Benjamin Netanyahu threatens to sue NY Times over Gaza coverage: ‘It's such clear defamation'
'The New York Times should be sued,' Netanyahu told Fox News on Thursday, adding: 'I am actually looking into whether a country can sue The New York Times… I think it's such clear defamation.'
Netanyahu's anger stems from a July 24 Times story on hunger in Gaza that ran with a prominent front-page photo of an emaciated 18-month-old boy, Mohammed Zakaria al-Mutawaq.
Advertisement
4 Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has threatened to sue The New York Times over its Gaza starvation coverage, calling it 'clear defamation.'
AP
He described the original presentation as an intentional attempt to smear Israel by implying it was starving Gaza's population.
The child's mother was quoted as saying he had been 'born healthy' before suffering severe malnutrition.
Later reporting revealed Mohammed suffered from cerebral palsy and complications linked to a genetic disorder, details absent from the original article and caption.
Advertisement
The paper faced backlash for misleading readers into believing the boy's condition was the result of Israeli policy.
The Times updated the story on July 30 with an editor's note clarifying the boy's medical history and removing the mother's claim that he was born healthy.
The correction was buried deep in the paper, 'the size of a postage stamp,' Netanyahu said and argued it failed to undo the damage caused by the initial coverage.
Advertisement
The controversy has become a flashpoint in the larger debate over how the war in Gaza is portrayed internationally.
'Israel is presented as though we are applying a campaign of starvation in Gaza,' Netanyahu said.
'What a boldfaced lie. There is no policy of starvation in Gaza, and there is no starvation in Gaza.'
Advertisement
He said that Israel has allowed humanitarian aid into the territory 'throughout the duration of the war' and that shortages are caused by Hamas stealing or diverting supplies.
The Times has defended its work, saying the editor's note reflected new information discovered after publication and that the core reporting on Gaza's humanitarian crisis remains accurate.
'Children in Gaza are malnourished and starving, as New York Times reporters and others have documented,' a spokesperson for the paper said.
4 Netanyahu's anger stems from a July 24 Times story on hunger in Gaza that ran with a prominent front-page photo of an emaciated 18-month-old boy, Mohammed Zakaria al-Mutawaq.
Anadolu via Getty Images
It also pushed back on the Israeli leader's criticism over appending its story.
'Mr. Netanyahu is referring to an update we made to a story about how the food crisis is affecting the civilian population,' the rep said in a statement.
'After publication, we learned that a child shown in that story — in addition to being severely malnourished — also had pre-existing health problems. That additional information gave readers a greater understanding of his situation.'
The Times rep blasted Netanyahu's 'attempts to threaten independent media providing vital information and accountability to the public', saying it was 'unfortunately an increasingly common playbook.'
Advertisement
4 The New York Times appended an editor's note clarifying that the child also had preexisting health conditions.
New York Times/X
The dispute comes as aid agencies and the United Nations continue to report widespread hunger and malnutrition in Gaza.
Relief groups describe catastrophic shortages of food, clean water and medicine, conditions they say are worsening as the war grinds on.
Israel blames Hamas for worsening the situation by seizing shipments, while its critics point to Israeli restrictions and military actions as the primary cause.
Advertisement
Pro-Israel groups and some US lawmakers have backed Netanyahu's criticism, accusing the Times of bias and of pushing a narrative that unfairly paints Israel as responsible for a man-made famine.
Supporters of the paper argue that such attacks are aimed at intimidating journalists and discouraging critical coverage of Israeli policy.
If Netanyahu follows through on his threat to take legal action against the Times, it would not be the first time an Israeli leader has taken an American media outlet to court.
4 The New York Times building in Manhattan, where Netanyahu's dispute with the paper has drawn international attention.
Melissa Bender/NurPhoto/Shutterstock
Advertisement
In 1983, Ariel Sharon, who was defense minister during the Israeli invasion of Lebanon in 1982, filed a libel lawsuit against TIME magazine.
That case revolved around a paragraph suggesting Sharon had urged Lebanese Christian militia leaders to seek revenge shortly before the 1982 Sabra and Shatila massacre, in which hundreds of Palestinian refugees were killed.
Sharon insisted the claim was false and defamatory.
Jurors concluded the disputed paragraph was defamatory and false but also found TIME had not acted with 'actual malice,' the legal standard public figures must meet to collect damages in the United States.
