Kilkenny must evolve to keep pace with competitors if they're to end Liam MacCarthy drought
Kilkenny
hurling, mulling over the county's longest wait.
Kilkenny are now officially going through their most protracted Liam MacCarthy Cup drought since they first won an
All-Ireland senior hurling
title in 1904. They had decade-long gaps without major silverware between 1922-32 and 1947-57, but Sunday's defeat to
Tipperary
ensures Kilkenny's current barren period will continue until at least 2026.
They were last crowned All-Ireland champions in 2015. In the 10 years before that the Cats owned hurling, winning eight All-Ireland titles between 2006 and 2015.
A shot of Brian Cody briefly flashed up on the screen during Sunday's semi-final. Cody, the most successful manager in the history of the game, stepped down as Kilkenny boss three years ago.
READ MORE
Several of his former players were dotted around Croke Park on Sunday – Henry Shefflin was in the press box on duty for RTÉ, Aidan 'Taggy' Fogarty was working for KCLR, David Herity was on the sideline as part of Liam Cahill's management team.
Derek Lyng, who had been one of Cody's most trusted lieutenants both as a player and later as a selector, was also on the sideline, trying to manage the Cats to a second All-Ireland final appearance on his watch.
At one stage that looked on the cards, until Tipp decided otherwise.
When Tipperary were reduced to 14 men and Kilkenny flicked over a couple of points to lead by two with seven minutes remaining, you would have forgiven the PA spin-master if they decided to prepare The Rose of Mooncoin for an airing.
Kilkenny, you see, don't lose from there. Or didn't used to. But they do now.
Some of Kilkenny's defending on Sunday was careless, bordering on sloppy. They conceded 3-11 in the first half, all from play, and coughed up possession needlessly at times, including a turnover which led to Oisín O'Donoghue's goal.
Oisín O'Donoghue scores Tipperary's fourth goal. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho
How O'Donoghue was able to get his shot away from within a tangle of Kilkenny defenders is a mystery.
Lyng had tried to plug the defensive holes by moving Paddy Deegan into the full-back line during the first half, and at the interval he hauled ashore Shane Murphy to introduce David Blanchfield.
But Blanchfield would be one of just three subs used by Kilkenny. The other two – Stephen Donnelly (66 minutes) and Killian Doyle (70) were brought on in the closing stages. With everything on the line, it suggests Lyng didn't quite trust the depth of his squad much beyond those already on the field.
Still, for Kilkenny to only manage four points from the moment of Darragh McCarthy's sending off until the final whistle is a stat that will haunt the Cats over the winter.
There is no dressing it up – this was a bad defeat for Kilkenny. While there's a sense that Tipperary are coming, nobody seems quite sure where Kilkenny are going.
That might sound odd given Kilkenny are six in-a-row Leinster champions. They also won the provincial title at minor and under-20 level this year. So they're still very much the princes of Leinster, but beyond that these are lean times for a county celebrated until recently as the kings of hurling.
Their last All-Ireland senior triumph was in 2015. Their last All-Ireland minor triumph was in 2014. Their last All-Ireland under-20/21 triumph was in 2022, before that it was 2008.
Of the 18 players who featured in the under-20 decider against Limerick three years ago, none started for the seniors against Tipperary on Sunday. Just one (Doyle) came off the bench. As of now, they haven't kicked on.
In this year's final Kilkenny's under-20s were beaten 3-19 to 1-16 by Tipperary at Nowlan Park and the manner of that loss generated plenty of criticism around the county.
There does not appear to be a conveyor belt of talent about to whizz off the production line in Kilkenny to bolster the senior team.
Kilkenny's TJ Reid with his daughter Harper after Sunday's game. Photograph: Tom O'Hanlon/Inpho
So, what happens when they lose the leadership and brilliance of players like TJ Reid and Eoin Murphy?
Cork, bolstered by three All-Ireland under-20/21 titles over the last five years, have been threatening a senior breakthrough for several seasons. The Rebels might well realise that ambition in a fortnight. Chances are they'll be around for a while.
Limerick have way too much talent to disappear, while Tipp now seem to have rediscovered their mojo. In Leinster, there are promising signs of progress emerging in Dublin and Offaly, and Kilkenny's status as best in the province is likely to be properly stress-tested over the coming seasons.
