Review condemns Taranaki Regional Council Treaty Principles Bill decision-making
Taranaki Regional Council
An internal review has condemned the Taranaki Regional Council's handling of its decision not to make a submission on the Treaty Principles Bill and not to debate the matter.
It found the December 2024 decision-making process inconsistent with standing orders, meeting protocols and broader principles of good governance, transparency and natural justice.
There was evidence of pre-meeting discussion and agreement among councillors
to oppose making a submission and to curtail debate
, which contributed to a perception of predetermination and bias.
The handling of a related deputation by New Plymouth District councillor Dinnie Moeahu also fell short of the expected standard of engagement and caused offence.
Dinnie Moeahu
Photo:
Supplied
Chief executive Steve Ruru undertook the
Council Conduct Review
which made a raft of recommendations to improve decision-making and rebuild trust with iwi.
He found the consequences of the December 2024 meeting "were severe, as it damaged the Council's reputation, resulted in a loss of trust and confidence in the elected Council from iwi partners and strained internal relationships".
Council chair Craig Williamson welcomed the recommendations in the report.
"It has been a challenging period for everyone and as a council we have taken time to reflect on what happened and how we can be better moving forward.
"This review has identified constructive ways we can do that, and I am confident the council will be stronger as a result."
Ruru's review looked at what happened before, during and after the meeting as well as the surrounding circumstances and processes.
"Important lessons have been learned and the report includes several key recommendations that the council will consider at its 5 August meeting.
"Firstly, it endorses the decision the council made in February to apologise to Mr Moeahu, the Taranaki community and councillors who were denied the opportunity to speak."
It recommended training and professional development for councillors on Te Tiriti o Waitangi and its application to the council's work, mātauranga Māori and tikanga of iwi in Taranaki.
It also recommended structured training around standing orders and meeting procedures, to ensure these were clear and consistently applied.
Ruru said the tight timeframe for submitting on the Bill meant it could not go before the Policy and Planning Committee first as it usually would.
His report said the draft submission should have instead been emailed to committee members for comment - even though that might not have changed the outcome.
It also recommended the council make greater use of additional meetings outside the set meeting cycle where necessary.
Transparency and public input were also areas for improvement with a recommendation that all council and committee meetings be held in venues where they can be livestreamed and recorded.
Ruru said his focus was now firmly on the future and the start of a new triennium after October's election was an opportunity for a fresh start.
"I have recommended practical steps for the incoming council to consider as well as learning opportunities for councillors. I have also looked at where council officers and I can provide more support and advice to elected members.
"When councillors meet after the election, they have the opportunity to implement better procedures, increase their understanding of Treaty and iwi issues and start the mahi to repair relationships and regain the full confidence of our community."
Ruru wanted to report to the new council on options for allowing greater public input at meetings.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
2 hours ago
- Scoop
Fix Auckland Announces Strong Candidates For Albany Ward: Victoria Short And Gary Brown To Drive Practical Change
Fix Auckland, led by Mayor Wayne Brown is committed to delivering tangible results for Auckland and fixing the Auckland Council. Wayne Brown is pleased to announce two formidable candidates for the Albany Ward: Victoria Short and Gary Brown. Albany Ward residents can be confident that Victoria and Gary will be strong, effective voices at the Council table. 'Both individuals bring a wealth of experience and a commitment to sound financial management. With their deep understanding of local community needs, they embodyg the "Fix Auckland" ethos of practical, accountable governance. 'The Albany Ward would be well served by Gary Brown and Victoria Short as their Councillors. Their combined experience and dedication to transparent, results-focused leadership perfectly align with Fix Auckland's mission. 'They the importance of fixing our infrastructure, supporting local businesses, and ensuring every ratepayer dollar delivers real value.' Says Wayne Brown. Victoria Short said 'Residents can expect a team that stands firmly for accountability, transparency, and results. One committed to elevating the voices of everyday Aucklanders and are focused on ensuring that every dollar is accounted for." Gary Brown said "As a team we bring a powerful message of transformation, accountability, and community-first governance to Auckland Council. We have a shared vision to reshape how the council operates and we want to ensure that the ratepayer is at the forefront of every financial decision we make.' Biographies Victoria Short brings a decade of experience navigating local and central government, ensuring she knows "how to get things done." As