockey writers Mike McIntyre and Ken Wiebe send news, notes and quotes from the morning skate, as well as injury updates and lineup decisions. Arrives a few hours prior to puck drop. Sign up for The Warm-Up
For most of the on-camera portion of their session, Carney remained silent as the president expounded at length on a variety of unrelated topics; when it came time to the PM to address the issue of annexation, however, Carney spoke matter-of-factly in terms Trump could understand:
'As you know, from real estate, there are some places that are never for sale. … Having met with the owners of Canada over the course of the campaign the last several months, it's not for sale, won't be for sale, ever.'
'Never say never,' Trump responded, to which Carney mouthed silently to numerous people in the room, 'Never.'
Message delivered.
And, as far as this first meeting is concerned, mission accomplished.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Observer
10 minutes ago
- National Observer
Ambrose says Ottawa can defeat western separatism with better listening
Former federal Conservative cabinet minister Rona Ambrose says the secessionist sentiment in Alberta is an unwelcome source of uncertainty for investors — but it could fizzle out quickly if Ottawa handles it right. Ambrose, now deputy chair at TD Securities, said Tuesday there's a feeling of resentment in Alberta and in neighbouring Saskatchewan. "I think that it can dissipate quite quickly if some of these underlying issues around how the energy sector has been treated by Ottawa are dealt with," she told a panel discussion at the Global Energy Show. Prime Minister Mark Carney can't take those feelings lightly, she said. "We've had 10 years that have created a huge division, east-west, in between the federal and provincial governments. He's got to heal that," Ambrose said of environmental policies Carney's predecessor, Justin Trudeau, brought in. "And so decisions he makes are not just for the economic benefit of Canada, but it's for the benefit of national unity, which is the most important thing a prime minister should always have top of mind." Ambrose said outreach and trust-building is paramount and the federal-provincial relationship is "already better." The chief executive of one of Canada's biggest oil and gas companies said the complaints are valid even if the separatist talk isn't the most constructive way to go about expressing them. "The way this separatist movement has manifested itself is really rooted in some grievances that I think are real and have frustrated this region for a long period of time," Cenovus Energy chief executive Jon McKenzie told the panel. McKenzie told reporters on the sidelines of the conference he has not been hearing from investors about the separatist rumblings, and that he agrees the movement will "go away" if political leaders address the concerns. Talk of Alberta going it alone or joining the United States has ratcheted up since the federal Liberals won a fourth term in office in April. In the province, where all but a few seats went Conservative blue, there is widespread discontent with federal environmental policies affecting the key oilpatch industry. Alberta Premier Danielle Smith has introduced a bill that, if passed, would make it far easier for Albertans to launch referendums on various topics — including splitting from Canada. Last month, the top executive of another major Alberta company said mere talk of secession has already been hurting the investment climate. Atco Ltd. CEO Nancy Southern said Asian partners in a major hydrogen project indicated they won't make final investment decisions unless there is certainty around the issue. "There's just too many questions for them to be confident that they can move forward with large-scale investment decisions, and so I think the separatist discussion is very unhelpful and not constructive to Alberta," Southern said in a May interview. Questions include how an independent Alberta would get its products to coastal ports, what kind of trade deals it would have with its neighbours, what currency it would use and how stable the economy would be. Southern said she understands Albertans' frustration with the federal government. "We have had the short end of the stick on many occasions as a result of new regulations and legislation and rule of law," Southern said. "I'm a big believer that this prime minister wants to change things and I think we need to sit down and work together."
