‘New kind of frontier': Shareholder proposals on AI becoming increasingly widespread
When Canada's most valuable companies hosted their annual general meetings this year, there was a new topic for shareholders to vote on among the usual requests to appoint board members and OK their executive compensation.
The proposal from Quebec-based investor rights group le mouvement d'éducation et de défense des actionnaires centred on artificial intelligence.
It asked 14 companies, including Canada's biggest banks, retailer Dollarama Inc. and telecom giant BCE Inc., to sign a voluntary code of conduct the federal government developed to govern the technology.
Experts say the proposal is likely just the start of what they expect to become an annual phenomenon targeting the country's biggest companies — and beyond.
'This is a new kind of frontier in Canada for shareholder proposals,' said Renée Loiselle, a Montreal-based partner at law firm Norton Rose Fulbright.
'Last year, this was not on the ballot. Companies were not getting shareholder proposals related to AI and this year, it absolutely is.'
Loiselle and other corporate governance watchers attribute the increase in AI-related shareholder proposals to the recent rise of the technology itself.
While AI has been around for decades, it's being adopted more because of big advances in the technology's capabilities and a race to innovate that emerged after the birth of OpenAI's ChatGPT chatbot in 2022.
The increased use has revealed many dangers.
Some AI systems have fabricated information and thus, mislead users.
Others have sparked concerns about job losses, cyber warfare and even, the end of humanity.
The opportunities and risks associated with AI haven't escaped shareholders, said Juana Lee, associate director of corporate engagement at the Shareholder Association for Research and Education (SHARE).
'In Canada, I think, in the last year or two, we're seeing more and more shareholders, investors being more interested in the topic of AI,' she said.
'At least for SHARE ourselves, many of our clients are making it a priority to think through what ethical AI means, but also what that means for investee companies.'
That thinking manifested itself in a proposal two funds at the B.C. General Employees' Union targeted Thomson Reuters Corp. with.
The proposal asked the tech firm to amend its AI framework to square with a set of business and human rights principles the United Nations has. It got 4.87 per cent support.
Meanwhile, MÉDAC centred its proposals around Canada's voluntary code of conduct on AI.
The code was launched by the federal government in September 2023 and so far, has 46 signatories, including BlackBerry, Cohere, IBM, Mastercard and Telus.
Signatories promise to bake risk mitigation measures into AI tools, use adversarial testing to uncover vulnerabilities in such systems and keep track of any harms the technology causes.
MÉDAC framed its proposals around the code because there's a lack of domestic legislation for them to otherwise recommend firms heed and big companies have already supported the model, director general Willie Gagnon said.
Several companies it sent the proposal to already have AI policies but didn't want to sign the code.
'Some of them told us that the code is mainly designed for companies developing AI, but we disagree about that because we saw a bunch of companies that signed the code that are not developing any AI,' Gagnon said.
Many of the banks told MÉDAC they'll soon sign the code. Only CIBC has so far.
Conversations with at least five companies were fruitful enough that MÉDAC withdrew its proposals.
In the nine instances where the vote went forward, the proposal didn't succeed. It garnered as much as 17.4 per cent support at TD Bank but as little as 3.68 per cent at engineering firm AtkinsRéalis Group Inc.
Loiselle said you can't measure the success of a proposal based on whether it passes or not.
'The goal of these shareholder proposals is more for engagement,' she said.
Sometimes, even just by filing a proposal, companies reveal more about their AI use or understand it's an important topic for shareholders and then, discuss it more with them.
While proposals don't always succeed, Lee has seen shareholder engagement drive real change.
SHARE recently had discussions with a large Canadian software company.
AI was central to its business but didn't crop up in its proxy statement — a document companies file governing their annual general meetings.
The firm also had no board oversight of the technology.
SHARE was able to get the company, which Lee would not name, to amend its board charter to include oversight of AI and commit to more disclosure around its use of the technology in its annual sustainability report.
'This is a really positive development and it's leading to improvement related to further transparency,' she said.
If the U.S. is anything to judge by, Lee and Loiselle agree Canadian shareholders will keep pushing companies to adhere to higher AI standards.
South of the border, AI-related proposals first cropped up around two years ago.
They've targeted Apple, The Walt Disney Co. and even Netflix, where a vote on disclosing AI use and adhering to ethical guidelines amassed 43.3 per cent support.
The frequency and spectrum of AI-related requests shareholders have only grown since and is likely to be mirrored in Canada, Loiselle said.
