HC: Aadhaar, PAN, voter ID don't make one a citizen
The man is accused of staying in India for more than a decade with forged and fabricated documents.
A bench of Justice Amit Borkar said provisions of the Citizenship Act lay down who can be a citizen of India and how citizenship can be acquired and documents such as the Aadhaar card, PAN card and voter ID are only meant for identification or availing services.
The court refused bail to Babu Abdul Ruf Sardar, alleged to be a Bangladeshi national, who entered India illegally without a valid passport or travel documents. He allegedly procured forged Indian documents such as Aadhaar card, PAN card, voter ID and also an Indian passport.
In 1955, Parliament passed the Citizenship Act which created a permanent and complete system for acquiring citizenship, Justice Borkar noted.
"In my opinion, the Citizenship Act of 1955 is the main and controlling law for deciding questions about nationality in India today. This is the statute that lays down who can be a citizen, how citizenship can be acquired and in what situations it can be lost," he said.
"Merely having documents such as Aadhaar card, PAN card or voter ID does not, by itself, make someone a citizen of India. These documents are meant for identification or availing services, but they do not override the basic legal requirements of citizenship as prescribed in the Citizenship Act," the HC said.
The law draws a clear line between lawful citizens and illegal migrants, the bench said.
People falling in the category of illegal migrants are barred from obtaining citizenship through most of the legal routes mentioned in the Citizenship Act, it added.
"This distinction is important because it protects the sovereignty of the country and ensures that benefits and rights meant for citizens are not wrongfully taken by those who have no legal status to stay in India," the court said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
23 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Tomorrow's Independence Day, not 'us vs them' day
We all want Independence Day to be safe and secure tomorrow. But much of I-Day has morphed from a spontaneous public celebration into a day of paranoid, xenophobic vigil. This week, a national-level skater and his father were denied a hotel room in Noida, because they were Bengali. The hotel staff reportedly explained to the two Kolkatans that the police had instructed them not to allow people from 'Bangladesh, Punjab, or Jammu and Kashmir to stay until August 15' and that 'people from Bangladesh' and Bengalis from West Bengal were the 'same thing'. Noida Police has denied giving any such instruction. Be that as it may, this is a genie that authorities have to put back in the bottle, ever since Delhi Police issued its infamous July 29 notification conflating Bengalis and (illegally residing) like this, however stray, show how dog whistling - seemingly innocuous messaging, but containing a covert instruction - is becoming normalised among a pliant, willing citizenry. Last month in Gurgaon, a 'verification drive' targeting illegal Bangladeshi immigrants led to migrant Indian Muslim workers being detained. Such paranoid binary thinking - 'them' vs 'us' - vitiates the very spirit of I-Day. It replaces trust and unity with suspicion and division, patriotic pride with paranoia. Worse, it seeps beyond August 15, feeding dangerous narratives India 2025 can well do without. GoI should issue a clear directive stating that valid IDs should suffice for hotel check-ins - which can, anyway, be verified with police if need be. The least it can do is condemn such divisive messagings before tomorrow, when all Indians celebrate freedom from a time when such nefarious conflations were the hallmark of colonial divide and rule. Elevate your knowledge and leadership skills at a cost cheaper than your daily tea. Regulatory gray area makes investing in LVMH, BP tough For Indian retail How IDBI banker landed plush Delhi properties in Amtek's INR33k crore skimming As 50% US tariff looms, 6 key steps that can safeguard Indian economy Jane Street blow pushes Indian quants to ancient Greek idea to thrive Stock Radar: Astra Microwave showing signs of bottoming out after 16% fall from highs; time to buy? F&O Radar | Deploy Broken Wing in Paytm to play stock's bullish outlook These 9 banking stocks can give more than 28% returns in 1 year, according to analysts Why 2025 Could Be The Astrological Turning Point We've Been Waiting For
Hans India
33 minutes ago
- Hans India
Farmers, Workers Demand Withdrawal of U.S. 50% Tariffs on India
Gadwal: Farmers' and workers' unions under the banner of the Samyukta Kisan Morcha staged a protest at the old bus stand in the district headquarters on Wednesday, demanding the immediate withdrawal of the 50% tariffs imposed by the United States on India. Speaking at the protest, Farmers' Association State Secretary Gopal Yadav and CITU District President A. Venkataswamy said the steep tariffs would severely damage India's economy, push up prices of goods and services, and worsen unemployment. They stressed that in a largely agrarian country like India, such measures would disproportionately hurt farmers, workers, and agricultural laborers. The leaders reiterated India's sovereign right to make trade agreements with any nation and questioned the U.S.'s authority to interfere in India's ties with Russia. They called on the Indian government to stand firm against 'imperial arrogance' and dictatorial policies aimed at creating a unipolar world, which they said were fueling wars and global economic decline. They pledged the support of farmers and workers for all government measures aimed at safeguarding the nation's economy and foreign policy independence. The protest saw participation from Telangana Praja Front State Treasurer Sankar Prabhakar, District President Naganna, CITU District Vice-President Upper Narasimha, Farmers' Association leaders Nagaraju and Khaja Mainuddin, CITU leader Narasimhraju, and others.
Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
Pushed to B'desh 50 days ago, man returns on HC hearing day
Kolkata: Twenty-two-year-old Malda migrant labourer Amir Sheikh — who was pushed into Bangladesh on June 25 — came back to India on Wednesday, his reappearance as mysterious as his disappearance from the country of his birth. A BSF explanation in the Calcutta High Court a couple of hours after Amir's return through the Basirhat border only added to the mystery as the agency insisted that he had crossed over to Bangladesh "inadvertently". "We have been told that this person inadvertently crossed over the border and went to Bangladesh and was apprehended by the BSF while crossing back to India," deputy solicitor-general Rajdeep Majumdar submitted. Amir was stuck in Bangladesh since June 25, prompting his father — Jiyem Sheikh — to file a habeas corpus petition in the Calcutta HC; he accused Rajasthan cops of arresting him for being a "Bangladeshi in India illegally", jailing him and then pushing him to Bangladesh with BSF help. You Can Also Check: Kolkata AQI | Weather in Kolkata | Bank Holidays in Kolkata | Public Holidays in Kolkata | Gold Rates Today in Kolkata | Silver Rates Today in Kolkata A division bench of Justice Tapabrata Chakraborty and Justice Reetobroto Kumar Mitra asked Jiyem on Wednesday to furnish a bond and take his son home after providing all details. Basirhat cops said the BSF handed Amir over to them at the Ghojadanga border. "We released him to his family in accordance with the Calcutta HC order after an initial inquiry based on details provided by the BSF," Basirhat superintendent of police Hossain Mehdi Rehman told TOI. Amir's plight came to light only after a viral video from Bangladesh, his father told the HC in his petition. Amir was working at a Sikar construction site since May but was detained by Rajasthan cops for being a Bangladeshi and pushed over the border on June 25, he added. A video surfaced on social media on July 2 showing a visibly distressed Amir in police custody in Bangladesh's Khulna. Amir was seen crying as he said: "I was working in Rajasthan. Police picked me up, saying I was a Bangladeshi." In the video, Amir is heard saying, "I showed my Aadhaar. I got additional documents tracing myself to Malda's Kaliachak. But they insisted on proof that I did not have. They kept me in jail for several weeks, handcuffed me and brought me here (unidentifiable place) and the BSF pushed me into Bangladesh. I do not know anybody in Bangladesh, I have nothing to eat."The Bengal administration stepped in after that as more and more tales of migrant workers from the state being harassed by cops — mostly in BJP-governed states like Delhi, Haryana and Maharashtra — poured in. "My son had his Aadhaar and tried to convince Rajasthan cops that he was from Malda but was labelled a Bangladeshi," Jiyem said. "Our family has been living in Malda's Jalalpur for 400 years. We have land records since the 1950s?" he added. West Bengal Migrant Labour Board chairperson and Trinamool Congress Rajya Sabha MP Samirul Islam said it was only because of the pressure that the BSF was forced to bring Amir back to Bengal. "They are now claiming that Amir was never deported! Then what happened? How did he end up in Bangladesh?" Islam asked, adding: "They first persecuted a poor man and now the BSF is resorting to lies after being thoroughly exposed. But that has always been the BJP policy." (Inputs from Subhro Maitra in Malda and Sanjib Chakraborty in Basirhat) Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
