Plan for 'poor quality' HMO for up to 17 people on family road kicked out
City planners issued a scathing report as they turned down a proposal to convert a property on Etwall Road, a five-bedroom family home in Hall Green, into a nine-bed HMO.
Dozens of neighbours objected, with concerns ranging from anti-social behaviour, noise, overlooking and the loss of privacy to parking and traffic concerns.
READ MORE: UK households risk £200 fine for binning toothpaste tubes ahead of new bin rules
READ MORE: England fans face £500 fine for wearing Lionesses shirts for Euro 2025
READ MORE: Birmingham bin strike latest as solidarity 'megapicket' halts waste wagons
Backed by Coun Timothy Huxtable, locals also worried about the loss of a family home, the close proximity to a nursery and the overdevelopment of the site.
The council agreed with their complaints and refused the application citing lack of parking and that development would be "poor quality living accommodation."
Get breaking news on BirminghamLive WhatsApp, click the link to join
The decision read: "The proposed change of use of the property would result in the loss of a five-bedroom family dwelling house, and insufficient justification has been provided to demonstrate that the need for a House in Multiple Occupation (HMO) in this location outweighs the important contribution this dwelling makes to the council's objectives, strategies and policies relating to housing provision."
The report went on: "The occupation of the property as an HMO by up to 17 people would result in a demonstrable increase in the numbers of comings and goings from the site and a greater level of noise and disturbance in comparison to the existing use as a family dwelling house.
"The proposed HMO would not, therefore, be appropriate to this location as it would result in unacceptable adverse impacts on the amenity of neighbouring occupiers."
Coun Huxtable said: "I'm really pleased this application has been refused as it would have detrimentally changed the whole character of the area and caused additional traffic problems to those already faced by local residents."
We have a suite of newsletters, tailored to your needs. They include Birmingham Politics, Nostalgia, Court and Crime Updates and, of course, BirminghamLive Daily - the biggest stories of the day sent at morning, lunch and evening.
There are also local ones like Black Country News, MySolihull and MySuttonColdfield. Choose which newsletters best suit you.
You can also get all your favourite content from BirminghamLive on WhatsApp. Click here to sign up for breaking updates about the biggest stories in the region.
And finally, if there is a story you think our journalists should be looking into, we want to hear from you. Email us on newsdesk@birminghammail.co.uk.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Plan to use cabin in grounds of home as a holiday let
THE owners of a cabin in the grounds of a house at Holt are asking permission to use it as a holiday let. The building, known as the Tree House, although not in a tree, sits on the corner of the site at Anchor Paddock in Batchelors Lane. Dorset Council is being asked to approve the change of use. The planning application, and others in the area, can be viewed on the authority's website using the references provided. P/FUL/2025/04518 : Anchor Paddock, The Tree House Batchelors Lane Holt BH21 7DS. Re-use of the existing building (known as The Treehouse) for holiday let purposes. P/HOU/2025/03952 : Bankside Holt Wood Horseshoes to Billberies Farm Lane Pond Head Rd Holt BH21 7DX. Alterations and extension to existing dwelling and retention of detached garage P/HOU/2025/04021 : Homeland Holt Wood Holt BH21 7DX. Erect single storey side extension P/FUL/2025/04731 : Meadow Cottage Horton Road Church Hill Woodlands To Horton Lane Woodlands BH21 8NB. Change of use of stables and conversion to residential accommodation
Yahoo
4 days ago
- Yahoo
Inside the Birmingham homeless shelter with sleeping pods and curfew where residents feel 'lucky'
Nestled in a former priest quarters under a mint green dome recognisable to most Brummies is a homeless centre where residents are given a second chance. It's one of the hottest days of the year and we're spending the morning at Tabor Living, a homeless accommodation in Birmingham. Tabor provides a roof, hot meals and mentoring to a group of around 15 residents in partnership with Father Hudson's Care - but is strict with who it accepts in order to give them the best chance at succeeding. READ MORE: I tried to retire three times but ditched the quiet life to train as a West Midlands coach driver READ MORE: Call for gambling tax hike to pull kids out of poverty as grim Birmingham picture laid bare We're in the grounds of St Catherine of Siena church, who in 2023, divided up some of their building so Tabor could move in. The majority of residents here, 12 men and 3 women, are in work or have their own businesses. "We look for people who are really looking to move on and they are looking for this kind of support and who need the space and time to build their finances" caseworker Bella Birch tells us. "You can see things reflected in society come through here, for example Section 21, which we were not seeing a year ago. That can then spiral into everything else" she added. Bella initially started as a volunteer, and is clearly is trusted by the residents, helping them with everything from visa rules to cooking food and getting a stall licence. Project manager Sharon Fear adds that it is a person's willingness to move forward and receive help that helps them qualify to live here. Any new resident will be interviewed by Bella and Sharon, who look for things like "motivation" and "routine." Jackie Webb, a parishioner of 40 years, has seen a number of changes in the area and in Birmingham, which is reflected