'The landscape for shareholder proposals is changing and I think that change is here to stay,' she said.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 21, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Will Marine Atlantic's commercial rate not being cut impact people in N.L.? Not much, says this trucker
While passengers riding the Marine Atlantic ferry will see a 50 per cent reduction in the cost of their ticket, commercial passengers and truckers won't see that same benefit. And while Newfoundland and Labrador's Minister of Jobs says it puts the province at a severe trade disadvantage, one trucker says it likely won't make much of a difference. "It was no big surprise, really. And it ain't going to impact the everyday lives of people here very much anyway, even if they're reduced," Tony Power, owner of operator of Power Trucking in Holyrood, told CBC News of the decision to not cut commercial rates for Marine Atlantic ferries. He pays $735 for a one way trip for his 75-foot truck. "If I reduce the rate to [merchants] for the ferry, they ain't going to take it off for the province anyway. There's just corporate greed across the board." Other ferries in Atlantic Canada and Quebec saw both commercial and passenger rates slashed in a decision by Prime Minister Mark Carney. Asked by CBC News why the change didn't apply to Marine Atlantic, St. John's East MP Joanne Thompson said rates needed to be frozen to protect other merchants in the industry. "Marine Atlantic is part of a broader chain of suppliers that bring commercial product in and out of the province. And we need to protect all players in the field, because we rely on the transfer of products from multiple sources," Thompson said. In response, Newfoundland and Labrador Jobs Minister Gerry Byrne said not lowering commercial rates goes against the announcement being a way to improve interprovincial trade efforts. "[Other Atlantic provinces] now have a very, very large competitive advantage over Newfoundland and Labrador in exports, in free trade, in competitiveness. Our economy now just took a blow," Byrne told CBC Radio Thursday. More passengers, delayed shipments? Power said he sided with Thompson's comments. He noted that if rates were to drop for travel on Marine Atlantic, other transporters would have to get the same cut and disrupt the overall market. But although he believes rates not being cut won't affect the price of food on the shelves, it could affect when it gets there — as a likely increase in passenger traffic could lead to less space being available for commercial trucks. "You're going to have less trucks per vessel," he said. "Those trucks that were there Tuesday for the [dangerous goods] crossing got to sit there 'till Wednesday. So, like, they got an extra two days on the wharf, which is delaying their products. It all got to come to the island, we got very few options to get to Newfoundland … that traffic got to come across that water." Power also expressed concerns with loosening interprovincial trade barriers, saying he believes it would impact the ability for local companies to prosper with business coming in from elsewhere.
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Ferryland's lighthouse is shining bright for the first time in 5 years
A shining light on Newfoundland's Avalon Peninsula has fully reopened for the first time in five years, which one business owner says will help the region shine even brighter. The Ferryland Lighthouse has faced several hurdles and partial closures in recent years, closing due to the COVID-19 pandemic and then facing a second long-term closure when the building was severely damaged by Hurricane Larry in 2021. Jill Curran, the owner of Lighthouse Picnics operating out of the lighthouse, said it led to tough questions having to be asked about the future of her business. "We accumulated, unfortunately, a lot of debt trying to work around that," Curran told CBC Radio's The St. John's Morning Show. "It was just so hard, and I'm so appreciative of all the people that stayed with us. Because we continued to operate, but each year we looked different as we figured things out." Now, five years after the start of the pandemic and four years after the hurricane, the lighthouse has been fully reopened and business is back in full swing. "It's Lighthouse Picnics, so the lighthouse is a key ingredient to what we're doing out there," she said. "Five years was a really long time. And there was many times, you know, we just kind of hit roadblock after roadblock. [We] stumbled, and it was just like, 'Is it ever going to happen?' And so it's just been amazing, we've just been so happy with the feedback." Curran said years of work had to go into getting the lighthouse reopened. It still had its original structure from its construction in 1870 at the time of the hurricane, which was pounded by wind and surf to the point where it began to crumble. Heavy structural work had to be completed, which was complicated by large-scale supplies needing to be brought in on a narrow, gravel road. Now the work has been finished, Curran said she's beyond excited to welcome people back to the lighthouse that has been in her family for generations. "It was a real labour of love, and it means the world to me to see it so accepted by visitors and the community," she said. "It just gives me so much hope to see the building open again. Its breathed life into our business again. And so I think our lighthouse, and so many historic buildings around the province, are really a way for us to pay tribute to those that came before us."
