logo
Spotify used to seem like a necessary evil for musicians. Now it just seems evil

Spotify used to seem like a necessary evil for musicians. Now it just seems evil

The Guardian5 days ago
Being an independent musician comes with plenty of challenges, but it also comes with privileges, and one of them is that you're free to speak your mind. You can live by your beliefs. When necessary, you can kick against the pricks. Today, I am joining a growing number of musicians kicking against one prick in particular. I have decided to remove my music from Spotify.
Don't get me wrong. I appreciate the positive side of streaming. It's convenient, like having your own radio station. If you're in a car and you want to hear Beasley Street by John Cooper Clarke – which I often do – it's there for you. This ease of access is a great thing for the listener.
And it can be a good thing for the artist too, if, after hearing a song on a streaming platform, the listener then buys the album or pays to see the artist in concert. But it's not so great if streaming is the listener's only engagement. Because that accessibility means fewer people now purchase music via digital download, vinyl or CD – which would be fine, if streaming royalty rates weren't atrocious.
Spotify pays artists between $0.003 and $0.005 per stream. For independent artists – especially those from the Pacific and First Nations communities, and artists without the machinery of major labels – this is insulting and completely unsustainable.
A royalty model that is not sustainable for artists leads to a situation where only the independently wealthy can create music – an outcome that is neither culturally healthy nor desirable. Of course, that's assuming the independently wealthy musicians are able to fight off the AI-generated music currently crowding onto the streaming platforms.
Don't think this situation has come about because times are hard for everybody. The music industry is making as much revenue as it did at its 1990s peak, but little of that money is making it through to those who play the instruments or sing the tunes. As musicians, we have been left with little choice but to hold out our begging bowls and tell ourselves that something is better than nothing.
But leaving Spotify is about more than the money. Spotify CEO Daniel Ek recently lead a €600m ($1.07bn) investment in a German defence company called Helsing, which specialises in AI-driven autonomous weapon systems, through his investment firm Prima Materia. Ek is also the chairman of Helsing, having joined the board in 2021 when his investment fund Prima Materia put €100m into the then-startup.
Ek isn't paid a salary by Spotify – he takes a share of its stock, last year alone cashing out a reported $345m. So here we are, artists helping to build algorithms to sell our music – and the success of that algorithm determines the flow of wealth to a man who invests in building machines that could kill people.
In recent years, we've witnessed the horror of AI drone wars in Ukraine and Gaza – children killed and hospitals destroyed with the press of the space bar. Ek is investing in technology that can cause suffering and death. Spotify used to seem like a necessary evil. By association, it now just seems evil.
So I have decided to remove my music from the platform. Many other artists have done the same thing. The removal of my works won't make any significant dent in the company's profits. It won't change my earnings much either, but I can no longer be complicit. I don't want my songs – some written with survivors of conflict – to enrich a man who helps to fund weapons.
And I am urging everyone else to quit Spotify. There are alternatives. These platforms (what a soulless word) are not perfect, but at least they aren't owned by individuals who align themselves with the arms race. If you're an artist, I ask you to think hard about where your music lives. If you're a listener, consider where your money goes. And as a music industry, let's think hard about who we take sponsorship from.
We can't keep handing our creativity, our loyalty and our cash to amoral tech giants who see music as content and war as business. I'd rather earn nothing than profit from destruction. As Deerhoof succinctly put it in their statement on leaving Spotify: 'If the price of 'discoverability' is letting oligarchs fill the globe with computerised weaponry, we're going to pass on the supposed benefit.'
David Bridie is an independent musician, producer and installation artist. Across four decades as a band member, solo artist and composer of film and TV soundtracks, he has released more than 30 albums. He is also the founder and artistic director of Wantok Musik Foundation, a not-for-profit music label that records, releases and promotes culturally infused music from Indigenous Australia, Melanesia and Oceania
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Spotify to hike prices again for millions worldwide next month – here's how much extra YOU'LL need to pay
Spotify to hike prices again for millions worldwide next month – here's how much extra YOU'LL need to pay

Scottish Sun

time7 hours ago

  • Scottish Sun

Spotify to hike prices again for millions worldwide next month – here's how much extra YOU'LL need to pay