The recriminations for Sunday's championship exit will continue for many weeks in Kilkenny, albeit among most hurling folk in the county there is a belief Lyng has done a decent job with the squad at his disposal.
Of Kilkenny's 2015 Liam MacCarthy winning team, Reid and Murphy are the only survivors who played in the All-Ireland final against Galway a decade ago. Richie Reid was an unused sub goalkeeper.
It seems probable now that in the near future a Kilkenny team will take to the field without a single remaining All-Ireland senior hurling winner.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
25 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Graham Geraghty predicts winner of Kerry vs Tyrone as well as Tailteann Cup final between Kildare & Limerick
IT'S mad how Kerry seem to do it every year — limp along at the start of the race and hit top gear coming to the finish line. The Kingdom 2 Meath legend Graham Geraghty writes for SunSport 2 Man of the Match Seán O'Shea was incredible against the Orchard Jack O'Connor used the anger at that criticism to fire up his players and they blew the Orchard away. Amazingly, Armagh stood off them as they fired 0-14 without reply but The Red Hands Malachy O'Rourke's men are the only county to have beaten Donegal this summer and like the Kingdom, the form is coming at the right time for them. Read More On GAA But you'd have to fancy Kerry based on what they did to the All-Ireland champions and I still feel there's a bit more in them. David Clifford scored 0-7. Pádraig Hampsey will probably mark him but will he be able to cope with him for a full game? Seánie O'Shea hit 0-12 against Armagh, starting with a two-pointer and the orange flags will be crucial again. Kerry got five the last day and Tyrone did the same against the Dubs but I think the Kingdom have the advantage in that scenario and that could be the winning of the game. Most read in GAA Football At the very start of the Championship, I called Kerry as my All-Ireland winners and I still think that could be the case. Obviously, Tyrone have their own game-plan to cut off the supply to Clifford but I just think Kerry have too much class all over. Watch RTE pundits' contrasting reaction to full-time whistle of Tipperary's epic win over Kilkenny Today is also massive for Kildare and Limerick The Lilywhites will be peering over the fence at what Meath have done since winning the second-tier Championship in 2023 and Down had a brilliant campaign this summer after last year's success. Limerick were excellent in their semi-final win over Wicklow and Jimmy Lee has a team who are really fighting for each other and play great football. But Kildare will see this as a huge chance to play for Sam Maguire next year and I fancy them to get it done and get on the road back to where they belong — competing for Leinster and All-Ireland titles.
RTÉ News
an hour ago
- RTÉ News
Kerry wary of unpredictable Tyrone in familiar clash
In Jack O'Connor's fiery post-match press conference following Kerry's dismantling of Armagh - almost as explosive as his team's second half performance - he was quick to draw a comparison with the summer of 2009. The '09 All-Ireland victory, O'Connor's third as manager and the first of his second stint in charge, has latterly gone down as one of the more famous Kerry triumphs of modern times. It is perennially invoked as a reminder that Kerry retain the capacity to go from nought to sixty at any moment, regardless of how sluggish their form. Indeed, this may be when they're at their most dangerous. "I said in the dressing room after the Cavan game, 'Lads, I've been here before where we've been written off, to f**k. Completely written off," O'Connor told the media in the bowels of the Hogan Stand. "And a Kerry team written off in Croke Park are dangerous because it just takes a bit of the heat off. It allows them to play with a kind of freedom and abandon." As was noted after that, the psychological context for the semi-final against Tyrone would be very different. After Kerry had devoured Dublin in the 2009 quarter-final in a performance comparable to their second half against Armagh a fortnight ago, they put in a flat showing in a forgettable semi-final win over Meath, who ironically appear in their first semi-final since that year on Sunday. Four years ago, they entered the 2021 All-Ireland semi-final as even bigger favourites against Tyrone than they are this weekend. The game was of course delayed by a fortnight, coming in the wake of the famous game of brinkmanship by the Tyrone management, when they threatened to forfeit an All-Ireland semi-final if it was not postponed by a further seven days to allow them to recover from a Covid outbreak which had hit the squad following their Ulster final victory. The GAA had originally insisted on a hard-line around re-fixtures in the Covid years, and it was a Kerry statement agreeing to a second postponement that allowed the association to backtrack. We know what happened then. The Tyrone players were considerably less waylaid by their Covid ordeal than many had imagined beforehand and Kerry