Politicians come worst out of a row over An Post's finances
An Post
at Cabinet this week is open to the accusation of being unsporting and using too much gun.
But at the same time we have a Cabinet Minister accusing one of his colleagues of leaking details of a briefing he gave on An Post in a deliberately damaging way.
The report in the Irish Daily Mail suggested Communications Minister
Patrick O'Donovan
told Cabinet that the company was on the brink of collapse, with cash reserves of less than €1 million. The paper said that, without the revenue generated by election-related mailing, the company would have made a loss last year.
The report so annoyed An Post chief executive, David McRedmond, that he
interrupted his holiday in Italy to go on
Morning Ireland and paint a different picture
: one of a company in rude good health. He said the accounts presented to Cabinet showed revenues of €1 billion for the first time and net profits of €10 million.
READ MORE
O'Donovan promptly followed him
on to the Claire Byrne show
on RTÉ radio and somehow managed to agree with McRedmond that the company was in good shape, without saying that the Irish Daily Mail story was wrong.
Instead, he turned his ire on his Cabinet colleagues, accusing one of them of leaking a distorted version of his briefing.
'But how a nameless minister or alleged nameless minister or source or whatever, would conflate that [his briefing] into saying this, the situation is dire. I don't know how they will come up with that.'
If we take O'Donovan at face value – and we have no reason not to – he has made a very serious allegation that one of his colleagues deliberately broke the law in order to damage a State-owned business that employs 10,000 people, and which is one of Ireland's most trusted brands. And the potential damage is significant, according to McRedmond, who warned it might cause big global customers to lose confidence in the business.
As ever the question is: why would someone do this? It is no secret that there are different views on An Post in Government. The briefing document for the incoming Minister in the Department of Public Expenditure, which was released earlier this year, makes the following observation: 'An Post's financial position remains extremely challenging. Mail volumes continue to decline and new services such as parcels are more competitive and hence lower margin. Significant existing State support means there is some ability to address sustainability, but this is limited.'
[
Ireland's economic plans threatened amid 'sobering' outlook
Opens in new window
]
There is no suggestion that the new minister,
Jack Chambers
, leaked the details of O'Donovan's briefing. His department's position is pretty much word for word the most recent assessment of An Post carried out by New Era, which provides financial and commercial advice to minsters and their department on semi-state company holdings.
It is a somewhat different picture from the upbeat one pained by McRedmond, but it is not hard to reconcile them.
McRedmond was brought in from the private sector
to run An Post in 2016, having previously worked in TV3 (now Virgin Media) and Eir.
The focus in the private sector is essentially short term. The future cannot be controlled, and the most important thing is this year's figures. If you were not optimistic you would not be in business.
McRedmond said as much on Morning Ireland in connection with the once-off revenue associated with election mailings that flattered last year's figures. 'Yes, we got a big boost from the elections last year, but if it wasn't the elections, it would be something else,' he said.
The public sector takes a longer-term and more conservative approach, as epitomised by New Era's assessment of An Post's prospects. McRedmond's sangfroid on its own is not going to cut it for New Era, when it comes to recommending that the Government accede to his request for more capital and higher borrowing limits. McRedmond wants this to further An Post's transformation into a delivery business competing with giants such as DHL and UPS.
[
David McRedmond: 'An Post has been brilliant. I've never been remunerated less and enjoyed a job more'
Opens in new window
]
It is still somewhat baffling why leaking details of a Cabinet meeting would enhance anyone's position in this debate. It's possible, of course, that it's more cock-up than conspiracy.
The story was really a nothing burger and only took off after McRedmond's performance on Morning Ireland, which was followed up by O'Donovan's accusations on Claire Byrne. It would not be the first time that the leaking of a titbit to a newspaper had spiralled out of control.