The streaming giant is looking to improve its margins CHANGING THEIR TUNE Spotify to hike prices again for millions worldwide next month – here's how much extra YOU'LL need to pay Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) SPOTIFY is set to hike its prices again for their millions of worldwide listeners next month. The price of its monthly premium individual subscription will increase from September in select markets. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 Spotify has been expanding its library of content to attract more subscribers Credit: Getty The Swedish streaming giant made the announcement on Monday, with subscribers expected to receive an email update explaining the price rise over the next month. Premium individual subscriptions will rise from 10.99 euros to 11.99 euros per month. This will occur in markets including South Asia, the Middle East, Africa, Latin America and the Asia-Pacific region. Spotify achieved its first annual profit for 2024, which can be linked to its previous price increases, as well as cost-cutting efforts in recent years. The company's shares have jumped by nearly 8 per cent this year, and they have gained about 40 per cent so far this year. The number of monthly active users and premium subscribers also increased over the second quarter. However, the company reported a loss during the period due to high taxes related to employee salaries. The price hike comes just months after Spotify showed developments on its "lossless audio" feature which is expected to make bills more expensive. It hopes to make songs sound even better for an extra fee for listeners. Last week, it was also revealed the company is making strict changes to its music app that could see some accounts deleted due to new UK age checks. Spotify's new AI feature lets you ask it to make any playlist for you – but there's a trick to finding it in the app Spotify has started showing popups asking people to confirm their age to access certain content made for adults, such as 18+ music videos. Users can confirm their age by sharing a selfie or their ID, a move which is compliance with new laws of the Online Safety Act. It is designed to protect children from easily stumbling across inappropriate material on the internet. A growing number of creators also are said to be joining the Spotify Partner Program. The programme is designed to help offer podcast creators more options for monetising their content. It has has also enabled the significant increase in video content on the platform for subscribers, according to CEO Daniel Ek. SAVE MONEY ON SPOTIFY One of the best ways to save money on Spotify is sharing. With a Premium Family subscription, you and five others can share the cost. You each get your own Spotify account with your own playlists and everything else, it's just billed from one place. To use Premium Family you have to all be living under the same roof. The plan currently costs £19.99. If you split that six ways, you're looking at £3.33 each, which is a lot less than paying for your own individual subscription at £11.99. Image credit: Getty

Hulu is DOWN across US leaving users unable to stream their favorite shows
Hulu is DOWN across US leaving users unable to stream their favorite shows

Daily Mail​

time8 hours ago

  • Daily Mail​

Hulu is DOWN across US leaving users unable to stream their favorite shows

Hulu is down for thousands of users across the US. Downdetector, a site that monitors online outage, shows issues hit the streaming platform around 4pm ET. Subscribers say they are unable to stream their favorite shows and videos, while some cannot log into the website or app. An outage map shows major cities, including New York City, Los Angeles, Tampa and Chicago, are in the red. Hulu has nearly 54 million paying subscribers in the US, and it is unclear how many are struggling to access the platform. Users report seeing an error message: 'We're having trouble loading this right now. Check your internet connection and try again.' Some subscribers have called for refunds amid the outage. 'Why are you down again? Hulu is a lot of money. Are we getting reimbursed?' on user shared on X. This is a developing story... More updates to come Hulu is down for thousands of users across the US. Downdetector, a site that monitors online outage, shows issues hit the streaming platform around 4pm ET. Another user posted on X: 'Getting 'upstream request timeout' statement on web.' Hulu's support page replied, saying that the team is looking into the issue. 'We're currently investigating this behavior with a high priority, and we hope to have a fix in place soon,' the support team shared on X. Some subscribers are being met with an 'Error playing video message.' 'We encountered an error playing this video. Please try restarting the video or select something else to watch,' the alert reads.

Scots Showbiz Star Debbz Stephens Becomes Chilli Eating Chanpion at Foodies Festival
Scots Showbiz Star Debbz Stephens Becomes Chilli Eating Chanpion at Foodies Festival

Scotsman

time12 hours ago

  • Scotsman

Scots Showbiz Star Debbz Stephens Becomes Chilli Eating Chanpion at Foodies Festival

Debbz said to host Jeremy Hitchen that she would like to compete as Craig, at first shocked then supportive, as the Moreish TV host was spotted munching some of the hottest chilli's on the planet. As the contest continued several contestants were seen leaving after they decided enough was enough and Debbz was declared a winner and received a giant Chilli soft toy with a winners rosette, a bottle of Chilli Olive Oil and a Bottle of Bubbly. Foodies Festival organiser Sue Hitchen told Debbz "I am so proud of you, well done on winning such a touch competition, well deserved' and hubby Craig said 'I could never have done that im overly proud of Debbz she loves hot food and can eat Vindaloo easily but never expected this". Debbz said: "That was tough as my tongue was stinging each time the hot Chilli peppers got stronger but hearing Craig support me and several members of the audience shout my name I had to carry on and now I'm over the moon to be the champion". Before heading to Foodies Festival the couple were over in the Czech Republic with music producer and QFX Scottish Dance music star Kirk Turnbull celebrating the release of the track he co write with the couple and he also produced namely Get Up Stand Up by 2Moreish which is now available to download on sites including Spotify, Apply Music, Tidal and Amazon Music 1 . Contributed Winner Debbz with Co star husband Craig and Foodies Festival Organiser Sue Hitchen Photo: Submitted Photo Sales 2 . Contributed Winner Winner Hot Chilli Dinner as Debbz claims victory Photo: Submitted Photo Sales 3 . Contributed Craig at Foodies Festival with Chilli Eating Queen Debbz Photo: Submitted Photo Sales 4 . Contributed 2Moreish Debbz the winner of the yearly Chilli Eating Contest Photo: Submitted Photo Sales

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store