Kilkenny must evolve to keep pace with competitors if they're to end Liam MacCarthy drought
Kilkenny
hurling, mulling over the county's longest wait.
Kilkenny are now officially going through their most protracted Liam MacCarthy Cup drought since they first won an
All-Ireland senior hurling
title in 1904. They had decade-long gaps without major silverware between 1922-32 and 1947-57, but Sunday's defeat to
Tipperary
ensures Kilkenny's current barren period will continue until at least 2026.
They were last crowned All-Ireland champions in 2015. In the 10 years before that the Cats owned hurling, winning eight All-Ireland titles between 2006 and 2015.
A shot of Brian Cody briefly flashed up on the screen during Sunday's semi-final. Cody, the most successful manager in the history of the game, stepped down as Kilkenny boss three years ago.
READ MORE
Several of his former players were dotted around Croke Park on Sunday – Henry Shefflin was in the press box on duty for RTÉ, Aidan 'Taggy' Fogarty was working for KCLR, David Herity was on the sideline as part of Liam Cahill's management team.
Derek Lyng, who had been one of Cody's most trusted lieutenants both as a player and later as a selector, was also on the sideline, trying to manage the Cats to a second All-Ireland final appearance on his watch.
At one stage that looked on the cards, until Tipp decided otherwise.
When Tipperary were reduced to 14 men and Kilkenny flicked over a couple of points to lead by two with seven minutes remaining, you would have forgiven the PA spin-master if they decided to prepare The Rose of Mooncoin for an airing.
Kilkenny, you see, don't lose from there. Or didn't used to. But they do now.
Some of Kilkenny's defending on Sunday was careless, bordering on sloppy. They conceded 3-11 in the first half, all from play, and coughed up possession needlessly at times, including a turnover which led to Oisín O'Donoghue's goal.
Oisín O'Donoghue scores Tipperary's fourth goal. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho
How O'Donoghue was able to get his shot away from within a tangle of Kilkenny defenders is a mystery.
Lyng had tried to plug the defensive holes by moving Paddy Deegan into the full-back line during the first half, and at the interval he hauled ashore Shane Murphy to introduce David Blanchfield.
But Blanchfield would be one of just three subs used by Kilkenny. The other two – Stephen Donnelly (66 minutes) and Killian Doyle (70) were brought on in the closing stages. With everything on the line, it suggests Lyng didn't quite trust the depth of his squad much beyond those already on the field.
Still, for Kilkenny to only manage four points from the moment of Darragh McCarthy's sending off until the final whistle is a stat that will haunt the Cats over the winter.
There is no dressing it up – this was a bad defeat for Kilkenny. While there's a sense that Tipperary are coming, nobody seems quite sure where Kilkenny are going.
That might sound odd given Kilkenny are six in-a-row Leinster champions. They also won the provincial title at minor and under-20 level this year. So they're still very much the princes of Leinster, but beyond that these are lean times for a county celebrated until recently as the kings of hurling.
Their last All-Ireland senior triumph was in 2015. Their last All-Ireland minor triumph was in 2014. Their last All-Ireland under-20/21 triumph was in 2022, before that it was 2008.
Of the 18 players who featured in the under-20 decider against Limerick three years ago, none started for the seniors against Tipperary on Sunday. Just one (Doyle) came off the bench. As of now, they haven't kicked on.
In this year's final Kilkenny's under-20s were beaten 3-19 to 1-16 by Tipperary at Nowlan Park and the manner of that loss generated plenty of criticism around the county.
There does not appear to be a conveyor belt of talent about to whizz off the production line in Kilkenny to bolster the senior team.
Kilkenny's TJ Reid with his daughter Harper after Sunday's game. Photograph: Tom O'Hanlon/Inpho
So, what happens when they lose the leadership and brilliance of players like TJ Reid and Eoin Murphy?
Cork, bolstered by three All-Ireland under-20/21 titles over the last five years, have been threatening a senior breakthrough for several seasons. The Rebels might well realise that ambition in a fortnight. Chances are they'll be around for a while.
Limerick have way too much talent to disappear, while Tipp now seem to have rediscovered their mojo. In Leinster, there are promising signs of progress emerging in Dublin and Offaly, and Kilkenny's status as best in the province is likely to be properly stress-tested over the coming seasons.
The recriminations for Sunday's championship exit will continue for many weeks in Kilkenny, albeit among most hurling folk in the county there is a belief Lyng has done a decent job with the squad at his disposal.
Of Kilkenny's 2015 Liam MacCarthy winning team, Reid and Murphy are the only survivors who played in the All-Ireland final against Galway a decade ago. Richie Reid was an unused sub goalkeeper.
