‘Delicious, affordable everyday eating': supermarket free-range eggs, tasted and rate
The Guardian's journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link. Learn more.
When it comes to welfare, forest-reared chickens are the gold standard, so when an egg packer commits to planting trees or providing meaningful canopy cover, as several UK egg brands do, I know the quality is likely to be superior. It's also worth noting that, while free-range chickens gain outdoor access at only 21 weeks, organic hens are allowed out from 12 weeks – an important distinction in their welfare.
This was one of the toughest taste tests I've done so far. When judging egg quality, I look at shell strength, the viscosity of the whites and the richness of the yolk, but freshness affects the albumen, and yolk colour is now largely engineered through beta carotene-rich feeds such as maize, paprika and marigold. Interestingly, the organic options all had classic sunshine-yellow yolks, in contrast to the vivid orange seen in several non-organic brands. A bold, marigold-orange yolk might be striking, but ultimately it doesn't tell us all that much about the egg's flavour.
With freshness varying by the box, I boiled all the eggs and scored them instead on what truly counts: taste, provenance and welfare. If you want the best flavour and nutrition, choose eggs with the longest sell-by date in the store. Just be warned, the fresher the egg, the more stubborn it is to peel when boiled. To overcome this, cool it under running water and peel immediately.
£3.20 for six at Ocado (53p each)£3.20 for six at Tesco (53p each)★★★★☆
Speckled brown shells and deep orange yolks give these Cornish eggs a strong visual appeal. The taste is subtle, savoury and well balanced. St Ewe leads in provenance, sharing producer stories on its website and becoming the EU's first B Corp-certified egg packer, which means it must meet rigorous social and environmental standards. A premium ethical splurge with rich flavour and standout transparency.
£1.80 for six at Waitrose (30p each)★★★★☆
One of the more economical, yet the eggs are high quality. Classic brown shells with rich, orange yolks that are sweet, jammy and full of flavour. Laid by British blacktail hens, these eggs have a loyal following. The Business Benchmark on Farm Animal Welfare ranks Waitrose as a tier-two leader, and while no specific farm origin is listed, the breed itself is impressive. Outstanding value with premium taste and trusted sourcing.
£1.80 for six at Ocado (30p each)★★★★☆
Thick, deep brown, speckled shells with glowing orange yolks and the most layered flavour in the bunch – rich, savoury and complex. RSPCA Assured, M&S's egg range consistently offers quality at an accessible price. Its farming standards and welfare credentials are good, and this egg proves it. Delicious, affordable and my top pick for everyday eating.
£3.45 for six at Sainsbury's (58p each)£3.75 for six at Ocado (63p each)★★★★☆
A handsome box of varied eggs, from speckled beige to classic tan, with rich, golden yolks. The flavour is simple but satisfying, with subtle, grassy notes. Certified organic for more than 20 years and Soil Association approved, their maize-enriched feed is completely GMO-free – a key organic standard and a reminder that maize and soya bean feeds are frequently genetically modified. Though on the pricier side, these eggs offer dependable quality with strong sustainability credentials. A solid organic choice.
£3.48 for 10 at Asda (35p each)£4.10 for 10 at Sainsbury's (41p each)★★★★☆
Classic brown shells with a few paler ones in the mix. The yolks are a deep orange-red, thanks to natural feed. Rich, sweet and satisfying flavour, and great for a soft boil or a showy scramble. RSPCA Assured and a two-star winner at the 2024 Great Taste Awards. Freshlay works with independent British farms and makes clear its commitments to higher welfare and free-range standards.
Sign up to The Filter
Get the best shopping advice from the Filter team straight to your inbox. The Guardian's journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link.
after newsletter promotion
£4.78 for 10 at Asda (48p each) £5.10 for 10 at Tesco (51p each)★★★★☆
A naturally varied box, with shells ranging from white and mottled to classic brown. The yolks are a soft sunflower yellow with a clean, sweet flavour. Purely Organic is the UK's first organic egg brand to be certified carbon neutral. Its farms include forested areas for enriched hen welfare, with clear transparency around its organic and sustainability commitments.
£2.20 for six at Sainsbury's (37p each)£2.20 for six at Tesco (37p each)★★★★☆
Classic speckled brown shells and golden yolks with a lovely, well-rounded flavour. These eggs come from farms that go well beyond the basics, with four times the tree cover required by RSPCA Assured standards and daily enrichment kits for the hens. The UK-made feed is formulated to boost vitamin D, and just two eggs provide roughly 94% of your daily intake. An intriguing initiative.
£2.85 for six at Sainsbury's (48p each)★★★☆☆
Classic, dark brown shells with the palest yolks in the test group – sunflower yellow, but still rich and sweet. RSPCA Assured, with a unique tree-planting initiative: Sainsbury's donates 1p from every dozen sold to the Woodland Trust. A thoughtful, ethical touch, and a product I trust thanks to the Soil Association Organic Certification, which has high standards and rigorous implementation.