Advertisement
Sharon received no monetary award, and TIME avoided financial liability, even though the jury agreed the reporting harmed his reputation and was untrue.
Both sides claimed victory — Sharon for proving the statement false, and TIME for preserving a key First Amendment protection.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
12 minutes ago
- The Hill
Israeli strike kills Al Jazeera correspondent Anas al-Sharif as toll on journalists in Gaza worsens
JERUSALEM (AP) — Israel's military targeted an Al Jazeera correspondent with an airstrike Sunday, killing him, another network journalist and at least six other people, all of whom were sheltering outside the Gaza City Hospital complex. Officials at Shifa Hospital said those killed included Al Jazeera correspondents Anas al-Sharif and Mohamed Qureiqa. The strike also killed four other journalists and two other people, hospital administrative director Rami Mohanna told The Associated Press. The strike also damaged the entrance to the hospital complex's emergency building. Both Israel and hospital officials in Gaza City confirmed the deaths, which press advocates described as retribution against those documenting the war in Gaza. Israel's military later Sunday described al-Sharif as the leader of a Hamas cell — an allegation that Al Jazeera and al-Sharif had previously dismissed as baseless. The incident marked the first time during the war that Israel's military has swiftly claimed responsibility after a journalist was killed in a strike. It came less than a year after Israeli army officials first accused al-Sharif and other Al Jazeera journalists of being members of the militant groups Hamas and Islamic Jihad. In a July 24 video, Israel's army spokesperson Avichay Adraee attacked Al Jazeera and accused al-Sharif of being part of Hamas' military wing. Al Jazeera calls strike 'assassination' Al Jazeera called the strike 'targeted assassination' and accused Israeli officials of incitement, connecting al-Sharif's death to the allegations that both the network and correspondent had denied. 'Anas and his colleagues were among the last remaining voices from within Gaza, providing the world with unfiltered, on-the-ground coverage of the devastating realities endured by its people,' the Qatari network said in a statement. Apart from rare invitations to observe Israeli military operations, international media have been barred from entering Gaza for the duration of the war. Al Jazeera is among the few outlets still fielding a big team of reporters inside the besieged strip, chronicling daily life amid airstrikes, hunger and the rubble of destroyed neighborhoods. The network has suffered heavy losses during the war, including 27-year-old correspondent Ismail al-Ghoul and cameraman Rami al-Rifi, killed last summer, and freelancer Hossam Shabat, killed in an Israeli airstrike in March. Like al-Sharif, Shabat was among the six that Israel accused of being members of militant groups last October. Funeral-goers call to protect journalists Hundreds of people, including many journalists, gathered Monday to mourn al-Sharif, Qureiqa and their colleagues. The bodies lay wrapped in white sheets at Gaza City's Shifa Hospital complex. Ahed Ferwana of the Palestinian Journalists Syndicate said reporters were being deliberately targeted and urged the international community to act. Al-Sharif reported a nearby bombardment minutes before his death. In a social media post that Al Jazeera said was written to be posted in case of his death, he bemoaned the devastation and destruction that war had wrought and bid farewell to his wife, son and daughter. 'I never hesitated for a single day to convey the truth as it is, without distortion or falsification,' the 28-year-old wrote. The journalists are the latest to be killed in what observers have called the deadliest conflict for journalists in modern times. The Committee to Protect Journalists said on Sunday that at least 186 have been killed in Gaza, and Brown University's Watson Institute in April said the war was 'quite simply, the worst ever conflict for reporters.' Al-Sharif began reporting for Al Jazeera a few days after war broke out. He was known for reporting on Israel's bombardment in northern Gaza, and later for the starvation gripping much of the territory's population. Qureiqa, a 33-year-old Gaza City native, is survived by two children. Both journalists were separated from their families for months earlier in the war. When they managed to reunite during the ceasefire earlier this year, their children appeared unable to recognize them, according to video footage they posted at the time. In a July broadcast al-Sharif cried on air as woman behind him collapsed from hunger. 'I am taking about slow death of those people,' he said at the time. Al Jazeera is blocked in Israel and soldiers raided its offices in the occupied West Bank last year, ordering them closed. Al-Sharif's death comes weeks after a U.N. expert and the New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists said Israel had targeted him with a smear campaign. Irene Khan, the U.N. Special Rapporteur on freedom of expression, on July 31 said that the killings were 'part of a deliberate strategy of Israel to suppress the truth, obstruct the documentation of international crimes and bury any possibility of future accountability.' The Committee to Protect Journalists said on Sunday that it was appalled by the strike. 'Israel's pattern of labeling journalists as militants without providing credible evidence raises serious questions about its intent and respect for press freedom,' Sara Qudah, the group's regional director, said in a statement.
