
Indigenous groups question government funding for Métis Nation of Ontario
The Chiefs of Ontario, which represents 133 First Nations in the province, shared with The Canadian Press data on more than 20 years worth of federal funding provided to the Métis Nation of Ontario.
It suggests that $819,836,061 went from Ottawa to the MNO — an organization First Nations leaders say has no legitimacy and threatens their rights.
'This data shows just how badly First Nations in Ontario are being harmed by the diversion of government funding to the MNO and away from the needs of First Nations and other legitimate groups,' the Chiefs of Ontario said in a media statement.
'The question is, why is the Crown sending hundreds of millions of dollars to the MNO when there is overwhelming evidence contradicting their claims?'
Tweet This
Click to share quote on Twitter: "The question is, why is the Crown sending hundreds of millions of dollars to the MNO when there is overwhelming evidence contradicting their claims?"
Story continues below advertisement
The data indicates the money came from several federal departments, including Indigenous Services Canada, Crown-Indigenous Relations, Parks Canada and Environment and Climate Change Canada.
The MNO also received funds from the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission and the Impact Assessment Agency related to the potential impacts of projects in their communities.
The conflict between First Nations, some Métis groups and the MNO stems from a 2017 decision by the government of Ontario to recognize six 'new, historic' Métis communities in the province — and a 2023 federal government bill, which never passed, that would have affirmed the MNO's right to self-government.
First Nations and other Métis groups say the communities represented by the MNO have no claim to Métis heritage and Ottawa and Ontario have no right to recognize them.
3:31
Métis Nation of Ontario accused of recasting ancestors as Métis
Last month, history professor Leila Inksetter of the University of Quebec in Montreal released a report drafted on behalf of the Wabun Tribal Council that concluded there is no evidence of a mixed-ancestry community in the Wabun Tribal Council's territory in northeastern Ontario.
Story continues below advertisement
The MNO rejected that report, saying that despite years of outside attempts 'to discredit' it, 'nothing has changed.'
Get breaking National news
For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
'The facts of history will not change because a new 'expert' has been paid to peddle the same Métis denialism,' the group said in a media statement.
The MNO has cited a 2003 decision by the Supreme Court of Canada to recognize a Métis community in and around Sault Ste. Marie, Ont. The case did not consider the six new communities recognized in 2017, but rather what may constitute a Métis right.
Another report, published last month and commissioned by Saugeen Ojibway Nation, also concluded there is no evidence of a distinct Métis community in their territory in southwestern Ontario.
'The historical evidence simply does not support this claim,' says the nearly 200-page report, written by two historians at the University of Toronto.
While the report says there were 'certainly individuals and families of mixed ancestry' in the region, that can't form the basis of a claim to a distinct community within Saugeen Ojibway Nation territory.
1:06
Manitoba Métis Federation president blasts Ontario group during identity summit
Jennifer St. Germain, MNO chief strategy officer, said Métis and First Nations 'should not be working at odds as we are not enemies.'
Story continues below advertisement
'We have worked together throughout our shared history to push colonial governments to respect the rights of Métis and First Nations peoples, to properly invest in the programs that matter to our families and communities, and to uphold the honour of the Crown,' she said.
'When the MNO and Ontario First Nations work together, we make real change for the better for our children, families, and communities, as well as our lands and waters.
'It's time to get back to the table rooted in our shared values of honesty, truth, and respect.'
Tweet This
Click to share quote on Twitter: "It's time to get back to the table rooted in our shared values of honesty, truth, and respect."
The Chiefs of Ontario says that the academic research 'merely reaffirms reality.'
'Not only are Ontario and Canada refusing to consult First Nations, they refuse to share the research they relied on or acknowledge the growing body of research and take steps to fix their mistakes,' the Chiefs of Ontario said in a media statement.
'It is extremely disappointing that Canada and Ontario … failed to do any adequate research before recognizing the MNO.'