a trained accountant, Victoria will bring scrutiny to financial decision-making and Council spending, driving value for every dollar. Her focus is on transparent, accountable decision-making, with a commitment to fixing infrastructure, supporting local businesses, and improving community services. A dedicated volunteer trustee for Life Education North Shore, Victoria is deeply invested in youth and community well-being. She is committed to listening to residents, fixing what's broken, and fiercely advocating for East Coast Bays, Hibiscus Coast, and Upper Harbour, working constructively with fellow Councillors to cut waste and drive progress for Auckland. Gary Brown, a proven local leader, is currently the Deputy Chair of the Hibiscus and Bays Local Board and a local businessman. He has consistently championed community projects and delivered results. With over 30 years of deep roots in the community, including extensive involvement with North Harbour Rugby and the Silverdale Rugby Club, Gary possesses a profound understanding of the Albany Ward's diverse needs. Gary advocates for locals, wise investment in infrastructure to create a thriving, world-class Auckland. His common-sense approach prioritises empowering local boards, embracing innovation, and ensuring transparent, accountable leadership for better services and value for money. Fix Auckland believes that Victoria Short and Gary Brown will be powerful advocates for the Albany Ward, working tirelessly to ensure the Council focuses on essential services, fiscal responsibility, and tangible improvements for residents.
Newsroom
5 hours ago
- Newsroom
Geothermal Strategy can be catalyst for transformational change
Opinion: The launch of the Government's draft Geothermal Strategy, 'From the Ground Up – a draft strategy to unlock New Zealand's geothermal potential', a first for our country, is a watershed moment. It signals that geothermal energy is no longer the quiet achiever in our energy system – the revived focus on its potential recognises that geothermal can be central to our national vision for a sustainable, resilient, and economically empowered future. We have worked in the geothermal sector with engineers, scientists, Māori trusts, and industry leaders for decades, here and globally, and it's clear his strategy is welcomed with enthusiasm and optimism. The direction is right. The language is ambitious. And the need is urgent. At the Geothermal Institute at the University of Auckland, we see this as more than a policy milestone – it's a long-awaited catalyst for transformational change. Hearing Ministers Shane Jones, Louise Upston and Shane Reti tell it, educating our young people and providing compelling career opportunities in geothermal needs to be at the heart of it. The importance of signals One of the most powerful aspects of the strategy is what it signals: that geothermal matters. That it has a future that can rival its storied past. That government sees the long-term opportunity and is willing to put its weight behind it. That's no small thing. As any developer or technology innovator will tell you, long-term certainty is the foundation of long-term investment. This strategy builds on tangible commitments already made – particularly in the Government's investment to accelerate research-backed supercritical geothermal technology development. This technology aims to harness extremely high-temperature fluids from deep underground to generate renewable energy more efficiently than conventional geothermal technology. That backing will keep New Zealand at the forefront of technology to tap ultra-hot geothermal fluids to produce radically more energy per well. This is complex science and engineering with high stakes and high rewards. If we get this right, we not only unlock more clean energy, but also more industrial process heat, more energy-dense sites, and more export opportunities for our solidified globally leading expertise. The ripple effects for regional economic development are significant: the creation of highly skilled, highly paid jobs in engineering, geoscience, subsurface modelling, advanced manufacturing and programme and environmental management in regions including Taupō, Kawerau and Rotorua, from Northland to the Central Volcanic Plateau. The students at the Geothermal Institute will be the first to tell you: these are real jobs that future-proof careers and bolster local economies. From field to frontier – the role of innovation, research and education Geothermal is a mature sector, but it's also a frontier sector. What struck me at the New Zealand Geothermal Week in Taupō this year wasn't just the technical excellence on display, but the dynamism. I had conversations with rangatahi curious about career pathways, with iwi-led developers eyeing up direct heat projects, with engineering consultants pitching AI-assisted reservoir models, and with international visitors in awe of the collaborative NZ Inc spirit in the room. Future skills were a strong emerging theme throughout, where the message was loud and clear: the sector is hungry for talent, and young people are hungry for purpose. We need to meet them in the middle – with curriculum pathways, internship pipelines, scholarships targeting local communities and a long-term commitment to Stem education throughout the education value chain. But building a globally competitive innovation pipeline requires sustained support. Training world-class geoscientists and engineers doesn't happen overnight. It needs