Global Plastics Treaty: India backs 'weak' plastic treaty draft with no cap on production, toxic chemicals
'We have some serious concerns on the text proposed by you, as we see many fundamental elements (scope) missing from the text,' said Naresh Pal Gangwar, Joint Secretary in the Union Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEF&CC) and head of India's delegation. 'Having said this, we consider this as a good enough starting point to further our work… We also urge other member states to have trust in your leadership and express their concern during the consultation process.'
The new draft, released by Intergovernmental Negotiating Committee (INC) Chair Luis Vayas Valdivieso, just ahead of the scheduled plenary on Wednesday evening, retains voluntary measures on product redesign, recycling, and waste management but deletes a previous article on production limits and omits all reference to chemicals of concern. The only nod to production appears in the preamble — a symbolic gesture far from the binding commitments sought by more than 100 countries.
India's alignment with the LMC, led by Kuwait and including Saudi Arabia, Iran, and Malaysia, places it firmly in the camp resisting upstream measures that target the root cause of plastic pollution — the sheer volume of plastic being produced. The bloc has consistently opposed any global phase-out list, production caps, or trade restrictions on plastic products.
The EU and its 27 member states blasted the draft, saying it 'doesn't meet the minimum requirements and falls short of UNEA 5/14,' and called for reinstating strong, binding measures to curb virgin plastic output. Norway, co-chair of the High Ambition Coalition, said the text was 'not acceptable as it stands.' Colombia outright rejected it as 'imbalanced,' drawing applause from observers and high-ambition delegations.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
11 hours ago
- Time of India
Global plastic treaty talks end without deal amid sharp rifts
New Delhi: After nearly two weeks of negotiations in Geneva , talks to finalise an international treaty to combat plastic pollution ended in the early hours of Friday without an agreement. The Geneva meeting was supposed to conclude an intergovernmental process that began in 2022, following a decision at the fifth United Nations Environment Assembly to design and adopt an internationally legally binding treaty to combat plastic pollution. Despite efforts by Luis Vayas Valdivieso, the chair of the negotiating committee, to arrive at consensus, countries failed to bridge their differences over issues such as reducing production of plastic polymers, including impact of plastics on health. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Play War Thunder now for free War Thunder Play Now Undo Broadly, fossil fuel and plastic producing countries such as Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, India advocated an approach that focuses on managing plastic waste while a large group comprising mostly small island states, Latin America, Africa and the European Union advocated for reduction in plastic production and in the use of toxic chemicals in plastic production as well as managing plastic waste. In the last 48 hours of the talks, Valdiveso produced two versions of a draft text that sought to bridge these positions. The first draft proposed by the chair on August 13 was criticised by countries proposing a production-to-disposal approach to plastic pollution as "unacceptable". The second iteration produced by the chair following round the clock consultations with countries including creating a smaller representative group did not find favour with countries advocating a narrower approach. Live Events The talks will now be resumed later, though the date is as yet undecided. Speaking to the media at the end of the meeting, UN Environment Programme Executive Secretary Inger Andersen said, "This has been a hard-fought 10 days against the backdrop of geopolitical complexities, economic challenges, and multilateral strains. However, one thing remains clear: despite these complexities, all countries clearly want to remain at the table. While we did not land the treaty text we hoped for, we at UNEP will continue the work against plastic pollution - pollution that is in our groundwater, in our soil, in our rivers, in our oceans and yes, in our bodies." India, despite its domestic policy on plastics, particularly single use plastic, extended producer responsibility, was among the countries vocal in their opposition to an approach that would include production of plastic polymers and use of chemicals in the agreement. For the first time since the plastic treaty talks began in 2022, India came out openly in support of the Like Minded Group , a loose group of 30 countries including Russia, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Malaysia. The Like-Minded Group and the Arab Group advocate a treaty that is effectively a waste management treaty on plastic products. In closed door meetings and submissions to the UN's plastic secretariat, India has made it clear it would not support any agreement that calls for cutting production of plastics. It argued that issues of impact on health were dealt with by agencies such as the WHO and were therefore beyond the mandate of the intergovernmental negotiations.
