Calcutta HC bars ‘tainted' candidates in alleged recruitment scam from reapplying
Justice Saugata Bhattacharya said that the appointment of the candidates was a result of fraud and cheating. Any application submitted by a 'tainted candidate' for the recruitment process stands cancelled, he added.
West Bengal's school education department on May 30 published a gazette notification regarding the fresh appointment of assistant teachers in upper primary, secondary and higher secondary classes in government-run and government-aided schools.
On July 1, Bhattacharya asked the state government why there was 'no express bar to debar the tainted candidates from applying' in the notification.
The court on Monday directed the state government to conclude the selection process expeditiously in line with the guidelines laid down by the Supreme Court, Live Law reported.
On April 3, the Supreme Court upheld the High Court's April 2024 order terminating the appointment of about 25,000 teachers and non-teaching staff by West Bengal's School Service Commission. The bench passed the order after observing that the recruitment process was 'vitiated by manipulation and fraud'.
The top court on April 17 permitted 'untainted' teachers to be retained until the end of the academic year or until fresh appointments are made, whichever is earlier. However, it did not grant relief to Group C and Group D employees, or non-teaching staff, whose appointments were also cancelled.
In April 2024, the High Court issued its direction on the termination of the appointments based on the findings of a re-evaluation of the Optical Mark Recognition sheets from the 2016 recruitment examination in the case.
The re-evaluation found that the selected teachers had been recruited against blank Optical Mark Recognition sheets.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
22 minutes ago
- The Hindu
There should not be targeted attempt to eliminate voice of some citizens, especially from deprived parts of India: Amartya Sen on SIR
1. Do you support the Election Commission's attempt to conduct a Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of the electoral rolls across the country? Getting the rolls right can indeed be a good exercise if it is done correctly. However, if in a hasty attempt to remove errors from the existing list, more errors are introduced, the result can be terrible. Volunteering to undertake this effort with little time and serious possibilities of significant bias can have the effect of making the election far less truthful than continuing to use the existing rolls. Many people have also questioned the neutrality of the Election Commission, and that is an issue that has to be appropriately assessed. But even with an unbiased Election Commission, there can be serious errors in a quickly produced electoral roll, particularly because of the absence of documentary evidence that many citizens, especially the poor and the deprived, are able to present. Class bias is a big danger here. 2. Is there a danger of disenfranchisement of large groups of people in the process of revising the rolls within a very short time, in a hurry? If there is a targeted attempt to eliminate the voice of some citizens, especially from the deprived parts of the nation, that would be a monstrous development. This must be totally avoided, and the Election Commission must take into account the reasons for suspicion that many fair-minded critics have found. It is extremely important that the Election Commission does not generate reason for suspicion by its choices, and that the Supreme Court plays its supervisory role actively and fairly. Indeed, the Supreme Court is ultimately the institution most responsible for making sure that the citizens' rights are not trifled with. As citizens of India, we all have to rely on the constitutional role of the Supreme Court and we are all dependent on its active protection of justice. This is a hugely important concern of citizens today, but there is, in addition, also the question of how the future would judge the Supreme Court today in the light of what they choose to do given the information they have. There is, in fact, a big tomorrow. 3. What do you think of the alleged atrocities against poor migrant Bengali workers in BJP-ruled states? There is a general point here that has to be addressed and also a special concern. The general point is that India is a country for all its citizens, and no part of the nation – whether Bengali or Tamil or Maharashtrian – should be discriminated against in any region of the country. Ill-treatment of Bengali workers elsewhere is very bad indeed, but so is the ill-treatment of any other group of migrant workers. That is the big general point, but a special concern, added to this, is the tendency of some political movements within India to portray many Bengali Indians as if they were Immigrants from Bangladesh. There have, unfortunately, been many attempts at treating Bengalis in general as Bangladeshis. Especially because of the anti-Muslim programmes of some political groups in India, Bengali Indians have often had to suffer from greater discrimination than other Indians. The level of ignorant confusion shown by many powerful officers in Delhi is truly catastrophic when they see the Bengali language (born between the tenth and the eleventh centuries – through the great poetry of Charyapad) as a 'Bangladeshi language'. 4. The BJP seems to be working hard in West Bengal to promote Hindutva in preparation of the state elections next year. Will they succeed? Bengal has had a long history of Hindu-Muslim cordiality as well as cooperative work shared by different communities. A political party that tries to generate communal narrow-mindedness might temporarily experience partial success through its divisive propaganda, but it will not be easy to turn Bengal into a communal bastion of hatred. Divisive efforts of this kind could sometimes have short-lived success, but Bengali culture and society are ultimately resistant to generating an invented internal enmity. The illusion of political gain, if any, from cultivated discord will turn out to be ephemeral.
