Municipalities call for changes to 'tremendously concerning' N.S. transportation bill
The Progressive Conservative government's proposed Bill 24 grants sweeping powers to the public works minister over transportation and transit decisions. It states the minister could order a municipality to build or remove infrastructure, and "do anything necessary" to ensure the smooth movement of people and goods.
If that work isn't done in a "reasonable time," the province could complete it — and the cost would become a municipal debt owed to the province.
Pam Mood, Yarmouth mayor and president of the Nova Scotia Federation of Municipalities, said dozens of mayors, wardens and senior municipal staff met last week to talk about the pending legislation.
She said there was a "huge fear" that municipalities would receive a bill they couldn't afford, pushing them into bankruptcy because of their inability to run deficits.
"There were pieces like that that were tremendously concerning," Mood said last Thursday.
NSFM members were also worried about municipal autonomy being removed "without a conversation," Mood said.
But Mood said she had a positive meeting with Municipal Affairs Minister John Lohr and Public Works Minister Fred Tilley late last week. Mood said the ministers told her the PC government does not intend to take dramatic steps such as billing a municipality for project work, and are open to clarifying wording that would "take away the angst" and concerns.
"That's certainly not the province's intention. They understand, like we do, whatever is good for municipalities is good to uplift the entire province," Mood said.
But Mood said a wording change is important.
"We can't have municipalities out there believing something that simply won't happen," she said. "Because when it's in the legislation, it's saying it can happen."
Mayor Elspeth McLean-Wile of the District of Lunenburg said she isn't comfortable with the bill's wording.
In a rural district made up of mostly provincial roads and few municipally-owned streets, McLean-Wile said she's concerned the minister could force the municipality to pay for improvements to provincial roadways.
McLean-Wile said municipal leaders are very aware of the importance of improving transportation and transit, and would be happy to collaborate with the government on a provincewide approach.
"One has to wonder, why does the province believe it needs that new power? And why would it not work with us to figure out solutions to this that could help meet their objectives, without jeopardizing the tax base and increasing the tax burden on municipal government?" McLean-Wile said.
"It isn't clear what the intent is behind this, and that is worrisome."
Bill 24 also changes the Joint Regional Transportation Agency (JRTA) to Link Nova Scotia, broadening its scope to the entire province instead of Halifax and surrounding areas.
The JRTA's final report has yet to be released, but the province has announced pieces, like a Halifax light-rail study and new highway connectors. Link N.S. will be able to acquire or build transportation assets, manage a transit service, and prepare a province-wide plan to improve transportation.
Mayor Cecil Clarke of the Cape Breton Regional Municipality said he's glad to see the province owning the transportation file, and is hopeful Link Nova Scotia's work could lead to expanded transit, port capacity, and light rail in CBRM.
"This brings me to a table we weren't at a year ago, so I'll treat it as an opportunity rather than a threat," said Clarke, a former Progressive Conservative MLA.
Bill 24 also states a municipality's regulations, bylaws and policies for transportation must be reasonably consistent with plans from the provincial government and Link N.S.
But Coun. Kathryn Morse of the Halifax Regional Municipality said she's concerned those provincial priorities might not always align with the capital city's — the latest example being Premier Houston's decision to remove the Halifax bridge tolls in April.
"It's going to increase traffic. It's not ideal in terms of managing traffic to remove tolls," said Morse, adding that cities like London and New York have gone in the opposite direction with congestion pricing.
"We're taking our existing congestion pricing away at not the best time. So to me, the whole toll removal, the way it was done is kind of a cautionary tale when it comes to Bill 24," Morse said.
CBC asked Halifax Mayor Andy Fillmore's office for reaction to Bill 24, but did not receive a response.
