‘Innocent life matters': The photographs of children that captured the world's conscience
The photograph of an emaciated child broke Prime Minister Anthony Albanese's heart.
'For anyone with any sense of humanity, you have to be moved by that, and you have to acknowledge that every innocent life matters, whether it be Israeli or Palestinian,' Albanese said.
'A one-year-old boy is not a Hamas fighter, and the civilian casualties and death in Gaza is completely unacceptable,' he told ABC's Insiders on Sunday. 'That boy isn't challenging Israel's right to existence, and nor are the many who continue to suffer from the unavailability of food and water.'
The image of Muhammad Zakariya Ayyoub al-Matouq being cradled by his mother Hedaya al-Muta'wi, captured on July 21 and distributed by the photographic network Getty, evoked previous pictures that shocked the world.
There is the photograph of Phan Thi Kim Phuc running from a napalm attack in 1972 during the Vietnam War, Steve McCurry's portrait of Afghan refugee Sharbat Gula in 1984, and a haunting image of a vulture stalking a Sudanese child amid widespread famine in 1993.
In each case, the ethics behind the photograph have become disputed. Was the image exploitative? Should the photographer have intervened? What toll did it take on the individual who became a symbol for wider suffering?
The Israeli embassy in Australia went further on Monday. Deputy head of mission, Amir Meron, told journalists that there was no starvation in Gaza and that 'false pictures' of the situation in the territory were spreading.
'This is a false campaign that is being [led] by Hamas, taking advantage of sick children in order to show a false claim and false presentation of hunger and starvation in the Gaza strip,' Meron said, without specifically referring to the image of al-Matouq.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
15 minutes ago
- ABC News
Warlpiri elder Ned Hargraves calls on PM to intervene in NT justice system
Warlpiri elder Ned Jampijinpa Hargraves has joined growing calls for federal intervention into law and justice policies in the Northern Territory, in a letter to Prime Minister Anthony Albanese. Speaking at the Garma Festival on Sunday, Mr Hargraves said his community of Yuendemu had "suffered a lot", and that new laws under the Country Liberal Party (CLP) government had "ripped the guts out of us". The outback town has suffered several traumatic losses in recent years — the police shooting death of Kumunjayi Walker devastated the community, and the death in custody of Mr Hargraves's 'jaja', or grandson, Kumunjayi White in Alice Springs earlier this year, adding to the hurt. Mr Hargraves today read out a letter he had written, addressed to the prime minister, urging him to intervene on the Northern Territory's Country Liberal Party's tough-on-crime agenda. "The NT government is acting from a criminal mindset — like an illegal occupying foreign power," he said, reading from the letter. Indigenous incarceration rates have worsened significantly under laws and bail reforms introduced over the past year of CLP governance, with more youth laws introduced in the past week. Mr Hargraves said the CLP's policies were archaic, "like something from the 50s or 60s". "The CLP government proudly announces that even more of our people will be jailed," he said. "They are using their power to destroy us, to take away our rights." Mr Hargraves said he wanted to turn things around for young Aboriginal Territorians, but was losing faith that it would happen. "Our children and their children's children cannot be living in fear." He said he wrote to Mr Albanese in June, but had not received a response. He said he hoped to speak with him at length at Garma, but was not afforded the opportunity, and so now planned to travel to Canberra to speak to him directly. "Take action now. Make history by demonstrating to the Australian public and the international community that you no longer support apartheid laws that continue to oppress First Nations people," he urged Mr Albanese. "I say to you, prime minister, you have got the power to turn this around and put a stop to it. "This is going too long, too far gone." Mr Hargraves also reiterated his calls for the police to release the CCTV footage of Kumunjayi White's death, and demanded that an independent investigation body be established to investigate Aboriginal deaths in custody. NT Police have previously ruled out the possibility of an independent inquiry. The NT's Minister for Aboriginal Affairs, Steve Edgington, told the ABC at Garma that his government's policies "aren't making things worse". "What we're trying to do is get on top of the issues that we're being faced with coming into government," he said. Asked about the over-representation of Indigenous people in prisons, and worsening Closing the Gap targets, Mr Edgington said there were several "systemic problems" at play. "Coming into government, our focus has been all about reducing crime, rebuilding the economy, and restoring that territory lifestyle," he said. "What we're focused on is improving housing, education, and trying to get those better health communities, but also empowering communities because we believe that decision making in those smaller communities is key to getting better outcomes across the board." Mr Hargraves is not alone in his criticism of the CLP's actions. Many First Nations leaders at Garma Festival this week have spoken out against the party's approach to crime reduction, following the Northern Australian Aboriginal Justice Agency's (NAAJA) calls for emergency intervention in June. The CLP government has remained steadfast in its agenda, justifying the incarceration of record numbers of First Nations people as part of its election promise to crack down on crime. The prime minister told crowds at Garma yesterday that "the privilege of government is the chance to serve this nation and to change it, to leave it for the better".
Sky News AU
an hour ago
- Sky News AU
Tens of thousands of pro-Palestinian protestors gear up to march across iconic Sydney Harbour Bridge as city grinds to a standstill
Thousands of pro-Palestinian protestors are beginning to assemble in the Sydney CBD to march across the Harbour Bridge which has come to an extraordinary standstill with police launching a mammoth response. Watch Sky News for rolling coverage. Subscribe to Sky News to receive all of the latest news and headlines, and hear from our world leading hosts and analysts. Hundreds of police officers around Harbour Bridge as protestors gather A heavy police presence will surround the Sydney Harbour Bridge to monitor thousands of pro-Palestinians protestors march across from Sunday afternoon. NSW Acting Assistant Police Commissioner Adam Johnson earlier urged residents to avoid Sydney's CBD where possible. ''If you're not going to engage in the assembly I would suggest you do not come to the city,'' Johnson said. ''There's going to be major disruptions. "But if you choose to come in and participate in the assembly, please do so reasonably, lawfully, listen to police instructions, listen to the marshals who are leading the procession as well.'' Officers warned they will be closely monitoring the large crowd for ''unlawful and anti-social behaviour''.
Sky News AU
an hour ago
- Sky News AU
Australia warned of looming ‘danger' from America amid social media ban
Sky News host Rowan Dean has warned of 'danger' Australia is currently facing amid a looming social media ban. 'As soon as we do come on to the radar around December ... the Americans will be looking at us and looking at how we are blocking access to YouTube, Twitter, Instagram, all these major American platforms,' he said. 'And the wrath of the Americans will come down, and it will see those tariffs go up, and it'll be the fault of the Albanese government and the Coalition.'
