Tax shortfall exceeds Rs1 trillion
The salaried class was the most affected segment that paid a record Rs437 billion in taxes till April, which were 52%, or Rs150 billion, more than last year. photo: FILE
Listen to article
The shortfall in tax collection widened to an alarmingly high level of Rs1.03 trillion in just 11 months of the current fiscal year despite imposing record new taxes in the budget, taking advances, withdrawing money from people's bank accounts and blocking refunds of companies and individuals.
Only in May, the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) faced a mammoth shortfall of Rs205 billion despite paying 5.3% less refunds compared to last year. The embarrassing outcome brings into question the government's strategy of collecting taxes from the already burdened classes and sectors of the economy.
One of the reasons for missing the monthly target by a wide margin is no new recovery of arrears in litigation cases, which both the government and the FBR had promised to recover through expeditious settlement of the cases.
The FBR provisionally collected Rs10.21 trillion from July through May of the current fiscal year, falling short of the target by Rs1.03 trillion, according to its statistics. The collection was still around 28%, or Rs2.2 trillion, higher than the previous fiscal year, but not enough to stay on track.
The key reasons behind the higher collection compared to last year were the imposition of more taxes in budget, particularly on the salaried class and corporate sector, and expansion of sales tax net to many untaxed areas. Yet the FBR missed the target by Rs1.03 trillion.
The FBR did not respond to a request for comment till the filing of the story.
The shortfall is far more than what the government committed in talks with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) in March this year, when the lender lowered the target by Rs640 billion for the full fiscal year.
In a meeting of the National Assembly Standing Committee on Finance on Thursday, PPP MNA Mirza Ikhtiar Baig said that the FBR illegally recovered money from multiple bank accounts in Karachi to meet its targets. Moreover, Utopia Industry, one of the top 12 exporters, is struggling to get Rs3 billion in refunds, a situation many industries are facing despite official claims of clearing refunds within 72 hours.
Details showed that in May the FBR paid Rs2 billion, or 5.3%, less refunds compared to the same month of last year. Total refund payments in 11 months reached hardly Rs458 billion, higher by just 1.1% and not in commensuration with the 28% rise in tax collection.
The salaried class was the most affected segment that paid a record Rs437 billion in taxes till April, which were 52%, or Rs150 billion, more than last year.
For May, the FBR's tax target was Rs1.1 trillion. However, despite taking advances and slowing refunds, it could collect Rs907 billion. The monthly collection was Rs271 billion, or 43%, more than last year, which a senior FBR official said was commendable in the current circumstances.
The IMF forced the country to impose new taxes, primarily burdening the salaried class and levying taxes on nearly all consumable goods, including medical tests, stationery, vegetables and children's milk.
For the July-May period, the FBR missed its targets for sales tax, federal excise duty (FED) and customs duty but again exceeded the income tax target on the back of overburdening the salaried class.
Income tax collection amounted to Rs4.9 trillion during the first 11 months of the current fiscal year, higher by Rs296 billion from the target. It was also Rs1.1 trillion more than last year. The burden was shared by the salaried class and the corporate sector as retailers and landlords remained under-taxed.
Sales tax collection stood at Rs3.5 trillion, a whopping Rs900 billion less than the target of Rs4.4 trillion. Sales tax remained the most difficult area for the FBR and one of the reasons for the low collection was less-than-estimated growth in large industries. The government had immensely increased the sales tax burden in the budget. The collection was Rs755 billion higher than last year.
The FBR collected Rs672 billion in FED, which was Rs166 billion less than the target. However, it was Rs180 billion higher than last year. The government did not spare homes, lubricants, fruit juices, cement, sugar, etc from FED in the last budget. Yet it failed to meet the target.
Customs duty collection stood at Rs1.16 trillion, below target by Rs265 billion. The collection was hit by lower-than-projected import volumes. It was also marred by the manipulation of goods declaration forms by importers in connivance with the corrupt elements. The amount was Rs172 billion higher than last year.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
5 hours ago
- Business Recorder
PARTLY FACETIOUS: Why did FBR Chairman cancel usual press conference after budget speech?
