logo
Don't believe the hype around robotaxis, HSBC analysts say

Don't believe the hype around robotaxis, HSBC analysts say

Tesla and Waymo are racing to build their own robotaxi empires, but not everyone is convinced the hype is justified.
A new report from analysts at HSBC found that the potential market for driverless taxis was "widely overestimated" and warned that it could take years before robotaxi fleets began returning a profit.
In a Monday note, HSBC analysts suggested that the idea robotaxis would be more profitable than their human-driven counterparts was based on a misconception.
Although robotaxi operators do not have to worry about the cost of paying a driver's wage, they said that driverless taxis face a slew of "overlooked" extra costs that would likely cut into profits.
According to HSBC's analysts, those include parking, charging, and cleaning fees, as well as teams of remote operators to intervene when things go wrong.
"When we factor in these costs, we believe robotaxis won't be break-even on a cash flow basis until 7-8 years after launch," the analysts wrote, adding that projections for robotaxi revenues vary from the "ambitious to the unrealistic."
Industry figures have been making bold claims about driverless cars for years.
Tesla CEO Elon Musk has said that robotaxis will add trillions of dollars to the company's market cap, and in May told CNBC that Tesla would have one million self-driving cars on the road by next year — a promise he also made back in 2019.
Amid the hype, driverless taxis are gradually becoming a reality. Tesla finally launched a pilot of its robotaxi service in Austin last month, and Alphabet-owned Waymo's autonomous Jaguar I-Paces have provided over 5 million paid rides over the past three years.
However, the division of Alphabet that includes Waymo continues to lose billions of dollars a year, and analysts estimate that Waymo's vehicles, which are outfitted with expensive sensors and lidar arrays, cost around $150,000 each.
The economics of Tesla's robotaxis are unclear, but Musk has suggested that the company's decision to use cameras and AI rather than lidar means they are cheaper to run than Waymo's.
Despite this, HSBC's analysts said the automaker faces numerous challenges in scaling its autonomous ride-hailing operation, ranging from regulatory barriers in China and Europe to upgrading the roughly 5 million Teslas on the road with hardware that is too old to run the company's robotaxi software.
They estimated that Tesla's robotaxi fleet would hit 20,000 to 25,000 cars by 2030, rising to 75,000 by 2035, and would not turn a profit until 2033.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Anti-Elon Musk protesters are coming for Tesla's new diner
Anti-Elon Musk protesters are coming for Tesla's new diner

The Verge

time22 minutes ago

  • The Verge

Anti-Elon Musk protesters are coming for Tesla's new diner

Tesla just opened a retro diner in Los Angeles, so it was only a matter of time before anti-Elon Musk protesters caught wind. The long-awaited retrofuturistic diner, complete with giant outdoor screens for drive-in movies, dozens of Supercharger stalls, and an Optimus robot serving popcorn, opened to huge lines in West Hollywood on July 21st. Protesters are planning on demonstrating outside the newly opened diner on July 26th, according to the Action Network website, which has served as a repository for the so-called Tesla Takedown movement. '[Elon Musk] wants to celebrate his reign of terror in OUR CITY, Occupied Los Angeles, with a cheesy Tesla-branded diner exclusively for his legion of conmen stock-pumpers and MLM influencer tryhards?' the website reads. 'WE SAY HELL NO.' '[Elon Musk] wants to celebrate his reign of terror in OUR CITY, Occupied Los Angeles, with a cheesy Tesla-branded diner exclusively for his legion of conmen stock-pumpers and MLM influencer tryhards?' Since early February of this year, Tesla has been the target of protesters opposed to Musk's involvement with the Trump administration. As Musk's Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) sought to eliminate humanitarian aid programs and fire tens of thousands of government workers, demonstrators have expressed their rage by picketing outside Tesla showrooms and demanding Tesla owners sell their vehicles. Others have taken things further, defacing Tesla vehicles with anti-Musk slogans, smashing windows, and even setting some Tesla property on fire. Musk's allies in the Trump administration are threatening to prosecute anyone caught defacing Tesla vehicles by classifying the acts as 'domestic terrorism.' Musk officially stepped back from DOGE in May, although he claims that he will remain involved with the group in some capacity. The following month, Musk and President Donald Trump had a public falling out, with the two engaged in a war of words. Trump has threatened to deport Musk, while Musk has accused the president of being on Jeffrey Epstein's alleged client list. Despite all the drama, anti-Musk protesters are trying to keep up the energy. Joel Lava, who has been helping lead the Tesla Takedown protests in Los Angeles, said he expects a large crowd outside the diner this Saturday. 'It's in West Hollywood,' Lava told The Verge. 'I think it's safe to say that Elon Musk is not a popular figure in West Hollywood. So I don't think it's going to be hard to protest it.' 'I think it's safe to say that Elon Musk is not a popular figure in West Hollywood.' While the weekly crowds may have diminished slightly from their peak in the spring, and while Musk may have distanced himself from the Trump administration, the Tesla Takedown movement hasn't given up. Lava said that dozens of people still show up every week to protest outside of Tesla locations in LA, buoyed by news of Tesla's worsening earnings statement and falling sales. He also cited recent reports of food that was supposed to ship out with USAID being left to rot in warehouses thanks to DOGE's funding cuts. And the news that Musk may start his own political party has further motivated the activists to keep up their presence, Lava said. 'Yes, our numbers have dwindled, but they have stayed strong,' he said. 'We've already built a community, [and] people will show up.' Lava said the tactics will be similar to those used in protests outside of Tesla dealerships and charging stations: raising awareness about Musk's efforts to decimate humanitarian aid and destroy the federal government. 'I think our simple message is Tesla funds fascism,' Lava said. 'You're going into this cafe, and you're giving a $300 billion man your own money to help destroy the fabric of our country. That's why we don't want you buying Tesla. And that's why you shouldn't go into this cafe.' Posts from this author will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All by Andrew J. Hawkins Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Electric Cars Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All News Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Policy Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Politics Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Tesla Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Transportation

