Financial ombudsman rebuked by MPs over handling of ex-chief's ‘dismissal'
The peer and chairwoman had been asked by MPs to explain why Ms Thomas had stepped down from her role as chief executive of the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) and whether any severance package was agreed.
She declined to do so, saying only that the move had been a 'mutual agreement' and citing her 'duties to safeguard the wellbeing of our employees' and 'protect the interests' of the ombudsman service.
In a letter to the committee on February 19, Baroness Manzoor claimed that 'as a member of the House of Lords, I cannot be required either to attend before the committee, or or to answer its questions,' the report says.
In Monday's report, MPs said that 'although this argument was strictly true' because Commons committees have no power to compel the Lords, 'it was unnecessary and disrespectful'.
Following Baroness Manzoor's letter, the committee ordered the FOS to submit details of any severance deal or financial package and any confidentiality or non-disclosure agreement negotiated between the service and Ms Thomas.
Although the FOS complied with the order, the committee has not published the details, claiming its decision not to do so reflects 'our awareness of the need to balance transparency against fairness to individuals.'
In its report, the committee sums up the reason for Ms Thomas' dismissal as a 'collapse in confidence' driven by 'fundamental disagreements' over strategy and operations between the board and the former chief executive.
'This collapse in confidence covered a broad range of issues and was not driven by a single event or topic,' it says.
'The mutual collapse in confidence led the FOS Board to dismiss Abby Thomas.'
Treasury Committee chairwoman Dame Meg Hillier said the service's failure to block Commons scrutiny should send a 'clear message' to others seeking to frustrate the process.
'I'm afraid that the handling of this situation by the senior leadership of the Financial Ombudsman Service has been deeply disappointing,' she said.
'The attempt to frustrate a House of Commons Committee from scrutinising the actions of a publicly accountable organisation ultimately proved unsuccessful.
'I hope this sends a clear message to any organisation considering similar action in future that Members of the House of Commons will have answers to the questions they ask on behalf of the British public, whether senior officials attempt to block them or not.'
Baroness Manzoor said: 'I highly value the Treasury Select Committee and the important role it plays in holding the financial sector to account.
'I am committed to providing open and transparent evidence to the committee, but there are rare instances when that can be difficult – particularly when it relates to employment matters.
'I have always treated the committee with the utmost seriousness and respect, and I know the Financial Ombudsman Service will continue to work closely with them in the future.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
an hour ago
- The National
John Swinney and Donald Trump to meet in Aberdeen
JOHN Swinney will use his meeting with Donald Trump to push for stronger US pressure on Israel and to seek trade concessions for key Scottish exports. Swinney is expected to urge the US president to back an immediate and lasting ceasefire in Gaza and increase humanitarian aid access during a meeting on Tuesday. The First Minister is also reported to have accepted an invitation to have dinner with the president on Monday night. Swinney is expected to make the case that the 'blunt human reality' of starvation in the enclave requires urgent international action. READ MORE: John Swinney to discuss 'horrific' Gaza humanitarian crisis with Donald Trump 'There must be an intensification of pressure on Israel,' Swinney said in a BBC interview. 'President Trump is ideally positioned – perhaps uniquely positioned – to ensure safe passage for humanitarian aid and push for a durable ceasefire. The people of Gaza face absolutely unbearable conditions.' Swinney will also press Trump to exclude Scotch whisky from the current 10% US tariff on UK exports. He argued the 'uniqueness' of Scottish whisky production merits special exemption. 'It can only be produced in Scotland. It's not a product that can be produced in any other part of the world," Swinney said. 'So there's a uniqueness about that, which I think means there is a case for it to be taken out of the tariffs arrangement that is now in place. 'Obviously the trade deal with the United States provides a degree of stability for economic connections with the United States, but the application of tariffs is increasing the costs for the Scotch whisky industry. 'So one of my objectives will be to make the case to President Trump that Scotch whiskey should be exempted from those tariffs. 'It's a product that is uniquely produced in Scotland, and it's a product that is much welcomed and supported within the United States. 'And I think there's a really good case for exempting Scotch whisky, and this is an opportunity that I have to put that case to President Trump on behalf of the Scotch whisky industry, which is a significant part of the Scottish economy.' Swinney said the tariffs are currently costing the industry around £4 million each week, describing them as a 'significant burden'. He added that reaching a deal would support economic growth and development in Scotland. 'Obviously, I'll be using every opportunity I have to try to put that across to President Trump," he continued. His interventions come as Prime Minister Keir Starmer meets Trump for broader discussions on the Middle East, the war in Ukraine, and the future of UK-US trade. While a recent UK-US Economic Prosperity Deal eased some barriers, tariffs on British steel remain unresolved. Industry leaders had feared a hike to 50%, but the current 25% rate still poses challenges, particularly with no new agreement following a July 9 deadline set by the Trump administration. READ MORE: Donald Trump to meet John Swinney and Keir Starmer for Gaza talks Downing Street said both governments are working "at pace" to provide long-term certainty for UK industry and deliver tangible benefits to workers on both sides of the Atlantic. Trump is also expected to discuss the war in Ukraine with Starmer, including coordinated efforts to pressure Vladimir Putin to end the invasion. After their meetings in Ayrshire, the pair will travel to Aberdeen for a private engagement. Trump struck a trade deal between the US and EU during his meeting with Commission President Ursula von der Leyen at Turnberry on Sunday. The agreement introduces a 15% tariff on most EU goods entering the US – down from a previously threatened 30% – and includes significant energy commitments.
