Music stars release silent album in protest against UK AI copyright plans
25 Feb 2025
More than 1,000 musicians, including Kate Bush, Cat Stevens and Annie Lennox, have released a silent album in protest of the proposed changes to British copyright laws around artificial intelligence (AI), which they warned could lead to legalised music theft.
The album, titled Is This What We Want, was launched on Tuesday and features recordings of empty studios and performance spaces, as backlash against the plan grows in the United Kingdom.
The proposed changes would allow AI developers to train their models on any material to which they have lawful access, and would require creators to proactively opt out to stop their work from being used.
Critics, including the artists participating in the silent album, say it would reverse the principle of copyright law, which grants exclusive control to creators over their work.
The emergence of AI has posed a threat to the creative industry, including music, raising legal and ethical questions on a new technological platform that could produce its own output without paying creators of original content.
Bush and other writers and musicians denounced the proposals in UK law as a 'wholesale giveaway' to Silicon Valley in a letter to The Times newspaper.
Ed Newton-Rex, organiser of the project, said musicians were 'united in their thorough condemnation of this ill-thought-through plan'.
In a very rare move, UK newspapers also highlighted their concerns, launching a campaign featuring wrap-around advertisements on the front of almost every national daily, with an inside editorial by the papers' editors.
A public consultation on the legal changes will close later on Tuesday.
British Prime Minister Keir Starmer wants to become a superpower in the AI industry. Responding to the album, a government spokesperson said the current copyright and AI regime was holding back the creative industries from 'realising their full potential'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Qatar Tribune
02-07-2025
- Qatar Tribune
Charlotte Lavelle: A life in art, from Atlantic shores to gobal stage
Ashraf Siddiqui Doha From an early age, Charlotte Lavelle's artistic path was clear. Born in Chester and raised near the Atlantic coast of Ireland, her creative talent was first noticed by her mother when Charlotte was just three. By age five, she was studying with a prominent local artist, a mentorship that helped spark a lifelong love of art. Aged six, Lavelle won her first art award in the Texaco Children's Art Competition, and her photo appeared in the Western People alongside her art teacher—a moment that cemented her connection to creativity and community. Talking to Qatar Tribune, Charlotte said that she was raised in a home rich with music and artistic encouragement, she and her siblings all learned instruments, influenced by their musically gifted mother and grandmother. Her deep engagement with the arts extended to theatre and sculpture, winning recognition at the Ballina Salmon Festival before pursuing a degree at Limerick School of Art and Design. Initially drawn to sculpture, she eventually majored in fashion design, a decision that led her to New York City and an internship with fashion icon Anna Sui. In New York, Lavelle contributed to high-profile design projects, including work for Naomi Campbell and development of Sui's first perfume. Her talent and diligence earned her increasing responsibilities, culminating in close involvement with the designer's personal archives. After returning to Europe, Lavelle worked with British fashion legend Vivienne Westwood, contributing to major exhibitions and collections inspired by classical art. Eventually, her focus returned fully to fine art. Lavelle's paintings—deeply influenced by the landscape and the emotional resonance of color—have been exhibited in Ireland, Malta, and Sicily. She completed a postgraduate degree at Burren College of Art, developing a practice rooted in nature, serenity, and sensory experience. Now based in Qatar, Lavelle continues to inspire through teaching and exhibitions. She curated the 'Art Matters' exhibition featuring over 300 student works and remains active in cultural life, also singing with the Qatar Concert Choir. Her work advocates for art as a tool for joy, unity, and even diplomacy — most recently contributing to the 'Greener Together' initiative, merging creativity with global sustainability efforts.
