logo
Former priest led movement with ‘extremely disturbing' services, court hears

Former priest led movement with ‘extremely disturbing' services, court hears

Christopher Brain, 68, from Wilmslow, Cheshire, was leader of the the Nine O'Clock Service (NOS), part of the Church of England, in Sheffield between 1986 and 1995.
Brain denies one count of rape and 36 counts of indecent assault between 1981 and 1995.
The prosecution allege NOS became a cult where Brain abused his position to sexually assault a 'staggering number' of women followers, exerting control over their lives and ostracising them from friends and family.
Inner London Crown Court has heard a 'homebase team' was set up to 'care for' Brain – referred to as 'the Lycra Lovelies' or 'the Lycra Nuns' – with witnesses reporting seeing the defendant surrounded by attractive women in lingerie at his home looking after his needs.
Mark Stibbe was a curate of St Thomas's Church in Sheffield when NOS was holding services there.
Giving evidence on Wednesday, he said there was 'concern' about the direction NOS was taking and discussion about Brain and what was going on at his home.
He told the court: 'I remember one church administrator or finance officer at St Thomas's who was like an old school army man and he brought up the negative optics, potentially anyway, of scantily clad, lycra-wearing pretty young women as he put it coming to and from Chris Brain's house on a regular basis to perform 'domestic duties'.'
The witness said the man got a 'roasting' for asking whether there was 'anything untoward' about it and that others at St Thomas's felt that if the church's vicar, Robert Warren, was not going to intervene then junior clergy had no business doing so.
He said it did not appear to him that Reverend Warren was able to control Brain.
He also recalled there was 'a lot of controversy' over the Greenbelt Christian arts festival 'into which NOS had poured many hours and many thousands of pounds'.
Dr Stibbe moved to another church in 1993 but attended a NOS service once it had moved to a new location in Ponds Forge after a member of his congregation expressed concerns to him about it.
Of his visit, he said: 'My view at the time was that it was extremely disturbing and that my friend who had said it was disturbing was correct.
'The reason I found it disturbing is that the things that had been reported from the Greenbelt Festival about girls gyrating in scantily clad costume in a worship context, that is what I was seeing in this context.'
Asked if he thought the women were willing participants, he told jurors: 'This is the thing that concerns me. I couldn't tell.
'In a progressive culture… it seemed to me to be a graphic, vivid contradiction to have young women behaving in what looked like a controlled manner.'
Dr Stibbe said he wrote to the then Bishop of Sheffield to ask about oversight of NOS.
'It seemed to me that it had drifted so far away from being a Christian ritual and Christian service and there were elements of it that deeply disturbed me and I felt it was not properly accountable,' he said.
'I do remember saying to him that I felt that if he did not step in and discern what was truly going on in the congregation that there would be disaster within one year.'
Of the response, he said: 'Part of it was a reprimand or rebuke and the rebuke was that we did not conduct witch hunts in the diocese. So I really had my ecclesiastical wrists slapped.'
He added that he was told then archdeacon Stephen Lowe was overseeing NOS and that 'that should be enough for me'.
Earlier the court heard from Rev Warren who said allegations that emerged about Brain's abuse 'came as a total shock', although he admitted he had a sense of 'cult-like elements' emerging in NOS.
Asked while giving evidence over a video link to explain what kinds of behaviour he saw, he said: 'Just a sort of controlling of people and a focus on Chris Brain almost as a sort of guru.'
He added: 'I think it was a sense of deference to Chris Brain that if you asked people about the service they would always say, well what Chris thinks is or what Chris wants is.
'With the other services I wouldn't get that sort of response.'
The reverend said if NOS had continued to hold services at St Thomas's he expects that behaviour would have become clearer and he would have done something about it.
He told the court that NOS had 400 regular worshippers when it left St Thomas's and at one stage there was a mass confirmation service of 93 members of NOS – 'the largest group that we had ever confirmed in one church'.
He agreed that NOS was exciting and innovative for the Church of England and that it could engage young people in ways the church was until then failing to do, incorporating 'rave' culture and music as part of worship.
'Some people who were at that service would come from 20 or 30 miles away because they found the service so inspiring,' he said.
The witness also told jurors that NOS functioned independently financially from St Thomas's, and that NOS contributed to payments to Brain as a 'lay leader' and then as a priest once he was ordained.
Brain's personal tutor during his ordination training also gave evidence, telling jurors how she initially thought he was arrogant, how he was often absent and failed to consistently meet deadlines.
Marilyn Parry said she raised issues with senior tutors and the diocese but that they did not appear to share her view, adding: 'They felt he should be given some slack because he was running such an important ministry for the church.'
'Mr Brain was not having a normal curacy so he was being fast tracked through the process,' she said. 'I felt it was a mistake.'
The court heard it would normally take three to four years for someone to be ordained from the time they begin training at college but that Brain was ordained in one.
The witness also said she had difficulty getting in touch with him and would often find 'young women' answering his phone, telling of a particular conversation that 'worried' her when a young woman said Brain could not take her call because he was being massaged by another member of the team.
Former members of NOS also gave evidence, telling the court how Brain led a 'luxurious' lifestyle with a 'lavish' car, mobile phone and 'the best' clothes.
They also said there was an 'expectation' that followers should try to contribute 10% of their income to NOS.
The trial continues on Thursday.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Church abuse victim stages quiet protest at General Synod
Church abuse victim stages quiet protest at General Synod