CBC
11 minutes ago
- CBC
Ex-cabinet minister says western separatism can fizzle out if Ottawa listens to grievances
Former federal Conservative cabinet minister Rona Ambrose says the secessionist sentiment in Alberta is an unwelcome source of uncertainty for investors — but it could fizzle out quickly if Ottawa handles it right. Ambrose, now deputy chair at TD Securities, said Tuesday there's a feeling of resentment in Alberta and in neighbouring Saskatchewan. "I think that it can dissipate quite quickly if some of these underlying issues around how the energy sector has been treated by Ottawa are dealt with," she told a panel discussion at the Global Energy Show. Prime Minister Mark Carney can't take those feelings lightly, she said. "We've had 10 years that have created a huge division, east-west, in between the federal and provincial governments. He's got to heal that," Ambrose said of environmental policies Carney's predecessor, Justin Trudeau, brought in. "And so decisions he makes are not just for the economic benefit of Canada, but it's for the benefit of national unity, which is the most important thing a prime minister should always have top of mind." Ambrose said outreach and trust-building is paramount and the federal-provincial relationship is "already better." The chief executive of one of Canada's biggest oil and gas companies said the complaints are valid even if the separatist talk isn't the most constructive way to go about expressing them. "The way this separatist movement has manifested itself is really rooted in some grievances that I think are real and have frustrated this region for a long period of time," Cenovus Energy chief executive Jon McKenzie told the panel. McKenzie told reporters on the sidelines of the conference he has not been hearing from investors about the separatist rumblings, and that he agrees the movement will "go away" if political leaders address the concerns. Separation talk ratcheted up since election Talk of Alberta going it alone or joining the United States has ratcheted up since the federal Liberals won a fourth term in office in April. In the province, where all but a few seats went Conservative blue, there is widespread discontent with federal environmental policies affecting the key oilpatch industry. Alberta Premier Danielle Smith has introduced a bill that, if passed, would make it far easier for Albertans to launch referendums on various topics — including splitting from Canada. Last month, the top executive of another major Alberta company said mere talk of secession has already been hurting the investment climate. Atco Ltd. CEO Nancy Southern said Asian partners in a major hydrogen project indicated they won't make final investment decisions unless there is certainty around the issue. "There's just too many questions for them to be confident that they can move forward with large-scale investment decisions, and so I think the separatist discussion is very unhelpful and not constructive to Alberta," Southern said in a May interview. Questions include how an independent Alberta would get its products to coastal ports, what kind of trade deals it would have with its neighbours, what currency it would use and how stable the economy would be. Southern said she understands Albertans' frustration with the federal government. "We have had the short end of the stick on many occasions as a result of new regulations and legislation and rule of law," Southern said.
CTV News
36 minutes ago
- CTV News
Anti-racism a ‘core municipal responsibility' says Sohi during update on Edmonton's strategy to address hate-based violence
The Sisters Dialogue unveiled a new ad campaign aimed at addressing gender-based Islamophobia in Edmonton. (Evan Klippenstein/CTV News Edmonton) The City of Edmonton received an update on its anti-racism strategy on Tuesday. The strategy to address hate-based violence and support the communities it affects was introduced by Mayor Amarjeet Sohi after the 2021 municipal election and was adopted by city council in 2022. 'Anti-racism work is not peripheral. It is a core municipal responsibility,' Sohi said on Tuesday. 'As Edmonton grows, this work ensures our services are becoming more accessible, our communities are inclusive, and our collective potential is fully realized.' During a Tuesday update, city administration said two out of three initial recommendations in the strategy had been completed. Those include expanding anti-racism grant funding – which Sohi said has supported about 140 initiatives in the city – and creating an organization within city administration to incorporate anti-racism and reconciliation action into city processes. That organization will work to meet seven corporate commitments over the next two years aimed at dismantling systemic barriers. 'The team's mandate involves working closely with colleagues across the corporation to celebrate diversity, promote inclusion, and begin to change a system that wasn't originally designed for everybody to be more equitable,' Salima Ebrahim, chief of staff to the city manager, explained. Sohi said he and members of his office also joined the Bloomberg Harvard City Leadership Initiative to learn more about how other North American cities are tackling racism and how Edmonton can follow suit. 'Are our services accessible for people from diverse backgrounds? Are we delivering the right level of services for those communities' needs, such as support for newcomers or building an efficient, effective public transit system that racialized people, or newcomers and low income people rely on? 'I think those are the things that we need to continue to monitor and press upon to see the positive change that we want to see.' The third priority, to create an independent anti-racism body has yet to be completed. Sohi said a 15-person panel has been assembled to advise the city on how best to create that body. More information on Edmonton's anti-racism strategy can be found on the city's website.