in the congregation, mostly made up of young families. The 74-year-old volunteers to help with the daily running of the church, explaining: "Tabor are very careful who they take." Referring to the area outside the church and the nearby subway, Jackie said: "We had a huge drug problem, people would shoot up and inject drugs. "Since Tabor came in it's cleaned up around here. Residents will come and help with gardening. "Our former 6ft 4 priest once went through the tunnel and was mugged, they realised he was a priest and they apologised! "I would run through it, it was really terrible. "It is a good use of space. I don't think Tabor has many failures." Tabor Living has nine emergency beds, 11 'next steps' rooms, and a communal area where residents share meals cooked by volunteers. Former market stall owner Rubi Das moved to Tabor in June after she was served a Section 21 notice, which allows landlords to evict tenants without a reason within eight weeks, in what is known as a no-fault eviction. 47-year-old Rubi said despite everything, she feels "lucky." "I didn't want to tell my friends [about being homeless], I felt low about it, people look at you in a different way" she said. Recalling her first day, Rubi said: When I came here everything changed, I was treated with respect. "I started feeling settled after a few weeks. "Losing my business and house, I was very stressed. "People think when you are homeless that's it, but it's not. "A lot of people give up, it's made me determined in my situation that I have been in." When people first arrive, they live in the row of 'pods' on the ground floor, with the aim that they will move upstairs, to the bigger rooms where you pay rent. With glass panes and a small window, the pods are a capsule with a charger, lamp, bed, table, chair and clothes rack. Sharon and Bella explained they help people with no recourse to public funds, voluntarily returning migrants, hospitality workers, warehouse workers, construction workers, to name a few. They also only assist people legally allowed to live and work in the country and "lower risk people" so residents can remain "focussed." When we visited Tabor two years ago there were more Eastern European residents, this year they are seeing more from West Africa, as well as locally from Birmingham and the UK. Residents must be in by 7:30pm to take part in the communal meals or come back to sort things like paperwork, and we're told the average stay is four months. Those who go upstairs to the 'move-on' rooms pay £400 a month - like Rubi. "I have been saving money I am determined to get somewhere" she said. She added: "There is light at the end of the tunnel."
Yahoo
12-08-2025
- Yahoo
Consultation launched into parking charges at major Birmingham parks and some say 'it's wrong'
Public consultation into parking charges at a popular country park in Birmingham has started - and members of the public have aired their concerns ahead of a decision being made. Birmingham City Council is running a formal consultation on whether it should charge motorists to park at Sheldon Country Park, a vast city green space, popular with Birmingham Airport plane spotters. The local authority is also formally seeking the views of the public on introducing parking charges at Sutton Park in Sutton Coldfield, and Lickey Hills Country park. READ MORE: Inside Birmingham gun station that ran from city home as pictures show crime among domestic life READ MORE: Every single crime in the West Midlands as police say less reported Council bosses said income from the proposed introduction of parking charges at all three major sites will contribute to ongoing upkeep and maintenance. It suggested that the cash will also be used for future improvements to the parks. The consultation for all three sites began on August 1 and will end on August 29 and Brummies have been urged to share their opinions on the "rate of charging and when you should be charged." Worried BirminghamLive readers have already shared their worry as the consultation period gets underway this summer holiday break. Commenting on our Facebook post, Robert Smith said: "It's a disgrace. They are public amenities, not business parks." Monica Lee Lee added: "It's wrong it makes a cheap affordable day out not affordable for some." Referring to the history of Sutton Park, Alan Johnson said: "Sutton Park was given to the people of the town by Henry the Eighth [residents] should not have to pay. More revenue would be made from people parking on the pavements." On the ongoing proposals, Cllr Majid Mahmood, cabinet member for environment and transport, said: 'We have some wonderful parks and green spaces across the city, but we need to be able to maintain them for the benefit of everyone. Introducing parking charges at these three major sites will help protect and maintain all our green spaces. 'Whether you use these parks for walking, cycling, exercising or meeting up with people, we want to hear your views on rate of charging and when you should be charged. 'We are also aware of potential impact of displacement parking and will therefore be looking at traffic restrictions in existing hotspot areas and any need for further restrictions following residents' feedback.' Details of proposed charges for three major city parks Proposed pricing structure for Sheldon Country Park 75p hourly rate (per hour, for up to 3 hours) £3.50 all day (3 hours+) £52 season ticket (annual) Free for blue badge holders Proposed pricing structure for Lickey Hills Country Park £1 hourly rate (per hour, for up to 4 hours) £5 all day (4 hours+) £28 coach parking (Beacon Hill only) £52 season ticket (annual) Free for blue badge holders Proposed pricing structure for Sutton Park £1 hourly rate (per hour, for up to 4 hours) £5 all day (4 hours+) £52 season ticket (annual) Free for blue badge holders