proceeded to butcher a host of opportunities in the first half - most infamous was Paul Geaney rounding the keeper only to pass to Stephen O'Brien, who was standing in the square when he palmed home. A brace of goals from Conor McKenna - temporarily back home in between Aussie Rules stints - and another from Cathal McShane saw Tyrone nab a 3-14 to 0-22 victory. Tommy Walsh's wayward late equaliser attempt in the dying seconds of extra-time would be his last act in a Kerry jersey. Tyrone's wins over Kerry in 2003, 2005 and 2008 are perhaps more celebrated but none had come so far out of leftfield as that one. Peter Keane cut a broken figure in the press conference and the wheels were quickly in motion for his removal. O'Connor, having given an indication of his interest, swiftly bid Kildare adieu and was back in Kerry for a third term within a matter of weeks. Tyrone's All-Ireland title defence in 2022 was even more abject than their efforts in the 2000s. After 2023 and 2024 saw little improvement, there was an inclination to write off their fourth All-Ireland as a fluke and an outlier in a strange year. A case of them capitalising on a power vaccuum at the top. Brian Dooher and Feargal Logan had delivered the ultimate glory in their first year but things petered out after that. Malachy O'Rourke was installed as their first ever outside manager, though his association with the county is long-standing, having lived in Ballygawley since the 1990s, winning two Tyrone titles with Errigal Ciarán as a player. The general perception is that they haven't set the world alight and that inconsistency has remained a constant companion. They achieved the unique feat of being relegated from Division 1 with seven points and were pipped by Armagh in the Ulster semi-final. A landmark win over Donegal in Ballybofey indicated they'd turned the corner only for them to produce an insipid display in losing at home to Mayo by seven points the next day out. Beating Dublin in the championship is no longer the statement it was even 12 months ago, though Tyrone produced a strong second half and final quarter to canter home by seven points in the finish. The eventual margin was a touch flattering due to a late two-pointer from Niall Morgan. The Tyrone-Dublin quarter-final was a strange, flawed game in which the Dubs' were undermined by chronic shooting and not for the first time this summer. Tyrone had lived on scraps in the first half, keeping themselves alive with two-pointers, two of them coming courtesy of Peter Harte. Their highly vaunted inside forwards, Darragh Canavan and Darren McCurry, had been mostly kept quiet though the younger Canavan, Ruairí, and Under-20 star Eoin McElholm, were especially effective when introduced late on as Dublin started to leave gaps at the back. Kieran McGeary also demonstrated some of the form which saw him win Footballer of the Year in 2021, with a strong display both in and out of possession. Kerry are again without Diarmuid O'Connor, with Tom O'Sullivan ruled out with injury after departing in the first half in the Armagh game. In midfield, Joe O'Connor has been a powerhouse, both aerially and going forward for Kerry. He's going up against Tyrone's retro twin-towers midfield pairing of Conn Kilpatrick and Brian Kennedy. The latter were successful against Dublin's Peader Ó Cofaigh Byrne, whose influence was heavily curtailed in the quarters. In his named team, O'Connor has opted to drop Mark O'Shea, another big kickout option, for the pace of Micheál Burns at wing-forward. David Clifford bagged a hat-trick in a thrilling league game between the sides in Pomeroy, as the visitors came away with a three-point win. It was in part Kerry's reputation for goal-scoring that presumably persuaded Armagh to defend so deep, allowing Sean O'Shea in particular to make hay from two-point range. Kerry have already demonstrated the fallibility of the form-guide and O'Connor is understandably on his guard against a Tyrone team coming in "under the radar." "They will be tough and anyone who underestimates them will learn about of the weapons they have starting with their goalkeeper. There's a big mobile midfield and some sharp forwards along with a good defensive system. We are under no illusions that this is going to be a tougher game than Armagh in many ways." Kerry: Shane Ryan; Paul Murphy, Jason Foley, Dylan Casey; Brian Ó Beaglaoich, Mike Breen, Gavin White (c); Sean O'Brien, Joe O'Connor; Micheál Burns, Seán O'Shea, Graham O'Sullivan; David Clifford, Conor Geaney, Dylan Geaney; Subs: Shane Murphy, Killian Spillane, Evan Looney, Armin Heinrich, Tom Leo O'Sullivan, Paudie Clifford, Mark O'Shea, Tomás Kennedy, Tadhg Morley, Paul Geaney, Tony Brosnan. Tyrone: Niall Morgan; Cormac Quinn, Padraig Hampsey, Niall Devlin; Peter Teague, Rory Brennan, Kieran McGeary; Brian Kennedy, Conn Kilpatrick; Seanie O'Donnell, Peter Harte, Ciarán Daly; Darren McCurry, Mattie Donnelly, Darragh Canavan. Subs: Oisin O'Kane, Aidan Clarke, Michael Rafferty, Frank Burns, Michael McKernan, Ben McDonnell, Michael O'Neill, Conor Meyler, Eoin McElholm, Mark Bradley, Ruairi Canavan.