It seems probable now that in the near future a Kilkenny team will take to the field without a single remaining All-Ireland senior hurling winner.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Kevin Cassidy: It feels like history repeating itself with Jim McGuinness and Donegal
Former Donegal All-Star Kevin Cassidy reckons history is repeating itself and that Jim McGuinness is working from a similar blueprint to the one he devised 15 years ago. McGuinness was initially appointed Donegal manager in 2010 before guiding the team to an Ulster title in 2011 and an All-Ireland semi-final appearance. The following year, 2012, they won Ulster again and went on to win the All-Ireland. His second coming as Donegal management has been eerily similar, so far, with an Ulster title success and All-Ireland semi-final appearance straight away in 2024. They've retained the Anglo Celt Cup this year, as they did in 2012, and are many people's favourites ahead of Sunday's All-Ireland semi-final to go on and claim Sam again. "Back at home, it feels like that too," said AIB ambassador Cassidy of history repeating itself. Read More Morris happy to trade injury risk for All-Ireland journey with Meath "With Jim, he takes on a project and he breaks everything apart and builds it back up, block by block. In 2011, that's what he did, he stripped it back and started to build. We failed in 2011 but he saw the differences in what needed to happen to get to the top table. "Like, if you look at the game against Galway last year, if we had Michael Murphy, would we have got over the line? Jim obviously identified that. He brought Michael back in. "I think they're playing a better mixture this year. We were just running the ball constantly last year. There's a small mixture change this year. I think for any team to win the All-Ireland, especially in Croke Park, you need to vary your game. You have to be able to kick it. "But yeah, it does look like that (2011 and 2012 repeating) at the minute. We have to get Meath out of the way first." Cassidy acknowledged that Meath could easily upset Donegal's plans. He said that the Royals possess the ability to hurt Donegal from two-pointers, or closer in with goals. "Monaghan were overly reliant on twos the last day," said Cassidy. "Donegal knew that if they closed that avenue off, then they weren't overly worried about what Monaghan would do inside. But Meath pose a different threat in that they have men inside who can hurt you also."
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Kerry rookies have held their own, but can they keep pace?
180. The total number of championship appearances among the 11 bodies that populated the Kerry bench against Armagh. A number is no use in isolation. How does it compare? Not great, actually. Their quarter-final Orchard opponents had a back-up cast with a combined figure of 257 championship appearances. Galway, in the curtain-raiser, had 300 championship appearances sitting in the Hogan Stand. Yes, yes, we can hear you say that Armagh, Galway, and their respective benches overflowing with household names such as the reigning All-Ireland winning captain, the reigning footballer of the year, a previous footballer of the year nominee, and six All-Star winners are no longer part of the championship conversation. Still, one would think it gives greater comfort to a manager and starting players to know such artillery can be rolled in when required. Paudie Clifford and Micheál Burns aside, Kerry's quarter-final bench was artillery-light. Within that bench, Darragh Lyne and Tom Leo O'Sullivan have not a single minute of championship game-time between them. Two more, Evan Looney, and Tomás Kennedy, had just one championship appearance to their respective names prior to throw-in. For both, that off-the-bench debut was as fresh as the Cavan preliminary quarter-final non-event a fortnight previous. Prior to their introduction against Armagh, the pair's combined total of championship minutes was 20. Add in Armin Heinrich's two championship involvements and what you had a fortnight ago was half the Kerry subs list boasting the scarcely believable pocket-sized total of four championship appearances, and none of them a start. Everyone knows the Kerry injury-list at this stage. Their fallen frontliners are Diarmuid O'Connor, Barry Dan O'Sullivan, and Tom O'Sullivan. Mike Breen, Tadhg Morley, and Tony Brosnan are all back in training, but having not been part of the matchday 26 for the dethroning of the champions, one wonders how much ground has been made up in the subsequent fortnight to deliver impactful involvement for the latest Ulster inspection. Ditto Paul Geaney, an unused sub against Armagh. Jack O'Connor's confirmation on Monday that Tom O'Sullivan (calf) will play no part against Tyrone means Evan Looney's third championship appearance and first start could be in the searingly hot kitchen of an All-Ireland semi-final. The 23-year-old's lengthy quarter-final cameo, in the wake of Sullivan's 24th minute departure, was quietly effective and without significant blemish. The free he won in the 29th minute ended in a Seán O'Shea two-pointer. 'It has been a very tricky season. Not alone have we had to deal with a lot of injuries, but we've had to deal with trying to get players back from the clubs and incorporate them into the system. The Crokes players came back late, you have to give them time off. 'We've managed to incorporate them in, and just as well that we had as many players as we had, because a lot of them have been used, and we've needed those panel players,' Jack said on Monday. 'There are players who thought they've been on the periphery; they are now pushed into action, and we're delighted with the way they're reacting.' Looney is part of that group. His Crokes clubmate Mark O'Shea is at the centre of that group. Also in his debut season with the Kingdom, he and Seán O'Brien began the year fourth and fifth in the Kerry midfield pecking order. If you wanted to factor in those recently departed to and recently returned from Australia, they'd be down around sixth and seventh. Again, their callowness is captured in the numbers. O'Shea made his championship debut as recently as May's Munster final. His first championship start was the defeat to Meath. O'Brien's first championship start was last year's Munster semi-final. He didn't start again in championship until the aforementioned preliminary quarter-final win over Cavan. There was nothing callow about their quarter-final contributions. O'Shea broke a third-minute Ethan Rafferty restart to Dylan Casey. The play concluded with Seán O'Shea's first orange flag. Neither O'Shea nor O'Brien allowed Armagh No.14 Andrew Murnin, who comes to midfield at kick-out time, a whiff of influence. Indeed, it was O'Shea exerting considerable influence at the beginning of the 11 Armagh kickouts where Kerry dismembered the opposition. O'Shea was central to Kerry spoiling three of the first four in that sequence, leading to a Paudie point, David two-pointer, and Seánie free. The midfield pairing later combined, following a sumptuous O'Brien sidestep of Ross McQuillan, to assist a David Clifford white flag. 'The league was good to us in that we used something like 35 players. Mark O'Shea played about 10 minutes, for example, up in Castlebar. That was the first action that he got, and then he got bits and pieces as we went along,' Jack noted earlier this week. Kerry's forced hand and quick promotion of these rookies has so far been without a detrimental hiccup on the results front. But as their swift education gets steeper and the injury list stubbornly persists, how long will that hold?
