Council Submission Raises Concerns Over Losses In Water Quality
The council's submission is in response to proposed wastewater environmental performance standards stemming from the Local Government (Water Services) Bill.
Taumata Arowai is consulting on the initial wastewater standards which regional councils will be required to implement through resource consent conditions, without making them stricter or more lenient, councillors heard at the April meeting of the Strategy and Policy Committee.
The council's submission advised that while the proposed standards are expected to enhance environmental outcomes and improve efficiencies, they conflict with current council initiatives to improve water quality.
Committee chair Warren Maher said the council has been systematically strengthening the limits of resource consents over time to improve water quality across the region in collaboration with territorial authorities.
'Many of the existing municipal wastewater discharges have one or multiple contaminant standards in their existing consents or current applications which are stricter than what the proposed standards would require.
'Implementing these standards as they are would significantly undermine the substantial efforts and investments made by territorial authorities, which have been actively supported by our council, in upgrading wastewater treatment plant discharges,' said Cr Maher.
'If the government decides to progress the standards, then they should at least enable the council to maintain current discharge quality levels. If not, then water quality across the region could deteriorate and the percentage of waterways experiencing significant adverse effects may worsen.'
Councillors also expressed their concerns regarding the proposal to grant new resource consents a 35-year timeframe.
'As a regulator, the council must be able to carry out a case-by-case assessment that considers localised effects and specific merits of an application to determine the appropriate duration of a resource consent,' said Cr Maher.
'Applying a blanket 35-year approach will not adequately account for future changes in environmental conditions, community needs and technology advancements.'
The proposed wastewater environmental performance standards are expected to be set by late 2025 following enactment of the Local Government (Water Services) Bill.
The report on the council's submission along with a recording of the Strategy and Policy Committee meeting can be viewed at waikatoregion.govt.nz/council-meetings/policy
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
15 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Rural minister on ‘listening tour'
Minister of Rural Communities Mark Patterson speaks at an open forum in Gore, joined by NZ First outreach adviser Kym McDonald. PHOTO: ELLA SCOTT-FLEMING Industry, energy, genetic engineering and artificial intelligence were the hot topics at an NZ First minister's open forum in Gore yesterday. Minister of Rural Communities Mark Patterson held a public meeting at the Gore Town & Country Club on Friday afternoon to connect with the issues of Southland. The minister said, though it sounded a bit "namby pamby", he was on a "listening tour" to gather feedback for his party to use to build policy for the next election. In his opening speech, he spoke of the similarities — and differences — of the coalition government, its endeavour to get rid of the "red and green tape" and the last government's mistakes. The three parties agreed "pretty much" on the bigger picture, but NZ First were more at the "interventionist" end, making things happen, he said. Interventions included the $1.2billion Regional Infrastructure Fund developed by himself and Shane Jones. The economy, inflation and cost-of-living crisis were the fault of the previous Labour Party government, he said. "[It] is a sort of direct impact of some really, really bad-quality spending towards the tail end of the last government." Southland had been going "gangbusters" in terms of industry growth, Mr Patterson said. Datagrid NZ's proposed data centre in Makarewa would be a "massive opportunity" for Southland. But he received pushback from the crowd, one member of the community expressing concerns about the "enormous" amounts of power such centres needed. Data centres generated a lot of heat which took power to cool down, and had surges needing random bursts of power, which all cost, the man said. He did not want to see that cost subsidised by the general public. Mr Patterson said he was apprehensive at first about the centres too, but he had come around. There was potential for 500-600 jobs, as the project sized up, 10ha of greenhouses using the industrial heat and up to 3500 jobs in auxiliary surrounding businesses. "That's the modelling they've put to us." Concerns around the proposed deregulation of genetic engineering and modification were also brought up, as were Mr Jones' recent comments denouncing the proposal. Mr Patterson said Mr Jones had made comments on the proposed deregulation of genetic engineering at a meeting in Hutt Valley last week, but the crowd's applause had drowned out some of his qualifying remarks. The Gene Technology Bill, which passed its first reading in Parliament last December, remains a contentious issue. Mr Patterson said NZ First supporters remained sceptical and that the party had received significant public feedback on the matter. Dr William Rolleston, a strong supporter of the Bill who was attending the meeting in Gore, recalled Mr Jones' warning about not allowing "Frankenstein" into the environment. Addressing public concerns about consumer and health authority reactions to GMO use in farming, Dr Rolleston assured that no genetic modifications had faced health authority objections and emphasised that farmers grew GM crops only where there was market demand. "Farmers wouldn't grow GM crops if they didn't think there was a market for it," the doctor said. Mr Patterson declined to comment further, citing the Bill's current status before the parliamentary committee.
