Call centre worker loses unfair dimissal case over abusive language on open phone line
Bosses at Infosys BPM Ltd concluded the worker, Colleen Lonergan, jeopardised a 'valuable' client contract and committed gross misconduct when she was heard to remark 'what a f***ing b***h' by the customer last year, the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) heard.
In a decision just published, the employment tribunal has rejected a series of statutory complaints against the firm by Ms Lonergan, including claims under the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977 and the Employment Equality Act 1998.
Ms Lonergan told the WRC the phrase was intended to 'describe the situation rather than the customer', the tribunal noted.
READ MORE
'The problem is that the customer heard it and took it to be a direct reference to her,' a WRC adjudicator wrote.
It happened during a 'particularly difficult' call on in June last year, when Ms Lonergan said she had been 'on the phone for an hour and 45 minutes without help', the tribunal noted.
Ms Lonergan's evidence was that she 'thought the call was on hold'.
Adjudication officer Penelope McGrath wrote in her decision that, by the time the case came before her, the tape of the call that had been reviewed in a company investigation had been wiped.
'There does not seem to be any doubt that the complainant used the word 'b***h' while on the call,' the adjudicator wrote. She noted the sworn evidence of the company investigator, a junior operations manager, that the phrase used was: 'What a f***ing b***h.'
'I understand that the tape was played in the course of the investigation and disciplinary process and that there was, at that time, no dispute that the language which was used was unacceptable,' Ms McGrath wrote.
The adjudicator wrote that it was to Ms Lonergan's credit that she 'owned her mistake immediately' and raised it with the team leader.
Ms Lonergan was allowed to keep working for a number of days while a disciplinary process took its course in early July 2024, but was 'marched out of the building' upon her dismissal in what the adjudicator considered to be 'regrettable' circumstances.
Ms Lonergan, had also advanced a complaint of workplace discrimination against her former employer, referenced absences from work owing to health trouble on one occasion, and 'a breakdown crying at work over home issues and bad calls from customers' on another.
'I was continually harassed about taking too long coming back from toilet and breaks even though I was struggling with my various health issues,' Ms Lonergan wrote in a letter to the WRC.
'It's my belief that when I made the mistake on the call… the company took full opportunity to terminate my employment because of my ongoing health issues,' she added.
The company's position was that there was 'no substance whatsoever to these allegations', the WRC noted.
Addressing the disability discrimination element of the claim, the adjudicator wrote that she did not form the impression that Ms Lonergan's team leader had to 'chivvy' her along from bathroom and smoke breaks any 'more or less' than other staff.
'I note there were never any disciplinary issues around timekeeping and must assume that the team leader was simply doing her job,' Ms McGrath wrote.
'The respondent's position is that the claimant's behaviour in calling a customer a 'f***ing b***h' on a recorded call was completely unacceptable in the workplace, constitutes gross misconduct and warranted dismissal,' its representative Muireann McEnery submitted.
Referencing this in her decision on the unfair dismissal claim, Ms McGrath wrote: 'I approve the respondent position as set out in the submission received.'