New Indian Express
20 hours ago
- New Indian Express
Global plastics treaty talks collapse in Geneva, future negotiations uncertain
GENEVA: After three years of negotiations, global efforts to finalise the world's first legally binding treaty to end plastic pollution collapsed without agreement in Geneva on Friday. Delegates from nearly 180 countries failed to reach consensus on a draft treaty, revealing deep divisions over the scope of the deal, decision-making procedures, and whether the treaty should address plastic production itself. Despite night-long discussions and a chaotic final plenary session that stretched into the early hours, negotiators were unable to bridge the widening fault lines. A revised draft text presented by the Chair lacked consensus, and by dawn, a weary room of delegates conceded there would be no deal. At the heart of the breakdown were conflicting visions. The High Ambition Coalition, made up of over 100 countries including the European Union, African nations, and small island states, pushed for a robust agreement with binding measures to reduce plastic production, phase out single-use items like cutlery and cups, and strengthen reuse and recycling systems. They also called for majority voting rules at future Conferences of the Parties (COP), arguing that consensus-based decision-making could paralyse the treaty. Opposing them was a bloc of oil-producing nations, including Saudi Arabia, Iran, and Russia, which dubbed itself the 'Like-Minded Group'. Backed by India, this coalition resisted any regulation of upstream plastic production and insisted the treaty should focus solely on waste management. They also opposed any move away from consensus decision-making. India's position was outlined in detail by Neelesh Kumar Sah, Joint Secretary in the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change. Speaking during the closing plenary, Sah argued that the treaty's scope must align strictly with the original 2022 UNEA 5/14 resolution, meaning it should focus on plastic pollution, not production. 'We look at the treaty as addressing plastic pollution unambiguously, and not to delve into regulating the production of primary plastic polymers,' Sah said. He also rejected the idea of globally mandated phase-outs for specific products or chemicals, and firmly reiterated that all treaty decisions should be made by consensus. On financing, India warned against any mechanisms that could place an undue burden on developing nations, stressing the need for technology transfer to be mandatory, not voluntary. 'A financial mechanism not based on the Rio Principles will put undue burden on developing countries, defeating the very purpose of fighting plastic pollution,' Sah added. The final hours of the fifth session of the Intergovernmental Negotiating Committee (INC-5.2) were marked by confusion and disarray. The plenary was adjourned near midnight on what was supposed to be the last day, only to be abruptly reconvened at 5:30am, a move that left smaller delegations unprepared and under-resourced. A final draft was only released hours earlier. Civil society groups voiced strong criticism of the process. 'No treaty is better than a bad treaty,' said Ana Rocha of the Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives (GAIA). 'Once again, negotiations collapsed, derailed by a chaotic and biased process that left even the most engaged countries struggling to be heard.' Swathi Seshadri, a petrochemical analyst at the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (IEEFA), said that despite the collapse, the urgency remains. 'There is hope, as negotiations will continue in a resumed session. But member states must act quickly. The polymer industry is already facing slower growth, lower margins, and reduced profitability, particularly in the Asia-Pacific region, where most expansion is expected. Delay will only deepen the economic and environmental cost,' she said.
NDTV
20 hours ago
- NDTV
Plastic Pollution Treaty Talks Collapse Without An Agreement
Switzerland: Talks aimed at striking a landmark global treaty on plastic pollution fell apart Friday without agreement, as countries failed to find consensus on how the world should tackle the ever-growing scourge. Negotiators from 185 nations worked beyond Thursday's deadline and through the night in an ultimately futile search for common ground between nations wanting bold action such as curbing plastic production, and oil-producing states preferring to focus more narrowly on waste management. Several countries voiced bitter disappointment as the talks unravelled, but said they were prepared for future negotiations -- despite six rounds of talks over three years now having failed to find agreement. "We have missed a historic opportunity but we have to keep going and act urgently. The planet and present and future generations need this treaty," said Cuba. Colombia added: "The negotiations were consistently blocked by a small number of states who simply don't want an agreement." Tuvalu, speaking for 14 Pacific small island developing states, said they were once again leaving empty-handed. "For our islands this means that without global cooperation and state action, millions of tonnes of plastic waste will continue to be dumped in our oceans, affecting our ecosystem, food security, livelihood and culture," the Polynesian archipelago said. Pollution fight 'cannot end here' The High Ambition Coalition, which includes the European Union, Britain and Canada, and many African and Latin American countries, wanted to see language on reducing plastic production and the phasing out of toxic chemicals used in plastics. A cluster of mostly oil-producing states calling themselves the Like-Minded Group -- including Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Russia, Iran, and Malaysia -- want the treaty to have a much narrower remit. "Our views were not reflected... without an agreed scope, this process cannot remain on the right track and risks sliding down a slippery slope," said Kuwait. Bahrain said it wanted a treaty that "does not penalise developing countries for exploiting their own resources". France's Ecological Transition Minister Agnes Pannier-Runacher said: "I am disappointed, and I am angry," saying a handful of countries, "guided by short-term financial interests", had blocked the adoption of an ambitious treaty. "Oil-producing countries and their allies have chosen to look the other way." The future of the negotiations was not immediately clear. Some countries called for a seventh round of talks in future, with the EU saying the latest draft was a "good basis for a resumed session", and South Africa insisting: "It cannot end here." The talks in Geneva -- called after the collapse of the fifth and supposedly final round of talks in South Korea late last year -- opened on August 5. Last-ditch scramble With countries far apart, talks chair Luis Vayas Valdivieso produced a draft text Wednesday based on the limited areas of convergence. But it was immediately shredded by all sides, plunging the talks into disarray, with the high ambition group finding it shorn of all impact, and the Like-Minded Group saying it crossed their red lines and lacked scope. Vayas spend Thursday in a frantic round of negotiations with regional groups, and produced a new version after midnight. Lead negotiators then held a meeting behind closed doors to thrash out whether there was enough in the text to keep talking. But shortly before sunrise, the game was up. Dumped, burned and discarded More than 400 million tonnes of plastic are produced globally each year, half of which is for single-use items. While 15 percent of plastic waste is collected for recycling, only nine percent is actually recycled. Nearly half, or 46 percent, ends up in landfills, while 17 percent is incinerated and 22 percent is mismanaged and becomes litter. The plastic pollution problem is so ubiquitous that microplastics have been found on the highest mountain peaks, in the deepest ocean trench and scattered throughout almost every part of the human body. On current trends, annual production of fossil-fuel-based plastics will nearly triple by 2060 to 1.2 billion tonnes, while waste will exceed one billion tonnes, according to the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development. (Except for the headline, this story has not been edited by NDTV staff and is published from a syndicated feed.)