Otago Daily Times
15 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Tide turning against clubs, codes fear
The country's sports clubs are battling mounting costs, funding issues and volunteer burnout. Reporter Adrian Seconi checks the pulse of the club scene in Otago. Sport Otago chief executive James Nation wonders whether we have reached a tipping point as sports clubs battle with rising costs and volunteer fatigue. Southern Football boss Dougal McGowan reached for the word catastrophic when describing the impact the Online Casino Gambling Bill will have if it goes ahead as proposed. Otago Rugby Football Association chief executive Richard Kinley is concerned that if the clubs cannot access adequate funding, they will have to pass on the extra costs and that could have a chilling effect on participation rates. Hockey Otago general manager Andy McLean said anything that made "funding harder to obtain was worrying". A report commissioned by the New Zealand Amateur Sport Association found national volunteer numbers had dropped 28% between 2018 and 2024. It also highlighted funding as a key issue, noting 72% of clubs were concerned about their long-term financial sustainability. Bill seen as threat The proposed Online Casino Gambling Bill looms as a major threat. If it goes ahead in its current guise, it will potentially undermine the funds available through class-4 gambling, which has propped up community sport since tobacco sponsorship was outlawed in New Zealand in the 1990s. Increased user charges for Dunedin City Council grounds and facilities have piled more pressure on clubs. It all paints a grim picture for community sport, Nation acknowledged. And neither do there appear to be many options. "Clubs are really loathe to put up their membership fees any more than they have, and so that's having an impact because all the costs for the clubs have certainly gone up," Nation said. The Dunedin City Council's sinking lid policy on class-4 gambling was starting to bite, McGowan added. "If you have a look at the types of organisations that get support from the class-4 gaming industry, it's such a broad spectrum of the community. "They help us with rent. They help us with insurance. They help us with staff salaries so that we can get staff out into the schools to support kids being active." "Without that, I think it will have such a significant effect on what it means to be a community in New Zealand." The proposed Online Casino Gambling Bill threatens to further chip away at the available pool of funds. The licensed online casinos would not be compelled to make community funding grants as the Bill stands. Former New Zealand Cricket boss Martin Snedden is leading the charge to get into the ear of the decision-makers. Submissions close on August 17 and McGowan encouraged sports organisations to engage in the process. "The flow-on effects for this could be catastrophic for community activity and sport," McGowan said. Kinley said it was important to impress upon the government the challenges "sport will face across the sector if this should be approved in its current form". "If clubs and sports can't access other forms of funding to support the community game, it'll be passed back to participants," he said. "So potentially the cost of participating in sport will increase, which is something that none of us want to see. "If we have less people participating in all sports because of financial difficulties, that could be potentially quite detrimental to society as a whole." McLean said hockey was in the same boat. "Class-4 gaming funding is really important in terms of supporting what we can deliver to the community," he said. "We want hockey to be as accessible as possible. "Anything that risks reducing the amount of class-4 funding that's available is obviously of concern ." Costs rising The other half of the battle to keep the books in balance is the rising expenses. Everything has gone up from the halftime oranges to the user charges for Dunedin City Council grounds and facilities. The latter has been quite a hike. McGowan said user charges have more than doubled since 2018. He has seen Southern Football's bill grow from $42,202 to $98,119 in 2025. It has been reluctant to pass that extra cost on to members and has instead opted to reduce the number of fields it uses to bring down the cost. Southern Football has budgeted a loss of $58,000 this financial period but that may double, McGowan said. The association cannot keep absorbing the costs. McGowan said he was going to have to have an awkward conversation with one club about its ongoing financial viability. It could lead to the club closing. He declined to say which one. Nation said the problem was widespread. "I think clubs are really having to have those conversations about their financials and how do we make sure that we are viable." Fewer volunteers The burden of helping bridge the gap between rising expenses and revenue often falls to volunteers, who are in dwindling supply. "They're there for the love of the sport and helping people out and not for the rewrite of their constitution and chasing up funding all the time," Nation said. "It's not a recipe for a great future. "I think there's a really core pool of volunteers that most clubs have. They may be ageing. "They may be struggling to bring people in. But I think the good clubs out there have got good structures in place, and they look after their volunteers, and they're doing well. "So it seems like for the level of people that are playing, it is pretty healthy across the board in Otago. "But I think there is a bit of a tipping point there ... and it's not going to take much to turn it to being a bit of an exodus." It is a gloomy assessment that Nation walked back a little by adding he does not believe the volunteer base has thinned as much in Otago as in other parts of the country. McGowan had similar thoughts. "We've got a very strong group of volunteers, some of them with considerable experience, who do an amazing job. And it's a big job now. "It's not like it used to be, where you'd just turn up on a Saturday and put the nets up. "They are running large organisations which have large cash flows. "We know our volunteers are required to do more and more, and it almost becomes like a second job for many of them. "I think it's got harder and harder, so I think we will start to see an impact on that pretty soon." Kinley said referee and coaching numbers were holding, but they did not keep statistics on overall volunteer numbers. "I would say that what I've found over the years, and this is a general comment, is that we tend to follow the things that happen in other areas of the country. "While we're holding OK, it's certainly an area that we need to focus on. I don't want us to see us following what the rest of the country has done."