BBC News

time10 hours ago

  • BBC News

Church abuse victim stages quiet protest at General Synod

Jenny Read says she was abused as a little girl at a church in the north-east of England. Last week she protested outside a meeting of the Church of England's parliament as it signed off on a compensation scheme for abuse victims, which she says is too little, too late. It is 07:30 BST on a grey, humid July morning in city is hosting General Synod - the Church of England's parliament - which is about to approve the landmark compensation Read, who travelled from her north-east of England home because she "had to be here", has already set up says, as a child, she was "sadistically" abused over a number of years at her local church by her own father, and also by a male curate and a female church adulthood, she and her sisters, who also say they were abused as children by the same people, reported the allegations to the Church of England three times, but it never launched a formal investigation. Ms Read is at General Synod to protest. But she is not blocking traffic, nor is she chanting or shouting into a megaphone. She is sitting peacefully in a camping chair opposite Central Hall, where the event is being held, drinking a cup of tea and eating a is quiet, but she no longer feels silenced and her presence is her stands a banner she has made. In big red, black and green letters it reads: "Three sisters sadistically abused at a NE church still waiting for justice." Ms Read's appearance in the shadow of the chamber housing the most powerful figures in the Church of England is the day members of the public, bishops, clergymen and clergywomen approach her to ask what her story is. Some take over food and Read says she is here to tell Church leaders that there is an "urgent need" to treat people who report abuse allegations with kindness because "that hasn't been our experience".Her fight for answers has been re-traumatising, she says, but she has waived her right to anonymity in order to share her may have passed but the mental anguish caused by the abuse and the alleged "fobbing off" from Church leaders has not, she a face-to-face meeting with her in May, Archbishop of York Stephen Cottrell, the interim leader of the Church, offered an "unequivocal apology" for the abuse she had experienced and "recognised that it will have affected her life in many ways".Last month, following a BBC investigation which revealed the Read sisters' story, the Church of England also said it was "truly sorry" for the response they received when they made their initial reports. 'Survivor focused' compensation The Church has put aside £150m for what it is calling the Redress Scheme, to which any victim of Church-related abuse can apply. It was agreed by General Synod, but still needs to be officially signed off by the Church says the scheme is "survivor focused" and "offers more than money".As well as financial compensation, which can range from £5,000 to £660,000, survivors and victims can also receive "a formal apology, acknowledgment, therapeutic support, and other forms of bespoke redress", it can be made via a designated website and "independently assessed by trained assessors" who will consider the type of abuse, aggravating factors and the impact on the victim, it will then decide the level of compensation and support given."This is about the Church facing its past failures with honesty and humility," it says. The Right Reverend Philip Mounstephen, who chairs the Church's Redress Board, says it is "a matter of great shame" that the scheme is needed. He has previously said it was unclear how many people would apply."I am confident the scheme will provide much needed redress to survivors," he says, adding it will be "bespoke" for each scheme has already been delayed by several years and, for Ms Read, it is too has already "spent so many hours and months" in therapy and does not want to "spend any more of my remaining years trekking to therapists", she says."Even if I got the highest award possible, that doesn't compensate for my trauma."Ms Read has been diagnosed with depression and post-traumatic stress disorder linked to her childhood abuse which has, at times, plagued her adult relationships have been affected and she has only ever been able to work part has panic attacks in religious buildings which make her feel "terrorised" to the point she "has to scream" and get out. Episodes of feeling suicidal mean she "has struggled to survive" on occasions. "Redress sounds good but, from past experience, I can't quite believe it," Ms Read says."It's really urgent to highlight the need for the Church to get safeguarding right, not just on paper but in actions."Her silent protest brought some closure and, after decades of her feeling dismissed, people have eventually listened, she says."I feel like my voice has finally been heard. I can now move on with the rest of my life." Follow BBC North East on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram.