India Today
an hour ago
- India Today
Abu Salem to serve 60 years' prison term, no early release for now: State to court
The Maharashtra government has said that gangster Abu Salem, convicted in the 1993 Mumbai serial blasts case, must serve a full 60-year prison term. In an order dated July 14, 2025, the state said Salem is not entitled to remission for the time refers to a reduction in a prisoner's sentence granted by the state, often based on good behaviour or other factors. It allows for early release but does not erase the had approached the High Court earlier this year, claiming he was entitled to be released on March 31, 2025, after completing 25 years of imprisonment, including time served as an undertrial and remission earned over the years. His petition, filed through advocate Farhana Shah, argued that he had earned both general and special remissions and cited a Supreme Court order upholding a commitment made by the Indian government to Portugal that he would not be jailed for more than 25 in an affidavit filed on July 30, Nashik Road Central Prison Superintendent Aruna A Mugutrao submitted to the court that the home department had issued an order on July 14 rejecting Salem's claim. The affidavit said Salem would have to serve 60 years to be eligible for remission and can only be released after completing 25 actual years in custody—excluding remissions—due to the sovereign assurance given to Portugal at the time of his was declared a proclaimed offender on October 15, 1993, and arrested in Lisbon on September 18, 2002. He was extradited from Portugal on November 10, 2005, after India assured the Portuguese government that Salem would not face the death penalty or a sentence beyond 25 years. This assurance was key to securing his Salem was later convicted in multiple serious cases, including the 1993 Mumbai serial blasts that killed 257 people and injured over 1,400. He was sentenced to life prison authorities stated that Salem has a long and serious criminal record, including fleeing the country after the blasts.'Salem has a history which is not a palatable one at all,' the affidavit said. 'After committing many crimes, he fled the country.'The affidavit also noted that a proposal for his early release had been sent to the state home department, along with recommendations from the Advisory Board, the trial court, the police, the district magistrate, and senior prison the state home department has decided not to approve the request. Citing the enduring trauma of blast victims and the gravity of the crime, it said Salem, like the other bomb blast convicts, would be considered for remission when he serves 60 years."People who suffered in the blast are still bearing the brunt of the horrific tragedy which unfolded in 1993," the government said.- EndsMust Watch
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
WBJEE 2025 Results Live Updates: West Bengal Engineering results to be released soon, check details here
WBJEE result 2025 : After weeks of judicial wrangling and administrative recalibration, the West Bengal Joint Entrance Examination Board (WBJEEB) is set to declare the WBJEE 2025 results today, offering long-overdue clarity to over a lakh engineering and pharmacy aspirants. The decision follows a crucial intervention by the Supreme Court of India, which stayed the Calcutta High Court's contentious June 17 order blocking the state's revised Other Backward Classes (OBC) list. The HC ruling had stalled the merit-based ranking system, delaying the entire result and admission process. Judicial gridlock broken by Supreme Court On July 28, a bench comprising Chief Justice B.R. Gavai and Justices K. Vinod Chandran and N.V. Anjaria vacated the high court's stay, asserting that the order appeared 'prima facie erroneous.' The apex court's directive allowed the WBJEEB to proceed with the delayed publication of results while incorporating legally verified caste category data. In response, the board reopened its official portal from July 31 to August 2, giving candidates a final opportunity to upload or update their caste certificates, a step deemed essential for recalibrating category-based rankings. WBJEE 2025: A timeline of disruption and resumption Exam held: April 27, 2025 Preliminary answer key released: May 9 OMR response sheets displayed: May 23–25 Expected result date (original): June 6 Judicial stay: June 17 (Calcutta HC) SC intervention: July 28 Result declaration: August 7 Board confirms preparedness for result publication Chairperson Sonali Chakraborty Banerjee affirmed that the board has finished integrating the updated caste data and is fully prepared to release the rank list. 'We are confident that the verification of caste credentials has been completed. Results will be declared on August 7, as scheduled,' Banerjee told reporters. A senior official from the state higher education department added, 'The decision to hold back the results until the legal process concluded was intentional and strategic. We cannot afford to compromise the sanctity of the merit list in a court of law.' Political underpinnings of the delay The crisis began in May 2024, when the Calcutta High Court struck down the inclusion of 77 communities in the OBC list, citing procedural lapses and lack of empirical data. The West Bengal government attempted to correct the course with a revised list, only for it to be challenged and stayed once again. This second stay paralyzed multiple public service exams and halted WBJEE's merit list compilation. The Supreme Court's July verdict not only cleared the path for WBJEE results but also set a precedent for evaluating administrative discretion in state reservation policies. Results to be available online today Students can check their results today by visiting The official rank card will display both the General Merit Rank (GMR) and the Pharmacy Merit Rank (PMR), which are critical for the next stage of the admission process — centralised e-counselling. WBJEE result 2025: Steps to download Candidates can follow the steps mentioned here to download the WBJEE result 2025: Visit the official website Click on the link titled 'Download Rank Card for WBJEE 2025' on the homepage. Enter your application number, password/date of birth, and security pin to log in. View your WBJEE 2025 rank card displaying scores and merit ranks. Download the rank card in PDF format and take a printout for future use. WBJEE result: Counselling process to begin soon The counselling schedule will be issued shortly after the results go live. The process will include: Online registration Choice filling and locking Seat allotment based on rank, category, and preferences Document verification Reporting to the allotted institute The counselling will take into account updated reservation data, meaning candidates must ensure their documents match the latest category details submitted. Institutional readiness and admission window Colleges across West Bengal are expected to begin onboarding students from the last week of August. Institutions have been directed by the higher education department to keep flexible academic calendars this year, in light of the delay caused by the judicial intervention. Admissions will proceed on the basis of WBJEE ranks, institutional cut-offs, and availability of seats, with separate rounds for General, OBC, SC/ST, TFW (Tuition Fee Waiver), and PwD categories.