£1.89 for six at Aldi (32p each)★★★☆☆
Uniform, dark beige shells with deep, rich orange yolks that look and taste luxurious. The flavour is sweet and full, thanks to the extra-rich yolk. Limited provenance details beyond being British, free-range and RSPCA Assured, though they carry a Great Taste Award. Aldi is known for strong sustainability credentials, giving this affordable option added appeal. Great value for rich-tasting, good-looking eggs.
£1.75 for six at Tesco (29p each)★★☆☆☆
Classic brown shells with a pale yellow yolk (the palest in the test) and a fairly plain flavour. RSPCA Assured and sourced from Northern Irish farms. Customer reviews are mixed, with several complaints about shell colour changes, though the eggs themselves seem consistent. Affordable, but unremarkable.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
35 minutes ago
- The Sun
I'm being forced to tear down my loft conversion – my neighbours call it a ‘monstrosity' but I'm going to fight back
A WOMAN who spent thousands renovating her Victorian home has been ordered to tear down her loft conversion after it was branded a "monstrosity". Rozia Hussian, 43, built a large extension on top of her 125-year-old terraced property in Worcester. 4 4 Records show the mid-terraced house was bought for £100,000 in 2003 and pictures show the outside was in a shabby condition with peeling paint and chipped brick work. Over the last four years, the three-bedroom house on Wyld's Lane, has undergone a complete makeover and according to Rightmove it is now worth up to £320,000. A wall and intercom system has been installed at the front of the house while a large dormer was built on top of the two-storey house. Mrs Hussain now faces having to demolish the dormer after Worcester City Council rejected her retrospective planning application. The council stated: "By virtue of its size, design and position, the addition of the large box dormer to the front of the property results in detrimental impact and creates significant harm to the character and appearance of the existing property and wider street scene in which it sits. "The dormer at Wylds Lane is much more visually intrusive than the approved, well-designed, more subtle addition." Mrs Hussain, who owns a newsagents in the city, said: "I don't know anything about the planning application being rejected. "I don't think it looks too big." Her neighbours have been mixed in their reaction to the council decision. One said: "I think the house looks much better now. Our pretty town has become a ghetto plagued by machete-wielding yobs "It was in a terrible state a few years ago but it now looks modern and clean. "The dormer doesn't really bother me but I think some people are concerned because it looks right onto their properties." Another resident, who lives nearby in a similar property, said: "A few years ago I applied to have a dormer on my house but it was refused. "The reason the council gave was because it would not be in keeping with the area or sympathetic to the age and heritage of the property. "In my view I just think that it would be grossly unfair if this woman was allowed to have a large dormer on her property when I was not. "I mean the extension is very big. It looks like an executive box you get at Premier League football grounds. "When my friend visited he asked what the monstrosity was on one of the houses so it's clearly noticeable to people." Mrs Hussain has three months to tear down the dormer or face enforcement action. A city spokesperson said: "An enforcement notice was served on 17 June that comes into effect on 17 July. "This requires the applicant to remove the dormer and restore the roof or adapt the current dormer so that it complies with the planning permission given. "They have three months to carry out the works. "They have until 17 July to appeal against the notice." What to do if you're in a property row with the council Know your rights Review your tenancy agreement, lease, or ownership documents to understand your rights and the council's responsibilities. Submit concerns in writing Raise any issues formally via email or letter. A written record will help if the matter needs to be escalated later. Use the council's complaints process All councils are required to have a formal complaints procedure. Details are typically available on the council's website. Seek independent advice Organisations such as Citizens Advice and Shelter offer free guidance on housing disputes and may be able to assist with legal next steps. Contact the Housing Ombudsman If the council fails to resolve the issue, complaints can be escalated to the Housing Ombudsman Service, which is free, impartial, and able to investigate unresolved housing matters. Keep detailed records Maintain copies of all correspondence, photographs of any issues (such as repairs), and notes from phone calls to support your case. 4
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Fussy eaters have terrorised restaurants. Don't let them wreak havoc in church
Sunday mornings for the Church of England parish priest are hectic. As the sun shoots through the edges of the curtains and many of us edge under the duvet, the vicar is up and about preparing for flock administration. In rural areas, such as ours, that can mean services in a handful of some seven churches. So they must prepare to chug along the lanes and then warmly greet the noble volunteers who have cleaned and decorated the church and then officiate for 14 odd souls who have bothered to turn up. Later that day, there might be more services and some private visits to elderly parishioners who request the sacrament at home. The visiting priest, a throwback to the days – now hard to imagine – when a doctor did home visits. She might already be wearing a clerical shirt and stiff dog collar, black trousers and black shoes, but onto the back seat goes the cassock, surplice, the seasonal stole, then maybe some wellies to get up that muddy church track. As there are communion services today, there's also a Tupperware box of communion wafers, as delivered by post