'A universal rule prevails: lessons need not be learned if they go counter to a declared strategy.' 'I would have you know I do learn lessons - if my strategy is not working, I adjust….' 'I was not referring to a common person like you, but politicians.' 'OK but do the selected qualify as politicians?' 'Of course, once you jump into the cesspit, the cesspit owns you.' 'You haven't heard of any successful rescue missions that have extracted individuals from the cesspit?' 'Not in the cesspit of politics. Anyway, if you were referring to the Budget presented on Tuesday being the same o same o, then let me assure you that the numbers game was won even more conclusively this time, almost as conclusively as the West was won.' 'Pretty dated comment, isn't it.' 'I don't understand…' 'Today the West does not bring to mind cowboys but refers to a US- led alliance which we are wooing or trying to woo and…' 'China will have to change its immigration and investment laws and….' 'Shut up, the Finance Minister said that the FBR collected 390 billion rupees from enforcement measures and next fiscal year would bring in much more and…' 'So then, why did the FBR Chairman cancel the usual press conference after the budget speech?' 'He must have developed a medical condition, but nonetheless I would urge the Finance Minister to verify it as he then over-exposed himself by giving interviews on several channels. A word of advice: give interviews after the post budget press conference.' 'That's the politician's way - any opportunity for exposure even if it goes into the realm of over exposure must be seized with both…both…' 'Hands?' 'I would go a step further, seize the opportunity with all limbs. Anyway, when I said lessons are not learned by politicians I wasn't referring to the locals but to Western politicians. Ursula von der Leyen announced the eighteenth sanction package against Russia. Shouldn't someone ask her what she reckons the eighteenth would achieve if the first seventeen did not work? Russia's growth was over 4 percent in 2024 while that of all Europeans countries floundered…' 'The number 18 brings to mind the intent to levy a tax on the traders.' 'Or the attempt to actually cut government expenditure instead of relying on a lower discount rate to reduce outlay.' 'As I said, politicians never abandon a strategy no matter how many times it fails.' Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
5 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Retail sector woes prompt tax on digital platforms: FBR
ISLAMABAD: Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) Chairman Rashid Mahmood Langrial Wednesday said tax has been imposed on digital platforms after serious concerns of formal retail sector paying sales tax as well as income tax on sales of goods. During post-budget press conference held on Wednesday, the FBR chairman clarified that 2.5 per cent tax would be applicable on income slab between Rs600,000 and Rs1.2 million under revised salary slabs. The tax rate of one per cent has been mentioned in the Finance Bill 2025-26. Taxing the digital frontier: Pakistan's bold move to tap e-commerce and online revenues Over Rs100 billion worth digital invoicing sales have been reported to the FBR. Sales through digital invoicing needs strong deterrence under self-assessment scheme. The integration of sales tax registered persons has been started through authorised integrators including Pakistan Revenue Automation Limited (PRAL). The FBR chairman stated that the country is moving towards digital economy. Formal retail sector is paying all kinds of taxes as compared to undocumented online companies engaged in selling of goods and paying no taxes. All Pakistan Retail Association has complaint to the FBR that the market of the documented sector has been at the verge of collapse due to informal sector. They are at a disadvantage of paying 18 per cent sales tax as compared to informal sector. The level playing field has been restored through the Finance Bill. Two percent tax of gross value of supplies would be applicable on persons supplying digitally ordered goods from within Pakistan through online market place, website and software applications. The FBR chairman stated that the board has included all taxable activities to incorporate digitally ordered taxable goods into the e-commerce sales tax framework. Presently, online marketplaces are required to withhold one percent sales tax on local supplies made by non-active taxpayer vendors. However, this does not fully capture the growing e-commerce sector, especially businesses using websites, apps, etc, for online sales to consumers. To address this, the withholding tax scope has been expanded to cover transactions settled via online payment or CoD. Under the proposed regime, payment intermediaries (banks, financial institutions, exchange companies, and payment gateways) will collect sales tax on digital payments, while couriers will handle tax collection for CoD transactions. Additionally, the withholding tax rate is set to increase from one per cent to two per cent. Under the Finance Bill 2025, in the case of supply of digitally ordered goods by online market place, website and software application from within Pakistan during the course of e-commerce, the liability tocollect and pay tax shall be of payment intermediary including a banking company, a financial institution, licensed exchange company or payment gateway in