Boston Globe
12 minutes ago
- Boston Globe
Israeli strike kills journalists in Gaza City, worsening the death toll for the media
Advertisement The incident marked the first time during the war that Israel's military has swiftly claimed responsibility after a journalist was killed in a strike. It came less than a year after Israeli army officials first accused al-Sharif and other Al Jazeera journalists of being members of the militant groups Hamas and Islamic Jihad. In a July 24 video, Israel's army spokesperson Avichay Adraee attacked Al Jazeera and accused al-Sharif of being part of Hamas' military wing. Al Jazeera called the strike 'targeted assassination' and accused Israeli officials of incitement, connecting al-Sharif's death to the allegations that both the network and correspondent had denied. 'Anas and his colleagues were among the last remaining voices from within Gaza, providing the world with unfiltered, on-the-ground coverage of the devastating realities endured by its people,' the Qatari network said in a statement. Advertisement International media have been mostly barred from entering Gaza throughout the war and Al Jazeera is among the few outlets still fielding a big team of reporters inside Gaza, chronicling daily life amid airstrikes, hunger and the rubble of destroyed neighborhoods. The network has suffered heavy losses during the war, including 27-year-old correspondent Ismail al-Ghoul and cameraman Rami al-Rifi, killed last summer, and freelancer Hossam Shabat, killed in an Israeli airstrike in March. Like al-Sharif, Shabat was among the six that Israel accused of being members of militant groups last October. Hundreds of people, including many journalists, gathered Monday to mourn al-Sharif, Qureiqa and their colleagues. The bodies lay wrapped in white sheets at Gaza City's Shifa Hospital complex. Ahed Ferwana of the Palestinian Journalists Syndicate said reporters were being deliberately targeted and urged the international community to act. Al-Sharif reported a nearby bombardment minutes before his death. In a social media post that Al Jazeera said was written to be posted in case of his death, he bemoaned the devastation and destruction that war had wrought and bid farewell to his wife, son and daughter. 'I never hesitated for a single day to convey the truth as it is, without distortion or falsification,' the 28-year-old wrote. The journalists are the latest to be killed in what observers have called the deadliest conflict for journalists in modern times. The Committee to Protect Journalists said on Sunday that at least 186 have been killed in Gaza and Brown University's Watson Institute in April said the war was 'quite simply, the worst ever conflict for reporters.' Al-Sharif began reporting for Al Jazeera a few days after war broke out. He was known for reporting on Israel's bombardment in northern Gaza, and later for the starvation gripping much of the territory's population. Qureiqa, a 33-year-old Gaza City native, is survived by two children. Advertisement Both journalists were separated from their families for months earlier in the war. When they managed to reunite during the ceasefire earlier this year, their children appeared unable to recognize them, according to video footage they posted at the time. In a July broadcast al-Sharif cried on air as woman behind him collapsed from hunger. 'I am taking about slow death of those people,' he said at the time. Al Jazeera is blocked in Israel and soldiers raided its offices in the occupied West Bank last year, ordering them closed. Al-Sharif's death comes weeks after a U.N. expert and the New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists said Israel had targeted him with a smear campaign. Irene Khan, the U.N. Special Rapporteur on freedom of expression, on July 31 said that the killings were 'part of a deliberate strategy of Israel to suppress the truth, obstruct the documentation of international crimes and bury any possibility of future accountability.' The Committee to Protect Journalists said on Sunday that it was appalled by the strike. 'Israel's pattern of labeling journalists as militants without providing credible evidence raises serious questions about its intent and respect for press freedom,' Sara Qudah, the group's regional director, said in a statement. Magdy reported from Cairo.
Yahoo
41 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Netanyahu Defends Gaza City Takeover Amid UN Warnings
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has defended the planned military takeover of Gaza City, despite increasing global criticism and warnings from the UN.
