Driver behind Hunter Valley bus crash that killed 10 to fight sentence
Ten people died when a bus flipped on Wine Country Drive near Greta on the way back from a wedding reception on June 11, 2023.
Bus driver Brett Button had taken 'significantly more' than his prescribed dose of the opioid-based painkiller Tramadol on the day of the horrific crash.
He'd also been stood down by a previous employer just a year prior after a pain specialist found he was addicted to Tramadol — which he'd been taking since the 1990s — and he did not tell operator Linq Buslines he was using the painkiller.
Button initially faced 10 counts of manslaughter, however; they were ultimately dropped after prosecutors agreed to a plea deal, much to the anger of the victims' families.
He pleaded guilty to 10 counts of dangerous driving occasioning death and nine of dangerous driving occasioning grievous bodily harm.
Button was sentenced to 32 years behind bars with a non-parole period of 24 years last year.
However, he has since moved to fight the sentence, with the matter heard briefly in Sydney's Court of Criminal Appeal on Thursday morning.
The Crown prosecutor told the court that it was an 'unusual matter'.
'It is only a sentence appeal – I don't use the word only lightly,' she told the court.
'There are three grounds of appeal.
'It is an unusual matter.'
The grounds of appeal are expected to be released sometime on Thursday or Friday, registrar Peter Clayton told the court.
She said there would be several victim impact statements in the 'fairly lengthy' Crown bundle.
'As I indicated, a number of victim impact statements, medical reports … quite a volume of documentary evidence,' she said.
She also indicated there'd be character references for Button.
Lawyers for Button didn't expect there to be re-sentencing materials put before the court at this stage.
He is set to front the court via a video link for a hearing on October 3.
Andrew Scott, 35, his wife Lynan Scott, 33, Nadene McBride, 52, her daughter Kyah McBride, 22, and her partner, Kane Symons, 21, Darcy Bulman, 30, Rebecca Mullen, 26, Zachary Bray, 29, Tori Cowburn, 29, and Angus Craig, 28, were killed in the crash.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
SA looks to fast-track childcare mobile phone ban after allegations of abuse in Victoria
The South Australian government is investigating whether it can expedite a ban on mobile phones in childcare centres, following allegations of child abuse material being produced at a Victorian childcare centre. The personal electronic device ban is due to come into force nationally in September, but the state government said on Thursday it was investigating whether the ban could be "brought forward even sooner". Education Minister Blair Boyer has also asked for "urgent advice" on installing CCTV in early childhood education centres (ECEC), adopting a register of educators, and strengthening the capacity of the regulator to notify families when issues arise. "I note the immediate actions relating to child safety announced by Victoria today, in light of the serious charges laid against a childcare worker," he wrote to chief executives of SA's Office for Early Childhood Development and Education Standards Board. It comes after Victorian police charged a childcare worker with more than 70 offences relating to eight alleged victims at a centre in Melbourne's south-west. Victorian Premier Jacinta Allan is also looking to bring forward a ban on mobile phones in childcare centres in that state. South Australian Attorney-General Kyam Maher said Mr Boyer had been working towards the ban in childcare centres for "some time" and was now seeking to have it brought forward. "Not having individual electronic devices that can record footage means film can't be made that can be passed on," he said. "It's a pretty self-explanatory thing that's being sought to be curtailed or banned." Mr Maher said the government was "keen to examine" any suggestions put forward that improved child safety, following the allegations in Victoria. "I think everyone was shocked, sickened and horrified," he said. Meanwhile, child sex offenders have been banned from working alongside child employees in South Australia. The legislation came into effect at the start of July, after passing state parliament last year. It applies to registered child sex offenders or those who have been charged with registrable child sex offences but not yet convicted. The SA government said previous laws only restricted child sex offenders in settings where children were the subject of the work, such as childcare. Mr Maher said the penalty for breaching the law was up to five years in jail. "SAPOL have now written to all of those who are registered to let them know of this change in the law," he said.