Who was Noel Stanton and how did the founder of the Jesus Army die?
Who was Noel Stanton and how did the founder of the Jesus Army die?

Scottish Sun

timea day ago

  • Scottish Sun

Who was Noel Stanton and how did the founder of the Jesus Army die?

Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Charismatic preacher turned cult leader Noel Stanton built a religious empire that hid horrific abuse behind colourful buses and a "Christian community" for nearly four decades. Born on Christmas Day 1926, this ordinary Baptist minister transformed into one of Britain's most controversial religious figures when he founded the Jesus Army in rural Northamptonshire. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 3 Noel Stanton preaching to his community Credit: BBC After his death in 2009, aged 82, shocking allegations emerged of systematic physical, sexual and psychological abuse spanning decades. A new BBC documentary now exposes the disturbing truth behind what one survivor describes as "a British cult hiding in plain sight." Who was Noel Stanton? In the 1970s, this firebrand preacher convinced dozens of idealistic Christians to hand over their homes, possessions, and even their children to create what he claimed would be "heaven on Earth" in rural Northamptonshire. Stanton established the Jesus Fellowship Church – better known as the Jesus Army – which grew from a small congregation at Bugbrooke Baptist Church into a nationwide movement with thousands of followers. Read more on cults 'DEEPLY DECIEVED' Sex cult brainwashed me into being a 'bride' for a rapist The bearded, authoritarian leader demanded total obedience from his flock. Members lived in communal houses, surrendered their savings to the group, and followed his increasingly bizarre rules about everything from diet to relationships. His preaching became increasingly focused on sexual "purity," with shocking footage from a 1993 documentary showing him urging followers to give their "genitals to Jesus". This obsession with controlling members' sexuality would later become central to many abuse allegations. How did the Jesus Army founder die? Noel Stanton died on May 20, 2009, aged 82, after leading his controversial religious movement for nearly four decades. Despite building what appeared to be a thriving Christian community with its distinctive fleet of colourful Jesus Army buses and evangelistic street outreach, Stanton's final years were marked by increasing scrutiny of his leadership methods. Watch moment rape cult leader who told followers he was an alien called Great Shaman is arrested in Argentina By the time of his death, cracks were already appearing in the movement he'd created, though the full extent of the abuse within the Jesus Army wouldn't become public knowledge until years later. Stanton was buried at the fellowship's New Creation Farm in Nether Heyford, a sprawling community site that had been purchased with money donated by his followers. Inside the controversial cult While presenting itself as a legitimate Christian church, the Jesus Army operated with all the classic hallmarks of a cult. Members were encouraged to cut ties with family and friends outside the group. Those living in communal "community houses" had to follow strict rules about everything from clothing to personal relationships. The group's radical "kingdom theology" taught followers that Stanton had special authority from God. This created an environment where questioning the leader was seen as questioning God himself. Ex-members describe an atmosphere of intense control, with decisions about jobs, marriages and even what clothes to wear dictated by "elders" appointed by Stanton. The Jesus Army became known for its distinctive evangelism style, with members in brightly coloured jackets approaching strangers in town centres, offering hugs and inviting them to join community life. What appeared to outsiders as a quirky but harmless Christian group was, behind closed doors, implementing practices that damaged hundreds of lives. 