the right investment and long-term partnerships. And to meet the Government's ambition to double geothermal energy use by 2040 will require scaling up education and training. That's why the strategy's success will ultimately rest not only on the high-level vision of geothermal growth, but also what sits behind it to fuel that growth. Reinforcing New Zealand's global leadership New Zealand already enjoys a stellar reputation in geothermal internationally. Our engineers and consultants are in demand in Southeast Asia, East Africa, North America, Latin America, the Pacific, Europe and beyond. Our training programmes and postgraduate education programmes have produced alumni who now lead geothermal policy development, regulation, production and scientific research on every continent. This strategy, if paired with smart investment and coordinated delivery, could elevate that leadership to the next level. We could be the first country to commercialise supercritical geothermal knowhow. We could be the global centre for geothermal workforce training, standards and certification. We could supercharge the export of integrated geothermal solutions, from power plant designs and drilling capability to stakeholder partnering frameworks, carbon capture innovations, critical minerals extraction, cutting-edge digital modelling and real-time assessment tools, and more. This is the soft power of geothermal – and it's rooted in decades of practical excellence, technical ingenuity, and manaakitanga. A call to action The Government's draft Geothermal Strategy establishes a clear framework for the growth of geothermal. At the launch this week, ministers set a challenge for our geothermal community to turn it into a bold, coherent vision for the future. The geothermal sector is ready – meeting challenges is what we do.
Scoop
6 hours ago
- Scoop
Review Condemns Taranaki Regional Council Treaty Principles Bill Decision-Making
, Taranaki Whanganui regional correspondent An internal review has condemned the Taranaki Regional Council's handling of its decision not to make a submission on the Treaty Principles Bill and not to debate the matter. It found the December 2024 decision-making process inconsistent with standing orders, meeting protocols and broader principles of good governance, transparency and natural justice. There was evidence of pre-meeting discussion and agreement among councillors to oppose making a submission and to curtail debate, which contributed to a perception of predetermination and bias. The handling of a related deputation by New Plymouth District councillor Dinnie Moeahu also fell short of the expected standard of engagement and caused offence. Chief executive Steve Ruru undertook the Council Conduct Review which made a raft of recommendations to improve decision-making and rebuild trust with iwi. He found the consequences of the December 2024 meeting "were severe, as it damaged the Council's reputation, resulted in a loss of trust and confidence in the elected Council from iwi partners and strained internal relationships". Council chair Craig Williamson welcomed the recommendations in the report. "It has been a challenging period for everyone and as a council we have taken time to reflect on what happened and how we can be better moving forward. "This review has identified constructive ways we can do that, and I am confident the council will be stronger as a result." Ruru's review looked at what happened before, during and after the meeting as well as the surrounding circumstances and processes. "Important lessons have been learned and the report includes several key recommendations that the council will consider at its 5 August meeting. "Firstly, it endorses the decision the council made in February to apologise to Mr Moeahu, the Taranaki community and councillors who were denied the opportunity to speak." It recommended training and professional development for councillors on Te Tiriti o Waitangi and its application to the council's work, mātauranga Māoriand tikanga of iwi in Taranaki. It also recommended structured training around standing orders and meeting procedures, to ensure these were clear and consistently applied. Ruru said the tight timeframe for submitting on the Bill meant it could not go before the Policy and Planning Committee first as it usually would. His report said the draft submission should have instead been emailed to committee members for comment - even though that might not have changed the outcome. It also recommended the council make greater use of additional meetings outside the set meeting cycle where necessary. Transparency and public input were also areas for improvement with a recommendation that all council and committee meetings be held in venues where they can be livestreamed and recorded. Ruru said his focus was now firmly on the future and the start of a new triennium after October's election was an opportunity for a fresh start. "I have recommended practical steps for the incoming council to consider as well as learning opportunities for councillors. I have also looked at where council officers and I can provide more support and advice to elected members. "When councillors meet after the election, they have the opportunity to implement better procedures, increase their understanding of Treaty and iwi issues and start the mahi to repair relationships and regain the full confidence of our community." Ruru wanted to report to the new council on options for allowing greater public input at meetings.