case the payment is made digitally and of the courier delivering the goods where those are supplied on Cash on Delivery (CoD) basis at the rates provided in the Eleventh Schedule. The FBR chairman also stated that sales tax has been imposed on the import of solar panels to create an enabling environment for domestic manufacturing industry. The FBR Member Inland Revenue (Policy) stated that domestic e-commerce covers a number of e-stores operating outside the formal banking system. They sell goods through Bykea and websites. The FBR has chalked out a domestic e-commerce framework for small and medium businesses selling goods through websites or online. A simple regime has been introduced for payment of tax through couriers and banks with final discharge of tax liability. The FBR Member said that four items have been included in the Third Schedule of the Sales Tax Act to check under-invoicing on the import of chocolates, pet food and imported cereal bars in retail packing. The FBR chairman stated that the non-profit organisations would go through strict scrutiny under the Finance Bill 2025-26. The FBR has laid down very strict conditions for the NPOs for availing exemption. Now the NPOs have to prove that they are not engaged in commercial activities. In future, we would review performance and scrutinise NPOs. Pointing out that globally non-profit organisations were not subjected to tax measures, Langrial said, 'No organisation will be exempt from scrutiny in the future.' Under the Finance Bill 2025-26, the FBR has listed entities granted complete exemption on any income and exemption subject to Section 100C provision respectively have been merged. Now all entities require approval under Section 100C to be declared as non-profit organisation and availing exemption against income. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
5 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Post-budget press briefing: Govt warns of Rs500bn more revenue steps
ISLAMABAD: Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb on Wednesday warned that additional revenue measures of up to Rs 500 billion would be taken next fiscal year, if enabling amendments and legislation on enforcement were not passed by parliament, adding that all the budget figures were locked with the International Monetary Fund (IMF). This he stated while addressing the post-budget press briefing which began with journalists from the independent media staging a walkout in protest against the Federal Board of Revenue's failure to provide the traditional technical briefing on the Finance Bill 2025-26 after the budget speech. Finance Minister flanked by FBR Chairman Rashid Mehmood Langrial and Secretary Finance continued the post-budget press briefing despite the boycott. Budget 2025-26: Pakistan targets 4.2% growth as Aurangzeb presents proposals 'for a competitive economy' Information Minister Ataullah Tarar was summoned to clear the air with the protesting journalists who tendered an apology with the assurance that the technical briefing would be held prompting independent journalists to end their boycott and rejoin the press conference after more than half an hour. The minister said, strengthened enforcement mechanisms have helped the federal government generate over Rs400 billion in additional revenues this fiscal year. He noted that while international stakeholders had previously doubted Pakistan's ability to implement tax laws effectively, the government had demonstrated that meaningful enforcement is possible. He said, tax-to-GDP ratio was projected to reach 10.4 percent this year and to 10.9 percent in fiscal year 2025-26. Of the Rs2.2 trillion targeted in overall revenue, only Rs312 billion is expected from new taxes, with the remainder stemming automatically from growth and enforcement. 'We have two ways — either we ensure enforcement or we introduce additional measures of up to Rs 400 to 500 billion. This is why we will go to the parliament to help us out with the enabling amendments and legislation,' said the minister, adding that they needed enabling amendments and legislation to plug leakages in the system. The minister further said that laws, legislation and taxes were there but there is lack of enforcement. 'The things that had never been reversed before have now been put into reversal, but that's not the eventual end state,' said the minister adding that the segments that have been subjected to undue burden, whether it's the formal sector, the beneficiary sector, the salaried class, the government should at least acknowledge that it is cognizant of their problems and that it will deal with those as soon as fiscal space is created. Talking about a 10 percent surcharge on electricity bills, FBR Chairman clarified that no additional surcharge has been imposed so far. Replying to a question regarding the federal government's plan to potentially delink population from the National Finance Commission (NFC) award, Finance Minister stated, 'everything will be done in consultation with the provinces including the national fiscal pact which was signed with the provinces. The provinces are projected to receive a record Rs8.2 trillion from the federal divisible tax pool in the upcoming fiscal year.' The minister termed tariff rationalization as a 'major and important step' in aligning Pakistan's trade and industrial policy with global standards. The initiative, he said, marks the beginning of a phased plan towards a simplified tariff regime, ultimately targeting an average tariff rate of just over 4 per cent. 