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
Kildare icon hopes Lilywhites can win Tailteann Cup – and then follow Meath's example by kicking on
KILDARE legend Johnny Doyle hopes the Lilywhites can follow Meath and Down's lead if they win the Tailteann Cup. Just two years on from winning the second-tier Championship, the Royals 2 Johnny Doyle, pictured for AIB ahead of today's Tailteann Cup final between Kildare and Limerick at 2:30pm Credit: Inpho 2 Captains Kevin Feely and Cillian Fahy during a Tailteann Cup Final media event Meath have beaten Dublin, Kerry and Galway and are in the All-Ireland semi-finals for the first time since 2009. They will face Donegal tomorrow at Croke Park. Down won the 2024 Tailteann Cup to book their place in the race for Sam this summer. And excellent group-stage wins over Clare and Louth were part of a hugely impressive campaign before their gripping 2-26 to 3-21 All-Ireland preliminary quarter-final loss to Galway. Now, Doyle hopes Kildare can benefit from the same lift if they beat Limerick in today's Tailteann showpiece at Croke Park. Read More On GAA He said: 'No 1, we have to go and win it — and maybe to the outside world Kildare should be beating Limerick. They'll beat them when they've beaten them and they won't beat them before that. 'Teams I've been on myself in the past when people say, 'Oh, you should win that', and we don't win. 'That's the consistency we probably lacked over the last few years, it's, 'Yeah, let's go and win and have no doubt', rather than spend another year in the Tailteann Cup thinking, 'Oh, we need to build for the future'. 'The future is now and we have to capitalise on that, but certainly it would be a big plus to win and kick on.' Most read in GAA Football Doyle, 47, is aware that Kildare fans can quickly lose faith. The Allenwood clubman was their coach under Glenn Ryan but a disastrous 2024 saw them fall into Division 3 of the NFL before a shock Tailteann quarter-final loss to Laois. Watch RTE pundits' contrasting reaction to full-time whistle of Tipperary's epic win over Kilkenny They were blasted on social media as things went from bad to worse. Doyle was largely oblivious to it but knew it affected the players. Ryan walked as boss after that defeat. Brian Flanagan took the reins for this year and, slowly but surely as they returned to Division 2 and saw off all challengers in this year's Tailteann to date, the Kildare support have come back onside. But Doyle admits last season was a nightmare. 'CAN BE FICKLE' He said: 'We can be fickle in Kildare. When we're winning the whole place gets behind the team and when you need the support when things aren't going well, that's when you really appreciate it. 'It was tough but to be fair, I mean a lot of people that give out, including myself, I put myself in this bracket and have maybe criticised club managers but when I meet them, I don't . . . 'It's easy to give out but nobody ever came up to me and ate the head off me or gave out to me or anything like that. 'I remember after the Laois game my sister ringing me saying, 'Are you all right?' I said, 'Yeah, I'm OK, just disappointed', and she was like, 'It's just that they're going mad online'. 'But that's part of it, we just have to accept that, but it was tough for everybody. You'd have nothing but the height of respect for those lads that just kept grafting and grafting. 'A lot of them are still there so you'd be so hopeful that they will get over the line because they put in massive work. To a man they stuck at it and hopefully they'll get the rewards.' AIB, proud sponsors of club and county, were joined by Johnny Doyle to look ahead to the Tailteann Cup final — 2025 marks AIB's tenth year as a sponsor of the All-Ireland Senior Football Championship and fourth year as a sponsor of the Tailteann Cup.