Tweet This
Click to share quote on Twitter: "It is extremely disappointing that Canada and Ontario … failed to do any adequate research before recognizing the MNO."
Open disputes over claims to Métis heritage came close last year to ripping apart the Métis National Council, which once acted as a national voice for Métis but now has just two provincial members.
The Métis Nation-Saskatchewan withdrew from the Métis National Council last September, citing concerns about the MNO and claiming the council had failed to ensure the integrity of its citizenship registry.
Story continues below advertisement
5:23
Ottawa signs self-government agreements with Metis Nation in Alberta, Saskatchewan, Ontario
The Métis Nation British Columbia withdrew from the council shortly after, saying it had lost confidence in the council's ability to serve as a national advocacy organization.
Their departure came years after the Manitoba Métis Federation withdrew from the council, citing similar concerns.
Will Goodon, the Manitoba Métis Federation's minister of identity protection and inter-Indigenous affairs, said the amount of public money available to Métis communities is limited and should not be shared with bodies that are not connected to what he calls the historic Métis Nation — largely recognized as descendants of the Red River communities in Manitoba.
One Parks Canada grant received by the MNO was meant to allow the organization to secure land and 'support creation of an ecological corridor in the region along the north shore of Lake Superior,' says a federal document.
Story continues below advertisement
Goodon said that type of funding raises red flags for both Red River Métis and First Nations concerned about the prospect of the MNO seeking land in their territories.
3:01
Federal contracts given to Indigenous companies without proof
The Manitoba Métis Federation said it's also troubled by the fact that the federal government last week invited MNO leaders to a meeting to discuss its controversial major projects legislation.
The federation, which boycotted that meeting, said the MNO's invitation undermined the integrity of the gathering and put the government's major projects agenda at risk.
'Canada and Ontario are pushing pro-development agendas. They say they will consult with 'Indigenous communities' but, in Ontario, the only consultations that should occur are with the rights holders — First Nations,' the Chiefs of Ontario said in a media statement.
'Pan-Indigenous approaches do not work and only devalue the true rights holders.'
Tweet This
Click to share quote on Twitter: "Pan-Indigenous approaches do not work and only devalue the true rights holders."
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Winnipeg Free Press
31 minutes ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Creating opportunities through housing
Opinion Chief Maureen Brown of Opaskwayak Cree Nation (OCN) describes the decision to build houses off-reserve as visionary ('Huge step for us': Opaskwayak opens downtown apartment building, July 4). Let's hope she is right and that it represents a new trend in looking for housing solutions. OCN's announcement follows on the heels of a decision made in January 2025 by the Roseau River Anishinaabe First Nation. They committed to building a 99-unit apartment building in Winnipeg with another large project in the planning stages. Both First Nations have recognized that their members are heading to Winnipeg and other centres for more than housing. What we are seeing appears to be a strategic shift in the thinking of First Nations leaders and their communities. It is likely to be followed by many more First Nations housing initiatives in larger centres for two reasons. Brook Jones / Winnipeg Free Press files Opaskwayak Creen Nation Chief Maureen Brown cuts the ribbon while Paragon Living president and CEO Nigel Furgus looks on during a ribbon-cutting ceremony for 380 Young St. on July 4. First, although OCN has its own long-established and successful business community, their announcement reflects both the need for housing and the need for its members to have broader opportunities for jobs, housing and other services beyond their community. The chief and council's decision is a logical and forward-thinking move. First Nations are facing growing populations and limited housing options. In addition, many remote and isolated First Nations communities have limited job and employment opportunities. For most isolated Manitoba First Nations communities, that reality hasn't changed in decades. In remote communities like Pukatawagan, the unemployment rate has remained around 75 per cent for the past 40 years and there is nothing on the horizon that suggests that will change. Tapping in to the Affordable Housing Fund's $14.8 billion is clearly part of OCN's ambitious plans. OCN committed $1.8 million towards the project and $15.6 million came from the federal AHF. OCN hopes to build a 129-unit apartment block in