She dismissed both the unfair dismissal and the disability discrimination complaints, along with further claims by Ms Lonergan under the Organisation of Working Time Act 1997, the Terms of Employment (Information) Act 1994, and the Payment of Wages Act 1991 and the Minimum Notice and Terms of Employment Act 1973.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
20 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Robert Dunne, son of former supermarket tycoon Ben Dunne, dies in New York
The death has taken place of Robert Dunne, son of the former head of Dunnes Stores, the late Ben Dunne. Mr Dunne, who was 50, died peacefully in New York on August 1st. He is to be buried on Monday in Castleknock Churchyard, Dublin, following a Requiem Mass at St Mochta's Church, Porterstown, Clonsilla. The Brehon Law Society of New York, where Mr Dunne worked as a lawyer, said it was with 'deep respect and remembrance' that it heard of the death of its President Emeritus. 'Rob's unwavering dedication to justice, his leadership within the Brehon Law Society, and his enduring commitment to the Irish-American legal community leave a lasting impression,' it said, announcing that a month's mind Mass is to be held in New York on September 4th. READ MORE Mr Dunne grew up in Castleknock, Co Dublin, attended Trinity College Dublin and the London School of Economics, worked in Dunnes Stores in the Ilac Centre, Dublin, and later moved to the US to work as a lawyer. He is survived by his mother, Mary, siblings Mark, Caroline and Nicholas, and wider family. Condolences posted on recalled his time in Castleknock, at Trinity, in the Ilac Centre, and in the US. 'I lived in NYC for twenty years and attended many interesting legal events invited by Rob. His laughter was infectious and wit, second to none. May he rest in peace,' said Antoin, formerly of Manhattan. In a moving interview with The Sunday Independent last year Mr Dunne spoke about being the son of one of the State's top business figures and a man whose life was filled with extraordinary controversy. Among the events he recalled was his father being kidnapped by the Provisional IRA in 1981, being arrested in Florida in 1992 when having a panic attack after taking cocaine, and the way his mother stuck with her husband during the ensuing controversy and his father's continuing struggles with cocaine. 'I think my dad developed what we would now call PTSD and he needed counselling,' Mr Dunne said in respect of the effect of the kidnapping. The fallout from the events in Florida included an audit being commissioned of Dunnes Stores accounts, which led in time to revelations about payments to Michael Lowry and the late Charles Haughey, and the associated inquiries by the McCracken and Moriarty tribunals. Mr Dunne told the newspaper that it was the events in Florida and the fallout from them that led to his decision to study law. He eventually set up his own firm in New York. Asked what he would say to his father, who died in 2023, Mr Dunne said he would tell him he couldn't have had a better father. 'You made lots of mistakes, but you owned all of them. Please know that I am nothing but proud of you.'
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Social media algorithms are encouraging anti-migrant violence, says campaign group
Social media algorithms have boosted videos of attacks on asylum seekers and encouraged far-right agitators to engage in increasingly violent behaviour, a report from an antiracism group said. The Hope and Courage Collective (HCC) said that in recent years the focus has been on homeless asylum seekers, who regularly faced threats and attacks on their tents. The trend has coincided with the increasing number of male asylum seekers being forced to sleep rough due to a lack of state accommodation since 2023. There have been many instances of anti-immigration figures filming homeless men in recent years, including physical attacks and the slashing of asylum seekers' tents, READ MORE 'Each post increases in reach, and the more the creator leans into hateful, dehumanising narratives the more attention the content receives. The pattern is unmistakable: hate fuels growth,' the report said. In a 'snapshot' study, the group documented one far-right agitator uploading multiple videos of homeless asylum seekers to TikTok over a 10-day period, which gained increasing numbers of views. This culminated in the asylum seekers being threatened with arson and the destruction of their tents. The three Somali asylum seekers were targeted as they stayed in tents in Herbert Park in Ballsbridge, Dublin 4, last month . 'Between July 3rd and 13th we analysed and documented a campaign of harassment whose online presence and reach grew rapidly from a few thousand views to over 124,000. The user posted footage of men in tents, encouraging followers to identify locations. He eventually filmed himself slashing tents,' Niamh McDonald from the Hope and Courage Collective said. One incident was caught on video where a man can be heard saying: 'Get the f**k out now. I'll be back in 15 minutes and I am going to f**king burn them. I am going to ring fellas now and they are coming with dogs, dogs. You have 15 minutes to get the f**k out of here.' The antiracism campaign group said these tactics started in May 2023 after a group of homeless asylum seekers set up a camp in a laneway on Sandwith Street, Dublin city centre. Over five days the camp was repeatedly attacked, culminating in the tents being set on fire . Copycats soon began mirroring these tactics, particularly two new 'hate organisers' who began posting videos of homeless asylum seekers and racking up hundreds of thousands of views, the group said. 'Their tactics escalated over time as their videos featured explicit intimidation, verbal abuse and threats of violence towards men living in homeless encampments. They shared footage across TikTok, YouTube and X . The emotive content, shares, comments and likes grow their online audience,' it said. The same men have been involved in masked protests outside the homes of politicians, including the house of Simon Harris when he was taoiseach, and have been intimidating workers at sites they claimed were intended for international protection. Hope and Courage Collective said social media algorithms were 'one of the main causes in this escalation of violence' and it called for EU measures to combat systems which amplify violence and hatred. 'European Commissioner Michael McGrath has the opportunity to show brave political leadership and tackle online hate by turning off the harmful recommender system, a river of hate that promotes outrage and results in real world violence, as part of Europe's new Democracy Shield being developed right now,' Ms McDonald said.
