Review: Jack of all trades, a master of none: 'Alter Ego' by Lisa
The album's premise is exploring five of Lisa's alter egos —named Roxi, Kiki, Vixi, Sunni and Speedi. According to the rapper herself, the debut album is a product of her experimenting with different styles. The concept of various personas initially intrigued me, hoping to see new sides of Lisa that had been suppressed by the limitations of YG Entertainment, her previous music label. However, the album doesn't commit to a cohesive direction in terms of music style and narration, failing to capture Lisa's artistry to its fullest extent. Pop-rap tracks such as 'Rockstar' and 'Lifestyle' contain catchy beats and lyrics about confidence and success. The 80s-inspired opener 'Born Again' and disco-pop track 'Moonlit Floor,' sampling a 90's classic, 'Kiss Me,' by Sixpence None The Richer , take the listener back in time while also exploring more sentimental topics. Lastly, synth-pop tracks such as 'New Woman' and 'Chill' explore a completely different sound compared to the other songs in the album.
'Alter Ego' is packed with guest appearances, including Raye , Doja Cat , Rosalía , Future , Tyla and Megan Thee Stallion , which does more harm than good. These household names in the music industry showcase distinct music genres, outshining Lisa who only adapts to her co-singers' styles. For instance, 'When I'm With You,' sounds like a track from Tyla's discography with Lisa as a feature, not the other way around. This is because Tyla has been known for creatively mixing South African music and dance with R&B and pop, but Lisa has never been associated with such style before. British singer-songwriter Raye and American rapper Doja Cat also steal the stage with their outstanding vocal performance in the powerful electropop opener 'Born Again.' The song sets a high initial expectation for the following tracks because of its heartfelt lyrics and addictive melody, which makes the rest of 'Alter Ego' underwhelming for listeners.
The bigger issue of this debut, however, lies in its lyricism. Some lines, such as ''Lisa, can you teach me Japanese?'' in her lead single, 'Rockstar,' simply lack intent and are out of place in the song. In other cases, Lisa repeatedly name-checks brands and flexes her wealth. For example, she sings, 'With five bad girls in the Honda Civic (Honda Civic)' in 'BADGRRRL' and 'Lo-lo-lo-lovin' it, these checks be comin' in / These checks be doublin'' in 'Lifestyle.' Having a couple of songs with such lyrics have the potential to be engaging, but the recycling of the same shallow topics makes the album repetitive and takes away from the listening experience. While Lisa sings about love and heartbreak in her softer songs such as 'Moonlit Floor' and 'Dream,' the restriction on the topics Lisa covers in her rap verses makes her album fall under a blunt category: ballads are for emotions and rap is for aggression. The album did not present a nuanced theme or a coherent personal narrative, which was the ultimate deal-breaker for me.
Despite its shortcomings, some tracks of the album demonstrate Lisa's strengths as a vocalist and rapper. One of the highlights of the album is 'Born Again,' one of the strongest works from Lisa's discography thus far, with rejuvenating lyrics about heartbreak, self-discovery and reinventing oneself. Another standout song is track 11, 'Lifestyle,' which quickly became a fan favorite upon release. The upbeat, heavy bass track was hailed as an empowering anthem, as many of Lisa and Blackpink's songs are. On the other hand, track 12 of the album, 'Chill,' showed a new and distinct side of Lisa and demonstrated her strengths vocally. The synth-pop track was the perfect blend of chill vibes and danceable beats, embodying the rapper's confident, swaggy personality through a refreshing style. The song became an instant favorite of mine because of how it highlighted Lisa's voice and complemented her artistic persona while also exploring something new. In my opinion, 'Chill' was the only song that truly achieved the goals that Lisa appeared to have when creating her debut album.