'Overall, there are 7,000 tariff lines. Additional customs duty has been removed on 4,000 lines, and in 2,700 of those, the customs duty has also been reduced,' the finance minister stated. 'Of these, around 2,000 tariff lines are directly linked to raw materials and intermediary goods used by exporters. This is a structural reform that has not been undertaken in the past 30 years. This is a huge step, and we are committed to taking it forward gradually', Aurangzeb added. The government's broader goal, according to Aurangzeb, is to reshape Pakistan's tariff architecture in a way that supports industrial growth and integrates the economy more deeply into global supply chains. Highlighting the significance of the policy shift, Aurangzeb said the reduction and elimination of customs duties on thousands of tariff lines will enable more efficient allocation of both capital and human resources within the economy. The reforms are designed to gradually replace import substitution with export promotion, a pivot the government considers essential for addressing Pakistan's recurring balance of payments crises and dollar liquidity pressures. He said that the government has offered as much relief as possible to the salaried class within the constraints of available fiscal space. 'This is the direction of travel, where do we want to take the salaried class. Different slabs, including at the highest levels, have been carefully considered. From both my perspective and the Prime Minister's, we provided as much relief as the fiscal space allows,' Aurangzeb said. He said the minimum wage would remain at its current level, Rs37,000, adding that it should be viewed in the context of inflation. 'Go to the industries and get their feedback on minimum wage. I think we are in a good place,' he asserted. Responding to criticism over salary hikes, the finance minister said, 'If we talk about raising salaries of government employees, then ministers' salaries should also be reviewed.' He pointed out that the salaries of the Senate chairman, deputy chairman, National Assembly speaker, and deputy speaker were recently increased. When questioned about whether their salaries had been raised from Rs250,000 to Rs2.15 million per month, the minister remarked that the focus should be on when ministers, ministers of state, and parliamentarians last received a salary adjustment. 'The cabinet ministers' salaries were last increased in 2016. If a salary raise had been made annually, the recent hike would not seem so high,' he explained. He also pointed to the phased reduction of the super tax on mid-sized corporations as part of the government's commitment to improving the business climate. 'Even if it's just a 0.5 percent reduction, it sends an important signal to the market,' Aurangzeb contended. The government, he said, announced a series of targeted reforms in the construction and agriculture sectors aimed at reducing transaction costs, supporting affordable housing, and ensuring credit access for small farmers. While overall tax liability has not been reduced, the government restructured the system to lower transaction costs, particularly for buyers, he claimed. To a question, the minister said, the increases in salaries and pensions were directly linked to the headline inflation, Consumer Price Index (CPI), ensuring adjustments reflect inflationary pressures. Aurangzeb said that pensions would now be linked to a Contributory Based Index (CBI) to ensure long-term sustainability. 'Worldwide, pensions and salaries are adjusted with inflation. We are adopting the same principle,' he added. Replying to a question regarding the contributory system for armed forces, Secretary Finance said that meetings were held with Defence Ministry in this regard, however, it was agreed that they could not be treated the same way on account of different terms of retirement period. Aurangzeb said no tax has been levied on fertilizers and pesticides which was negotiated with the IMF on the directions of Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif as the administration regards these items as critical inputs for agriculture. 'Agriculture has been, and will remain, the backbone of our economy,' he said, adding that greater federal policy coordination is needed on devolved subjects like seed technology, mechanization, and agri-financing. He pointed to a modest 1.9 percent rise in government expenditure, crediting prudent financial management and stated that despite inflation, the government managed to contain subsidies and reduce debt servicing, while selectively increasing spending, where necessary, for national priorities. Aurangzeb stressed on the need to end protectionism, increase productivity and reduce the price of raw materials so that not only textiles but every exporting sector benefits. Responding to a question the finance minister said that the first installment of Eurobonds worth $500 million was due in September, while the next was due in March. 'We are prepared and willing to pay', he added. The minister reiterated his hopes of Pakistan launching yuan-denominated Panda bonds this year, adding that credit enhancement through the Asian Development Bank and the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank was in progress. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