St. Boniface in 2026, and a third major project of 240 units in south Winnipeg in 2028 using the same approach. The new approach is good for First Nations members and it is good for the city of Winnipeg. It takes advantage of a new federal housing initiative and it will ultimately be part of the solution for some of the homeless and unhoused living on our river banks and taking shelter where they can find it. Brown has noted that this will solve the housing problem for some OCN members, but it will also be a significant investment and help diversify OCN's already impressive business holdings. The Roseau River Anishinaabe First Nation and OCN leadership are responding to the fact that across the country, more than 50 per cent of First Nations people live off reserve. First Nations young people, particularly, are voting with their feet. OCN has acknowledged that half of its population already lives off-reserve. This is familiar to most First Nations leaders and the provincial and federal governments. The second reason is that life outcomes for people living in isolated communities, Indigenous and non-Indigenous, are compromised everywhere. Statistics Canada reported many years ago that about 60 per cent of the disparity in individual income, educational attainment, health and life expectancy could be accounted for by a community's isolation. Living in communities a long way away from a major centre is a risk factor. There is evidence that isolation and limited opportunities are likely to contribute to the high suicide rate, high levels of addiction, drug problems and the various forms of violence and self-abuse that reflect the despair that result from having limited opportunities. Overcrowding in the houses that are habitable add to growing discontent among its youth, who face adulthood in their communities with no work, little income and few recreational facilities or other social services. These are not conditions where young people thrive. A healthy community is not possible when most 15-to-30-year-olds have no work, no prospects of work, few recreational options and little available by way of physical or mental health services if they need help. The multiple challenges that face First Nations leaders are exacerbated by the fact that existing housing in the most remote communities is inadequate, dilapidated and falling further into disrepair. Living in overcrowded conditions is hard on people and the houses. Making minor or major repairs in a home in a remote or isolated community poses its own problems. Doing major renovations is complicated by the absence of building supplies, hardware or trades people necessary to complete the repairs. The end result is that fixing houses in most First Nations is a long, elaborate and frustrating exercise. And it's expensive. Tuesdays A weekly look at politics close to home and around the world. Everyone needs to have a place to live, a place to raise a family, a place to feel secure. Like too many other First Nations, Pukatawagan leadership has struggled for decades to meet the demand for housing in their communities. Unfortunately, the prohibitive cost of building, certainly in remote communities, limits their ability to respond to the need and results in overcrowding, and often deteriorating housing conditions. That is why Pukatawagan, too, has been exploring housing options in larger urban centres. The involvement of First Nations in the development of housing should be seen as a welcome trend. As OCN Chief Maureen Brown suggests, projects like the new apartment development in Winnipeg demonstrates the power of inclusion. She noted that, 'When we invest in Indigenous-led projects, we are investing in sustainable growth for everyone.' Housing is the foundation for healthy families and healthy children. When the OCN chief notes that the projects they are starting in Winnipeg are a necessary part of meeting both their housing needs and their goal of economic diversification, other levels of government should step up to facilitate this new approach. Urban off-reserve housing can solve many problems. It is not only an opportunity for economic growth for First Nations, but an opportunity to create spaces for young people transitioning from remote communities to larger communities. Places that can sustain them. Urban places that can offer them hope for a better future. It is a way forward for all of us, and the benefits will extend not only to those who engage in making the transition to the city and supporting their families in affordable housing, but will enrich us all over the long-term. Governments at all levels and First Nations need to be encouraged and supported in finding ways to move this housing agenda forward. Ralph Caribou lives in Pukatawagan and is a University College of the North (UCN) regional community co-ordinator, former Mathias Colomb band chief, and education director. Jerry Storie is a former Flin Flon MLA and represented Pukatawagan for many years.