Tesla Expected to Report Falling Profit as Car Sales Fall
Tesla Expected to Report Falling Profit as Car Sales Fall

New York Times

time22 minutes ago

  • New York Times

Tesla Expected to Report Falling Profit as Car Sales Fall

Tesla is expected to report on Wednesday a slump in profit, the third quarterly decline in a row, as the company cut car prices in an attempt to revive sales. Analysts estimate that the company earned $1.2 billion from April to June, according to Bloomberg, down from $1.4 billion a year ago. Sales are expected to have fallen to $22.6 billion from $25.5 billion in the second quarter of 2024. Tesla has not reported an increase in quarterly profit since the third quarter of 2024. Tesla's weak earnings are likely to reinforce concern among some investors that Elon Musk is neglecting the car business while he focuses the company's resources on autonomous driving software, self-driving taxis and humanoid robots. Mr. Musk has said those technologies will make Tesla the most valuable company in the world. Tesla has begun testing a limited self-driving taxi service in Austin, Texas. Wall Street has largely bought into that vision, and the company's share price is up around 50 percent since early April. But such taxis and robots are not yet generating significant revenue for Tesla, and the company remains reliant on the car business to finance Mr. Musk's futuristic plans. Tesla's sales have been losing momentum because it is not offering more affordable and appealing new models even as other carmakers like BYD of China have rolled out many new vehicles while slashing prices. In addition, Mr. Musk's support for right-wing political causes has alienated many electric car buyers in Europe and the United States and has distracted him from running the company. Last month, he announced plans to form a new political party in the United States after his relationship with President Trump deteriorated. Want all of The Times? Subscribe.

The Trade Desk vs. Alphabet: Which Ad-Tech Stock is the Smarter Buy?
The Trade Desk vs. Alphabet: Which Ad-Tech Stock is the Smarter Buy?

Yahoo

time23 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

The Trade Desk vs. Alphabet: Which Ad-Tech Stock is the Smarter Buy?