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
'Can I see some ID?' As online age verification spreads, so do privacy concerns
Ontario-based cybersecurity expert Richard Rogerson was surprised to get ID'd by a children's online gaming platform last month. His three kids had been playing the Roblox game Murder Mystery, until the platform put it behind an age verification system. They were asked to enter the email address of a parent, for permission to update their content maturity setting from "Mild" to "Moderate" if they wanted to keep playing. The email, which Rogerson shared with CBC News, asked him to enter his birthday and verify his age using a government-issued ID or credit card. "When my kids sent me a form saying, 'Upload your driver's licence,' you can imagine the amount of resistance that I had towards that," he said. While he had no problem with his kids playing the game, Rogerson declined to upload his ID, unsure how securely his data would be stored. His kids have had to give up Murder Mystery as a result. Online age verification systems are sweeping the internet as jurisdictions introduce laws to prevent children from accessing certain content, and a wave of privacy concerns has followed. The U.K.'s Online Safety Act took effect last Friday, putting age gates on pornography and other content deemed "harmful" to minors. Many websites are now required to ask U.K. users to verify their age using identifiers like selfies, driver's licences, passports or credit cards, triggering frustration and backlash from some users. While some sites have pulled out of the country rather than comply with the new rules, others are rolling out their own measures beyond the U.K. YouTube announced Tuesday it will introduce an age verification system with select U.S. users before implementing it more broadly. The video streaming platform will analyze the browsing patterns of users to determine their age before asking for other forms of ID. "We're seeing this kind of pop up everywhere," said Rogerson, who is the founder of Packetlabs, a cybersecurity firm specializing in professional hacking services. Data breaches raise alarms Rogerson says it's a good idea to restrict minors from accessing certain content, but it's also important to address related privacy and security concerns. Most companies rely on third-party verification systems, so the average user won't know who is privy to their private information, how secure it is, or how it's being stored. If that data is breached, the fallout can be disastrous. "You think about an adult website getting compromised, and here's all the faces of all the people and where they live, and here's all the content they viewed," Rogerson said. "That would be quite, quite damaging." Last Friday, San Francisco-based Tea Dating Advice Inc said in a statement that some 72,000 images, including 13,000 selfies and photo IDs, were leaked online from Tea, an app designed for women to vet dates by sharing information about men. Rogerson says Canada has mandatory breach notification laws, but some companies aren't sophisticated enough to even know when they've been breached. He says the U.K.'s General Data Protection Regulation, while not perfect, offers strong privacy protections in some areas and stiff penalties for violations. But he worries Canada is lagging behind, as its proposed legislation aimed at modernizing online privacy laws has been stalled. "We need the privacy laws here in Canada to protect Canadians, because it's every every day we're seeing companies get breached with hordes and hordes of privacy related information," he said. The Online Harms Act was introduced in February 2024 but didn't pass, and the federal government may rewrite or reintroduce the act. Justice Minister Sean Fraser recently said the government plans to take a "fresh" look at the legislation over the summer, though it's unclear what changes are coming. A ministry spokesperson did not answer whether age verification might be one of those changes, saying in an email Friday that the government "cannot speculate on legislation or content at this time." WATCH | Federal government debates online age verification: Can Canada really block kids from watching porn? | About That 1 year ago Tough choice for users Cliff Steinhauer, director of information security and engagement at the National Cybersecurity Alliance, a non-profit that promotes online safety, says age verification requirements present users with a tough choice when faced with insufficient or unclear privacy policies from the apps and websites they use. "It's like, either do this and accept the policy, or don't do it and don't get access to the service," he said. "As a user, I think you have to really ask yourself: Am I comfortable with this? If this were to be breached, what would the impact on me be? What is the risk that I'm taking by putting this selfie into this app? And is this service worth the risk?" Steinhauer says privacy laws need to put safeguards around age verification systems, like guarantees of deleting the data as soon as the user's age is verified. Several U.S. states have already implemented age verification laws. Last week, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld a Texas law requiring porn sites to verify the ages of all visitors after a judge previously struck it down as a violation of free speech. Australia has legislated a social media ban for users under 16, which is slated to go ahead in the coming months, and Quebec is considering following suit. Verification needed: advocate The Canadian Centre for Child Protection has been lobbying the federal government to mandate online age verification. Jacques Marcoux, the centre's director of research and analytics, worries about children being harmed by sexually explicit material online, pointing to a 2022 Mediasmart survey that found three in 10 Canadian youth in Grades 7 to 11 had encountered explicit material inadvertently, with most saying they were between the ages of nine and 13 when it first happened. Marcoux says while there is no perfect way to do it, verification is needed to require website operators to act more responsibly. Without that piece, he says other proposed online child protection measures could be hard to enforce. "I think this is maybe a first step in moving towards a better system, where it will be refined over time," he said. As a tech-savvy parent himself, Marcoux says even with parental controls, it's "impossible" to monitor a child's online activity 24/7. "The bottom line is that the current situation — which is that children of all ages have unfettered, no-friction access to essentially the whole of the content of the internet — is a problem that we can't turn away from," he said.