The primary issue of 'Alter Ego' is its lack of originality. With an incoherent theme, repetitive lyrics and unnecessary features, the album fails to take its listener through a unique journey. However, its versatility in terms of genres and sounds allows fans to see new sides of Lisa, highlighting her potential for growth. Even though 'Alter Ego' fails to showcase Lisa's unique identity, it is still a huge milestone for her career as an independent soloist. Related
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
7 hours ago
- Forbes
Rosé Beats Blackpink On The Charts And Makes History
Less than a year ago, Blackpink superstar Rosé finally delivered her debut solo album, Rosie. By that point, the singer had been a global sensation for years thanks to her work with the K-pop girl group, and she had also managed to establish herself on her own — as had her three bandmates. By the time Rosie arrived, several tunes from the set had already been pushed as singles. All of them became successful, but one in particular stands out as one of the biggest hits ever by a K-pop soloist. That track has helped turn Rosie into not just a chart win, but a historic success story for Rosé. Rosie Reenters the Billboard 200 Rosie is back on the Billboard 200 this week. The full-length reenters the 200-spot ranking of the most consumed albums in the U.S. at No. 168. The comeback is exciting for Rosé and her fans, but it's especially meaningful because of the amount of time the title has now spent on America's most competitive albums tally. Longest-Charting Full-Length by a Female K-Pop Act As it returns to the Billboard 200, Rosie reaches 27 weeks on the ranking. Rosé's almost-self-titled project now stands as the longest-charting full-length by any female K-pop act in U.S. history. Before its reentry, Rosie had matched both Blackpink's The Album and Get Up by NewJeans, which each held on for 26 frames — exactly half a year. Rosé Trails BTS and Jimin Only seven albums by K-pop stars have enjoyed longer stays than Rosie. Six of them come from BTS, including Love Yourself: Answer, Map of the Soul: 7, and Proof. Also on that list is Muse by BTS member Jimin, which racked up 34 weeks somewhere on the Billboard 200. 'Apt.' Powers Rosé's Album Rosie is largely being kept afloat thanks to the ongoing success of lead single "Apt.," her collaboration with Bruno Mars. The track is still present on two tallies in the U.S. — the Hot 100 and the Radio Songs chart. More than a month ago, "Apt." broke the records on both lists and became the longest-charting tune by any K-pop musician in American history. It continues to extend that lead every frame. Streams, sales, and airplay of the cut remain healthy, and they play a large role in Rosie moving thousands of units each week. Luminate reports that in the most recent tracking period, Rosé's set shifted just under 9,700 equivalent units. Almost 2,100 of those were pure purchases, while streaming activity accounts for much of the rest.
Forbes
7 hours ago
- Forbes
Lisa Matches Her Bandmate On Billboard's Radio Chart
Blackpink's comeback has begun as the South Korean girl group's new single "Jump" continues to live on multiple Billboard charts and remains a huge smash all around the world. Several of the four women who make up the globe-dominating band are also present on tallies in the United States as soloists, as all of them focused on their own careers in between Blackpink eras. Lisa is having a great week, in particular, as she claims two radio wins in the U.S., and both manage to move up on important all-time rankings. Lisa's 'Priceless' Climbs At the moment, "Priceless," Lisa's collaboration with Maroon 5, is her biggest hit. That track lives on four rankings and climbs on one of them, the Adult Contemporary chart, where it hits a new high of No. 17. The tune simultaneously reaches a lucky 13 weeks on the Pop Airplay chart, the main list of the biggest singles at top 40 radio. As it reaches that milestone, "Priceless" becomes a historic win among K-pop acts. Fourth-Longest-Running Hit by a Female K-Pop Soloist "Priceless" now ranks as the fourth-longest-running song by any female K-pop soloist in the history of the Pop Airplay chart. In this instance, musicians are classified as K-pop acts if they are primarily known for their output in that style. Lisa does not originally hail from South Korea, and she has produced work that can be labeled under other genres, such as pop and hip-hop, but since she got her start as one-fourth of Blackpink, she will forever be known — at least in some circles — as a K-pop star. Last week, "Priceless" was on the same level as "Toxic Till the End" by fellow Blackpink member Rosé. Both tunes managed an even dozen frames on the Pop Airplay ranking, but now "Priceless" has advanced beyond Rosé's single. Rosé Holds the All-Time Record Rosé still owns the record for the longest stay on the Pop Airplay tally among female K-pop soloists. She and Bruno Mars kept "Apt." on the list for 28 weeks. Lisa comes in second place with "Moonlit Floor (Kiss Me)," the only other tune by a K-pop female solo musician to live on the list for 20 frames or more, as it held on for exactly 20 turns. Jennie, one of the other two members of Blackpink, hit big with "One of the Girls" alongside The Weeknd and Lily-Rose Depp. That R&B tune racked up 15 stays on the roster. 'Moonlit Floor (Kiss Me)' Ties a Different Record While "Priceless" can be found on the Radio Songs, Pop Airplay, Adult Contemporary, and Adult Pop Airplay charts, "Moonlit Floor (Kiss Me)" is only still going on the Adult Contemporary tally. Lisa's solo cut hits its milestone twentieth frame on the radio roster, and in doing so, ties with two other tunes as the second-longest-running hit by any K-pop artist. Lisa matches two BTS behemoths: "My Universe" with Coldplay and "Dynamite." Rosé and Mars' "Apt." sits three weeks ahead with 23 turns on the roster.