But the situation remains that a Government Minister has publicly and emphatically accused an unidentified Cabinet colleague of breaching confidentiality and leaking confidential information in a nefarious manner. That is something that has to be taken seriously.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Times
13 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Global markets soar amid signs of progress on US trade deals
Global markets soared on Thursday as investors digested US corporate earnings along with signs of progress in tariff negotiations between the US and its trading partners. Dublin Euronext Dublin was up 1.3 per cent, largely boosted by strong performances from the Irish banks. Bank of Ireland and AIB were up 4 per cent and 3 per cent respectively, with the banking sector generally up across Europe. Ryanair continued its recent rise, climbing 0.7 per cent. Its peer airline Wizz Air finished down 0.5 per cent after it missed first-quarter profit estimates. 'There was a bit activity around the airlines due to that news flow, and Ryanair benefited from that,' said a trader. READ MORE Elsewhere, two heavyweights on the index, food giant Kerry Group and Cavan-based insulation specialist Kingspan, both finished up 0.5 per cent. London Britain's FTSE 100 rose to a record close, boosted by upbeat corporate results and optimism over a potential EU-US trade agreement. The benchmark FTSE 100 closed up 0.9 per cent, while the domestically-oriented midcap FTSE 250 gained 0.6 per cent. The personal care and grocery stores index led sectoral gains, up 2.6 per cent, boosted by Reckitt, up 9.9 per cent, after the consumer goods company raised its annual revenue forecast. Healthcare stocks rose 1.9 per cent with AstraZeneca up 2.1 per cent after the drugmaker's rare immune disorder drug succeeded in an advanced trial. GSK added 1.4 per cent after the US Food and Drug Administration on Wednesday extended its review of the drugmaker's blood cancer drug. Media stocks advanced 2.3 per cent, led by ITV which rose 13.3 per cent after the broadcaster's half-year results beat forecasts. Conversely, precious metal miners fell 1.4 per cent, tracking a drop in gold prices. Endeavour Mining fell 1.3 per cent, and Fresnillo was down 2.1 per cent. Europe Shares on the Continent advanced amid reports the European Union and Washington were close to clinching a tariff agreement, close on the heels of a similar deal with Japan. MSCI's gauge of stocks across the globe rose 3.03 points. The pan-European Stoxx 600 index rose 0.23 per cent, while Europe's broad FTSEurofirst 300 index rose 0.2 per cent. The Dax 40 in Frankfurt gained 0.2 per cent, but the Cac 40 in Paris fell 0.4 per cent. New York The S&P 500 and the Nasdaq hit record highs as big technology stocks rose after Google parent Alphabet's robust earnings, while the Dow was weighed down by losses in IBM, UnitedHealth, and Honeywell. In morning trading, the S&P 500 gained 0.25 per cent; and the Nasdaq Composite gained 0.25 per cent. Alphabet rose 1.9 per cent after it raised its 2025 capital spending forecast, shrugging off trade jitters, and reinforcing investors' confidence in AI investments and returns. Losses in UnitedHealth, IBM and Honeywell weighed on the blue-chip Dow, which fell 0.33 per cent – though it remained close to its December 4th record high. UnitedHealth lost 3.7 per cent. The insurer revealed it's co-operating with a Department of Justice probe into its Medicare practices, following reports of both criminal and civil investigations. IBM dropped 8 per cent as its second-quarter results fell flat with investors, hampered by disappointing sales in its core software division. Honeywell, meanwhile, dipped 4.6 per cent despite topping Wall Street's expectations and raising its annual outlook. Electric vehicle maker Tesla tumbled 9 per cent, as CEO Elon Musk warned of 'a few rough quarters' due to cuts in EV incentives. The stock has fallen about 25 per cent for the year so far. Some of Wall Street's heavyweights were starting to feel the sting of Trump's sweeping tariffs. American Airlines fell 9.2 per cent after forecasting a bigger-than-expected third-quarter loss, hurt by sluggish domestic travel demand. – Additional reporting: Agencies


Irish Times
13 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Profits rise at Cashel Blue producer with aims to fund further capital investment
Profits rose at Cashel Farmhouse Cheesemakers, the producer of the famous Cashel Blue cheese, with the company aiming to use the surplus to fund further capital investment. J & L Grubb Limited, the company behind the brand, recorded profit of more than €960,000 in the 2024 financial year, according to filings made to the Companies Registration Office. This followed a profit of €951,000 in 2023. A spokesman said the company was 'building reserves to allow continued investment' after it made a 'huge capital investment' in 2010. The Cashel Blue brand was created by Louis and Jane Grubb in 1984 and has continued to be made by hand on the same farmland since it was founded. It is based in Fethard, Co Tipperary. READ MORE The brand is now led by a new generation of the family: the founders' daughter and her husband, Sarah Furno and Sergio Furno. Speaking to The Irish Times, the spokesman said that 2023 was a 'particularly good year' with the company having benefited from a 'post-Covid bounce', which he said benefited the food sector generally. In 2024, however, a sharp increase in milk prices forced the company to 'change its pricing slightly' as farmers were hit by a wetter than expected start to the year, which disrupted dairy volumes and price. 'Every cost has gone up. You name it and everything has gone up,' the spokesman said, with the family business seeking to retain a 'simple philosophy' of trying to build the company sustainably in order to be able to 'make the next step.' 'We are a sustainable, family-based rural business trying to hire people from the locality. We use locally produced milk, and hire our labour locally as much as possible.' The majority of the business' sales are domestic, around 70 per cent, with the balance exported to other markets. While tariffs may impact the company's exports to the US, they only have a small portion of their exports exposed to that market. The market turmoil, however, has created 'opportunities' for the company as there is interest from new markets in their product as people are 'now shy of buying American', the spokesman said. Accumulated profits stood at €9.2 million, with more than €500,000 in finished goods in stock by the end of 2024. The company had 22 employees in 2024, down seven from the year prior.