from FA Dumont Church Supplies and a bottle of Poterian Fair Trade Communion Wine (a light South African bottle, fortified to 15 per cent and with a balancing sweetness, akin, but not as heavy, to port). Then, onto the front seat goes their Bible, prayer book and the little black book with their sermons in and their phone with the list of churches waiting for their officiating. But then, what's this? Their other half calls from the house: 'Darling, you left the dietaries on the kitchen table.' Lest they forget! There's four gluten-free in the first church, one in the second, one non-alc in the third. If dealing with declining attendance, rudderless leadership, poverty, leaking roofs and a visceral culture clash of modernity and tradition wasn't enough, the vicar must now cater for varying dietary requirements. Ahead of the General Synod, which began on Friday in York – an annual event of discussion and debate by the church's governing body – one Abigail Ogier, a lay synod member from the Diocese of Manchester, posted an official question as to what progress had been made to enable parishioners unable to consume alcohol or gluten to take communion. After all, Canon B17 of the Canons of the Church of England stipulates that bread for Communion must be made from 'the best and purest wheat flour that conveniently may be gotten' and that wine should be 'the fermented juice of the grape, good and wholesome'. And the Church's official view is that while you can water down the wine and fiddle with the bread recipe, it must still contain minimal wheat and the wine must still be made of fermented grape juice. Which is a red flag for the gluten-averse or non-alc purist. Many of whom have had enormous fun in recent years marauding their way through the hospitality sector parading their intolerances, often at the very last minute, just as the chef calls, 'Service!' at the pass. And, while I wouldn't for a moment doubt the likes of the genuine coeliac, nut-allergic, or alcohol-intolerant, everyone in hospitality knows that many people take pleasure in gloriously labelling themselves as intolerant as they worship the latest food fad, paraded by some pesky irritant on TikTok. But the intolerant minority have sway, which is why whenever you order in a UK restaurant the server must ask, 'Does anyone have any allergies?' in spite of the fact that the overwhelming answer is 'no', and that if you have an intolerance the responsibility to remember and voice it should be on you. So will the intolerance purists cry foul if the C of E sticks by its guns? A blessing isn't quite the same as a full-on bit of Sunday morning transubstantiation. So doubtless to appease the shrieking few, the vicar must add to his burden of duties at the altar rail. 'Blood of Christ, Non-alc or 15 per cent ABV… Body of Christ, single cross, sealed edge, diameter special wholemeal or individually-wrapped gluten free?' As a restaurant critic with a diagnosed intolerance of wheat, dairy and alcohol, which I studiedly ignore as the fun of consumption outweighs the ensuing dodgy tummy, I'll never waver from a wheat-based wafer. And I demand the 15 per cent ABV. The reward of slogging through a service being that little morning hit of alcohol. I'm not sure if it's the blood of Christ, but my own spirits certainly soar.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
South Elmsall waste site operator appeals health hazard decision
The operator of a waste recycling site which was stripped of its licence over concerns the facility was causing a health hazard has appealed against the Environment Agency (EA) issued a permit revocation notice in June against Minore, which runs the site, in Hacking Lane, South Elmsall, which came into effect on 4 July.A planning inspector said excessive amounts of hazardous material stored at the land had created multiple health risks, while residents also complained about a foul smell coming from the Chambers, area manager for the EA in Yorkshire, confirmed Minore, also known as Mineral Processing Ltd, had launched an appeal. She said: "The environmental permit will now stay in place until the Planning Inspectorate has announced the outcome of this appeal."The suspension notice, however, remains in place during this time. [This will] prevent more waste being brought onto the site and requires the removal of waste that is in breach of the permit conditions."If the operator does not comply with the suspension notice, it will be committing an offence."She added the EA "understood the impact this site is having on the community and our increased regulatory response continues". Last month, Wakefield Council refused permission for the facility to continue to documents, almost five times the permitted amount of materials had been stored on the permit had allowed a maximum of 50,000 tonnes to be stored at the information provided by Minore between 2016 and 2023 revealed there were 233,772 tonnes at the site, according to the Local Democracy Reporting Service. The EA has called for the removal of at least 180,000 tonnes of non-inert material.A planning inspector said in a report published last month that the facility also posed a risk to nearby watercourses, including Frickley previously said it was "disappointed" with the decision from the company added it planned to transform the land into wildflower meadow, wetland, ponds and public open space.A spokesperson for the firm said: "Currently the site is excavating materials and processing them, which is not in contravention of the notices issued by the EA but in compliance with them."The site has been here since the late 19th century as Victorian brickworks, ash pit and council tip for the deposit of coal ash from domestic fires, up until the late 1950s."The company samples the water regularly as part of the monitoring regime and has found no effect on Frickley Beck when taking water samples."Our employees have been working at the site for over 12 years and now fear for their jobs due to this escalation." Listen to highlights from West Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.