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Sir Keir's wife punting at Ascot while government threaten to destroy racing – it's D-Day and we need a leader
I've argued long and hard for a clear, coherent structure at the top MATT CHAPMAN Sir Keir's wife punting at Ascot while government threaten to destroy racing – it's D-Day and we need a leader Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) IT'S apparently D-Day for British Racing in what appears to be a Brexit moment for the sport as its major power forces respond to proposals for radical change without really knowing what they are getting themselves into. Sound familiar? Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 1 Victoria Starmer looked to have a great time at Ascot on Saturday - let's hope the BHA get strong leadership and someone with contacts in the corridors of power can convince her husband not to annihilate racing with draconian taxes Credit: Getty This is all to do with whether Labour peer Lord Allen is thrust into the position of BHA chairman. Should he come or will he go now? That depends on how much everyone clashes! Those considering Lord Allen's many demands - in order for him to take up the role - include the Racecourse Association, Racehorse Owners' Association, Thoroughbred Breeders' Association and Licensed personnel. Lord Allen has basically said take my ideas or leave them and I won't bother with you all. He doesn't need the money and he's not a massive horse racing fan. As has so often been the case with those in charge at the BHA, it appears he's not too fussed about it. We have got used to leaders coming, messing up a few things, and going in a fanfare of what a marvelous job they have done. On ITV Racing's Opening Show on Saturday I asked four questions about Lord Allen and his objectives, and what help he might be. Usually when I do that my phone goes mad with people answering my observations and putting me right. On this occasion it was silent. Lord Allen and racing appear in favour of an independent BHA Board. Indeed this seems to be an absolute necessity. But no one has said who would be on it? I can't see how you could ever have one. Someone please explain. Who are you going to have - who is independent? Secondly, in recent days the Jockey Club and Ascot have come out insisting Lord Allen must be appointed. Have they done this knowing he won't join the BHA or he will? If you know he's not going to be on board then it would look as though you wanted to do the right thing for the sport but others stopped you. In some eyes that would give an organisation credit. Equally if he did become BHA chairman you will have Lord Allen's backing. It's clever if you think about it. And trust me, behind the scenes, whatever anyone says, this is about individuals rather than the good of the sport. It always will be and anyone who kids themselves otherwise is delusional. If Lord Allen is the savior, why is racing in turmoil about a current new tax on the sport? What is Lord Allen doing about it? Has he talked to Sir Keir Starmer? Again silence. And finally once again, how is it with all the people in horse racing we have who love the game - from the King and Queen down - no one seems to get through to Sir Keir that he might be on the verge of destroying British Racing? Sir Keir's wife, Victoria, was at Ascot on Saturday for the King George VI and Queen Elizabeth Stakes. It seems quite bizarre to me when you think what Government is threatening to do. Answers on a postcard please. By the way, enjoy Glorious Goodwood. All the best coverage in The Sun! FREE BETS - GET THE BEST SIGN UP DEALS AND RACING OFFERS Commercial content notice: Taking one of the offers featured in this article may result in a payment to The Sun. You should be aware brands pay fees to appear in the highest placements on the page. 18+. T&Cs apply. Remember to gamble responsibly A responsible gambler is someone who: Establishes time and monetary limits before playing Only gambles with money they can afford to lose Never chases their losses Doesn't gamble if they're upset, angry or depressed Gamcare – Gamble Aware – Find our detailed guide on responsible gambling practices here.
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Exact time Donald Trump to meet Sir Keir Starmer in Scotland today as leaders set for showdown talks
The US President praised Sir Keir for doing a 'very good job' in office MAJOR SUMMIT Exact time Donald Trump to meet Sir Keir Starmer in Scotland today as leaders set for showdown talks Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) DONALD Trump is to meet Sir Keir Starmer at his Turnberry golf resort in Ayrshire this morning. The Prime Minister will engage in "wide-ranging" discussions with the US President on issues including trade and the Israel-Hamas war. Sign up for the Politics newsletter Sign up 3 Trump is to meet Sir Keir Starmer at his Turnberry golf resort this morning Credit: Reuters 3 The Prime Minister will engage in "wide-ranging" discussions with the US President Credit: EPA 3 John Swinney will also meet the president during his five day visit to the country Credit: Reuters Later, the PM and First Minister John Swinney will attend a banquet-style dinner hosted by the US leader in the north-east. It comes ahead of him opening a new 18-hole golf course in honour of his late Scottish mother, Mary Anne Macleod, at Menie, Aberdeenshire, on Tuesday. According to an itinerary published by website Trump will meet Starmer at noon. The pair will then hold "bilateral" discussions at 12:30pm. Starmer is expected to raise the prospect of reviving ceasefire talks between Israel and Hamas and the future of tariffs on British steel. The two leaders have built a rapport on the world stage despite their differing political backgrounds, with Mr Trump praising Sir Keir for doing a "very good job" in office ahead of their talks today. First Minister John Swinney, who will also meet the president during his five-day visit to the country, said he would urge Mr Trump to apply pressure on Israel to agree to a lasting ceasefire and allow more humanitarian aid into Gaza. "I think what's important is that we focus on the solutions that are required now, and the absolutely immediate situation is a necessity for a ceasefire and for humanitarian aid to need to flow into Gaza so that the people of Gaza can be saved from the starvation that they face," Mr Swinney told BBC Breakfast. "And that is the blunt human reality of the situation that we face, and there must be an intensification of pressure on Israel. "And I think President Trump is ideally positioned. In fact, he's perhaps uniquely positioned to apply that pressure to Israel to ensure that there is safe passage for humanitarian aid to support the people of Gaza, who face an absolutely unbearable set of circumstances as a consequence of the conflict. "And a key part of that must be the application of a durable ceasefire, the flow of humanitarian aid and the progress towards a two state solution in the Middle East." The Republican President will leave for Aberdeen at 3:45pm and arrive in the Granite City at 5:25pm.