Yahoo
10 hours ago
- Yahoo
What to expect on Netflix thanks to Harry and Meghan's new deal
The Sussexes have secured a new deal with Netflix to produce films, television shows and documentaries. Harry and Meghan have given the streaming giant first options on their output from Archewell Productions. Here is what to expect from the couple on Netflix in the coming months: – With Love, Meghan – Season 2 The second instalment of Meghan's lifestyle show will debut later in August. Netflix said: 'Meghan returns with a fun and heartwarming new season, welcoming celebrity chefs, talented artists, and beloved friends for hands-on adventures filled with laughter and discovery.' It promises 'playful cooking challenges' and 'DIY projects', adding: 'Meghan and her guests explore bold flavours, experiment with new techniques, and discover simple ways to add beauty to everyday life.' The show, Netflix says, is 'all about embracing playfulness over perfection and finding joy in creating together'. Season one was not, however, well received by critics and the show has a 3.2 rating out of 10 on – With Love, Meghan: Holiday Celebration The special holiday episode of With Love, Meghan will air in December. Netflix invites viewers to 'join Meghan in Montecito for a magical holiday celebration'. It adds: 'Together, friends and family deck the halls, create holiday feasts, craft heartfelt gifts, and share lots of laughs – with simple how-tos to follow at home. 'It's a holiday wonder with warmth, tradition, and a generous dose of joy.' The Sussexes used to spend Christmas with the royal family at Sandringham but Harry and Meghan, who moved to the US five years ago, last did so in 2018. Harry is estranged from his brother the Prince of Wales after a bitter fallout and has a troubled relationship with his father the King. – Meet Me At The Lake The 'romance feature' is an adaptation of the bestselling novel by Carley Fortune. 'This romantic drama follows a decade-spanning love story that begins with a chance encounter and a broken promise,' Netflix says. No date has been announced for the project – news of which first emerged two years ago. The story deals with mental health, postnatal depression and childhood trauma over losing a parent in a car crash, with some of the themes said to have similarities with Harry and Meghan's own experience. – Masaka Kids, A Rhythm Within The new documentary short, by Campfire Studios in Association with Wontanara Productions and Archewell Productions, will focus on a tiny orphanage in Uganda which was borne out of the HIV/Aids crisis. Harry and Meghan are listed among the producers and the documentary will be released later this year. The duke only recently stepped down from Sentebale, the charity he founded nearly 20 years ago to help children orphaned by Aids in Lesotho, following a boardroom battle with its chairwoman. Harry, who was left devastated by the development and who is considering starting a new humanitarian charity, vowed to continue his commitment to supporting youngsters in the region. Netflix says: 'In the heart of Uganda's Masaka region, where the shadows of the HIV/Aids crisis linger, a small orphanage becomes a beacon of hope. 'Masaka Kids, A Rhythm Within goes beyond the viral videos to reveal a vibrant, one-of-a-kind community where orphaned children transform hardship into joy, dancing their way toward healing, belonging, and the promise of a brighter future.' It is not known whether Harry and Meghan will feature in the documentary. – Future projects Archewell Productions says it is 'in active development on additional projects with Netflix that span a variety of content genres'. The Sussexes' contract has been described as a 'multi-year, first look deal for film and television projects'.