Otago Daily Times
15 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Amend away, amend away
Dunedin Labour MP Rachel Brooking has run a few marathons in her time, and she put in another long-distance effort in the House this week. She wasn't keeping count, but by my tally she delivered 31 speeches this week — and it would have been 32 but for her having to leave for the airport on Thursday afternoon to catch the last convenient flight home. As would be expected, it was the Resource Management Act which dominated Brooking's week, although she also found the time to delve into the inner workings of the Local Government (Water Services) Bill, and the Hauraki Gulf / Tīkapa Moana Marine Protection Bill as well. It was the Resource Management (Consenting and Other System Changes) Amendment Bill which kept Brooking going for most of the week though. The relevant minister, Chris Bishop, has been labouring with a heavy cold all week and his heart must have sunk as Brooking — armed with pens, post-it notes and slabs of drafts and amendment papers — rose to her feet on Tuesday afternoon. Parliament is blessed with many MPs who can pick the minutest bone with any word or sentence — the Greens' Lawrence Xu-Nan and Bishop himself when in Opposition spring to mind — but few are as forensic and diligent as Brooking when it comes to working through clauses and sub-clauses. And she had plenty of material, the minister having just that morning tabled a substantial amendment paper. So substantial, in fact, that what Brooking suspected had happened was that the version of the Bill reported back from select committee — and not as yet agreed to by Parliament — had been used as the template for the soon to be amended again Bill. "This is a terrible way to make laws," Brooking lamented. "It's very frustrating, when you have been through a select committee process and have asked about the wording of different phrases and made amendments in the select committee process, to see that all upended on the day of the committee stage of the Bill." Bishop, to his credit, was somewhat repentant about that: "In mitigation, most of the changes in the Amendment Paper have been publicly announced, in some cases, a couple of months, if not earlier, than today. So members have had a good opportunity to kick those issues around." As it turned out, they were about to do a lot more kicking ... and not without good reason, as the Bill — now an Act — attempted to achieve a heck of a lot within its many pages. The much-criticised RMA is due to be axed next year: in the meantime the Amendment Act makes a many short-term changes to time frames for consent processing in areas such as infrastructure, renewable energy, farming and consenting after natural disaster. It is very broad in some places and narrowly specific in others — such as allowing the demolition of Wellington's Gordon Wilson flats and allowing Auckland to develop land around its railway stations. A lot of this is reasonable, Brooking agreed, in her third reading speech. "Labour was supporting this Bill when it was introduced and even at the second reading, despite having concerns about some of the changes that were made at select committee," she said. "But something happened on Tuesday morning. That was that a very large Amendment Paper was dropped and it made significant changes to the Bill. Changes that we were not even able to debate in this House because government members chose to stand up and close the debate on these very important aspects." Brooking then proceeded to give the government a stern and emotional telling off for its terrible law making ... none of which was enough to stop it being passed by lunchtime Thursday. Best supporting actor Taieri Green list MP Scott Willis also deserves an honorable mention in despatches for his efforts this week. Not only did he put his shoulder to the wheel with a succession of interventions on the aforementioned RMA Bill, he also had a crack at Science minister Shane Reti during Question Time on Thursday concerning job losses in the sector. Answering Willis' question about how many jobs had been lost in the sector since the formation of the government, Reti conceded that 134 jobs were to go with the disestablishment of Callaghan Innovation — the point that Willis was trying to make — but Reti also highlighted a Stats NZ survey which suggested a recent increase of people working in the sector. Which is not the same as jobs being lost, a point Willis soon made ... as well as pointedly asking if those laid-off scientists would be heading to the airport departure lounge post-haste. "I think that scientists who have been disestablished through part of the reforms will have a skill set that will be able to be applied in other parts of the science sector," Reti replied — which is true, but which also side-stepped the question of in which country's science sector that might be.