Both The Trade Desk, Inc TTD and Alphabet Inc GOOGL play pivotal roles in the programmatic advertising ecosystem. TTD operates a leading demand-side platform (DSP), which helps advertisers focus on data-driven ads. Alphabet, on the other hand, dominates the digital ad space through its massive ecosystem comprising Google Search, YouTube and more. Since both firms have a massive exposure to the booming connected TV (CTV) and retail media trends, this makes for an intriguing comparison for investors. So, which stock makes a better investment pick at present? Let's deep dive into the pros and cons for each company. The Case for TTD TTD is confident in its ability to outpace the market and seize future opportunities owing to solid execution across key initiatives, CTV, retail media, international expansion, Kokai, UID2 and OpenPath. The Kokai platform is now being used by two-thirds of the clients, much ahead of schedule. The platform is delivering on lower funnel KPIs, including 24% lower cost per conversion and 20% lower cost per acquisition, per TTD. 100% adoption by clients is expected to be completed by this year's end. The integration of Koa AI tools was highlighted by management as a 'game changer' for the Kokai platform. It recently introduced Deal Desk, an innovation within its Kokai platform designed to enhance how advertisers and publishers manage one-to-one deals and upfront commitments. The acquisition of Sincera, a leading digital advertising data company, will aid in enhancing its programmatic advertising platform by integrating Sincera's actionable insights on data quality. It recently unveiled the OpenSincera application to offer Sincera's rich advertising metadata to the ad tech ecosystem. First-quarter revenues jumped 25% year over year while adjusted EBITDA was $208 million (34% margin). Video, which includes connected TV or CTV, represented a high 40 percent share of digital spend, while mobile had a mid-30 percent share. It expects at least $682 million in revenues for the second quarter of 2025, implying approximately 17% year-over-year growth. The stock's recent addition to the S&P 500 index has increased its visibility and potentially aided in attracting more institutional ownership. Nonetheless, increasing macroeconomic uncertainty and escalating trade tensions do not augur well for TTD, as these could squeeze ad budgets. The company highlighted the impact of the volatile macro backdrop, particularly on the large global brands. If macro headwinds worsen or persist into the second half of 2025, revenue growth may face further pressure due to reduced programmatic demand. The intensely competitive nature of the digital advertising industry, dominated by industry giants like Alphabet and Amazon, continues to put pressure on TTD's market position. While CTV remains a strong revenue driver, the market is increasingly fragmented and competitive. Heavy reliance on CTV for growth is a concern, as any adverse impact on this segment could weigh heavily on the company's overall performance. Moreover, TTD derived 88% of its revenues from North America, while only 12% came from international markets. A weak international footprint limits TTD's total addressable market expansion potential. The Case for GOOGL Alphabet dominates digital ad space with its online ad platform. The main sources of its ad revenues are Google Search, YouTube ads, Google Network, Google AdSense and Google Ad Manager. The company's ginormous ad technology infrastructure integrates both DSP and supply-side platforms, aids advertisers in reaching their target across the web, mobile apps, and CTV. Alphabet's efforts to infuse AI in Search are driving top-line growth. Circle to Search now features AI Mode. AI Mode is also accessible through Lens within the Google app on both Android and iOS devices. Circle to Search is now available on 300 million-plus Android devices. Earlier, Alphabet announced the launch of Offerwall. It is a flexible tool designed to aid publishers earn revenue while offering their audience choices. Offerwall is now available in Ad Manager. The company also rolled out new features, which include Optimize. Optimize utilizes AI to decide the best time to display the Offerwall for each visitor, thereby maximizing engagement and revenues. In 2024, Google advertising revenues increased 11.2% over 2023 to $264.59 billion, driven by a 13.2% increase in Google Search & other revenues and a 14.7% increase in YouTube ads. In 2024, ad revenues accounted for 75.6% of the total revenues. In the first quarter of 2025, Google advertising revenues rose 8.5% year over year to $66.885 billion and accounted for 74.1% of total revenues. Search and other revenues were up 9.8% and YouTube's advertising revenues improved 10.3% year over year. Alphabet's ad business faces several headwinds. Regulatory scrutiny is intensifying, particularly in the United States and Europe. The landscape has become increasingly competitive with both small and established players aggressively vying for ad dollars. Privacy changes such as the depreciation of third-party cookies and Apple's iOS tracking restrictions are also reforming the digital ad landscape. Nonetheless, business diversification, especially cloud and AI, with stupendous financial resources, gives it an edge and reduces reliance on one segment. Alphabet generated $36.15 billion of cash from operations in the first quarter of 2025. Cash equivalents and marketable securities were $95.328 billion at the quarter-end. Share Performance for TTD & GOOGL Over the past month, TTD and GOOGL have gained 13.7% and 14.8%, respectively. Image Source: Zacks Investment Research Valuation for TTD & GOOGL Valuation-wise, TTD is overvalued, as suggested by the Value Score of F, while GOOGL has a Value Score of C. In terms of the forward 12-month price/earnings ratio, TTD shares are trading at 41.06X, higher than GOOGL's 19.35X. Image Source: Zacks Investment Research How Do Zacks Estimates Compare for TTD & GOOGL? Analysts have made no revisions for TTD's bottom line for the current year in the past 60 days. Image Source: Zacks Investment Research For GOOGL, there is a marginal upward revision. Image Source: Zacks Investment Research TTD or GOOGL: Which Is a Better Pick? TTD and GOOGL currently carry a Zacks Rank #3 (Hold) each. You can see the complete list of today's Zacks #1 Rank (Strong Buy) stocks here. While both The Trade Desk and Alphabet are benefiting from the rise in CTV and retail media, Alphabet stands out due to its broader ad ecosystem, stronger financials, and diversified revenue streams. Its massive scale, robust AI integration, and better valuation make it a more resilient long-term investment. Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research? Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click to get this free report Alphabet Inc. (GOOGL) : Free Stock Analysis Report The Trade Desk (TTD) : Free Stock Analysis Report This article originally published on Zacks Investment Research ( Zacks Investment Research

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store