Qatar Tribune
21-06-2025
- Qatar Tribune
Draper's Queen's hopes dashed by big-serving Lehecka
PA Media/DPA London Jack Draper failed in his bid to be crowned the new British king of Queen's Club after a three-set defeat by Jiri Lehecka in the semi-final on Saturday. Lehecka became the first Czech finalist since Ivan Lendl 35 years ago after a 6-4, 4-6, 7-5 victory. It was a tough loss for Draper on home soil with the British number one angrily smashing his racket and damaging a digital advertising hoarding as the match slipped away. But it has been a successful week for the 23-year-old, with his run to the last four earning him a top-four seeding at Wimbledon. The Czech will meet Carlos Alcaraz or fellow Spaniard Roberto Bautista Agut in Sunday's final. 'It means a lot,' said Lehecka. 'You don't meet a player like Jack every day, he's an amazing competitor.' One poor service game at the start, punctuated by two aces and a double fault on break point, ultimately cost Draper the first set. He did not get a sniff on the Lehecka serve, with his fellow 23-year-old regularly sending down aces approaching 140mph. In the second Draper began making inroads, a stunning flicked backhand cross-court winner helping bring up his first break points. But Lehecka repelled all four to hold for 2-2, with Draper beginning to cut a frustrated figure on the baseline. With singer Jon Bon Jovi watching from the posh seats, the tension was briefly lifted with a blast of his biggest hit 'Livin' on a Prayer' at the change over. Draper re-emerged in a blaze of glory, an ace sealing a hold to love before a winner down the line levelled the match. Lehecka forced a break point at 4-4 but netted after a long, tense exchange and Draper survived. However, Lehecka was looking the stronger and, after a comfortable hold, snatched the break for 6-5 with a stunning backhand winner. Draper smashed his racket in anger, earning a code violation, before Lehecka finished the job to win in two hours and seven minutes, ensuring Britain's wait for a first Queen's winner since Andy Murray in 2016 goes on. While Draper will be disappointed not to have reached the final - something he had dreamed of as a child - he can be encouraged by his overall performance as Wimbledon approaches. His run to the last four ensures he not only goes there in good confidence but as one of the top four seeds, ensuring he would avoid defending champion Alcaraz or world number one Jannik Sinner until at least the semi-finals. 'I don't condone that behaviour, but at the same time, that's kind of where I was at today,' Draper said of his racquet-smashing. 'I was trying to use everything I could. I tried to compete [for] every ball. But in the end, anger just spilled over a little bit too much.'
Qatar Tribune
17-06-2025
- Qatar Tribune
Draper laughs off snub as Emma picks Carlos for US Open
PA Media/DPA London Jack Draper joked that he did not blame Emma Raducanu for choosing Carlos Alcaraz over him as her mixed doubles partner at a star-studded US Open event this summer. Raducanu and world number two Alcaraz are among 16 big-name pairs announced by Flushing Meadows organisers on Tuesday. Asked if the two current British number ones could have got together instead, Draper said: 'A wise person once told me you should find the best partner - and that's what she did. I don't blame her at all for that. 'He's obviously the best player in the world probably right now, along with (Jannik) Sinner. Great at doubles, as well. She's gone about and chose the best partner, for sure. Hopefully they do well.' Draper, currently world number six, has linked up with Olympic champion Qinwen Zheng of China. 'I think it's a good format for the players to get prepared for the US Open, having a shot at playing with another top player,' he added. 'Qinwen I know from the Tour. I have seen her around. Obviously a great player herself and has a really good game. 'It will be fun to get out there and play with her and see how we get on. It was me who messaged. It was nice to get that together and let's see how we get on.' Alcaraz, who joined Draper in the second round at Queen's Club on Tuesday, said: 'She's gonna be the boss! 'I'm super excited about it. I think it's going to be great. It was an amazing idea for the tournament. 'I've known Emma since a really long time ago, so we know each other. I have a really good relationship with her. We are going to enjoy it, for sure. 'I will try to bring my doubles skill. We will try to win. But obviously it's going to be really, really fun.' It was announced earlier this year that the US Open mixed doubles event will be played over two days in the week before the main tournament. It was an attempt to attract more high-profile players, and it has certainly worked. The event will take place on August 19 and 20, with the winners scooping a prize pot of $1 million. Not all the pairs announced on Tuesday might make the cut, with entries open until July 28.