Mayor Mood said conversations with the PC government will continue as the bill moves through Province House. The legislation was introduced on Feb.20, and has yet to pass second reading or the law amendments committee.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
2 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Tory byelection candidate sorry for residential schools comments
BRANDON — A Progressive Conservative candidate in an upcoming Manitoba byelection has apologized for comments she made in the past about residential schools. Colleen Robbins, the Tory candidate for Spruce Woods, wrote on X in July 2021: 'I don't believe for once that any human ever started the residential school to abuse children. 'I agree it was what they thought at the time to help the Indigenous, which didn't happen.' On Monday, the 61-year-old said she never learned about residential schools while she was in school. 13082025 Colleen Robbins of the PC Party of Manitoba speaks during the Souris & Glenwood Chamber of Commerce byelection debate with Ray Berthelette of the NDP and Stephen Reid of the Manitoba Liberal Party at the Avalon Theatre in Souris on Wednesday evening. (Tim Smith/The Brandon Sun) 'I apologize for my ignorance,' she said in an interview with the Brandon Sun. 'I believed — honestly at the time — that they were just like a regular school that people moved to, to be educated,' she said. 'But since the truth and reconciliation has come to light, and all of this, we're all learning and reading about it more and more. I just didn't think that they started it out to be like that. But in fact, residential schools were to take the culture out of them, and that is just so wrong in every which way. And I apologize.' Kelly Saunders, a political science professor at Brandon University, said the optics of this are bad for the PCs. 'I don't think this is good for the party, because it's only going to remind Manitobans of the fact that the party has had a troubled record when it comes to Indigenous issues,' she said. Earlier this year, the PC party apologized for its stance during the 2023 election to not fund the search of a Winnipeg-area landfill for the remains of Indigenous women murdered by a serial killer. 'Those issues have been a bit of an albatross around the party's neck,' Saunders said. 'This statement made by a candidate, even given the fact that it was made a few years ago, this is not the kind of bad press that the party is looking for these days.' Robbins also defended comments she made earlier this year regarding U.S. President Donald Trump, when he imposed tariffs on Canada and Mexico, citing drugs going into the U.S. from both countries. 'I am so sorry you have to do this to us … Thought our countries were friends,' she commented in early February. Phrasing it that way was both sarcastic and a bad choice of words, she clarified on Monday, especially when readers don't know who she is as a person. Robbins said she was mad at the American president in that comment. 'Friends don't put tariffs on or hurt each other,' she said, calling herself a patriotic Canadian. 'And I was being sarcastic there. That was not me apologizing for anything.' She said that comment, along with others regarding U.S. politics, are being taken out of context by the people reposting them. Robbins said those people are 'fear mongering' and running a 'smear campaign.' Wednesdays Sent weekly from the heart of Turtle Island, an exploration of Indigenous voices, perspectives and experiences. Stephen Reid, the Liberal candidate for Spruce Woods called Robbins' comments 'terrible' and hopes she learns from the experience. 'When someone shows you who they are, listen,' he said. 'That's something that people need to keep in mind.' The Sun reached out to NDP candidate Ray Berthelette, but a campaign manager said he was door-knocking and wasn't available for an interview. The byelection is set for Aug. 26 — Brandon Sun
CBC
2 days ago
- CBC
PC byelection candidate apologizes for 2020 Twitter post professing hate for unions
The Progressive Conservative candidate in Manitoba's Spruce Woods byelection is apologizing for a 2020 Twitter post where she professes hate for labour unions. Colleen Robbins is running for the PCs in the byelection to replace former PC MLA Grant Jackson, who resigned his southwestern Manitoba seat in March to make a successful run for the House of Commons as the Conservative MP for Brandon-Souris. Over the past weekend, a series of old posts Robbins deleted from Twitter were collected in a Reddit thread. In one of the posts, dating back to the Ontario teachers strike in 2020, Robbins said "this is actually why I hate unions." In an interview on Monday, Robbins said hate is a strong word she should not have used in a post, even if she was upset about the strike at the time. "There was going to be a lot of children out of school again and I was angry, but using that type of word for me is is very strong because I don't like using that type of word for anyone," Robbins said while campaigning near Alexander, west of Brandon. "I don't hate anybody or anything. I believe in collective bargaining. I believe that we should be at the table listening to each side. I believe in all of that." Robbins also said her husband received some distressing medical news around the time she made the post but said she must apologize nonetheless. She said two other Twitter posts included in the Reddit thread have been taken out of context. In 2021, Robbins replied "sold" to a post about a U.S. senator musing about buying Canada. She said that post took place in the context of a national controversy about the Keystone XL Pipeline. "I wanted that oil sold and going to the U.S.," she said. "That's what I believe that post was all about; nothing about Canada itself as being sold. "I'm a very patriotic person. I Iove Canada and I will not ever support selling Canada to to the U.S." In a response to a Donald Trump announcement about placing tariffs on Canadian goods earlier this year, Robbins replied on what's now called X that "I am sorry you have to do this to us. I thought our countries were friends." Robbins said she was not being kind to the U.S. president. "I was being sarcastic and saying stop being an ass and work with us," she said. Robbins is running in Spruce Woods against Ray Berthelette of the NDP and Liberal Stephen Reid. All three candidates are slated to take part in a debate slated for the hamlet of Sprucewoods, near Shilo, on Wednesday. On Monday, Berthelette promised to improve part of Highway 2 west of Souris, something Jackson petitioned the former NDP government to do when he was the PC MLA. While the PCs have held Spruce Woods since the constituency was created in 2011, the NDP government made a flurry of funding announcements in southwestern Manitoba prior to the byelection call. Advance polls in the byelection are open until Aug. 25. Byelection day is Aug. 26.
