HC dismisses caste validity petition, imposes Rs10K fine for suppression of facts
Nagpur: The Nagpur bench of
Bombay high court
dismissed a plea challenging the denial of a Scheduled Tribe (ST) validity certificate by a member of the 'Halbi' community. It held that the petitioner suppressed material facts regarding his blood relative's caste status and imposed a cost of Rs10,000 for misleading both the scrutiny committee and the judiciary.HC directed the petitioner, Murlidhar Khadge, to deposit the imposed cost with the High Court Legal Services Sub-Committee within four weeks.
A division bench of Justices Nitin Sambre and Vrushali Joshi ruled that Khadge, an employee of Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited, failed to disclose that his close relative, Gajanan Khadge, previously obtained a caste validity certificate belonging to the Special Backward Class (SBC) 'Koshti' caste. This certificate was issued in 2014, and the familial connection was reflected in a family tree submitted in 2018, which was not disputed.The petitioner cited a 1917 school record of his grandfather, Ukarda Kisanji, which identified Ukarda as 'Halbi', a recognised Scheduled Tribe. In an earlier writ petition in 2022, the court directed the scrutiny committee to verify this historical record through a Vigilance Cell and reconsider the petitioner's claim.However, after being pointed out by additional govt pleader Sangeeta Jachak, the court found that Khadge withheld the critical fact of his relative's SBC status both during the earlier litigation and in proceedings before the scrutiny committee.The court observed that if Khadge's claim were accepted, it would result in members of the same family holding caste validity certificates for two different groups — 'Halbi' (ST) and 'Khosti' (SBC) —without adequate justification. It ruled that there was no credible explanation from the petitioner for the omission and referred to prior Supreme Court and HC judgments emphasizing that fraud vitiates all proceedings.Additionally, the scrutiny committee's Vigilance Cell unearthed historical records from 1917 and beyond that documented the caste of other paternal relatives, including the petitioner's father, cousin, and great-grandfather, as 'Koshti'. The court concluded that the burden of disproving these adverse entries lay on the petitioner, who failed to do so convincingly.Citing the petitioner's deliberate suppression of facts and the legal consequences of misleading quasi-judicial bodies, the court refused to interfere with the scrutiny committee's April 2, 2025 order rejecting the tribe claim.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
19 hours ago
- Time of India
Pune civic body to step up action against people spitting in public spaces
Pune: Pune Municipal Corporation (PMC) is stepping up its efforts to combat public defacement and enforce sanitation norms, with a particular focus on deterring spitting in public places. Since the beginning of 2025, PMC has penalized 549 individuals, collecting a total of Rs5.5 lakh in fines. While there was a slight increase in April, the overall trend shows a decline in reported cases since Jan. In Jan, 223 cases were registered, dropping to 118 in Feb. Since March, the number of cases has remained in the double digits — 69 in March, 74 in April, and 65 in May. The fine for each offence is Rs1,000. PMC has added 10 new vehicles to its flying squads. These squads will now be better equipped to catch offenders violating solid waste management guidelines, including those spitting, using banned plastic, burning garbage, and littering. Previously, squad vehicles were shared across multiple ward offices, but with this addition, each of the 15 ward offices will now have a dedicated vehicle for robust enforcement. Anand Kulkarni, a medical practitioner from Hadapsar, said surveillance can effectively deter public nuisances. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 2025 Top Trending local enterprise accounting software [Click Here] Esseps Learn More Undo "Civic authorities should monitor busy areas through the existing CCTV network. The civic body should alert citizens through digital displays and public announcement systems about maintaining cleanliness. Local police and civic officials can coordinate efforts using mobile applications to report violations swiftly," he said. Shantanu Gosavi, a resident of Kothrud, said, "Regular patrolling teams should be equipped with devices to record evidence of violations. Installing motion sensors and smart bins in sensitive areas can help track waste disposal patterns. The collected data can identify hotspots requiring increased vigilance." The fine ranges from Rs200 to Rs1,000 per offence. "The civic administration created a lot of awareness about public sanitation. Action was taken across civic areas, and the drive will continue in the days to come," head of PMC's solid waste department Sandip Kadam said.