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Transport authority approves settlement of Swords BusConnects corridor legal action
The board of the National Transport Authority (NTA) has approved a proposed settlement to halt legal action taken against its planned BusConnects corridor from Swords to Dublin city centre. The NTA would not disclose the terms of the settlement, but the board's approval raises hopes judicial review proceedings will be dropped to allow construction of the 12km route granted planning permission more than a year ago. The Swords corridor is one of 12 segregated bus routes to be built as part of the €4 billion scheme to transform the capital's bus services. The planned route runs from the south side of Swords town in north Dublin, past Dublin Airport and through Santry along the Swords Road, then along the Drumcondra Road and Dorset Street to the top of O'Connell Street and Parnell Square. READ MORE The NTA secured permission from An Bord Pleanála for the route in June of last year, but judicial review proceedings against the board's decision were initiated in August by two separate parties: owners of a business park near the airport and a veterinary practice south of Swords. The cases have not yet been heard in the High Court but in their submissions to An Bord Pleanála both Brendan Collins, of Collinstown Business Park, and Conor O'Scanaill, of O'Scanaill Veterinary Surgeons raised concerns about the effect the bus corridor would have on their properties. Minutes of a recent NTA board meeting show details of a 'settlement proposal' were presented to the board by interim NTA chief executive Hugh Creegan. 'Following the overview provided, the board approved the terms of the proposed agreement to settle the particular judicial reviews proceedings being taken in relation to the Swords to City Centre Core Bus Corridor scheme,' the minutes state. This is the first settlement approved by the board in an effort to bring an end to legal action taken against one of the bus corridor schemes. Of the 12 corridors, judicial review proceedings have been taken in relation to seven, the corridors from Swords, Clongriffin, Belfield/Blackrock, Blanchardstown, Templeogue/Rathfarnham, Bray and Kimmage. The other five now have 'full' planning permission as the time frame by which they could be challenged in the courts has expired. These are the routes from Ballymun/Finglas, Liffey Valley , Ringsend, Tallaght/Clondalkin and Lucan. [ BusConnects route will come in 'on time, on budget', says Darragh O'Brien Opens in new window ] Green Party transport spokesman Feljin Jose said the delays caused by the judicial reviews were extremely concerning. 'The NTA has to build three of these at the same time over the next four to five years to get this done this side of 2035. Seven out of the 12 approved corridors in judicial review is not a good return rate and will add at least a year, maybe up to two years, delay.' The settlement of the Swords cases would be a win for Dubliners, he said. 'Without knowing the details of the settlement I can only say it's good news if the cases are dropped and the quicker we can get this done and have bus priority and improved cycling and pedestrian infrastructure.' The plaintiffs and their legal representatives declined to comment on the settlement agreement. A spokeswoman for the NTA said it could not comment on the details of the proposed agreement 'other than to acknowledge that the board approved the terms of the agreement at the June board' meeting. Construction of the first core bus corridor from Liffey Valley to the city centre is due to begin next month.