Winnipeg Free Press
2 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Tory MLAs among Western Canada's ‘kindred spirits' invited to join U.S. by Maine politician
Some members of the Manitoba Legislative Assembly have received an 'absurd, unsolicited' letter from an American senator inviting provinces in Western Canada to join the U.S. The four-page invitation, titled A Vision for Welcoming Western Canada into the United States, was sent by Joseph E. Martin, a Republican senator for the 19th district in the eastern state of Maine. 'This would not be an annexation,' the invitation said. 'It would be an adoption, welcoming home kindred spirits…' It described how Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Alberta and British Columbia could seek admission as full American states. It raised hackles and made headlines after British Columbia Progressive Conservative MLA Brennan Day complained about it on social media last week, calling it 'nonsense.' A spokesman for Manitoba's PC caucus communications said he canvassed a number of PC MLAs Monday to see if they'd received the letter from Martin. 'A handful acknowledge receiving it — just as they receive correspondence from anyone who wants to send something,' said PC caucus communications spokesperson Jon Lovlin. 'No one responded to such an absurd, unsolicited proposition,' Lovlin said in an email. The senator's pitch to join the U.S. touted its constitution and legal system, with roots in the 'Christian moral order' and speech that's 'truly free' with without any 'tribunals or hate speech commissions,' he noted. A spokesperson for Manitoba's NDP caucus said Monday that none of its members received the pitch from the Maine state senator. Liberal MLA Cindy Lamoureux (Tyndall Park) and independent MLA Mark Wasyliw (Fort Garry) said they weren't aware of receiving it, either. In B.C., Day said the letter attacked Canadian institutions, including the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, parliamentary government, bilingualism and multiculturalism. He said he didn't know why he received the senator's letter but suspected it might have to do with 'rhetoric' coming out out of Alberta. There, a group is advocating for Alberta to cease being a Canadian province. Alberta's Citizens Initiative Act allows an elector to propose a question to put to a public vote, if they can gather enough signatures in support within a set time frame. On Thursday, an Alberta Court of King's Bench judge said he'd hear arguments and rule on whether a proposed referendum question on separating from Canada is constitutional. 'The citizens of Alberta deserve to have these arguments made properly and heard in full,' Justice Colin Feasby's decision said. 'Democracy demands nothing less.' After all of U.S. President Donald Trump's talk about making Canada the 51st state, University of Manitoba political studies professor Christopher Adams said he isn't surprised that western separatism is on the radar of a Republican state senator. 'The issue of Alberta separatism is no doubt getting some attention, and so I'm not surprised that somebody's jumping on this type of an issue,' Adams said Monday. 'I think that there are times when American politicians don't understand Canadian thinking, and this would be one example.' Martin, whose senate office is in the state capital of Augusta, did not respond to a request for comment. — With files from the Canadian Press Carol SandersLegislature reporter Carol Sanders is a reporter at the Free Press legislature bureau. The former general assignment reporter and copy editor joined the paper in 1997. Read more about Carol. Every piece of reporting Carol produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