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Colm 'Gooch' Cooper: Lose again to Tyrone and you'd have to review everything
Seven games into this year's Championship and David Clifford is still averaging almost 10 points per game for Kerry. Even by his standards, it's a new level of prolific scoring with 0-5, against Meath, his lowest return since the start of the Munster Championship. The thing is, Colm Cooper, the man who previously carried the mantle of forward of his generation, reckons 'there's more under the bonnet' to come from Clifford. "To me, he seems revitalised this year, he seems hungrier," said AIB ambassador 'Gooch'. "Mentally, I think he's in a stronger place, I think he'd got a little bit drained. He had a season there at one point where Fossa went to Croke Park and he was dealing with the passing of his Mam, it was a difficult time for him but he looks to be really enjoying his football again. "He's beginning to mature as a footballer I think, he's making other players better around him. His ability has never been in question, he can do anything, but he's now making the team a better team as well and that comes with maturity. He's living up to the hype, living up to the expectations and I think there's more under the bonnet too." Cooper pulled down the shutters on his Kerry career in early 2017, a year before Clifford's senior debut. So they never played together but they do meet occasionally around Killarney. Cooper is a Dr Crokes man from the town while Clifford's native Fossa is only a few kilometres out the road. "He's living in Killarney, I'm living in Killarney, we bump into each other with the kids," said the eight-time All-Star. "It's very casual chats, never a deep-down conversation about football, it's more casual and low-key. Like everybody else, I sit back in the stands and admire and gasp at some of the stuff he does." Clifford's top form has remained a constant throughout 2025 though he is undoubtedly even more of a handful with his brother Paudie in the team, supplying the ammo and diverting attention. Cooper expects that Paudie will be returned to the team for Saturday's All-Ireland semi-final against Tyrone after his powerful half-time introduction against Armagh. That would mean leaving Cooper's Crokes clubmate Micheál Burns on the bench again, despite his excellent impact against Armagh when he came on. Jack O'Connor has stated that Tony Brosnan could be an option too, Paul Geaney less so. And there's Dara Moynihan and Killian Spillane to consider as well. "If Paudie starts, they might hold Micheál and bring him in, that would be my initial expectation," said Cooper. "From Micheál's point of view, he's probably saying, 'I can't do any more to force my way in'. But if you were to ask me, I'd say they'll start Paudie Clifford and look at Micheál Burns being an impact off the bench. "That's going on the presumption that there's 70 minutes in Paudie Clifford and I don't know that for sure. He's missed a lot of football, particularly over the last two months, so it's a big decision for them." Cooper's gut feeling is that whatever way Kerry arrange the furniture, they'll always feel at home in the big house, Croke Park. "There's a year that sticks out in my mind, 2009, we were struggling big time in the qualifiers," said Cooper. "I think Antrim nearly beat us, Sligo nearly beat us and Longford gave us a real test up in Longford. We were just sauntering along, we couldn't find that gear and we just needed to get to Croke Park. All of a sudden it was the Dubs on a Bank Holiday weekend in 2009 and it certainly got the juices flowing for the players. It took Croke Park to bring the best out of us and I think maybe it's the same for the lads now. "Injuries have hampered Kerry in terms of finding their rhythm a little bit. But certainly the second-half display against Armagh would indicate that they've been looking to Croke Park all year and they've been ready to pounce." Failing to show up and losing to Tyrone doesn't bear thinking about. If it happens, then Kerry will have been knocked out of each of the flagship football championships - minor, U-20 and senior - by Tyrone teams this year. "Certainly for the general public and supporters like myself, it is a concern if we're driving down the road to Kerry on Saturday night if Tyrone have beaten you again, and have beaten you at every grade," said Cooper. "You would have to have a review of everything that's going on."