Global News
8 hours ago
- Global News
Saskatoon city council talks budgets and AI
See more sharing options Send this page to someone via email Share this item on Twitter Share this item via WhatsApp Share this item on Facebook Saskatoon city council chambers were filled with local business owners, expressing their concerns for increasing property taxes. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy As the cost of living continues to rise, some are suggesting city council should look into AI to cut costs. Watch the video above for more.


CTV News
9 hours ago
- CTV News
Qatar sentences the country's Baha'i leader to 5 years for social media posts
This undated photo provided by his family in June 2025 shows Remy Rowhani, the head of the National Spiritual Assembly that governs Baha'i affairs in Qatar. (Family photo via AP, File) The leader of the small Baha'i community in Qatar was sentenced Wednesday to five years in prison for social media posts that allegedly 'cast doubt on the foundations of the Islamic religion,' according to court documents obtained by an international Baha'i organization monitoring the case. A three-judge panel of Qatar's Supreme Judiciary Council issued the verdict against Remy Rowhani, 71, who has been detained since April, according to documents provided to The Associated Press by the Baha'i International Community office in Geneva, Switzerland. The judges rejected a defense request for leniency on grounds that Rowhani suffered from a heart condition, according to the documentation. Saba Haddad, the Geneva office's representative to the United Nations, depicted the verdict as 'a serious breach and grave violation of the right to freedom of religion or belief and an attack on Remy Rowhani and the Baha'i community in Qatar.' Haddad's office, in a post on X, called on the international community 'to urge Qatar's government to uphold international law and ensure Mr. Rowhani's immediate release.' There was no immediate response from Qatar's International Media Office to AP's queries about the case. The verdict came just two weeks after a group of U.N. human rights experts expressed 'serious concern' about Rowhani's arrest and detention, which they depicted as 'part of a broader and disturbing pattern of disparate treatment of the Baha'i minority in Qatar.' 'The mere existence of Baha'is in Qatar and their innocuous presence on X cannot be criminalized under international law,' they said. Rowhani -- former head of Qatar's Chamber of Commerce -- had been arrested once previously, accused of offenses such as routine fundraising related to his leadership of Qatar's Baha'i National Assembly. The latest charges, filed in April, involve the Baha'i community's X and Instagram accounts, which contain posts about Qatari holidays and Baha'i writings. According to the documentation provided by the Geneva office, Qatari prosecutors alleged that these accounts 'promoted the ideas and beliefs of a religious sect that raises doubt about the foundations and teachings of the Islamic religion.' Rowhani's daughter, Noora Rowhani, who lives in Australia, said via email that the five-year verdict is 'so unfortunate and so shocking.' 'My eye condition is deteriorating and in five years, even if I meet, him I will most probably not be able to see him anymore,' she added. The Baha'i faith -- a small but global religion with an interfaith credo -- fits comfortably into the religious spectrum of most countries but in several Middle East nations, Baha'i followers face repression that is drawing criticism from rights groups. The abuse is most evident in Iran, which bans the faith and has been widely accused of persecuting Baha'i followers, human rights advocates say. They also report systemic discrimination in Yemen, Qatar and Egypt. Advocates say Iran's government has pressed for repression of the Baha'i followers in countries where it holds influence, such as Yemen, where Iran-backed Houthi rebels control the northern half of the country, and Qatar, which shares with Iran the world's largest natural gas field. The Baha'i faith was founded in the 1860s by Baha'u'llah, a Persian nobleman considered a prophet by his followers. Muslims consider the Prophet Muhammad the highest and last prophet. From the Baha'i faith's earliest days, Shiite Muslim clerics have denounced its followers as apostates. That repression continued after Iran's 1979 Islamic Revolution, when many Baha'i followers were executed or went missing. There are less than 8 million Baha'i believers worldwide, with the largest number in India. Associated Press religion coverage receives support through the AP's collaboration with The Conversation US, with funding from Lilly Endowment Inc. The AP is solely responsible for this content. David Crary, The Associated Press