Irish Times
21 minutes ago
- Irish Times
‘Honest belief' of consent raised in pair's appeals against convictions for rape of vulnerable teenager
Two of three men jailed for the gang rape of a vulnerable teenager who had recently left State care have launched appeals against their convictions, arguing issues of consent were relevant during their trial. At the Court of Appeal on Thursday, counsel for Dion Genockey (26) argued the trial judge should have advised the jury his client may have had reasons for not mentioning to gardaí that he believed the victim had given her consent. On behalf of Daryl Rooney (27), it was argued he was not aware the woman had not given her consent. Genockey, of Clarion Quay Apartments, and Rooney, of Railway Street, Dublin city centre, were convicted of raping the woman at Bull Island, Dollymount, Dublin, on January 5th, 2016. READ MORE The convictions came in 2022 following a second trial at the Central Criminal Court. The jury in the first trial, held in 2020, was unable to reach a verdict. Genockey was sentenced to nine years in prison, while Rooney was sentenced to 10 years. A third accused, Troy Ryan, of Lower Gardiner Street, Dublin city centre, was also convicted and sentenced to 9½ years. The sentencing court heard the men maintain their innocence and do not accept the jury's verdict. Genockey's senior counsel, Thomas O'Malley, said his client had given evidence at the trial that the complainant had consented, but he had not mentioned this in interviews with gardaí. Mr O'Malleysaid Genockey was advised by his father not to mention anything to gardaí, which in this case turned out to be his defence. Counsel submitted that the trial judge ought to have told the jury they must consider the possibility that Genockey may have had reasons for not mentioning to gardaí that he believed the woman had consented. Senior counsel for Rooney, Dominic McGinn, said that, to achieve a rape conviction, the prosecution must prove the act, the absence of consent and that the accused knows there is an absence of consent. In this case, said counsel, the third aspect was lacking. Mr McGinn said the complainant said she was not interested in sexual activity, but when Rooney was alone with her in the car, she did not say anything. Ms Justice Isobel Kennedy said that while he was relying on the defence of 'honest belief' of consent, this belief must be founded in reality. 'Where is the counter evidence? The evidence was all going the one way, as she said she did not consent,' said Ms Justice Kennedy. Mr McGinn said the complainant had changed her mind about getting into the car with the men, which made Rooney 'alive to the fact she was a young woman who could change her mind'. 'By the time he got into the car, he knew two others had had sexual relations with her,' said Mr McGinn. He said that in her evidence, the complainant said she made it clear to the first two men that she was not consenting, but Rooney was not aware of that. On behalf of the State, senior counsel Eilis Brennan said the prosecution had argued that this was a very vulnerable woman addicted to tablets and was targeted by the men. They lured her away in a car, even though she told them she did not want to have sex, and took her to a remote location. Addressing Rooney's claim he did not know the woman did not consent, Ms Brennan said 'honest belief' of consent is subjective, but there must be some reality to it. She said there was ample evidence for the matter to go to a jury. Mr Justice Patrick McCarthy, presiding over the three-judge court, said the court would deliver its judgment at a later date.