India Gazette
21 hours ago
- India Gazette
Rouse Avenue court declines cognisance of charge sheet against former MP Udit Raj
New Delhi [India], June 5 (ANI): The Rouse Avenue court on Thursday declined cognisance of the charge sheet of the Delhi police against Congress leader and former MP Udit Raj as the court noted no evidence regarding his identity. He is not seen in the video produced by the Delhi Police regarding a protest outside the residence of former Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal at Feroz Shah Road. The protest was organised on January 20, 2025. An FIR was registered at the police station on Parliament Street. It was alleged that Udit Raj led the protest. Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate (ACJM) Neha Mittal refused to take cognisance of the charge sheet filed against him. While declining cognisance, the court noted that there is no evidence on record regarding the identity of the accused. Despite the fact that the incident in question was filmed by the police officials, the accused cannot be seen in the entire video. 'In view of this, the court is of the considered opinion that there is insufficient ground for taking cognisance of the offence punishable under section 223 Bhartiya Nagrik Sanhita (BNS). No other offence appears to have been made out from the charge-sheet. Accordingly, cognisance in the present case is declined,' ACJM Neha Mittal said in the order passed on June 5. Delhi police filed a charge sheet against Udit Raj for an offence punishable under section 223(a)/3(5) BNS on the allegations that on January 20, 2025, a crowd of 30-35 people under his leadership were raising slogans in front of the house of former Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal, due to which Firoz Shah Road started getting jammed and inconvenience was caused to the commuters. The police stated that they were holding banners. They further stated that the protesters were informed by the senior officers through a loudhailer about the promulgation of an order under Section 163 BNSS and the applicability of the Model Code of Conduct. The charge sheet said they were warned against continuing with their protest, but they kept on demanding Rs.18,000 per month salary, just like other religious heads. The court said that nothing on record shows that the accused knew of the order issued by the concerned ACP. The court observed, 'It has been vaguely averred in the complaint that the accused kept on raising the slogans despite announcement on loudhailer regarding the imposition of Section 163 BNSS by senior police officers.' 'However, no such police officer has been named in the entire charge-sheet who apparently made the announcement, nor their statement under Section 180 BNSS has been recorded,' the court noted in the order. The court said that there is nothing on record to show that the warning was brought to the knowledge of accused. It said, 'Further, in the video recording of the incident placed on record, no such warning can be heard. No banners can be seen in the video regarding the warning about the imposition of Section 163 BNSS/ Sec 144 CrPC in the area. Thus, there is nothing on record to show that the order dated on 29.1.2024 under Section 163 BNSS was brought to the notice of the accused and other protesters,' the court said. (ANI)
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
Three recovery agents held for aiding Hagawanes in cheating case
Pune: The Mahalunge MIDC police on Thursday arrested three men for illegally confiscating an earthmoving machine and handing it over to the Hagawane family members about a month ago. Deputy commissioner of police Shivaji Pawar said, "We have arrested Yogesh Raskar (25), Vaibhav Pingale (27) — both of Talegaon Dhamdhere, and Ganesh Potale (25) of Mohitewadi for aiding Lata Hagawane and her son Shashank in a cheating case registered with the police on May 29." Pawar said, "The trio are recovery agents with a bank and had taken away the machine. They gave it to the Hagawanes, despite the bank stating there was no need to seize the machine." With the fresh arrests, the number of suspects in the cheating case has reached five, including Lata and Sushant. Earlier, the Hagawanes were arrested in the dowry harassment case of Vaishavi, who allegedly committed suicide at her residence in Bhukum last month. Pawar said, "The trio claimed that the bank had ordered that the earthmover, which was taken on loan from the bank by the complainant in the case, be seized. Instead of giving the machine to the bank, the trio gave it to the Hagawanes." The victim (33) of Khed lodged a complaint stating that Lata owned the machine and the complainant had agreed to purchase it from her. He was paying a monthly instalment of Rs50,000 to Shashank to repay the loan. Pawar said, "However, instead of paying the instalments, Shashank conspired with recovery agents and illegally took back the machine from the victim and kept it in his possession." Police said when the victim approached Shashank and demanded back either the machine or the money, Shashank threatened him with a licenced pistol. The victim suffered a financial loss of Rs11.7 lakh because of all this. Pune: The Mahalunge MIDC police on Thursday arrested three men for illegally confiscating an earthmoving machine and handing it over to the Hagawane family members about a month ago. Deputy commissioner of police Shivaji Pawar said, "We have arrested Yogesh Raskar (25), Vaibhav Pingale (27) — both of Talegaon Dhamdhere, and Ganesh Potale (25) of Mohitewadi for aiding Lata Hagawane and her son Shashank in a cheating case registered with the police on May 29." Pawar said, "The trio are recovery agents with a bank and had taken away the machine. They gave it to the Hagawanes, despite the bank stating there was no need to seize the machine." With the fresh arrests, the number of suspects in the cheating case has reached five, including Lata and Sushant. Earlier, the Hagawanes were arrested in the dowry harassment case of Vaishavi, who allegedly committed suicide at her residence in Bhukum last month. Pawar said, "The trio claimed that the bank had ordered that the earthmover, which was taken on loan from the bank by the complainant in the case, be seized. Instead of giving the machine to the bank, the trio gave it to the Hagawanes." The victim (33) of Khed lodged a complaint stating that Lata owned the machine and the complainant had agreed to purchase it from her. He was paying a monthly instalment of Rs50,000 to Shashank to repay the loan. Pawar said, "However, instead of paying the instalments, Shashank conspired with recovery agents and illegally took back the machine from the victim and kept it in his possession." Police said when the victim approached Shashank and demanded back either the machine or the money, Shashank threatened him with a licenced pistol. The victim suffered a financial loss of Rs11.7 lakh because of all this.