3 Aerial view of Sheepfold Grange, Northampton, Jesus Army Credit: Google Shock abuse claims Following Stanton's death, horrifying accounts of systematic physical, emotional, psychological and sexual abuse began to emerge from former members. Children as young as two were routinely "disciplined" with birch canes in a practice known as "rodding", causing physical and psychological trauma that survivors still deal with today. The group conducted terrifying "exorcisms" on members thought to be possessed by demons, with some subjected to hours of shouting, physical restraint and psychological abuse under the guise of spiritual cleansing. There were also several unexplained deaths within the community that former members claim weren't properly investigated at the time. Perhaps most disturbing were the widespread sexual abuse allegations. Multiple members, many of whom were children when the abuse occurred, have since come forward with accounts of sexual assault perpetrated by senior figures within the organisation. The cult's strict sexual teachings, which demanded celibacy from single members while simultaneously creating an environment where authority figures had unchecked power, created perfect conditions for predators. 3 The Jesus Army commune in Northampton was the site of many abuses Credit: Jesus Fellowship Central Offices/Youtube The Redress Scheme The scale of abuse was so extensive that, following the official disbanding of the Jesus Army in 2019, the Jesus Fellowship Community Trust established a Redress Scheme to compensate victims. The scheme identified numerous abusers within the organisation, with victims ranging from young children to vulnerable adults who had been drawn into the community. By November 2021, when the scheme closed, hundreds of former members had come forward with claims of serious abuse suffered during their time in the Jesus Army. Former members continue to speak out about their experiences, with many featured in the powerful new BBC documentary "Inside the Cult of the Jesus Army," which exposes the shocking truth behind what once appeared to be just an eccentric Christian group. The Jesus Fellowship Community Trust has acknowledged that "serious harm" was caused to many former members, particularly children, and has apologised for the "pain and suffering" experienced by those who lived under Stanton's leadership. What began as a dream of Christian community ended as a nightmare for hundreds of victims – a stark reminder of how easily religious devotion can be twisted into control and abuse when placed in the wrong hands.

Jay Slater died accidentally after falling from a height while in Tenerife, coroner concludes
Jay Slater died accidentally after falling from a height while in Tenerife, coroner concludes

ITV News

timea day ago

  • ITV News

Jay Slater died accidentally after falling from a height while in Tenerife, coroner concludes

A teenager who went missing in Tenerife sparking a month-long search before his body was found in a ravine died as a result of an accidental fall, a coroner has concluded. Jay Slater, 19, disappeared while holidaying on the Spanish island with friends after he was forced to leave a nightclub because he was so drunk. Jay, from Oswaldtwistle, was holidaying on the Spanish island and had been to the NRG music festival at the Papagayo nightclub in the resort of Playa de las Americas on 16 June 2024. A friend said the teen had taken ecstasy pills, and possibly ketamine, along with cocaine and alcohol, during the night, before choosing to go to an Airbnb, miles away, with two men they had met on the holiday, Preston Coroner's Court was told. The following morning he then began a 14-hour walk home through the mountains in intense heat. After a huge search and rescue operation his body was found by a mountain rescue team almost a month later in a steep and inaccessible area, near the village of Masca on 15 July.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store