The Australian
2 hours ago
- The Australian
Melbourne: Redline auto electrics car shop targeted in Melton factory fire
Police are investigating a suspicious fire that broke out at a car repairs shop in the outer suburbs of Melbourne early on Thursday morning. The fire broke out at a factory on Glenville Drive in Melton about 2.50am. No one was inside the premises at the time of the incident. The business is Redline auto electrics and airconditioning. Its Facebook page with more than 600 followers shows custom jobs modifying often niche and retro cars. Police on scene after a suspicious factory fire in Glenville Drive, Melton. Picture: NewsWire/Ian Currie Police said the fire caused extensive damage to the building. A crime scene has been established, and the investigation is ongoing. Police are urging anyone who witnessed the incident, has CCTV or dashcam footage, or has information to contact Crime Stoppers on 1800 333 000 or submit a confidential report online at Redline auto electrics and airconditioning did not respond to NewsWire's request for comment. More to come Robert White Cadet Robert got his start as an Editorial Assistant at the Daily Telegraph in 2024 before entering the Newscorp cadet program. With a background in history and law Robert has a passion for politics and crime reporting as well as telling meaningful stories. @white_robb73416 Robert White
ABC News
2 hours ago
- ABC News
Tony Burke had a busy week with a cyber hack, arts backpedal and immigration detention debate
Welcome back to your weekly federal politics update, where Brett Worthington gets you up to speed on the happenings from Parliament House. The minister walked into a studio. Add in his three portfolios and on the surface it's classic joke structure. A man walks into a familiar environment and hilarity ensues. Tony Burke, the minister for home affairs and immigration, cyber security and the arts, was the man walking into the ABC studio this week. But once he started talking, it was clear that there wouldn't be a laugh anywhere in sight. Burke is one of the most senior figures in Prime Minister Anthony Albanese's government. When the parliament is sitting, he runs the House of Representatives and is among the names thrown around as could-be prime ministers one day (though, in fairness, there are no shortage of names that get thrown in that category). His hefty workload is a sign of the trust Albanese puts in him but it also means, as was the case this week, he's a man trying to put out many fires on many fronts. Burke's week started with a Sunday morning interview on Sky News, in which he conceded nobody in the so-called NZYQ cohort had come close to meeting the threshold to be re-detained. The cohort consists of hundreds of people released from immigration detention after a landmark High Court ruling found their detention was unconstitutional. The ruling prompted a raft of legislative responses rushed through the federal parliament at breakneck speed, including ankle monitoring, curfews and mandatory jail sentences for visa breaches. There was also the establishment of a preventative detention regime, which allows authorities to apply to a court to have someone re-detained if they were deemed a threat to the community. "No-one has come close to reaching the threshold that is in that legislation," Burke told Sky News. The minister's comments prompted Coalition cries that the laws need to be re-written, not that the Coalition was rushing to offer up any suggestions on what that might look like. Burke, instead, has other plans. "I keep meeting with the department and keep asking, 'OK what people do we have at different thresholds that we can run a case …' I'm not giving up, I'm going to keep doing it, but I'll tell you, to be honest, I would much prefer the individuals out of the country," he said. Given the whopping majority the government commands in the parliament, Coalition demands can be easily dismissed. Labor backbenchers furious that the party breached its platform kept stayed quiet when the government rushed mandatory sentencing laws through parliament last term. At the time, the spectre of a Peter Dutton-led Coalition government spooked those who might otherwise speak out against their party. But with Dutton now vanquished and another election years away, quietening concerns on the backbench will become a much harder feat. By Wednesday, Burke was walking into the ABC's studios in Melbourne, where another scandal was engulfing another portfolio. Hours earlier, Qantas admitted it had fallen victim to a massive cyber hack on a third-party platform that held the records of 6 million customers. The airline confirmed names, email addresses and phone numbers had been accessed, but credit card and passport details were not. Burke, wearing his cyber security hat, said he'd spoken with the acting chief executive twice earlier in the day and that the airline was fully co-operating with the government. "I know that Qantas have been doing a lot over time to uplift their cyber security," he said. "But, you know, any vulnerability is unacceptable." The interview was only just getting started and Burke was suddenly having to account for another scandal that had engulfed another of his portfolios. As he reached for his arts minister hat (you can decide what that might look like), he told the ABC that 20 minutes before he'd entered the studio he had taken a call from Creative Australia chief executive Adrian Collette. Collette was was ringing to tell Burke that Khaled Sabsabi had been reinstated as Australia's representative at the 2026 Venice Biennale. It's been a rollercoaster few months for Sabsabi, who was commissioned for the prestigious art event in February, only for him and curator Michael Dagostino to have their invitation rescinded a week later when the Creative Australia board intervened. Their initial announcement prompted criticism in the federal parliament, with Liberals condemning works from decades earlier that depicted former Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah, and a 2006 work depicting the September 11 attacks. In the months since, there's been a review of the initial decision that found "no single or predominant failure of process, governance or decision making that resulted, ultimately, in the decision to rescind the selection of the artistic team", but instead "a series of missteps, assumptions and missed opportunities". Burke told the ABC that all decisions had been at arms-length from his office but that he had continue to support the board throughout. "When they made the decision to appoint, I said I supported it," Burke said. "When they made the decision to terminate, I said I'd support that." (The whole description sounded a lot like Pauline Hanson in 2018 when she insisted she hadn't flip flopped: "I said no originally, then I said yes. Then I have said no, and I've stuck to it." But we digress) The saga has seen prominent departures from Creative Australia. Burke insists the organisation retains his confidence. There's no doubt Burke, a guitarist, is a lover of the arts, particularly live music. But with everything else already on his dance card, the sector is closely waiting to decide if the portfolio needs to go to someone who can dedicate more time to the role given the dire outlook for parts of the $64 billion sector. Politicians are often accused of being out of touch and detached from the issues of real people. Anyone watching Sunrise on Wednesday morning got to see just how human they can be. Speaking about a horrific story that emerged from Victoria a day earlier, Housing Minister Clare O'Neil wiped away tears as she spoke of the panic she was struck by when she frantically checked if her children attended a centre linked to an alleged child sex offender. The incident prompted the state government to urge infectious diseases testing for about 1,200 children. Inquiries were launched, there were calls for a royal commission and the federal government quickly vowed it would cut the purse strings to centres that put child safety at risk. It's been a decade since a royal commissioner recommended working with children checks should be streamlined and standardised across the country, and federal education minister Jason Clare this week conceded implementing that change had taken too long. He conceded the system wasn't up to scratch and that change "can't happen soon enough". Like O'Neil, there are no shortage of parents of young children that sit around Albanese's cabinet table. The public has seen the outrage they felt following the revelations from Melbourne. They're also now watching to see what the government does to stop it happening again.
